Horizontal gene transfer: Learning from losers

Bacteria can overcome environmental challenges by killing nearby bacteria and incorporating their DNA.
  1. Benjamin Kirkup  Is a corresponding author
  1. US Army, United States

The ruthless nature of Darwinian selection does not allow much room for carelessness. So, when a competitor eventually suffers a setback, the obvious response is to leave him in the dust and to snap relentlessly at the heels of anyone further ahead. Now, in eLife, Robert Cooper, Lev Tsimring and Jeff Hasty from the University of California, San Diego report how this may not always be the case (Cooper et al., 2017).

Some organisms, in particular bacteria, have the ability to transfer genetic material from nearby organisms, rather than just between parent and offspring. For many years it was thought that this process, also known as horizontal gene transfer, happened relatively rarely and mostly by accident. Moreover, it was thought that the recipients used the DNA mostly as a source of energy, though incorporation of foreign DNA could drive long-lasting evolutionary trends (Kurland et al., 2003; Nielsen et al., 2014; MacFadyen et al., 2001). In contrast, horizontal gene transfer is increasingly acknowledged as a routine way organisms acquire beneficial and adaptive genes, such as genes that confer resistance against antibiotics and antiseptics. One bacterium can, in effect, ‘learn’ important traits from other bacteria.

Some bacteria can speed up the process of horizontal gene transfer by killing their neighbors in order to get to their DNA. For example, the bacterium Streptococcus pneumoniae secretes toxins to kill sister cells or closely related bacteria, and then extracts their DNA (Steinmoen et al., 2002; Croucher et al., 2016; Wholey et al., 2016). Other bacteria, including the bacterium that causes cholera, use a contact-dependent killing mechanism known as the ‘type VI secretion system’ that involves delivering toxins directly into their victim (Borgeaud et al., 2015).

Cooper et al. placed two distantly related types of bacteria, Acinetobacter baylyi and Escherichia coli, on a surface containing nutrients over which they could grow. E. coli had been modified to produce a fluorescent protein in order to track its fate/whereabouts. The researchers observed that A. baylyi killed E. coli and extracted their DNA, which caused A. baylyi to become fluorescent. Moreover, mutant A. baylyi that had lost the ability to kill were still able to integrate the DNA released when their wild-type siblings killed E. coli. Cooper et al. showed that the extraction of DNA from E. coli and its integration into A. baylyi happened so often it could be observed in real time. A. baylyi that killed the E. coli and released its DNA increased the rate of gene transfer by several orders of magnitude compared to A. baylyi that had been stripped off the ability to kill. This raises the question: what can a bacterium learn from another bacterium that it has just vanquished?

Certain Acinetobacter bacteria thrive in hospital settings, where they can cause serious infections in compromised patients (Oberauner et al., 2013). These bacteria are also able to rapidly develop clinically-impactful antibiotic resistance (Durante-Mangoni et al., 2015). Cooper et al. showed that by killing nearby bacteria, A. baylyi could also acquire genes that made them resistant to antibiotics within hours. The researchers then tested two factors that could theoretically block horizontal gene transfer: enzymes that degrade DNA and irrelevant DNA. The enzymes reduced transfer rates, but the irrelevant DNA did not. Finally, a mathematical model was used to evaluate the experimental data and to simulate a range of conditions that could affect the gene transfer. The simulations showed that killing-enhanced gene transfer was more effective when A. baylyi outnumbered E. coli.

The work of Cooper et al. suggests that horizontal gene transfer rates, and as a particular case, the rate of antibiotic resistance aquisition, could be many orders of magnitude higher than previously thought, therefore challenging current antibiotic-resistance prevention strategies. Moreover, incorporating new genes and thus new abilities into a functioning genome is risky – even more so when the source genome has failed to survive. This risk is, however, minimized if the first bacterium ‘knows’ why the second one has died (that is, it has been killed by the first bacterium) and can, therefore, dismiss the cause of death as irrelevant.

Even under stressful conditions, such as exposure to antibiotics, A. baylyi will still encounter organisms that are able to grow. It will kill them, sample their genomes and may even locate those parts of the genome that enabled the other bacteria to survive (Sandegren and Andersson, 2009). However, it remains unclear to what extent A. baylyi samples the genome of the cells it has killed, and how it regulates the learning process to make it relatively ‘safe’ for themselves.

Bacteria face many selective pressures at any given moment, and most insights obtained through studying interactions between two species will not apply when several species are present (Østman and Adami, 2014; Guimarães et al., 2017). To understand why and how the bacteria learn as they do, we will need to explore DNA exchange under more realistic and multi-dimensional conditions. However, for the moment, Cooper et al. have furthered our understanding in exciting ways.


    1. Østman B
    2. Adami C
    Recent Advances in the Theory and Application of Fitness Landscapes
    509–526, Predicting evolution and visualizing high-dimensional fitness landscapes, Recent Advances in the Theory and Application of Fitness Landscapes, Berlin, Heidelberg, Springer.

Article and author information

Author details

  1. Benjamin Kirkup

    Benjamin Kirkup is in the DoD CWMD Fusion Center, US Army, Ft. Belvoir, United States

    For correspondence
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
    ORCID icon "This ORCID iD identifies the author of this article:" 0000-0002-8722-6218

Publication history

  1. Version of Record published: November 17, 2017 (version 1)


© 2017, Kirkup

This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.


  • 2,315
    Page views
  • 210
  • 1

Article citation count generated by polling the highest count across the following sources: Crossref, PubMed Central, Scopus.

Download links

A two-part list of links to download the article, or parts of the article, in various formats.

Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)

Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)

Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)

  1. Benjamin Kirkup
Horizontal gene transfer: Learning from losers
eLife 6:e32703.

Further reading

    1. Computational and Systems Biology
    2. Structural Biology and Molecular Biophysics
    Artur Meller, Jeffrey M. Lotthammer ... Gregory R Bowman
    Research Article

    The design of compounds that can discriminate between closely related target proteins remains a central challenge in drug discovery. Specific therapeutics targeting the highly conserved myosin motor family are urgently needed as mutations in at least 6 of its members cause numerous diseases. Allosteric modulators, like the myosin-II inhibitor blebbistatin, are a promising means to achieve specificity. However, it remains unclear why blebbistatin inhibits myosin-II motors with different potencies given that it binds at a highly conserved pocket that is always closed in blebbistatin-free experimental structures. We hypothesized that the probability of pocket opening is an important determinant of the potency of compounds like blebbistatin. To test this hypothesis, we used Markov state models (MSMs) built from over 2 milliseconds of aggregate molecular dynamics simulations with explicit solvent. We find that blebbistatin’s binding pocket readily opens in simulations of blebbistatin-sensitive myosin isoforms. Comparing these conformational ensembles reveals that the probability of pocket opening correctly identifies which isoforms are most sensitive to blebbistatin inhibition and that docking against MSMs quantitatively predicts blebbistatin binding affinities (R2=0.82). In a blind prediction for an isoform (Myh7b) whose blebbistatin sensitivity was unknown, we find good agreement between predicted and measured IC50s (0.67 mM vs. 0.36 mM). Therefore, we expect this framework to be useful for the development of novel specific drugs across numerous protein targets.

    1. Computational and Systems Biology
    2. Neuroscience
    Zhe Chen, Garrett J Blair ... Hugh T Blair
    Tools and Resources

    Epifluorescence miniature microscopes ('miniscopes') are widely used for in vivo calcium imaging of neural population activity. Imaging data is typically collected during a behavioral task and stored for later offline analysis, but emerging techniques for online imaging can support novel closed-loop experiments in which neural population activity is decoded in real time to trigger neurostimulation or sensory feedback. To achieve short feedback latencies, online imaging systems must be optimally designed to maximize computational speed and efficiency while minimizing errors in population decoding. Here we introduce DeCalciOn, an open-source device for real-time imaging and population decoding of in vivo calcium signals that is hardware compatible with all miniscopes that use the UCLA Data Acquisition (DAQ) interface. DeCalciOn performs online motion stabilization, neural enhancement, calcium trace extraction, and decoding of up to 1024 traces per frame at latencies of <50 ms after fluorescence photons arrive at the miniscope image sensor. We show that DeCalciOn can accurately decode the position of rats (n=12) running on a linear track from calcium fluorescence in the hippocampal CA1 layer, and can categorically classify behaviors performed by rats (n=2) during an instrumental task from calcium fluorescence in orbitofrontal cortex (OFC). DeCalciOn achieves high decoding accuracy at short latencies using innovations such as field-programmable gate array (FPGA) hardware for real time image processing and contour-free methods to efficiently extract calcium traces from sensor images. In summary, our system offers an affordable plug-and-play solution for real-time calcium imaging experiments in behaving animals.