Highly sensitive in vivo detection of dynamic changes in enkephalins following acute stress

Reviewer #1 (Public Review):

Summary:

The present study by Mikati et al demonstrates an improved method for in-vivo detection of enkephalin release and studies the impact of stress on the activation of enkephalin neurons and enkephalin release in the nucleus accumbens (NAc). The authors refine their pipeline to measure met and leu enkephalin using liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry. The authors subsequently measured met and leu enkephalin in the NAc during stress induced by handling, and fox urine, in addition to calcium activity of enkephalinergic cells using fiber photometry. The authors conclude that this improved tool for measuring enkephalin reveals experimenter handling stress-induced enkephalin release in the NAc that habituates and is dissociable from the calcium activity of these cells, whose activity doesn't habituate. The authors subsequently show that NAc enkephalin neuron calcium activity does habituate to fox urine exposure, is activated by a novel weigh boat, and that fox urine acutely causes increases in met-enk levels, in some animals, as assessed by microdialysis.

Strengths:

A new approach to monitoring two distinct enkephalins and a more robust analytical approach for more sensitive detection of neuropeptides. A pipeline that potentially could help for the detection of other neuropeptides.

Weaknesses:

Some of the interpretations are not fully supported by the existing data or would require further testing to draw those conclusions. This can be addressed by appropriately tampering down interpretations and acknowledging other limitations the authors did not cover brought by procedural differences between experiments.

Reviewer #2 (Public Review):

Summary:

The authors aimed to improve the detection of enkephalins, opioid peptides involved in pain modulation, reward, and stress. They used optogenetics, microdialysis, and mass spectrometry to measure enkephalin release during acute stress in freely moving rodents. Their study provided better detection of enkephalins due to the implementation of previously reported derivatization reaction combined with improved sample collection and offered insights into the dynamics and relationship between Met- and Leu-Enkephalin in the Nucleus Accumbens shell during stress.

Strengths:

A strength of this work is the enhanced opioid peptide detection resulting from an improved microdialysis technique coupled with an established derivatization approach and sensitive and quantitative nLC-MS measurements. These improvements allowed basal and stimulated peptide release with higher temporal resolution, lower detection thresholds, and native-state endogenous peptide measurement.

Weaknesses:

The draft incorrectly credits itself for the development of an oxidation method for the stabilization of Met- and Leu-Enk peptides. The use of hydrogen peroxide reaction for the oxidation of Met-Enk in various biological samples, including brain regions, has been reported previously, although the protocols may slightly vary. Specifically, the manuscript writes about "a critical discovery in the stabilization of enkephalin detection" and that they have "developed a method of methionine stabilization." Those statements are incorrect and the preceding papers that relied on hydrogen peroxide reaction for oxidation of Met-Enk and HPLC for quantification of oxidized Enk forms should be cited. One suggested example is Finn A, Agren G, Bjellerup P, Vedin I, Lundeberg T. Production and characterization of antibodies for the specific determination of the opioid peptide Met5-Enkephalin-Arg6-Phe7. Scand J Clin Lab Invest. 2004;64(1):49-56. doi: 10.1080/00365510410004119. PMID: 15025428.

Another suggestion for this draft is to make the method section more comprehensive by adding information on specific tools and parameters used for statistical analysis:

1. Need to define "proteomics data" and explain whether calculations were performed on EIC for each m/z corresponding to specific peptides or as a batch processing for all detected peptides, from which only select findings are reported here. What type of data normalization was used, and other relevant details of data handling? Explain how Met- and Leu-Enk were identified from DIA data, and what tools were used.

2. Simple Linear Regression Analysis: The text mentions that simple linear regression analysis was performed on forward and reverse curves, and line equations were reported, but it lacks details such as the specific variables being regressed (although figures have labels) and any associated statistical parameters (e.g., R-squared values).

3. Violin Plots: The proteomics data is represented as violin plots with quartiles and median lines. This visual representation is mentioned, but there is no detail regarding the software/tools used for creating these plots.

4. Log Transformation: The text states that the data was log-transformed to reduce skewness, which is a common data preprocessing step. However, it does not specify the base of the logarithm used or any information about the distribution before and after transformation.

5. Two-Way ANOVA: Two-way ANOVA was conducted with peptide and treatment as independent variables. This analysis is described, but there is no information regarding the software or statistical tests used, p-values, post-hoc tests, or any results of this analysis.

6. Paired T-Test: A paired t-test was performed on predator odor proteomic data before and after treatment. This step is mentioned, but specific details like sample sizes, and the hypothesis being tested are not provided.

7. Correlation Analysis: The text mentions a simple linear regression analysis to correlate the levels of Met-Enk and Leu-Enk and reports the slopes. However, details such as correlation coefficients, and p-values are missing.

8. Fiber Photometry Data: Z-scores were calculated for fiber photometry data, and a reference to a cited source is provided. This section lacks details about the calculation of z-scores, and their use in the analysis.

9. Averaged Plots: Z-scores from individual animals were averaged and represented with SEM. It is briefly described, but more details about the number of animals, the purpose of averaging, and the significance of SEM are needed.

A more comprehensive and objective interpretation of results could enhance the overall quality of the paper.

Reviewer #3 (Public Review):

Summary:

This important paper describes improvements to the measurement of enkephalins in vivo using microdialysis and LC-MS. The key improvement is the oxidation of met- to prevent having a mix of reduced and oxidized methionine in the sample which makes quantification more difficult. It then shows measurements of enkephalins in the nucleus accumbens in two different stress situations - handling and exposure to predator odor. It also reports the ratio of released met- and leu-enkephalin matching what is expected from the digestion of proenkephalin. Measurements are also made by photometry of Ca2+ changes for the fox odor stressor. Some key takeaways are the reliable measurement of met-enkephalin, the significance of directly measuring peptides as opposed to proxy measurements, and the opening of a new avenue into the research of enkephalins due to stress based on these direct measurements.

Strengths:

-Improved methods for measurement of enkephalins in vivo.

-Compelling examples of using this method.

-Opening a new area of looking at stress responses through the lens of enkephalin concentrations.

Weaknesses:

1. It is not clear if oxidized met-enk is endogenous or not and this method eliminates being able to discern that.

2. It is not clear if the spatial resolution is really better as claimed since other probes of similar dimensions have been used.

3. Claims of having the first concentration measurement are not quite accurate.

4. Without a report of technical replicates, the reliability of the method is not as well-evaluated as might be expected.