Cyclin-dependent kinase 5 (Cdk5) activity is modulated by light and gates rapid phase shifts of the circadian clock

Reviewer #1 (Public Review):

In the manuscript "Cyclin-dependent kinase 5 (Cdk5) activity is modulated by light and gates rapid phase shifts of the circadian clock", Brenna et al study the role of Cdk5 on circadian rhythms and they conclude that the CDK5 gates the activity of light on phase shifts at ZT by showing that the behavioural shifts to light as a result of CDK5 silencing only affect light-induced phase shifts at ZT/CT 14 but not at other times.

Further, they delineate the mechanism behind this phenotype and demonstrate that 1) CDK5 activity is downregulated following a light pulse via a loss of interaction with p35 and demonstrate this via an activity assay. 2) knock-down of CDK5: increases CREB, CAMK-ii/iv phosphorylation, likely via increasing calcium levels along with alterations to the localisation of Cav3.1, 3) reduces: light-induced response in vivo at ZT14 in the SCN.

They suggest this mechanism involves light 'silencing' CDK5-pathway (possibly by disrupting P35 interaction and dysregulating this pathway) which under basal conditions phosphorylates DARP32 leading to PKA inhibition and by extension reduction in activation of the calcium-calmodulin kinase activity and leading to reduced CREB activity. The authors finally evaluate gene expression changes of previously described light-responsive-genes in at ZT14 and the SCN.

This is an interesting piece of work that explains how circadian responses to light could be gated and is generally well supported by a wealth of data. Whilst I found the overall involvement of CDK5 in gating light response interesting and convincing, I have some concerns about their interpretation of the data surrounding the mechanism, which I have detailed below. I also think this manuscript could be improved with a slightly different structure and concise discussion for the benefit of a broader scientific audience.

Reviewer #2 (Public Review):

Summary:

Definition of the role of CdK5 in circadian locator activity and light induced neural activity in the mouse SCN in-vivo revealing its mode of action through PKA-CaMK-CREB signaling pathway.

Strengths:

The experimental approaches are carried from in-vivo, to cellular and molecular level and provide first evidence for the specific involvement of CdK5 in light-induced phase advance of the free-running rhythm.

Weaknesses:

The behavioral analyses are limited to some selected parameters.
Downstream effects on circadian oscillation of gene expression and physiological functions in other brain regions, and organs is missing.