Motor neurons are dispensable for the assembly of a sensorimotor circuit for gaze stabilization

  1. Dena Goldblatt
  2. Basak Rosti
  3. Kyla Rose Hamling
  4. Paige Leary
  5. Harsh Panchal
  6. Marlyn Li
  7. Hannah Gelnaw
  8. Stephanie Huang
  9. Cheryl Quainoo
  10. David Schoppik  Is a corresponding author
  1. Department of Otolaryngology, Neuroscience & Physiology, and the Neuroscience Institute, NYU Grossman School of Medicine, United States
  2. Center for Neural Science, New York University, United States
5 figures, 7 tables and 1 additional file

Figures

Figure 1 with 2 supplements
phox2a loss-of-function mutants fail to develop nIII/nIV motor neurons and vertical eye rotation behavior.

Associated with Figure 1—figure supplement 2. (A) Schematic of vestibulo-ocular reflex circuitry and the genetic loss-of-function approach used to perturb motor-derived signals. (B) Fluorescent in …

Figure 1—figure supplement 1
Extraocular motor neuron fate is perturbed in phox2a mutants.

(A) Fluorescent in situ hybridization images of nIII/nIV motor neurons, labeled by Tg(isl1:GFP), in wildtype larvae at 2 dpf. Panels from left to right show: (1) isl1+ motor neurons, (2) mRNA for vac…

Figure 1—figure supplement 2
phox2a specifies nIII motor neuron fate in a dose- and birthdate-dependent manner.

(A) Images of nIII/nIV motor neurons, labeled in Tg(isl1:GFP), in wildtype siblings (left) and phox2a heterozygotes (middle) at 5 dpf. Wildtype image same as in Figure 1E. One hemisphere shown. …

Motor neurons are dispensable for proper connectivity between utricular sensory afferents and projection neurons.

Associated with Table 1. (A) Schematic of pitch vestibulo-ocular reflex circuitry. Dashed lines outline projection neurons as calcium imaging target. Nose-down/eyes-up channel represented with blue; …

Motor neurons are dispensable for proper connectivity between semicircular canal sensory afferents and projection neurons.

Associated with Table 1. (A) Schematic of impulse tilt experiments. Yellow dashed lines outline projection neurons as calcium imaging target. Impulse-responsive neurons (ventrally-localized) shown …

Projection neurons are anatomically and molecularly poised to assemble with motor neuron partners in phox2a mutants.

(A) Schematic of retrograde photofill experiments. Projection neuron axons expressing the photolabile protein Kaede are targeted at the midbrain-hindbrain boundary with ultraviolet light. Converted …

Figure 5 with 5 supplements
Motor neurons are dispensable for normal transcriptional profiles of projection neurons.

Associated with Figure 5—figure supplement 1, Figure 5—figure supplement 4, Table 3. (A) Schematic of sequencing approach. Central projection neurons (Tg(–6.7Tru.Hcrtr2:GAL4-VP16);Tg(UAS:E1b-Kaede)) …

Figure 5—figure supplement 1
Flow cytometry gating strategy to sort fluorescently-labeled neurons for bulk RNA sequencing.

(A) Sequential gates used to sort fluorescent neurons labeled with Tg(–6.7Tru.Hcrtr2:GAL4-VP16);Tg(UAS-E1b:Kaede);Tg(isl1:GFP). Gate A excluded presumptive debris (small cells). Gate B isolated …

Figure 5—figure supplement 2
Molecular identification of projection neurons using a reference single-cell RNA sequencing atlas.

(A) UMAP visualization of a single-cell RNA sequencing atlas of n=1,468 neurons labeled in Tg(–6.7Tru.Hcrtr2:GAL4-VP16);Tg(UAS-E1b:Kaede), generated with 10 x Genomics (Materials and methods). Each …

Figure 5—figure supplement 3
Visualization of transcripts in siblings and phox2a null mutants with fluorescent in situ hybridization is (1) consistent across larvae and (2) scales with predicted detection in projection neurons.

(A-A’) Fluorescent in situ hybridization against itga9 for three sibling (A) or phox2a null mutant (A’) larvae (72 hpf), imaged with identical conditions. Left column shows RNA (green); right …

Figure 5—figure supplement 4
Differential gene expression in an unfiltered bulk sequencing dataset of siblings and phox2a mutants.

(A) Volcano plot showing differentially expressed genes across an unfiltered bulk RNA sequencing dataset. Dashed lines represent significance cutoffs: horizontal line, p adjusted>0.05; vertical …

Figure 5—figure supplement 5
phox2a expression in the medial vestibular nucleus may underscore differential gene expression phenotypes in bulk data.

(A) Fluorescent in situ hybridization against phox2a in a 5 dpf larvae (axial view). Top panel shows phox2a RNA (green); bottom panel, merge with neurons visualized with Tg(isl1:GFP);Tg(–6.7Tru.Hcrtr…

Tables

Table 1
Statistical comparisons of tilt responses across genotypes.

WT (sampled) refers to an n=125 neuron subset, sampled with replacement from a reference dataset of wildtype projection neurons. Data shown is mean/standard deviation unless otherwise noted. p val …

WT (all)WT (sampled)phox2a+/+phox2a+/-phox2a-/-p val
Tonic tilt stimuli
n (neurons/fish)255/10125 /x76/5109/6297/16
% observed (nose-up/nose-down/untuned)50/44/737/54/940/54/756/37/744/50/6
ΔF/F, nose-up1.28 ± 1.231.27 ± 1.191.09 ± 1.031.12 ± 0.901.02 ± 0.820.26
ΔF/F, nose-down2.01±1.661.99 ± 1.691.38 ± 0.911.98 ± 1.612.07±1.480.16
directional tuning strength, nose-up0.84 ± 0.280.83 ± 0.300.87 ± 0.260.81 ± 0.280.81 ± 0.290.70
directional tuning strength, nose-down0.72 ± 0.300.72 ± 0.310.73 ± 0.310.77 ± 0.300.68 ± 0.290.54
Impulse stimuli
n (neurons/fish)255/10125 /x76/5109/6297/16
% observed (responsive/unresponsive)58/4257/4357/4360/3970/30
ΔF/F0.41 ± 0.460.33 ± 0.280.29 ± 0.290.22 ± 0.160.32 ± 0.281.0E-05
directional tuning strength0.08 ± 0.360.10 ± 0.380.003 ± 0.410.07 ± 0.480.07 ± 0.410.64
Multiple comparisonsgenotypep valCohen’s d
ΔF/F to impulsesWT to sampledp=0.130.21
WT to +/+p=0.040.27
WT to +/-p=3.8E-060.48
WT to -/-p=0.0060.24
+/+to +/-p=0.470.34
+/+to -/-p=0.890.11
+/-to -/-p=0.020.49
Table 2
Statistical comparisons of projection neuron topography across genotypes.

WT (sampled) refers to an n=125 neuron subset, sampled with replacement from a reference dataset of wildtype projection neurons. Data shown is the median/standard deviation distance from the …

WT (all)WT (sampled)phox2a+/+phox2a+/-phox2a-/-p val
Tonic tilt stimuli
nose-down
n (cells/fish)111/1051 /x41/540/6147/16
dorsoventral20.0 ± 8.425.0 ± 8.415.0 ± 9.025.0 ± 8.720.0 ± 9.10.03
mediolateral17.4 ± 6.017.6 ± 6.519.3 ± 6.615.3 ± 5.616.8 ± 6.60.15
rostrocaudal16.8 ± 9.616.5 ± 9.619.5 ± 9.616.1 ± 10.418.2 ± 9.60.49
global organization0.09
nose-up
n (cells/fish)111/1051 /x41/540/6147/16
dorsoventral30.0 ± 10.325.0 ± 10.827.5 ± 10.925.0 ± 10.430.0 ± 10.50.67
mediolateral14.9 ± 7.115.1 ± 5.916.7 ± 7.018.6 ± 9.813.2 ± 7.29.6E-06
rostrocaudal16.1 ± 9.816.7 ± 10.412.5 ± 10.714.8 ± 10.414.8 ± 10.70.51
global organization2.7E-07
Multiple comparisonsgenotypep valCohen’s d
dorsoventral, nose-downWT to sampled0.860.17
WT to +/+0.540.29
WT to +/-0.960.13
WT to -/-0.080.34
+/+to +/-0.350.41
+/+to -/-0.990.05
+/-to -/-0.070.45
mediolateral, nose-upWT to sampled0.910.03
WT to +/+0.570.35
WT to +/-0.0060.57
WT to -/-0.690.20
+/+to +/-0.740.23
+/+to -/-0.090.55
+/-to -/-5.4E-060.74
Impulse stimuli
n (responsive)148/10138 /n43/555/5214/16
dorsoventral20.0 ± 9.820.0 ± 10.120.0 ± 10.720.0 ± 10.920.0 ± 10.30.57
mediolateral19.0 ± 5.916.1 ± 6.816.7 ± 8.620.4 ± 7.219.8 ± 5.80.003
rostrocaudal21.9 ± 9.917.3 ± 9.815.4 ± 9.113.0 ± 9.922.0 ± 9.52.9E-05
global organization1.2E-0.9
Multiple comparisonsgenotypep valCohen’s d
mediolateral, responsiveWT to sampled0.990.002
WT to +/+0.320.37
WT to +/-9.820.17
WT to -/-0.330.23
+/+to +/-0.910.14
+/+to -/-0.0070.55
+/-to -/-0.050.37
rostrocaudal, responsiveWT to sampled0.980.37
WT to +/+0.120.29
WT to +/-0.0010.53
WT to -/-0.070.10
+/+to +/-0.900.72
+/+to -/-0.950.33
+/-to -/-0.230.21
Table 3
Differentially expressed genes in projection neurons.

Star indicates a gene was evaluated using fluorescent in situ hybridization. # symbol indicates a gene was also differentially expressed in adjacent phox2a-expressing medial vestibular neurons (see F…

Gene% of projection neurons with expressionLog2 fold changep adjusted
Upregulated
* # itga91.923.03.9E-06
si:dkey-54n8.21.39.60.007
myof1.3–8.30.010
gbe1a1.97.00.01
# dysf1.96.90.016
* # twf1b2.55.90.024
cers3a2.59.20.025
asip2b1.38.70.032
# pole1.37.30.041
abtb2a3.14.70.041
* # p4hb6.35.10.044
postnb3.810.10.044
fhdc32.54.50.044
Downregulated
msmo11.3–8.38.4E-06
*rxfp2a4.4–8.51.1E-05
si:ch73-204p21.21.3–9.92.2E-04
tsta30.0–6.66.8E-04
* # satb1a8.2–3.00.001
# polrmt1.9–8.70.002
# znf9751.3–5.00.003
# phldb1a3.1–5.80.004
asns2.5–7.80.032
nr1i21.9–5.50.039
Control
evx236.40.460.99
myt1la80.52.60.44
Table 4
Top 50 expressed genes in an unfiltered bulk RNA sequencing dataset of phox2a siblings.

‘% of unfiltered 10 x neurons’ refers to gene detection in a single-cell atlas of neurons labeled in Tg(–6.7Tru.Hcrtr2:GAL4-VP16);Tg(UAS-E1b:Kaede) (n=1,468 neurons). ‘% of projection neurons’ …

Gene% of unfiltered 10 x neurons with expression% of projection neurons
ints523.215.1
stmn1b78.678.6
sox4a6.53.1
basp161.462.9
hmgb3a68.269.8
ptmaa84.577.4
gapdhs28.930.2
pnrc281.378.6
snap25a65.778.0
gpm6ab81.178.6
calm3b0.00.0
marcksl1b88.886.2
tuba1c59.954.7
cd81a43.349.7
meis1b87.987.4
rtn1a73.474.8
elavl387.182.4
hmgb1b57.249.7
ptmab80.773.6
zc4h256.958.5
meis2b57.149.7
slc25a551.455.3
mab21l262.768.6
h3f3c69.161.6
rtn1b36.433.3
elavl478.767.3
gng337.242.8
pik3r3b77.483.6
tubb525.325.2
histh1l61.062.9
serinc151.959.1
ckbb23.530.8
az1a43.549.7
az1b36.938.4
actb123.628.3
ywhaba36.240.9
ywhag236.250.9
si:ch211-222l21.173.863.5
si:dkey-276j7.145.856.0
aldocb19.317.6
actb227.030.8
tmem59l39.856.6
calm2b37.947.2
hmgn673.665.4
h2afx159.653.5
cd99l232.436.5
cirbpb77.873.6
ppdpfb74.565.4
stxbp1a52.366.0
Control
evx233.836.4
Table 5
Top 50 differentially expressed genes in an unfiltered bulk RNA sequencing dataset of phox2a siblings and null mutants.

One star indicates a gene was retained in a filtered subset of projection neurons; %, evaluated using fluorescent in situ hybridization. ‘% of unfiltered 10 x neurons’ refers to gene detection in an …

Gene% of unfiltered 10 x neurons with expressionPutative originLog2 fold changep adjusted
Upregulated
macc10.1r4-624.03.2E-06
CR559941.10.023.73.4E-06
si:dkey-65b12.60.023.53.4E-06
si:ch73-106n3.20.123.53.4E-06
mcm100.1MNs23.43.4E-06
si:ch211-244o22.20.5r4-623.43.4E-06
dre-mir-10a0.023.33.5E-06
itga40.3r5-6 (inhibitory)23.23.5E-06
si:dkeyp-87d8.80.023.23.6E-06
arsj0.5MNs23.03.9E-06
tlr10.023.03.9E-06
* % itga92.3r4-723.03.9E-06
tofb0.5r4-69.11.4E-05
myo7ba0.4r4-79.81.0E-04
zfand10.1MNs9.01.5E-04
% slc22a7a0.7r4-710.21.5E-04
agrp0.013.44.1E-04
si:dkey-46i9.60.1r5-77.76.8E-04
muc2.20.09.46.9E-04
cd370.09.19.8E-04
musk0.3r4-69.41.2E-03
mcamb0.2r5-78.32.7E-03
ppp1r420.5r5-6 (inhibitory)7.93.1E-03
CR677513.10.09.93.5E-03
Downregulated
* % satb1a7.9r4-7 (inc inhib), MNs–8.61.0E-06
*znf9750.7r4-6–8.31.5E-06
phldb1a0.6r5-7 (inc inhib)–9.21.5E-06
TSTA30.0–9.73.4E-06
si:dkey-24p1.60.0–8.38.4E-06
si:dkey-77f5.140.2r5-7–8.51.1E-05
tha10.1MVN–10.32.1E-05
serpinh20.5r4-6–9.03.7E-05
ghrh0.3r4-7–9.56.9E-05
asah1b0.8r4-7–7.89.9E-05
msmo10.9r5-7, inc inhib–8.91.1E-04
tagln20.3glia–8.42.2E-04
zgc:1748630.1MNs–9.92.2E-04
* % rxfp2a3.2r4-7, inc inhib–6.66.8E-04
bmp40.7r4-7–6.86.8E-04
cfl1l0.1r4-6–8.46.8E-04
* polrmt4.2r4-7, inc inhib–8.86.9E-04
anxa2a0.6r4-7–3.01.3E-03
galr1a0.3MVN–9.11.4E-03
selenow2b0.1–8.01.8E-03
% bckdhbl1.4r4-7, glia, MNs–8.72.1E-03
boka0.5r5-7–8.62.9E-03
cyldb0.2r4-7–7.93.0E-03
pon20.6r4-7, glia, MNs–5.03.1E-03
si:ch73-204p21.20.3r5-7, inc inhib–8.23.5E-03
and20.1r4-6–5.83.7E-03
Control
evx233.8r4-70.460.99
Table 6
Differentially expressed genes in phox2a-expressing medial vestibular neurons.

Star indicates a gene was evaluated in projection neurons using fluorescent in situ hybridization. # indicates a gene was significantly differentially expressed in projection neurons. ‘% of medial …

Gene% of medial vestibular neurons% of projection neuronsLog2 fold changep adjusted
Upregulated
itga42.20.623.23.5E-06
* # itga96.71.923.03.9E-06
musk2.20.69.40.001
# dysf6.71.96.90.016
* # twf1b8.91.95.90.024
gabrr2a2.22.56.80.040
# pole2.20.07.30.041
* # p4hb15.61.35.10.044
col27a1b2.20.68.00.044
Downregulated
asah1b2.20.0–8.31.5E-06
boka2.20.0–9.21.5E-06
* # satb1a6.78.2–3.00.001
# polrmt4.41.9–8.70.002
# znf9752.21.3–5.00.003
# phldb1a2.23.1–5.80.004
fosl1a2.20.0–5.40.016
pitpnaa2.20.0–8.80.036
sgpp12.20.6–7.10.038
Key resources table
Reagent type (species) or resourceDesignationSource or referenceIdentifiersAdditional information
Chemical compound, drugTweenThermo Fisher ScientificBP337-100
Chemical compound, drug32% paraformaldehydeElectron Microscopy Sciences15714
Chemical compound, drugProteinase KThermo Fisher Scientific25530049
Peptide, recombinant proteinPapainWorthington BiochemicalLK003178
Chemical compound, drugHanks Buffered Salt Solution (HBSS)Thermo Fisher Scientific14170112
Chemical compound, drugEarl’s Buffered Salt Solution (EBSS)Thermo Fisher Scientific24010043
Peptide, recombinant proteinDNAseWorthington BiochemicalLK003172
Peptide, recombinant proteinDAPIInvitrogenD1306
Chemical compound, drugL15 MediumThermo Fisher Scientific11415064
Chemical compound, drugFetal bovine serum, qualified, triple-filteredThermo Fisher ScientificA3160501
Peptide, recombinant proteinCollagenase Type 1 ASigma AldrichC9891-500MG
Chemical compound, drugLow melting point agaroseThermo Fisher Scientific16520
Chemical compound, drugEthyl-3-aminobenzoic acid ethyl ester (MESAB)Sigma AldrichE10521
Chemical compound, drugPancuronium bromideSigma AldrichP1918
Commercial assay, kitin situ hybridization chain reaction v3.0 (HCR)Molecular InstrumentsN/A
Commercial assay, kitRNAqueous Micro Total RNA Isolation KitThermo Fisher ScientificAM1931
Commercial assay, kitMEGAshortscript T7 Transcription KitThermo Fisher ScientificAM1354
Commercial assay, kitQiaQUICK PCR Purification KitQiagen28104
Commercial assay, kitEnGen Spy Cas9 NLSNew England BiolabsM0646T
Strain, strain background (Danio rerio)Tg(–6.7Tru.Hcrtr2:GAL4-VP16)Lacoste et al., 2015; Schoppik et al., 2017ZFIN: ZDB-TGCONSTRCT-151028–8
Strain, strain background (Danio rerio)Tg(UAS-E1b:Kaede)Scott et al., 2007ZFIN: ZDB-TGCONSTRCT-070314–1
Strain, strain background (Danio rerio)Tg(isl1:GFP)Higashijima et al., 2000ZFIN: ZDB-ALT-030919–2
Strain, strain background (Danio rerio)Tg(UAS:GCaMP6s)Chen et al., 2013ZFIN: ZDB-TGCONSTRCT-140811–3
Strain, strain background (Danio rerio)phox2ad22This studyN/A
Strain, strain background (Danio rerio)phox2ad19This studyN/A
Strain, strain background (Danio rerio)phox2ai2This studyN/A
Sequence-based reagent (primers)phox2a forward primerSigma AldrichN/ACAGCCAGAGCAACGGCTTCC
Sequence-based reagent (primers)phox2a reverse primerSigma AldrichN/AAAGCCGACAACAGTGTGTGTGTAA
Sequence-based reagent (primers)phox2a guide 1Sigma AldrichN/ACTCGCCACCGCCAGCTGCAC
Sequence-based reagent (primers)phox2a guide 2Sigma AldrichN/ACTCCGGCTTCAGCTCCGGCC
Sequence-based reagent (oligonucleotides)HCR probesIntegrated DNA TechnologiesN/A
Software, algorithmFiji/ImageJSchindelin et al., 2012RRID: SCR_02285
Software, algorithmAdobe Illustrator (2021)AdobeRRID: SCR_010279
Software, algorithmMatlab 2020bMathworksRRID: SCR_001622
Software, algorithmSeurat v4Hao et al., 2021https://satijalab.org/seurat
Software, algorithmCRISPR Guide RNA Design ToolBenchlinghttps://benchling.com/crispr
Other20 micron cell strainerpluriSelect431002060Method details (Neuron harvesting)
OtherSH800z 100 micron sorting chipSonyLE-C3210Method details (Flow cytometry)

Additional files

Download links