Author response:
Reviewer #1 (Public review):
Summary:
Review of the manuscript titled " Mycobacterial Metallophosphatase MmpE acts as a nucleomodulin to regulate host gene expression and promotes intracellular survival".
The study provides an insightful characterization of the mycobacterial secreted effector protein MmpE, which translocates to the host nucleus and exhibits phosphatase activity. The study characterizes the nuclear localization signal sequences and residues critical for the phosphatase activity, both of which are required for intracellular survival.
Strengths:
(1) The study addresses the role of nucleomodulins, an understudied aspect in mycobacterial infections.
(2) The authors employ a combination of biochemical and computational analyses along with in vitro and in vivo validations to characterize the role of MmpE.
Weaknesses:
(1) While the study establishes that the phosphatase activity of MmpE operates independently of its NLS, there is a clear gap in understanding how this phosphatase activity supports mycobacterial infection. The investigation lacks experimental data on specific substrates of MmpE or pathways influenced by this virulence factor.
We thank the reviewer for this insightful comment and agree that identification of the substrate of MmpE is important to fully understand its role in mycobacterial infection.
MmpE is a putative purple acid phosphatase (PAP) and a member of the metallophosphoesterase (MPE) superfamily. Enzymes in this family are known for their catalytic promiscuity and broad substrate specificity, acting on phosphomonoesters, phosphodiesters, and phosphotriesters (Matange et al., Biochem J., 2015). In bacteria, several characterized MPEs have been shown to hydrolyze substrates such as cyclic nucleotides (e.g., cAMP) (Keppetipola et al., J Biol Chem, 2008; Shenoy et al., J Mol Biol, 2007), nucleotide derivatives (e.g., AMP, UDP-glucose) (Innokentev et al., mBio, 2025), and pyrophosphate-containing compounds (e.g., Ap4A, UDP-DAGn) (Matange et al., Biochem J., 2015). Although the binding motif of MmpE has been identified, determining its physiological substrates remains challenging due to the low abundance and instability of potential metabolites, as well as the limited sensitivity and coverage of current metabolomic technologies in mycobacteria.
(2) The study does not explore whether the phosphatase activity of MmpE is dependent on the NLS within macrophages, which would provide critical insights into its biological relevance in host cells. Conducting experiments with double knockout/mutant strains and comparing their intracellular survival with single mutants could elucidate these dependencies and further validate the significance of MmpE's dual functions.
We thank the reviewer for the comment. In our study, we demonstrate that both the nuclear localization and phosphatase activity of MmpE are required for full virulence (Figure 3D–E). Importantly, deletion of the NLS motifs did not impair MmpE’s phosphatase activity in vitro (Figure 2F), indicating that its enzymatic function is structurally independent of its nuclear localization. These findings suggest that MmpE functions as a bifunctional protein, with distinct and non-overlapping roles for its nuclear trafficking and phosphatase activity. We have expanded on this point in the Discussion section “MmpE Functions as a Bifunctional Protein with Nuclear Localization and Phosphatase Activity”.
(3) The study does not provide direct experimental validation of the MmpE deletion on lysosomal trafficking of the bacteria.
We thank the reviewer for the comment. The role of Rv2577/MmpE in phagosome maturation has been demonstrated in M. tuberculosis, where its deletion increases colocalization with lysosomal markers such as LAMP-2 and LAMP-3 (Forrellad et al., Front Microbiol, 2020). In our study, we found that mmpE deletion in M. bovis BCG led to upregulation of lysosomal genes, including TFEB, LAMP1, LAMP2, and v-ATPase subunits, compared to the wild-type strain. These results suggest that MmpE may regulate lysosomal trafficking by interfering with phagosome–lysosome fusion.
To further validate MmpE’s role in phagosome maturation, we will perform fluorescence colocalization assays in THP-1 macrophages infected with BCG/wt, ∆mmpE, complemented, and NLS-mutant strains. Co-staining with LAMP1 and LysoTracker will allow us to assess whether the ∆mmpE mutant is more efficiently trafficked to lysosomes.
(4) The role of MmpE as a mycobacterial effector would be more relevant using virulent mycobacterial strains such as H37Rv.
We thank the reviewer for the comment. Previously, the role of Rv2577/MmpE as a virulence factor has been demonstrated in M. tuberculosis CDC 1551, where its deletion significantly reduced bacterial replication in mouse lungs at 30 days post-infection (Forrellad et al., Front Microbiol, 2020). However, that study did not explore the underlying mechanism of MmpE function. In our work, we found that MmpE enhances M. bovis BCG survival in both macrophages (THP-1 and RAW264.7) and mice (Figure 2A-B, Figure 6A), consistent with its proposed role in virulence. To investigate the molecular mechanism by which MmpE promotes intracellular survival, we used M. bovis BCG as a biosafe surrogate and this model is widely accepted for studying mycobacterial pathogenesis (Wang et al., Nat Immunol, 2025; Wang et al., Nat Commun, 2017; Péan et al., Nat Commun, 2017).
Reviewer #2 (Public review):
Summary:
In this paper, the authors have characterized Rv2577 as a Fe3+/Zn2+ -dependent metallophosphatase and a nucleomodulin protein. The authors have also identified His348 and Asn359 as critical residues for Fe3+ coordination. The authors show that the proteins encode for two nuclease localization signals. Using C-terminal Flag expression constructs, the authors have shown that the MmpE protein is secretory. The authors have prepared genetic deletion strains and show that MmpE is essential for intracellular survival of M. bovis BCG in THP-1 macrophages, RAW264.7 macrophages, and a mouse model of infection. The authors have also performed RNA-seq analysis to compare the transcriptional profiles of macrophages infected with wild-type and MmpE mutant strains. The relative levels of ~ 175 transcripts were altered in MmpE mutant-infected macrophages and the majority of these were associated with various immune and inflammatory signalling pathways. Using these deletion strains, the authors proposed that MmpE inhibits inflammatory gene expression by binding to the promoter region of a vitamin D receptor. The authors also showed that MmpE arrests phagosome maturation by regulating the expression of several lysosome-associated genes such as TFEB, LAMP1, LAMP2, etc. These findings reveal a sophisticated mechanism by which a bacterial effector protein manipulates gene transcription and promotes intracellular survival.
Strength:
The authors have used a combination of cell biology, microbiology, and transcriptomics to elucidate the mechanisms by which Rv2577 contributes to intracellular survival.
Weakness:
The authors should thoroughly check the mice data and show individual replicate values in bar graphs.
We kindly appreciate the reviewer for the advice. We will update the relevant mice data in the revised manuscript.
Reviewer #3 (Public review):
Summary:
In this manuscript titled "Mycobacterial Metallophosphatase MmpE Acts as a Nucleomodulin to Regulate Host Gene Expression and Promote Intracellular Survival", Chen et al describe biochemical characterisation, localisation and potential functions of the gene using a genetic approach in M. bovis BCG and perform macrophage and mice infections to understand the roles of this potentially secreted protein in the host cell nucleus. The findings demonstrate the role of a secreted phosphatase of M. bovis BCG in shaping the transcriptional profile of infected macrophages, potentially through nuclear localisation and direct binding to transcriptional start sites, thereby regulating the inflammatory response to infection.
Strengths:
The authors demonstrate using a transient transfection method that MmpE when expressed as a GFP-tagged protein in HEK293T cells, exhibits nuclear localisation. The authors identify two NLS motifs that together are required for nuclear localisation of the protein. A deletion of the gene in M. bovis BCG results in poorer survival compared to the wild-type parent strain, which is also killed by macrophages. Relative to the WT strain-infected macrophages, macrophages infected with the ∆mmpE strain exhibited differential gene expression. Overexpression of the gene in HEK293T led to occupancy of the transcription start site of several genes, including the Vitamin D Receptor. Expression of VDR in THP1 macrophages was lower in the case of ∆mmpE infection compared to WT infection. This data supports the utility of the overexpression system in identifying potential target loci of MmpE using the HEK293T transfection model. The authors also demonstrate that the protein is a phosphatase, and the phosphatase activity of the protein is partially required for bacterial survival but not for the regulation of the VDR gene expression.
Weaknesses:
(1) While the motifs can most certainly behave as NLSs, the overexpression of a mycobacterial protein in HEK293T cells can also result in artefacts of nuclear localisation. This is not unprecedented. Therefore, to prove that the protein is indeed secreted from BCG, and is able to elicit transcriptional changes during infection, I recommend that the authors (i) establish that the protein is indeed secreted into the host cell nucleus, and (ii) the NLS mutation prevents its localisation to the nucleus without disrupting its secretion.
We kindly appreciate the reviewer for the advice and will include the relevant experiments in the revised manuscript. The localization of WT MmpE and the NLS mutated MmpE will be tested in the BCG infected macrophages.
Demonstration that the protein is secreted: Supplementary Figure 3 - Immunoblotting should be performed for a cytosolic protein, also to rule out detection of proteins from lysis of dead cells. Also, for detecting proteins in the secreted fraction, it would be better to use Sauton's media without detergent, and grow the cultures without agitation or with gentle agitation. The method used by the authors is not a recommended protocol for obtaining the secreted fraction of mycobacteria.
We agree with the reviewer and we will further validate the secretion of MmpE using the tested protocol.
Demonstration that the protein localises to the host cell nucleus upon infection: Perform an infection followed by immunofluorescence to demonstrate that the endogenous protein of BCG can translocate to the host cell nucleus. This should be done for an NLS1-2 mutant expressing cell also.
We will add this experiment in the revised manuscript.
(2) In the RNA-seq analysis, the directionality of change of each of the reported pathways is not apparent in the way the data have been presented. For example, are genes in the cytokine-cytokine receptor interaction or TNF signalling pathway expressed more, or less in the ∆mmpE strain?
We thank the reviewer for pointing this out and fully agree that conventional KEGG pathway enrichment diagrams do not convey the directionality of individual gene expression changes within each pathway. While KEGG enrichment analysis identifies pathways that are statistically overrepresented among differentially expressed genes, it does not indicate whether individual genes within those pathways are upregulated or downregulated.
To address this, we re-analyzed the expression trends of DEGs within each significantly enriched KEGG pathway. The results show that key immune-related pathways, including cytokine–cytokine receptor interaction, TNF signaling, NF-κB signaling, and chemokine signaling, are collectively upregulated in THP-1 macrophages infected with ∆mmpE strain compared to those infected with the wild-type BCG strain. The full list of DEGs will be provided in the supplementary materials. The complete RNA-seq dataset has been deposited in the GEO database, and the accession number will be included in the revised manuscript.
(3) Several of these pathways are affected as a result of infection, while others are not induced by BCG infection. For example, BCG infection does not, on its own, produce changes in IL1β levels. As the author s did not compare the uninfected macrophages as a control, it is difficult to interpret whether ∆mmpE induced higher expression than the WT strain, or simply did not induce a gene while the WT strain suppressed expression of a gene. This is particularly important because the strain is attenuated. Does the attenuation have anything to do with the ability of the protein to induce lysosomal pathway genes? Does induction of this pathway lead to attenuation of the strain? Similarly, for pathways that seem to be downregulated in the ∆mmpE strain compared to the WT strain, these might have been induced upon infection with the WT strain but not sufficiently by the ∆mmpE strain due to its attenuation/ lower bacterial burden.
We thank the reviewer for the comment. We will update qRT-PCR data with the uninfected macrophages as a control in the revised manuscript.
Wild-type Mycobacterium bovis BCG strain still has the function of inhibiting phagosome maturation (Branzk et al., Nat Immunol, 2014; Weng et al., Nat Commun, 2022). Forrellad et al. previously identified Rv2577/MmpE as a virulence factor in M. tuberculosis and disruption of the MmpE gene impairs the ability of M. tuberculosis to arrest phagosome maturation (Forrellad et al., Front Microbiol, 2020). In our study, transcriptomic and qRTPCR data (Figures 4C and G, S4C) show that deletion of mmpE in M. bovis BCG leads to upregulation of lysosomal biogenesis and acidification genes, including TFEB, LAMP1, and vATPase. To further validate MmpE’s role in phagosome maturation, we will perform fluorescence colocalization assays in THP-1 macrophages infected with BCG/wt, ∆mmpE, complemented, and NLS-mutant strains. Co-staining with LAMP1 and LysoTracker will assess whether the ∆mmpE mutant is more efficiently trafficked to lysosomes.
Furthermore, CFU assays demonstrated that the ∆mmpE strain exhibits markedly reduced bacterial survival in both human THP-1 and murine RAW264.7 macrophages, as well as in mice, compared to the wild-type strain (Figures 4A and C, 6A). These findings suggest that the loss of MmpE compromises bacterial survival, likely due to enhanced lysosomal trafficking and acidification. This supports previous studies showing that increased lysosomal activity promotes mycobacterial clearance (Gutierrez et al., Cell, 2004; Pilli et al., Immunity, 2012).
(4) CHIP-seq should be performed in THP1 macrophages, and not in HEK293T. Overexpression of a nuclear-localised protein in a non-relevant line is likely to lead to several transcriptional changes that do not inform us of the role of the gene as a transcriptional regulator during infection.
We thank the reviewer for the comment. We performed ChIP-seq in HEK293T cells is based on the fact that this cell line is widely used in ChIP-based assays due to its high transfection efficiency, robust nuclear protein expression, and well-annotated genome (Lampe et al., Nat Biotechnol, 2024; Marasco et al., Cell, 2022). These features make HEK293T an ideal system for the initial identification of genome wide chromatin binding profiles of novel nuclear effectors such as MmpE.
Furthermore, we validated the major observations in THP-1 macrophages, including (i) RNAseq of THP-1 cells infected with either WT BCG or ∆mmpE strains revealed significant transcriptional changes in immune and lysosomal pathways (Figure 4A); (ii) Integrated analysis of CUT&Tag and RNA-seq data identified 298 genes in infected THP-1 cells that exhibited both MmpE binding and corresponding expression changes. Among these, VDR was validated as a direct transcriptional target of MmpE using EMSA and ChIP-PCR (Figures 5E-J, S5D-F). Notably, the signaling pathways associated with MmpE-bound genes, including PI3K-Akt-mTOR signaling and lysosomal function, substantially overlap with those transcriptionally modulated in infected THP-1 macrophages (Figures 4B-G, S4B-C, S5C-D), further supporting the biological relevance of the ChIP-seq data obtained from HEK293T cells.
(5) I would not expect to see such large inflammatory reactions persisting 56 days postinfection with M. bovis BCG. Is this something peculiar for an intratracheal infection with 1x107 bacilli? For images of animal tissue, the authors should provide images of the entire lung lobe with the zoomed-in image indicated as an inset.
We thank the reviewer for the comment. The lung inflammation peaked at days 21–28 and had clearly subsided by day 56 across all groups (Figure 6B), consistent with the expected resolution of immune responses to an attenuated strain like M. bovis BCG. This temporal pattern is in line with previous studies using intravenous or intratracheal BCG vaccination in mice and macaques, which also demonstrated robust early immune activation followed by resolution over time (Smith et al., Nat Microbiol, 2025; Darrah et al., Nature, 2020).
In this study, the infectious dose (1×10⁷ CFU intratracheally) was selected based on previous studies in which intratracheal delivery of 1×10⁷CFU produced consistent and measurable lung immune responses and pathology without causing overt illness or mortality (Xu et al., Sci Rep, 2017; Niroula et al., Sci Rep, 2025). We will provide whole-lung lobe images with zoomed-in insets in the revised manuscript.
(6) For the qRT-PCR based validation, infections should be performed with the MmpEcomplemented strain in the same experiments as those for the WT and ∆mmpE strain so that they can be on the same graph, in the main manuscript file. Supplementary Figure 4 has three complementary strains. Again, the absence of the uninfected, WT, and∆mmpE infected condition makes interpretation of these data very difficult.
We thank the reviewer for the comment. As suggested, we will conduct the qRT-PCR experiment including the uninfected, WT, ∆mmpE, Comp-MmpE, and the three complementary strains infecting THP-1 cells. The updated data will be provided in the revised manuscript.
(7) The abstract mentions that MmpE represses the PI3K-Akt-mTOR pathway, which arrests phagosome maturation. There is not enough data in this manuscript in support of this claim. Supplementary Figure 5 does provide qRT-PCR validation of genes of this pathway, but the data do not indicate that higher expression of these pathways, whether by VDR repression or otherwise, is driving the growth restriction of the ∆mmpE strain.
We thank the reviewer for the comment. The role of MmpE in phagosome maturation was previously characterized. Disruption of mmpE impairs the ability of M. tuberculosis to arrest lysosomal trafficking (Forrellad et al., Front Microbiol, 2020). In this study, we further found that MmpE suppresses the expression of key lysosomal genes, including TFEB, LAMP1, LAMP2, and ATPase subunits (Figure 4G), suggesting MmpE is involved in arresting phagosome maturation. As noted, the genes in the PI3K–Akt–mTOR pathway are upregulated in ∆mmpE-infected macrophages (Figure S5C).
To functionally validate this, we will conduct two complementary experimental approaches:
(i) Immunofluorescence assays: We will assess phagosome maturation and lysosomal fusion in THP-1 cells infected with BCG/wt, ∆mmpE, Comp-MmpE, and NLS mutant strains. Colocalization of intracellular bacteria with LAMP1 and LysoTracker will be quantified to determine whether the ∆mmpE strain is more efficiently trafficked to lysosomes.
(ii) CFU assays: We will perform CFU assays in THP-1 cells infected with BCG/wt or ∆mmpE in the presence or absence of PI3K-Akt-mTOR pathway inhibitors (e.g., Dactolisib), to assess whether activation of this pathway contributes to the intracellular growth restriction observed in the ∆mmpE strain.
(8) The relevance of the NLS and the phosphatase activity is not completely clear in the CFU assays and in the gene expression data. Firstly, there needs to be immunoblot data provided for the expression and secretion of the NLS-deficient and phosphatase mutants. Secondly, CFU data in Figure 3A, C, and E must consistently include both the WT and ∆mmpE strain.
We thank the reviewer for the comment. We will provide immunoblot data for the expression and secretion of the NLS-deficient and phosphatase mutants. Additionally, we will revise Figure 3A, 3C, and 3E to consistently include both the WT and ΔmmpE strains in the CFU assays.
Reference
Branzk N, Lubojemska A, Hardison SE, Wang Q, Gutierrez MG, Brown GD, Papayannopoulos V (2014) Neutrophils sense microbe size and selectively release neutrophil extracellular traps in response to large pathogens Nat Immunol 15:1017-25.
Darrah PA, Zeppa JJ, Maiello P, Hackney JA, Wadsworth MH 2nd, Hughes TK, Pokkali S, Swanson PA 2nd, Grant NL, Rodgers MA, Kamath M, Causgrove CM, Laddy DJ, Bonavia A, Casimiro D, Lin PL, Klein E, White AG, Scanga CA, Shalek AK, Roederer M, Flynn JL, Seder RA (2020) Prevention of tuberculosis in macaques after intravenous BCG immunization Nature 577:95-102.
Forrellad MA, Blanco FC, Marrero Diaz de Villegas R, Vázquez CL, Yaneff A, García EA, Gutierrez MG, Durán R, Villarino A, Bigi F (2020) Rv2577 of Mycobacterium tuberculosis Is a virulence factor with dual phosphatase and phosphodiesterase functions Front Microbiol 11:570794.
Gutierrez MG, Master SS, Singh SB, Taylor GA, Colombo MI, Deretic V (2004) Autophagy is a defense mechanism inhibiting BCG and Mycobacterium tuberculosis survival in infected macrophages Cell 119:753-66.
Innokentev A, Sanchez AM, Monetti M, Schwer B, Shuman S (2025) Efn1 and Efn2 are extracellular 5'-nucleotidases induced during the fission yeast response to phosphate starvation mBio 16: e0299224.
Keppetipola N, Shuman S (2008) A phosphate-binding histidine of binuclear metallophosphodiesterase enzymes is a determinant of 2',3'-cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase activity J Biol Chem 283:30942-9.
Lampe GD, King RT, Halpin-Healy TS, Klompe SE, Hogan MI, Vo PLH, Tang S, Chavez A, Sternberg SH (2024) Targeted DNA integration in human cells without double-strand breaks using CRISPR-associated transposases Nat Biotechnol 42:87-98.
Marasco LE, Dujardin G, Sousa-Luís R, Liu YH, Stigliano JN, Nomakuchi T, Proudfoot NJ, Krainer AR, Kornblihtt AR (2022) Counteracting chromatin effects of a splicing-correcting antisense oligonucleotide improves its therapeutic efficacy in spinal muscular atrophy Cell 185:2057-2070.e15.
Matange N, Podobnik M, Visweswariah SS (2015) Metallophosphoesterases: structural fidelity with functional promiscuity Biochem J 467:201-16.
Niroula N, Ghodasara P, Marreros N, Fuller B, Sanderson H, Zriba S, Walker S, Shury TK, Chen JM (2025) Orally administered live BCG and heat-inactivated Mycobacterium bovis protect bison against experimental bovine tuberculosis Sci Rep 15:3764.
Péan CB, Schiebler M, Tan SW, Sharrock JA, Kierdorf K, Brown KP, Maserumule MC,
Menezes S, Pilátová M, Bronda K, Guermonprez P, Stramer BM, Andres Floto R, Dionne MS (2017) Regulation of phagocyte triglyceride by a STAT-ATG2 pathway controls mycobacterial infection Nat Commun 8:14642.
Pilli M, Arko-Mensah J, Ponpuak M, Roberts E, Master S, Mandell MA, Dupont N, Ornatowski W, Jiang S, Bradfute SB, Bruun JA, Hansen TE, Johansen T, Deretic V (2012) TBK-1 promotes autophagy-mediated antimicrobial defense by controlling autophagosome maturation Immunity 37:223-34.
Shenoy AR, Capuder M, Draskovic P, Lamba D, Visweswariah SS, Podobnik M (2007) Structural and biochemical analysis of the Rv0805 cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis J Mol Biol 365:211-25.
Smith AA, Su H, Wallach J, Liu Y, Maiello P, Borish HJ, Winchell C, Simonson AW, Lin PL, Rodgers M, Fillmore D, Sakal J, Lin K, Vinette V, Schnappinger D, Ehrt S, Flynn JL (2025) A BCG kill switch strain protects against Mycobacterium tuberculosis in mice and non-human primates with improved safety and immunogenicity Nat Microbiol 10:468-481.
Wang J, Ge P, Qiang L, Tian F, Zhao D, Chai Q, Zhu M, Zhou R, Meng G, Iwakura Y, Gao GF, Liu CH (2017) The mycobacterial phosphatase PtpA regulates the expression of host genes and promotes cell proliferation Nat Commun 8:244.
Wang J, Li BX, Ge PP, Li J, Wang Q, Gao GF, Qiu XB, Liu CH (2015) Mycobacterium tuberculosis suppresses innate immunity by coopting the host ubiquitin system Nat Immunol 16:237–245
Weng Y, Shepherd D, Liu Y, Krishnan N, Robertson BD, Platt N, Larrouy-Maumus G, Platt FM (2022) Inhibition of the Niemann-Pick C1 protein is a conserved feature of multiple strains of pathogenic mycobacteria Nat Commun 13:5320.
Xu X, Lu X, Dong X, Luo Y, Wang Q, Liu X, Fu J, Zhang Y, Zhu B, Ma X (2017) Effects of hMASP2 on the formation of BCG infection-induced granuloma in the lungs of BALB/c mice Sci Rep 7:2300.
