Scientists have revealed how a major pest of tea crops can escape the tea plant’s natural catechin defense mechanisms.
A scanning electron micrograph of a female Kanzawa spider mite (Tetranychus kanzawai) on a tea leaf. Image credit: Takeda et al. (CC BY 4.0)
The research, published previously as a Reviewed Preprint in eLife and appearing today as the final Version of Record, is described by the editors as an important study with convincing evidence that links an enzyme, DOG15, with the ability of a spider mite to adapt to and overcome the catechin-based defenses of tea.
Catechins, which are abundant in green tea, are perhaps best known as antioxidants that benefit human health. But for herbivorous pests trying to feast on tea plants, they are a multifaceted defense mechanism – they are toxic, irritate the pest on contact, and inhibit their feeding.
Even the hardiest pests, such as the two-spotted spider mite (TSSM), are unable to tolerate catechins, yet another closely related species, the Kanzawa spider mite (KSM), includes a population of mites that has adapted to feeding on tea and is barely troubled by any of these defenses.
“It is unclear why some herbivores can survive and reproduce on catechin-rich tea plants and others cannot,” says lead author Naoki Takeda, who worked on this study as a doctoral student at the Graduate School of Bio-Applications and Systems Engineering, Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology, Tokyo, Japan. “We wanted to know how these tea-farm populations overcome the catechin defenses and what makes them different from spider mites that cannot.”
To do so, the team grew the tea-adapted and tea-non-adapted populations of KSM and TSSM on tea leaves for 10 days and recorded survival and egg laying. Only the tea-adapted population was able to reproduce. After 10 days, about 90% of the tea-adapted KSM were still alive, compared with about 5% of the tea-non-adapted KSM and about 33% of TSSM, and the latter two laid almost no eggs.
The group then exposed mites to aqueous solutions of the four major green tea catechins and compared their toxicity. For the catechol-type catechins (epicatechin and epicatechin gallate), more than half of the tea-adapted KSM survived even a 10% solution, the highest concentration tested, and far exceeding the concentration tolerated by the TSSM.
The catechins affected not only the mites’ survival but also their behaviour. On glass plates coated with catechins on one side only, the TSSM and the KSM group that had not adapted to tea avoided the coated side because it caused contact irritancy. To test whether they could feed, the group coated leaves with catechins and covered them with a thin film, so the mites could only feed by penetrating the film. Under these conditions, the KSM that had not adapted to tea hardly fed at all. By contrast, the tea-adapted KSM was barely affected by any of the three defenses: toxicity, contact irritancy and feeding inhibition.
Next, the team set out to explore the mechanism underlying the KSM resistance to catechins. They grew the three mite populations on tea leaves and a more favourable host – kidney bean leaves – and compared gene expression and protein levels. The only gene switched on at higher levels on both counts in the tea-adapted KSM population was DOG15, which belongs to a family of enzymes called intradiol ring-cleavage dioxygenases (DOGs) and is a gene the mites acquired from fungi.
In tea-adapted KSM, the amount of DOG15 mRNA was about 20 times higher when the mites were feeding on tea leaves than when the same mites were feeding on kidney bean leaves. It was also about 32 times the level of DOG15 in the TSSM feeding on tea leaves. Moreover, when the team depleted the amount of DOG15, even the tea-adapted KSM struggled to survive. This suggests that high expression of DOG15 is needed for this pest mite to be able to survive on tea leaves.
To find out how this enzyme differs between mite species, they looked at the instructions used to govern the enzyme’s structure – its amino acid sequence. They found just two differences in the amino acid for DOG15 between TSSM and KSM, but when they compared the activity of the two different versions of DOG15, they found the KSM version could break down catechins more efficiently than the TSSM type.
However, the team were interested to see that the amino acid sequences for the tea-adapted and non-adapted KSM were the same. This suggests that the structural change alone is not sufficient to protect against catechins, and that the tea-adapted KSM has also acquired the ability to boost DOG15 production sharply when it feeds on tea.
Green tea is a beverage of choice for senior author Takeshi Suzuki, who drinks it every day. Image credit: Takeshi Suzuki (CC BY 4.0)
“This is the first demonstration that a gene received from fungi has been put to use against plant chemical defenses through two stages of change – structural and regulatory,” Takeda says. “The next step will be to characterise how the enzyme breaks down catechin and whether additional detoxification pathways might contribute to the mite's adaptation.”
For senior author Takeshi Suzuki, Professor at the Graduate School of Bio-Applications and Systems Engineering, Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology, who drinks green tea every day, the importance of this study is very close to home: “I was born in Shizuoka, a major green tea-growing region of Japan, and the tea fields and Mount Fuji were part of my everyday scenery. Back then, I had no idea that such a battle was being fought between tea plants and spider mites in those very fields. I am deeply moved to have been able to reveal part of the ingenious mechanism by which spider mites overcome catechin defenses through the structural change and expression control of an enzyme of fungal origin.”
Media contacts
Emily Packer
eLife
e.packer@elifesciences.org
+441223855373
About
eLife is a non-profit organisation advancing open science by transforming how research is communicated, reviewed, and assessed. By developing open tools and collaborating with research communities, institutions, and funders, we are building a fairer, more effective global research ecosystem. In support of our mission, we introduced our publish-review-curate (PRC) model where every article we review is published as a Reviewed Preprint that includes the article, feedback from the reviewers, and an eLife Assessment summarising the significance of the findings and strength of evidence. eLife is supported by the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation, the Max Planck Society and Wellcome. Learn more at https://elifesciences.org/about.
To read the latest Evolutionary Biology research in eLife, visit https://elifesciences.org/subjects/evolutionary-biology.
And for the latest in Plant Biology, see https://elifesciences.org/subjects/plant-biology.