Figures and data
(a) Domain organization of full-length (FL) BTK and the BTK linker-kinase domain (LKD) fragment used in this study: PHTH, Pleckstrin homology-Tec homology domain; PRR, proline-rich region; SH3, Src homology 3 domain; SH2, Src homology 2 domain, SH2-kinase linker (L) and the catalytic kinase domain. Key residues are indicated above each domain. (b) Autoinhibited conformation of FL BTK based on the crystal structure of FL BTK [40]. The PHTH domain (purple) is dynamic, in transient contact with several regions on the core SH3-SH2-kinase domain and is not visible in the crystal structure of full-length BTK [40]. Dynamics of the PHTH domain is represented by the multiple poses of the PHTH domain and the double headed arrow. (c) Co-crystal structure of BTK LKD (light cyan cartoon) bound to Ibrutinib (PDB ID: 5P9J) showing the location of C481 (yellow spheres), T474 and L528 (red spheres) within the kinase active site (broken oval). (c) Pie charts showing the prevalence of the BTK resistance mutations in CLL patients treated with various BTK inhibitors. The total number of patients with mutations in BTK are indicated below each chart. See Supp. Table 1 for additional details.
The BTK kinase domain can interconvert between active and inactive conformations. (a) Superposition of the structure of BTK linker-kinase domain (LKD) bound to Dasatinib (PDB ID: 3K54) in the active kinase conformation (grey cartoon) with the Ibrutinib bound structure (PDB ID: 5P9J) in the inactive conformation (red cartoon). The expanded inset shows the inward movement of the αC-helix, the change in W395 rotamer conformation and the K430/E445 salt bridge formation that accompanies kinase activation. (b-f) Co-crystal structures of BTK LKD (light cyan cartoon) bound to Ibrutinib (PDB ID: 5P9J), Acalabrutinib (PDB ID: 8FD9), Zanubrutinib (PDB ID: 6J6M), Tirabrutinib (PDB ID: 5P9M) and Pirtobrutinib (PDB ID: 8FLL) in the inactive kinase conformation. The inhibitors are shown as dark blue sticks, the kinase activation loop is purple and C481, Y551 and W395 residues are shown as sticks with transparent spheres. Electron density for part of the activation loop is missing in the Ibrutinib co-crystal structure and is indicated as dotted lines (b). In the Acalabrutinib structure, the activation loop has several mutations [36] and the SH2-kinase linker (including W395) is absent (c). Electron density for W395 sidechain is missing in the BTK:Pirtobrutinib co-crystal structure (f). (g) Overlay of the BTK:Ibrutinib, Acalabrutinib, Zanubrutinib, Tirabrutinib and Pirtobrutinib co-crystal structures. With the exception of the Tirabrutinib co-crystal structure (e), no major structural variation is observed in the kinase domains. The activation loop in the Tirabrutinib bound structure adopts a different conformation compared to the other co-crystal structures.
BTK inhibitors stabilize the inactive kinase conformation in solution. The tryptophan side chain region of the 1H-15N TROSY HSQC spectra of 15N-labelled apo BTK linker-kinase domain (black spectrum) overlaid with that of the inhibitor bound spectrum (cyan spectrum). Here and in subsequent figures, the broken black and grey lines indicate the position of the BTK W395 resonance in the active (αC-in) and inactive (αC-out) states respectively as shown in Figure 2a. The shift in the BTK W395 resonance upon inhibitor binding is indicated by an arrow in each spectrum. The structures of each inhibitor are shown on the right. The BTK W395 indole NH resonance is in the inactive (αC-out) position in the Ibrutinib (published earlier [16]), Acalabrutinib, Zanubrutinib and Tirabrutinib bound BTK LKD samples. Multiple peaks corresponding to W395 are seen in the Tirabrutinib bound spectrum suggesting that the kinase adopts multiple conformations in solution. The downfield shift observed in W395 in the Pirtobrutinib bound structure is likely due to local changes in the chemical environment due to the distinct chemical structure of Pirtobrutinib. W395 assignments in the inhibitor bound spectra were confirmed by acquiring inhibitor bound spectra with the BTK LKD W395A mutant (see Supp. Fig. S1).
Assessing the impact of BTK inhibitors on full-length BTK by HDX-MS. (a) Intact mass analysis of wild-type FL BTK before (bottom spectrum, black) and after one hour incubation with a 2-fold molar excess of covalent BTK inhibitors: Ibrutinib (red), Acalabrutinib (purple), Zanubrutinib (blue) and Tirabrutinib (orange) show a mass increase of one inhibitor molecule. (b) Clinically approved BTK inhibitors induce allosteric changes in full-length BTK. Relative deuterium level of peptides in apo BTK was subtracted from the deuterium level of the corresponding peptide from each drug-bound form of BTK (D WT drug-bound-D WT apo) and the differences colored according to the scale shown. In this and subsequent figures, peptic peptides are shown from N- to C-terminus, top to bottom, and the amount of time in deuterium is shown left to right. The relative difference data shown here represents a curated set of peptides that are coincident across all 6 states (apo and five drug-bound BTK forms). The identification of these chosen peptides, the relative difference values, and the complete data set for each state can be found in the Supplemental Datafile. The approximate position of the domains of BTK, as described in Figure 1a, is shown at the left. Deuterium incorporation curves of selected peptides (indicated with a gray box in panel b and labelled i-vi) from various regions of the protein are shown below. Data for Ibrutinib has been previously published [16].
(a-e) Mapping the HDX-MS changes induced by each BTK inhibitor on the structure of the BTK SH3-SH2-kinase fragment (PDB ID: 4XI2). Major differences greater than 1.0 Da are shown as dark blue (decrease) or dark green (increase); modest differences between 0.5 Da and 1.0 Da are shown as light blue (decrease) and light green (increase). Localization of the changes in deuterium incorporation was accomplished using overlapping peptides included in the complete peptide data set provided in the Supplemental Datafile. The location of peptides i – vi from Figure 4 are indicated in panel a. Data corresponding to Ibrutinib has been previously published [16].
Probing the impact of the BTK resistance mutations T474I and L528W on BTK. (a-d) Western blot comparing the kinase activity of full-length (FL) BTK wild-type (WT), T474I and L528W mutants. BTK autophosphorylation was monitored using the BTK pY551 antibody and the total protein levels monitored using the Anti-His antibody. (b, d) Histogram quantifying the western blots shown in (a and c). The blots were quantified and normalized as described in the Materials and Methods. Data shown are the average of three independent experiments. (e) HDX difference data for the BTK T474I and L528W mutants (DMutant apo -DWT apo). Color scale and peptide/time course arrangement are the same as in Figure 4. See the Supplemental Datafile for additional information, including all peptide identifications and deuterium values. (f,g) Mapping the mutational induced HDX-MS changes on the structure of the BTK SH3-SH2-kinase fragment. (h) Deuterium incorporation curves of selected peptides (indicated with a gray box in panel e and labelled i-iv) from various regions of the protein are shown. (i) The tryptophan side chain region of the 1H-15N TROSY HSQC spectra of 15N-labelled apo WT BTK linker-kinase domain (black spectrum) overlaid with that of the apo mutant kinase spectrum (cyan spectrum). The boxed region in the T474I spectral overlay is expanded above.
The BTK L528W mutant can activate HCK. (a-f) Kinase activity of HCK in the presence or absence of full-length BTK L528W mutant was compared in a western blot assay by monitoring PLCγ1 phosphorylation (pY783 antibody) and HCK autophosphorylation (pY antibody). Total protein levels monitored using the Anti-His antibody. Full-length WT BTK preincubated with Zanubrutinib was used as a control. (b, d and f) Histogram quantifying the western blots shown in (a, c and e). The blots were quantified and normalized as described in the Materials and Methods. Data shown are the average of three independent experiments. (b and c) Kinase activity of HCK in the presence or absence of the isolated linker kinase domain (LKD) fragment of the BTK L528W mutant (b) or the full-length proline mutant of BTK L528W (BTK FL L528W/Pro: BTK L528W/ P189A/P192A/P203A/P206A, (c)) was compared as in (a). (g) Thermal stability analysis of BTK FL WT and BTK FL L528W. Data shown are the average of three independent experiments.
HDX-MS analysis of BTK inhibitor binding to BTK T474I and L528W mutants. (a-d) Relative deuterium level of peptides in apo mutant BTK was subtracted from the deuterium level of the corresponding peptide from each inhibitor-bound form of BTK (Ddrug-bound-Dapo) and compared to the changes in the WT protein. The differences are colored according to the scale shown. (e) Deuterium incorporation curves of selected peptides (indicated with a gray box in panels a-c, and labelled i-iv) are shown.
NMR analysis of BTK inhibitor binding to the BTK T474I and L528W mutants. The tryptophan side chain region of the 1H-15N TROSY HSQC spectra of 15N-labelled apo BTK linker-kinase domain (black spectrum) overlaid with that of the inhibitor bound spectrum (cyan spectrum). The broken black and grey lines indicate the position of the BTK W395 resonance and have been described earlier in Figure 3. The shift in the BTK W395 indole NH resonance upon inhibitor binding is indicated by an arrow in each spectrum. The red asterisks indicate the presence of unbound kinase domain in the inhibitor bound NMR sample.
Half-life of clinically approved BTK inhibitors: Ibrutinib[64], Acalabrutinib [65], Zanubrutinib [66], Tirabrutinib [67] and Pirtobrutinib [68].
Assignment of W395 in inhibitor bound spectra of BTK LKD. The tryptophan side chain region of the 1H-15N TROSY HSQC spectra of 15N-labelled inhibitor bound BTK linker-kinase domain WT (black spectrum) overlaid with that of the inhibitor bound BTK LKD W395A spectrum (cyan spectrum). The boxed peak indicates the W395 resonance in each of the WT inhibitor bound spectrum.
