Main text

Yun Pyo Kang, Laura Torrente, Aimee Falzone, Cody M Elkins, Min Liu, John M Asara, Christian C Dibble, Gina M DeNicola Kang YP, Torrente L, Falzone A, Elkins CM, Liu M, Asara JM, Dibble CC, DeNicola GM. 2019. Cysteine dioxygenase 1 is a metabolic liability for non-small cell lung cancer. eLife 8:e45572. doi: 10.7554/eLife.45572.

Published 20, May 2019

Figure 3, Figure 3—figure supplement 2B, Figure 5—figure supplement 3A and Figure 5—figure supplement 4C have an erroneous label that groups the PC9 cell line with KEAP1 mutant cell lines. This cell line, while previously characterized as having high NRF2 activity (DeNicola GM et al., Nat Genet. 2015 Dec;47(12):1475-81), do not have a KEAP1 mutation. This error does not affect our conclusions, but may lead to confusion in the field about the mutation status of this cell line, which we would like to avoid. Thus, this labelling error is being changed as following.

Correction of figure labels (1-4): KEAP1WT→ NRF2LOW; KEAP1MUT→ NRF2HIGH

1. Figure 3D

After correction
Before correction

2. Figure 3—figure supplement 2B

After correction
Before correction

3. Figure 5—figure supplement 3A

After correction
Before correction

4. Figure 5—figure supplement 4C

After correction
Before correction

Correction of description in figure legends (Changes are underlined):

1. Figure 3

After correction

(d) (Top) Western blot analysis of NRF2, CDO1 and α-Tubulin expression in NRF2LOW and NRF2HIGH (KEAP1 mutant: H1792, HCC15, A549, H322, and H460) NSCLC cell lines expressing CDO1Y157F. (Bottom) Intracellular cysteine concentration of the parental cell lines (minus doxycycline). (Right) Correlation between CDO1 protein levels and intracellular cysteine concentrations. CDO1 protein was normalized to α-Tubulin. N = 13.

Before correction

(d) (Top) Western blot analysis of NRF2, CDO1 and α-Tubulin expression in KEAP1 wild-type and KEAP1 mutant NSCLC cell lines expressing CDO1Y157F. (Bottom) Intracellular cysteine concentration of the parental cell lines (minus doxycycline). (Right) Correlation between CDO1 protein levels and intracellular cysteine concentrations. CDO1 protein was normalized to α-Tubulin. N = 13.

2. Figure 5—figure supplement 3A

After correction

(a) Western blot analysis of GOT1, CSAD and HSP90 levels in NRF2LOW and NRF2HIGH NSCLC cell lines. Mouse liver is included as a positive control for GOT1 and CSAD expression. Cells were fed with fresh RPMI +10% FBS 4 hr prior to lysate collection.

Before correction

(a) Western blot analysis of GOT1, CSAD and HSP90 levels in KEAP1 wild-type and KEAP1 mutant NSCLC cell lines. Mouse liver is included as a positive control for GOT1 and CSAD expression. Cells were fed with fresh RPMI +10% FBS 4 hr prior to lysate collection.

3. Figure 5—figure supplement 4B

After correction

(b) Analysis of cell viability following starvation of NRF2LOW (gray) and NRF2HIGH (red) NSCLC cell lines of cystine for 3 days. Cell numbers were analyzed with crystal violet and normalized to cells grown in cystine-containing media. N = 3 replicates/group.

Before correction

(b) Analysis of cell viability following starvation of KEAP1 wild-type (gray) and KEAP1 mutant (red) NSCLC cell lines of cystine for 3 days. Cell numbers were analyzed with crystal violet and normalized to cells grown in cystine-containing media. N = 3 replicates/group.

4. Figure 5—figure supplement 4C

After correction

(c) Analysis of cell viability following treatment of NRF2LOW (gray) and NRF2HIGH (red) NSCLC cell lines with 0–10 mM Na2SO3 for 3 days. Viable cells were analyzed with CellTiter-Glo and normalized to untreated cells. N = 3 replicates/group.

Before correction

(c) Analysis of cell viability following treatment of KEAP1 wild-type (gray) and KEAP1 mutant (red) NSCLC cell lines with 0–10 mM Na2SO3 for 3 days. Viable cells were analyzed with CellTiter-Glo and normalized to untreated cells. N = 3 replicates/group.

Correction of description in main text (Changes are underlined):

1. After correction

To investigate the NRF2-dependent regulation of CDO1 protein in NSCLC, we generated a doxycycline-inducible lentiviral expression system to reintroduce GFP, CDO1WT or a catalytically inactive CDO1 mutant (Y157F, Ye et al., 2007) at single copy into the panel of NRF2LOW and NRF2HIGH NSCLC cell lines (Figure 3D, figure 3—figure supplement 2). The level of CDO1 protein expression in these cells was similar with the physiological Cdo1 levels in mouse lung and liver (Figure 3—figure supplement 2B), with liver being one of the highest CDO1-expressing tissues that is responsible for supplying TAU to the body (Stipanuk et al., 2015). We find that CDO1 accumulated to higher levels in NRF2HIGH cells than NRF2LOW, although accumulation was observed in many NRF2LOW cell lines as well (Figure 3D).

Before correction

To investigate the NRF2-dependent regulation of CDO1 protein in NSCLC, we generated a doxycycline-inducible lentiviral expression system to reintroduce GFP, CDO1WT or a catalytically inactive CDO1 mutant (Y157F, Ye et al., 2007) at single copy into the panel of KEAP1WT and KEAP1MUT NSCLC cell lines (Figure 3D, figure 3—figure supplement 2). The level of CDO1 protein expression in these cells was similar with the physiological Cdo1 levels in mouse lung and liver (Figure 3—figure supplement 2B), with liver being one of the highest CDO1-expressing tissues that is responsible for supplying TAU to the body (Stipanuk et al., 2015). We find that CDO1 accumulated to higher levels in KEAP1MUT cells than KEAP1WT, although accumulation was observed in many KEAP1WT cell lines as well (Figure 3D).

2. After correction

Next, we examined the toxicity of CDO1 products to NSCLC cell lines. Treatment of cells with CSA and Na2SO3, but not HTAU, led to cytotoxicity (Figure 5—figure supplement 4A). We found that (CYS)2 starvation and Na2SO3 treatment were universally toxic to NSCLC cell lines, which did not depend on NRF2 activity (Figure 5—figure supplement 4B,C). In addition, CDO1, CSA and Na2SO3 sensitized A549 cells to oxidative stress (Figure 5—figure supplement 4D,E), consistent with their ability to deplete (CYS)2. Collectively, these results demonstrate that CSA and SO32- are toxic to NSCLC cells regardless of NRF2 activity, suggesting that resistance to (CYS)2 starvation is not an inherent phenotype of NRF2HIGH cells. Rather, they are sensitive to CDO1 expression due to high intracellular CYS and CDO1 stabilization.

Before correction

Next, we examined the toxicity of CDO1 products to NSCLC cell lines. Treatment of cells with CSA and Na2SO3, but not HTAU, led to cytotoxicity (Figure 5—figure supplement 4A). We found that (CYS)2 starvation and Na2SO3 treatment were universally toxic to NSCLC cell lines, which did not depend on KEAP1 mutation status (Figure 5—figure supplement 4B,C). In addition, CDO1, CSA and Na2SO3 sensitized A549 cells to oxidative stress (Figure 5—figure supplement 4D,E), consistent with their ability to deplete (CYS)2. Collectively, these results demonstrate that CSA and SO32- are toxic to NSCLC cells regardless of KEAP1 mutation status, suggesting that resistance to (CYS)2 starvation is not an inherent phenotype of KEAP1 mutant cells. Rather, they are sensitive to CDO1 expression due to high intracellular CYS and CDO1 stabilization.

The article has been corrected accordingly.

Article and author information

Author details

  1. Yun Pyo Kang

  2. Laura Torrente

  3. Aimee Falzone

  4. Cody M Elkins

  5. Min Liu

  6. John M Asara

  7. Christian C Dibble

Version history

  1. Version of Record published:

Copyright

© 2019, Kang et al.

This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.

Metrics

  • 556
    views
  • 11
    citations

Views, downloads and citations are aggregated across all versions of this paper published by eLife.

Download links

A two-part list of links to download the article, or parts of the article, in various formats.

Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)

Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)

  1. Yun Pyo Kang
  2. Laura Torrente
  3. Aimee Falzone
  4. Cody M Elkins
  5. Min Liu
  6. John M Asara
  7. Christian C Dibble
  8. Gina DeNicola
(2019)
Correction: Cysteine dioxygenase 1 is a metabolic liability for non-small cell lung cancer
eLife 8:e52671.
https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.52671

Share this article

https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.52671