The tadpole larva of a sea squirt is only the second animal to have its entire nervous system mapped out, and the results confirm that there is still much to learn from the smallest brains.
Brains come in different sizes. Sperm whales have the largest, weighing in at over 7 kilograms, whereas the dwarf males of a worm called Dinophilus gyrociliatus have the smallest, containing just 66 neurons (Windoffer and Westheide, 1988). Whether large or small, one feature unites all brains more than anything else: their neurons are connected to form intricate networks. This property is not seen in other organs, like the liver, kidneys or skin. Mapping networks of neurons has now become a central theme in neuroscience, as evidenced by the rise of the field of connectomics.
Producing wiring diagrams of neural networks – or connectomes – that show the specific connections between cells requires use of electron microscopy to image ultrathin slices of neural tissue. This approach has led to spectacular progress in recent years, but it can only analyse relatively small volumes. For example, a mouse brain is approximately 1 cm3, which is about 100,000 times larger than the volume that can currently be imaged and analysed. This is why size matters in connectomics. To date, a complete connectome has been produced for just one species, the nematode worm Caenorhabditis elegans. This wiring diagram, which was published 30 years ago, contains 302 neurons and took over a decade of effort (White et al., 1986).
Now, in eLife, Kerrianne Ryan, Zhiyuan Lu and Ian Meinertzhagen from Dalhousie University report that they have mapped the connectome of a tadpole larva of the ascidian Ciona intestinalis (Ryan et al., 2016). Adult ascidians are quite unremarkable, water-filled sacs that squirt when removed from the sea – which is why they are commonly called “sea squirts” (Figure 1A). However, their tadpole-like larvae have attracted interest ever since the Russian embryologist Alexander Kowalewsky discovered in 1867 that they have the same basic body plan as the vertebrates (i.e. animals with backbones, ranging from fish to humans; Mikhailov and Gilbert, 2002). Later molecular studies confirmed that they were indeed our closest “invertebrate” relatives (Delsuc et al., 2006), and Ciona has now become an important laboratory animal in many areas of biology.
With fewer than 200 neurons, the nervous system of a Ciona larva is small and comes close to the lower limits of brain size. Nevertheless, imaging and reconstructing most of the neurons in the nervous system of a single specimen required a gargantuan effort. First, Ryan et al. sliced a single larva into 7,000 sections, just tens of nanometres thick, and imaged the sections using electron microscopy (Figure 1B). The high-resolution images were then aligned and the neurons were painstakingly traced by hand. Finally, the connections for each and every neuron were identified and annotated. This resulted in the near-complete wiring diagram of the Ciona larva, representing the second connectome of any animal.
So, what can we learn from the connectome of Ciona? First, it is what is called a “small-world” network, meaning that it has highly connected local sub-networks linked together by a smaller number of long-range connections. This is similar to how the C. elegans connectome, social networks and power grids are organised (Watts and Strogatz, 1998). Overall, the 177 neurons are connected such that, on average, it only takes 2.7 steps to go from one node in the network to another.
The connectome also shows that a Ciona larva has clearly separate peripheral and central nervous systems. The peripheral nervous system contains a few sensory neurons that are in direct contact with the environment. The central nervous system consists of sensory systems containing a single eye on the right side of the head, an organ that is sensitive to gravity, and cells that are thought to sense pressure (Figure 1C). These sensory systems connect to highly interconnected relay neurons found at the back of the brain. These relay neurons in turn project to interneurons and motorneurons that are also part of the central nervous system and that eventually innervate into the larva’s muscles.
How can the connectome help us understand how the Ciona larva does what it does? Well, almost everything these creatures do involves their muscles. Even before hatching, asymmetric muscle contractions cause the larva’s tail to flick 10 times per second and help it to hatch from its egg. Tail flicks then persist after hatching and may be important for changing direction when swimming (Mast, 1921). Moreover, as a larva ages, its movements change and become driven by symmetric tail contractions that occur about 20–30 times per second. The larvae also respond to different stimuli – including light, gravity and shadows – by altering the activity of their muscles (Zega et al., 2006; McHenry and Strother, 2003); for example, young larvae will swim up against the direction of gravity (Tsuda et al., 2003). Ryan et al. have now fully mapped neuronal pathways responsible for these relatively simple behaviours, from sensory organs to muscles (Figure 1D).
Simple as these behaviours may be, they are not independent. Instead, the network allows crosstalk at different levels. This suggests that the brain may indeed integrate different stimuli but only trigger one pattern of movements at a time – which is consistent with how these larvae actually swim (Zega et al., 2006). These findings show that, even though each larva is small and anatomically simple, the underlying neural networks in its nervous system are complex and integrated.
Ryan et al. noted another intriguing feature of the Ciona connectome. Most animals studied to date display a left-right symmetry, so that for each neuron on the left, there is a counterpart on the right. However, most of the nervous system of Ciona lacks this symmetry (Figure 1D). Moreover, even those groups of neurons that are symmetric – such as the motorneurons – are connected to other cells in an asymmetric way. It is not known why the nervous system of Ciona is so strongly asymmetric, but it may have something to do with the streamlining of the ascidian body plan. Asymmetries can be found in all brains, including our own, but to a lesser extent; so Ciona may provide clues on the development and function of asymmetry in brains.
The Ciona connectome holds lessons for those trying to understand how the brain works. It clearly shows that we are not done with the smallest brains yet; despite having few neurons, the Ciona network is complex and we are still far from fully understanding it. More generally, it suggests that it would be wise to solve some other small brains before we tackle more complex ones. This suggestion also makes economic sense, when you consider that a single mouse connectome would roughly cost the same as 100,000 small brain connectomes. Perhaps others working in the connectomics field will be inspired by the beautiful work of Ryan, Lu and Meinertzhagen, and turn their attention to the smallest of brains first.
Direct evidence for the role of pigment cells in the brain of ascidian larvae by laser ablationJournal of Experimental Biology 206:1409–1417.https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.00235
The structure of the nervous system of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegansPhilosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 314:1–340.https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.1986.0056
Development of swimming behaviour in the larva of the ascidian Ciona intestinalisJournal of Experimental Biology 209:3405–3412.https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.02421
- Version of Record published: December 6, 2016 (version 1)
© 2016, Bezares-Calderón et al.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.
Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)
Download citations (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)
Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)
Respiratory chemoreceptors regulate breathing in response to changes in tissue CO2/H+. Blood flow is a fundamental determinant of tissue CO2/H+, yet little is known regarding how regulation of vascular tone in chemoreceptor regions contributes to respiratory behavior. Previously, we showed in rat that CO2/H+-vasoconstriction in the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) supports chemoreception by a purinergic-dependent mechanism (Hawkins et al., 2017). Here, we show in mice that CO2/H+ dilates arterioles in other chemoreceptor regions, thus demonstrating CO2/H+ vascular reactivity in the RTN is unique. We also identify P2Y2 receptors in RTN smooth muscle cells as the substrate responsible for this response. Specifically, pharmacological blockade or genetic deletion of P2Y2 from smooth muscle cells blunted the ventilatory response to CO2, and re-expression of P2Y2 receptors only in RTN smooth muscle cells fully rescued the CO2/H+ chemoreflex. These results identify P2Y2 receptors in RTN smooth muscle cells as requisite determinants of respiratory chemoreception.
The presence and identity of neural progenitors in the enteric nervous system (ENS) of vertebrates is a matter of intense debate. Here, we demonstrate that the non-neuronal ENS cell compartment of teleosts shares molecular and morphological characteristics with mammalian enteric glia but cannot be identified by the expression of canonical glial markers. However, unlike their mammalian counterparts, which are generally quiescent and do not undergo neuronal differentiation during homeostasis, we show that a relatively high proportion of zebrafish enteric glia proliferate under physiological conditions giving rise to progeny that differentiate into enteric neurons. We also provide evidence that, similar to brain neural stem cells, the activation and neuronal differentiation of enteric glia are regulated by Notch signalling. Our experiments reveal remarkable similarities between enteric glia and brain neural stem cells in teleosts and open new possibilities for use of mammalian enteric glia as a potential source of neurons to restore the activity of intestinal neural circuits compromised by injury or disease.