Abstract
Rapidly dividing cells can eliminate slow growing neighbors through the apoptotic process of cell competition. This process ensures that only high fitness cells populate embryonic tissues and is proposed to underlie the ability of oncogene-transformed cells to progressively replace normal cells within a tissue. Patches of cells in the Drosophila wing disc overexpressing the oncogenic Taiman (Tai) transcriptional coactivator kill normal neighbors by secreting Spätzle ligands that trigger pro-apoptotic Toll signaling in receiving cells. However, extracellular signaling mechanisms responsible for elimination of slow growing cells by normal neighbors remain poorly defined. Here we show that slow growing cells with reduced Tai (Tailow) are killed by normal neighbors through a mechanism involving competition for the Wingless (Wg/Wnt) ligand. Elevated Wg signaling significantly rescues elimination of Tailow cells in multiple organs, suggesting that Tai may normally promote Wg activity. Examining distribution of Wg components reveals that Tai promotes extracellular spread of the Wg ligand from source cells across the wing disc, thus ensuring patterned expression of multiple Wg-regulated target genes. Tai controls Wg spread indirectly through the extracellular glypican Dally-like protein (Dlp), which binds Wg and promotes its extracellular diffusion and capture by receptors. Data indicate that Tai likely controls Dlp at two levels: transcription of dlp mRNA and Dlp intracellular trafficking. Overall, these data indicate that the Tai acts through Dlp to enable Wg transport and signaling, and that cell competition in the Tailow model arises due to inequity in the ability of epithelial cells to sequester limiting amounts of the Wg growth factor.
Introduction
The development of an organism is a tightly controlled process, with multiple signaling pathways converging to achieve correct patterning, morphogenesis, and cell fates. As the earliest cells begin to populate tissues, it is advantageous that the fittest progenitors give rise to the entire organism. One example of this is in the formation of the epiblast—early embryonic cells go through a selection process, where more fit cells with higher amounts of pluripotency factors such as TEAD or Myc outcompete cells with a relatively lower dose of these factors[1,2]. This process of pruning unfit cells and selection of fitter cells for survival is known as “cell competition.”
The phenomenon of cell competition was first described in the context of Drosophila melanogaster cells with defective ribosomal protein function, termed “Minutes”, that could survive when surrounded by like cells but died in a heterotypic environment mixed with wildtype cells[3]. Cells that die in a heterotypic environment are called “losers,” as they undergo apoptosis through mechanisms triggered by neighboring cells termed “winners”. A variety of apoptotic mechanism have been proposed to underlie loser fate, including exposure to the pro-apoptotic cytokine Spätzle (Spz) produced by oncogene transformed ‘winners’[4–6], non-autonomous induction of autophagy[7,8], loss of apicobasal polarity[9], and inequities in expression of the transmembrane factor Flower[10], the secreted protein SPARC[11], or the Ca+2 binding protein Azot[12]. Altering the dose of the dMyc oncogene has also been proposed to generate competitive differences by altering the ability of cells to compete for limiting amounts of the Dpp morphogen[13,14].
In previous work we found evidence that wing cells overexpressing the conserved coactivator and oncogene Taiman (Tai; human AIB/SRC3/NCOA3) kill neighboring cells by overproduction and secretion of Spz ligands, in particular Spz4[6], which is similar to a proposed mechanism by which excess Myc confers winner status[4]. Intriguingly, Drosophila cells with reduced Tai expression are viable, proliferate more slowly than normal cells, and generate small but properly patterned organs [15]. However, they have not been tested for their fitness status, and whether they become losers that resemble cells with reduced levels of the dMyc oncogene (i.e., Myclow cells, as in [4,5]). Here we have used a homozygous viable allele of tai that behaves as a weak hypomorph to investigate the role of Tai in cell competition. We find that larval wing disc cells with reduced Tai (Tailow) survive in a homotypic environment but are eliminated by neighboring wildtype cells in a heterotypic environment of clonal mosaics. A genetic screen to identify pathways involved in competitive elimination of Tailow cells identifies alleles of the Wnt/Wg pathway inhibitor Adenomatous polyposis coli (APC) as suppressors of Tailow elimination, suggesting that Tailow elimination may be due to a deficit of Wg signaling. Examining the Tai-Wg link more closely reveals that Tai is required for formation of the Wg gradient in the larval wing pouch and for patterned activation and repression of Wg target genes at different points along the Wg gradient. We trace this defect to a role for Tai in promoting levels and intracellular trafficking of the Dally-like protein (Dlp) glypican, which binds extracellular Wg and facilities its movement away from source cells. Evidence suggests that Tai is a key determinant of the effect of Dlp on Wg steady-state levels: excess Dlp triggers Wg accumulation in Tai-depleted cells, but triggers Wg loss in cells that also express Tai. Dlp accumulates intracellularly in Tailow clones, confirming a link between Tai and Dlp trafficking. Given that cells lacking Apc are ‘winners’ in the wing pouch and adult intestine[16,17], we propose that Tai regulates competitive status though an underlying developmental role in promoting Dlp-dependent Wg capture and signaling. As a result, cells with reduced Tai are disadvantage with normal neighbors for capture of limiting amounts of Wg.
Results
Cells with reduced Tai are selectively killed in clonal mosaics
Combining the weak, viable hypomorph taik15101 with a deletion (Df ED678) that completely removes the second copy of tai produces small but normally patterned adults with proportionally smaller organs[15]. Larval wing discs from these taik15101/Df animals contain background levels of apoptotic cells (Fig. 1A-A’,D) suggesting that wing size reduction is the result of a proliferative deficit rather than surplus apoptosis. This hypothesis is consistent with our previous finding that Tai promotes cell division in the larval wing[15]. Generating boundaries between taik15101 cells (taik15101,FRT40A) and normal cells (FRT40A) using the Flp-FRT mosaic system results in significantly elevated cleaved Dcp-1 (cDCP-1) caspase within taik15101 clones (Fig. 1B-B”, C-C”, D), indicative of apoptosis. This excess cDcp1 is especially evident in taik15101 clones located in the wing pouch, a developing epithelium that is widely used to assess competitive status [4,18]. These data show that pouch cells with one hypomorphic tai allele (i.e., taik15101/Df) are viable when surrounded by like cells, but that cells with two copies of the taik15101hypomorph die when surrounded by taiwtcells. These data indicate the existence of an extracellular competition mechanism that allows normal taiwt cells to kill taik15101(hereafter tailow) neighbors.
Elimination of tailow cells requires Wg, Hippo, and canonical apoptosis pathways
A mini-w+minigene present in the taik15101 hypomorph generates red pigment that visually marks tailow heterozygous or homozygous cells in the adult eye. As in the larval wing disc, taik15101/Df cells readily populate an adult eye composed of alike cells, but patches of tailow cells form small clones when placed in competition with control (white−;FRT40A) cells using an eye-specific Flpase transgene (eyFLP) (Fig. 2A-B). By comparison, cells carrying a mini-w+ marked FRT40 chromosome occupy approximately 50% of the adult eye.
To identify genes and pathways involved in elimination of tailoweye cells, a collection of mutant alleles of candidate competition factors (Supplemental Table 1) were screened for dominant rescue of tailowsmall clone size in the adult eye (Fig. 2C-H). This approach yielded ‘hits’ in the pro-apoptotic Rpr-Hid-Grim (RHG) factors (hid1and the H99 deletion), the Hippo pathway kinase warts (wts1), and the Wg pathway inhibitor Adenomatous polyposis coli (ApcMI01007). Alleles affecting components of the Spz-Toll, IMD, or ecdysone pathways did not obviously modify tailow clone size, nor did alleles of other candidate factors such as the transmembrane proteins flower and Sas, the transcription factors p53 and Xrp1, the autophagy factor Atg1, and the secreted glycoprotein Sparc [8-11,19-22] (data not shown). These genetic data confirm separate elements of tailow loser fate: rescue by hid1and H99 provide genetic evidence that elimination of tailowcells requires the canonical RHG-Diap1-Caspase pathway (rev. in [23]), while rescue by wts1 is consistent with Tai protecting against the “loser” fate through Yorkie, which is bound by Tai and phosphorylated by Wts[15,24,25]. By contrast, tailow rescue by Apc suggests an unexpected link between Tai competitive status and Wg signaling. A second Apc mutation (ApcQ8) in combination with an inactivating allele in its paralog Apc2 (Apc2N175A) similarly increases survival of tailow cells in the eye (Fig. 2H).
The larval wing pouch is bisected along the D-V (dorsoventral) midline by a stripe of Wg-expressing cells that generate mirror image gradients (dorsal and ventral) that guide wing growth and patterning[26]. Quantification of tailow clone size within the larval wing pouch at 50hrs post induction (hsFlp) indicates that RHG, wts, or Apc/Apc2 alleles recovered in the eye screen also increase the size of tailow pouch cells (Figure 3A-H), with H99 and the compound ApcQ8,Apc2N175A allele having the largest effects. H99 and Apc alleles also enhance recovery of 76hr old tailow clones, which are normally eliminated by this time point (Fig. S1). Together, these data indicate that competitive elimination of tailow cells requires RHG proteins and can be attenuated by derepressing the Wg or Hippo pathways.
Tai modulates transcription of Wg-regulated genes and formation of the Wg gradient
The extended survival of 76hr tailow clones in Apc and Apc,Apc2 heterozygous backgrounds imply a relatively strong link between Tai and Wg signaling. To test sensitivity of Wg pathway activity to Tai dosage, UAS transgenes were used to test whether tai overexpression or reduction affects transcription of two Wg target genes: naked cuticle (nkd), a mid-threshold target of the Wg gradient that is expressed in bands of cells on either side of the DV midline[27] (nkd-lacZ), and wg itself, which is repressed by an autoinhibition loop that refines wg transcription to a narrow stripe at the DV midline[28] (wg-lacZ). Tai overexpression (en>tai) expands nkd-lacZ expression into dorsal and ventral domains that correspond to distal tails of the Wg gradient and normally express low nkd (Fig. 4A-A”, B-B”, see brackets, and 4D-E). Tai depletion strongly retards nkd-lacZ in regions close to the DV midline that normally receive high Wg (Fig. 4C-C”, D-E). Examining wg transcription with the wg-lacZ transgene shows that tai RNAi (enGal4) causes wg-lacZ to spread dorsally and ventrally away from the DV margin (Fig. 5B-B’, see arrow), while reciprocally elevating tai has little effect on wg transcription (Fig. 5C-C’). These data are consistent with Tai acting as a positive upstream regulator of Wg signaling in pouch cells, such that activation of nkd and autoinhibition of wg each fail when Tai is removed.
Failure to constrain wg-lacZ activity to DV margin cells in Tai-depleted discs (see Fig. 5B’) resembles the effect of mutations that block receipt of the Wg ligand[28]. Examination of the Wg gradient in pouch cells with reduced Tai in the posterior domain (en>tai RNAi) detects robust Wg in source cells but significant reduction in Wg spreading into the dorsal and ventral pouch (Fig. 6A vs. 6C, arrows). This loss of the Wg gradient occurs despite expansion of the wg expression domain in Tai RNAi pouches (see Fig. 5B-B’). Overexpression of Tai produces gaps in the stripe of Wg protein in DV cells (Fig. 6B, arrows) that also does correlate with a loss of wg transcription (see Figs. 5C-C’), suggestive of a post-transcriptional effect of excess Tai on Wg stability, uptake, or trafficking in the DV regions. Quantification of anti-Wg staining intensity confirms that Tai RNAi blocks formation of the Wg gradient and indicates that Tai overexpression elevates Wg in regions further from the DV margin (Figs. 6D-E). Considered together, these data are consistent with a requirement for Tai in forming the Wg gradient by control of Wg protein extracellular diffusion and/or internalization and turnover.
Tai is required for expression of Dally-like protein, a glypican required for Wg signaling
The GPI-anchored glypican Dally-like protein (Dlp) binds lipidated Wg and facilitates its extracellular diffusion and capture by Frizzled receptor[29–33]. Notably, homozygous loss of Apc produces competitive ‘winners’ by upregulating the secreted enzyme, Notum, which then cleaves Dlp and deprives normal neighbors of the ability to sequester or sense Wg[17]. Given that Apc heterozygosity rescues tailow elimination, tai alleles were tested for modulation of Dlp levels in the larval pouch. Excess Tai significantly elevates Dlp protein among posterior cells (en>tai) and Tai depletion had the opposite effect of depleting Dlp (Figs. 7A-C and graphs in 7D-E). Expression of the Dlp-related glypican Dally[34] also rises upon Tai overexpression but is insensitive to Tai depletion (dally-lacZ; Figs. S2A-C), other than shrinkage of the dally-lacZ pattern due to reduced Posterior (P)-domain size due to Tai loss (arrows Figs. S2A’ vs. S2C’). These data indicate that Tai is rate-limiting for Dlp expression in the pouch and may be able to induce dally expression when overexpressed.
Examining Dlp dynamics further, we find that RNAi depleting the extracellular protein Pentagone, which promotes Dlp/Dally glypican internalization and turnover[34], produces little change in Dlp levels among Tai-depleted cells (Fig. S3A-C, see bracketed regions). RNA-seq analysis of Tai-expressing wing discs detects elevated dlp mRNA, indicating that Tai may control dlp mRNA abundance (Fig. S4). Consistent with this hypothesis, EcR CUT&RUN analysis [35] in 3rd instar larval wing discs detects EcR binding peaks on the broad and dlp loci; dlp is flanked by two EcR peaks with another located in a dlp intron (Fig. S4). Orthogonal slices that traverse the Wg stripe of en>tai discs from control (anterior) to Tai overexpressing (posterior) regions confirm that Tai overexpression lowers Wg protein levels (Fig. S5). Notably, expression of a dlp transgene causes Wg accumulation on the DV flanks of Tai-depleted wing discs (Fig. 7E-E’), indicating that tai RNAi cells are similar to wt cells and retain Wg when provided extra Dlp[31]. However, expression of dlp together with tai (en>tai,dlp) has a reciprocal effect of enhancing Wg loss protein at the DV margin (Fig 7F-F’) and Wg build-up on the dorsal hinge (asterisk in 7G’). Given that Tai expression with the same driver (en>tai) elevates Wg transcriptional output across the pouch (see Figs. 4-5), this loss of Wg may be due to enhanced trafficking and/or uptake. These data suggest that Tai status determines the effect of excess Dlp on Wg levels: Dlp depletes Wg levels across the pouch cells when excess Tai is present but retains Wg in Tai-depleted cells. A reciprocal test of a Dlp role in Tai overexpressing discs indicates that two different dlp RNAi lines do not rescue gaps in the Wg stripe that appear with Tai-overexpressing (arrows, Fig. S6A-D). These data indicate that Tai status determines the effect of excess Dlp on Wg, but that excess Tai may engage a different mechanism to modulate Wg protein in DV margin cells.
In the course of these analyses, we noted that wild type Tai or a version of the protein lacking PPxY motifs required to bind Yki [15] (TaiPPxA) drive accumulation of Dlp protein across the pouch (enGal4) (Fig. S7A-B) including in the DV midline region where Dlp is normally excluded (e.g., see arrows in Fig. 7A). Under normal circumstances, Dally is expressed in this region (e.g., see Fig. S2) and promotes short range Wg signaling from source cells[36]. Consistent with this local dependence on Dally, Tai-depletion only in DV midline cells with a wing margin driver (big bang (bbg)-Gal4) has only a mild effect on distribution of Wg protein; however, providing exogenous Tai to these cells broadens the Wg-positive domain (Fig. 8A-C). Given that Tai does not elevate wg transcription (see Fig. 5C), this finding indicates that overexpressing Tai in DV midline cells is sufficient to enhance local spread of Wg protein and increase abundance of Wg-positive puncta (in Fig. 8B’) which have been shown to correspond to secretory vesicles[37]. Thus, expression of Tai in source cells enhances Wg secretion, while expression in the DV flanks can cooperate with excess Dlp to deplete Wg across the Posterior (P) -domain.
Dlp protein is altered in tailow clones
Relative to the lethal tai RNAi transgene (e.g., with actin5c-Gal4[38]), the viable tailow allele is predicted to yield correspondingly weaker phenotypes. To improve recovery of comparatively rare tailow pouch clones, hsFlp was applied in the H99/+ background (see Fig 3). In this configuration, tailow pouch clones contain elevated levels of Dlp relative to adjacent control cells (arrows, Fig. 9A-A”). This result suggests that tailow could perturb Dlp intracellular traffic, either during secretion or internalization. To test this model, Dlp was reanalyzed in tailowclones under conditions that do not permeabilize membranes; this approach detects only basal levels of Dlp on the surface of control and tailow disc cells (Fig. 9B-B”). Indeed, closer inspection of tailowhypomorphic clones in tangential slices indicates that Dlp is mislocalized to the cytoplasm (Fig. 9C-D). Given that removing Pent, which stimulates Dlp internalization[34], does not rescue Dlp loss in Tai RNAi cells, Tai may promote both dlp mRNA expression and Dlp protein secretion, and that the consequent decline in ability to compete for Wg with normal neighbors deprives tailow cells of a signal necessary for growth and survival.
Discussion
Here we show that cells with a reduced dose of the Tai coactivator, which functions in the ecdysone and Hippo pathways[15,39], are killed by normal neighbors through a mechanism involving competition for the Wingless (Wg/Wnt) ligand. Elevated Wg signaling significantly rescues elimination of Tailow cells in multiple organs, suggesting that Tai may normally promote Wg activity. Examining distribution of Wg components reveals that Tai promotes extracellular spread of the Wg ligand from source cells across the wing disc, thus ensuring patterned expression of multiple Wg-regulated target genes. Tai controls Wg spread indirectly through the extracellular glypican Dally-like protein (Dlp), which binds Wg and promotes its extracellular diffusion and capture by receptors. Data indicate that Tai likely controls Dlp at two levels: transcription of dlp mRNA and Dlp intracellular trafficking. Overall, these data indicate that the Tai acts through Dlp to enable Wg transport and signaling, and that cell competition in the Tailow model arises due to inequity in the ability of epithelial cells to sequester limiting amounts of the Wg growth factor.
One key conclusion from these data is the mechanism through which Taihigh cells kill normal neighbors (e.g., through Spz-Toll)[6] is distinct from the mechanism that eliminates Tailow cells. The former mechanism is produced by triggering an innate immune pathway and may require priming by chronic microbial infection[18], while the latter derives from a developmental role in Dlp-mediated Wg diffusion and turnover (this study). These mechanisms may both occur in vivo, although in different contexts, with Taihigh overexpression mimicking oncogene activation in cancer, and Tailow representing cells in developing tissues that receive weaker proliferative or survival signals than neighbors. In the developing wing disc, gradual scaling of the Wg gradient as the tissue grows ensures that adjacent cells experience only incremental changes in concentration of pro-growth morphogens[40]. Artificially steepening of a gradient, as occurs in pent mutant wing discs[21], or creating patches of cells deficient in morphogen capture (e.g., with tailow or taiRNAi) or signaling (e.g., as in Wg pathway mutants[17]) within an otherwise intact gradient each create sharp differences in morphogen activity. This model is supported by the finding that artificial boundaries between glypican expressing and non-expressing cells is sufficient to induce cell competition among Drosophila follicle stem cells[41]. Intriguingly, dlp follicle clones are ‘winners’ while dally clones are ‘losers’, which implies different roles for Wg in survival of pouch cells vs. follicle stem cells.
The finding that tai alleles perturb Dlp expression, retard the Wg gradient, and interact with Apc alleles in eye and wing epithelia seems to suggest that Tai gain and loss phenotypes in these tissues may be driven in part by changes in Wg signaling. It remains to be determined whether Tai acts broadly across multiple tissues and developmental stages to modulate Wg, or whether this role is limited to specific cell types. As Tai is a transcriptional coactivator it is likely to mediate its Wg regulatory effects through other factors that directly contact DNA. The identity of this factor(s) is unclear. One candidate is the ecdysone receptor EcR, which brings Tai into a transcriptional regulatory complex whose components are conserved across metazoans (i.e., ERα-NCOA3-p300)[42]. The role of EcR in innate immune transcription[43] is consistent with our finding that EcR is involved in intertissue invasion led by Taihigh cells[6]. However, the role of an EcR-Tai complex in death of Tailow cells has not been examined. Ecdysone can promote (or ‘gate’) activity of both major morphogen gradients in the wing disc[44], and the presence of EcR CUT&RUN peaks in the dlp genomic region (see Fig. S4) seems to imply EcR may have some role in Dlp expression. EcR can also repress wg transcription in areas of the pouch[45], much as we have found that Tai represses wg transcription on either side the DV margin (see Fig. 5B). However further work is required to determine whether either of these roles requires an EcR-Tai complex. Mild rescue of tailow elimination by a wts allele indicates that slight elevation of Yki activity can promote tailowsurvival. However, the ability of the non-Yki binding form of Tai, TaiPPxA, to efficiently induce Dlp accumulation in pouch cells is not consistent with a requirement for Tai to bind Yki during the competition process. Alternatively, Tai may modulate Wg signaling independent of interactions with EcR and Yki, perhaps through other transcription factors. Determining Tai-binding partners involved in regulation of the Wg pathway and establishing Tai transcriptional targets whose products modulate secretion and/or endocytosis of glypicans could yield broad insight into mechanisms that calibrate morphogen diffusion in development and disease.
Lead contact and resource availability
Requests for resources and reagents should be directed to and will be fulfilled by Lead Contact (kmoberg@emory.edu).
Acknowledgements
We thank the Emory Integrated Cellular Imaging Core for their expertise and assistance. We also thank E. J. M. Storkebaum, the Developmental Studies Hybridoma Band (DSHB), Bloomington Drosophila Stock Center (BDSC), the Harvard Transgenic RNAi Project (TRiP), and the Vienna Drosophila Stock Center for antibodies and stocks. We also thank members of Moberg laboratory for their helpful discussion. This work was funded by NIH T32 GM008367-30, NIH F31 Predoctoral Fellowship CA254207 (CKS), and NIH R01 GM121967 (KHM)
Materials and Methods
Drosophila culture
Fly stocks were maintained under standard culture conditions at 25°C, 12 hr light:dark cycles in humidity-controlled incubators. Experiments used a mix of female and male animals. All crosses were maintained on standard molasses food supplemental with yeast. Unless specified, flies were mated and allowed to lay eggs for a period of 24-48 hours, and then dissected at wandering third instar. Lines used are referred to in Key Resources Table (BDSC stock numbers indicated).
Strategy for randomization and/or stratification
Animals of both sexes were used for experiments. A minimum of 10 total imaginal wing discs over three biological replicates were used in all experiments. Figures presented are representative images of each genotype.
Adult eye screen
Adult females were aged for three days to allow condensation of pigment granules then frozen at −20°C for >5 minutes before imaging with a Nikon SMZ800N microscope at 25X magnification (2.5X objective x 10X eyepiece) using a Leica MC170HD camera and a Nii-LED High intensity LED illuminator. Flies were submerged in 70% ethanol to eliminate glare. Multiple focal planes were imaged and merged in Photoshop to generate a final image.
Cell Competition Assays
Mated flies were allowed to lay for 24 hrs before flipping into a new vial. 48-50 hrs after egg lay (AEL), FLP recombinase was induced by heat-shocking of the larvae at 37°C for about one hour, except for in the generation of “Flp-out” clones where larvae were heat-shocked for 1.5 hrs. Third instar larvae were then dissected at 96 hrs AEL. Both male and female larvae were dissected. Clonal areas were measured using ImageJ, and only clones in the wing pouch were considered for analysis.
Immunofluorescence and microscopy
Immunofluorescence and microscopy were performed using standard methods. Briefly, wing discs were dissected in 1X phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), fixed for 20 minutes in 4% paraformaldehyde (PFA) at room temperature (RT), rinsed 5X in 1X PBS, and then permeabilized with 1X PBS and 0.3% Triton X-100 (0.3% PBST). For extracellular stain without permeabilization, the protocol was performed as in [46]. Discs were then blocked with 10% normal goat serum (NGS) and then incubated in diluted primary antibody containing 10% NGS and 1X PBS and 0.1% Triton X-100 (0.1% PBST). Samples incubated in primary antibody solution at 4°C overnight, washed 5X with 0.1% PBST, incubated with DAPI (1:500) for 5 minutes, washed 3X with 0.1% PBST, and then incubated for 1 hr at RT with secondary antibody solution diluted with 10% NGS and 0.1% PBST. Discs were then washed 5X times with 0.1% PBST and incubated in n-propyl gallate (NPG, 4% w/v in glycerol) overnight. Discs were mounted in NPG on glass coverslips and then imaged with a Nikon A1R confocal system using 20X and 40X objectives. Images were processed with Fiji, Photoshop, and Illustrator software. ImageJ was used for clonal area measurements. Refer to Key Resources Table for full list of antibodies, dilutions, and other reagents used.
Fluorescence intensity analysis
Fluorescence intensities were measured across equal regions of interest (ROIs) using Image J/Fiji. Briefly, the ROI was positioned such that it was: 1) centered over the AP boundary as defined by the en>GFP control channel, 2) below the DV line (approximately halfway between the DV boundary and the bottom of the pouch), and 3) extended approximately halfway into each compartment (anterior and posterior). Raw fluorescence intensity values were standardized such that the mean anterior fluorescence was equal to 1, and posterior fluorescence was relative to anterior. Analyses and fluorescence intensity plots were performed and created in R (R version 4.1.1 (2021-08-20)). Posterior: anterior mean fluorescence intensity ratios were plotted, and statistics performed using GraphPad Prism. Unpaired t-tests with Welch’s corrections were performed.
Quantitation and Statistical Analyses
Unpaired Student’s t-tests or one-way ANOVAs (GraphPad Prism) were used to analyze significance between datasets. Significance was considered to be p<0.05. Normal distributions were assumed.
Key resources table
Supplemental Figure Legends
Figure S1. H99 and Apc alleles allow tailowcells to survive 76hrs after clonal induction. Wing discs bearing 76hr old (post-hs) pouch clones of (A) FRT40A cells or (B-G) tailow cells in the indicated genetic backgrounds. Clones are GFP-negative and twinspots are bright green. (H) Clone:Twinspot area ratios (pixels) of the same genotypes as in A-G. Note significant rescue of tailow survival by H99 and Apc heterozygosity. ****p <0.001 ***p = 0.0007, ns = not significant (One-way ANOVA with Dunnett post hoc test).
Figure S2. dally does not respond to Tai depletion but can be induced by excess Tai. (A-C) Expression of the dally-lacZ reporter detected by anti-ßgal stain (greyscale) in (A-A”) control (en>GFP,RFP), (B-B”) Tai overexpressing (en>tai,GFP), or (C-C”) Tai-depleted (en>taiRNAi,GFP) discs. Arrows in A’ and C’ indicate shrunken pattern of dally-lacZ expression in a Tai-depleted Posterior (P)-domain.
Figure S3. RNAi of Pent, which promotes Dlp internalization, does not fully restore Dlp in Tai-depleted disc regions. Anti-Dlp signal in (A-A”) control (en>GFP), (B-B”) Tai-depleted (en>tailow) discs, or discs (C-C”) co-depleted for Tai and Pent (en>taiRNAi+pentRNAi). Brackets denote P-domain with Dlp depletion with tai RNAi.
Figure S4. Evidence of dlp transcription regulated by Tai. Top (A): IGV traces of RNA-seq reads from control (green; en>GFP) and Tai-expressing (red; en>tai) larval wing discs laid over (middle-B) a genomic map of the dlp region. Bottom (C): EcR-association peaks in the dlp region (published in 35).
Figure S5. Excess Tai downregulates Wg levels within source cells at the DV margin. Wg signal (greyscale) in a Tai overexpressing disc (en>tai,GFP) imaged en face (A-A’) and (B-B’) tangential slices corresponding to region 1 and region 2 in magnified view (B-B’). Panel C and associated regions 1 and 1 show equivalent analysis in control (en>GFP,RFP) discs.
Figure S6. RNAi depletion of Dlp is not sufficient to block the Tai-induced gaps in the DV stripe of Wg. Wg signal (greyscale) in wing discs expressing either of two dlp RNAi constructs alone (#1 or #2 in A-B) or in combination with Tai overexpression (C-D). Arrows in C’ and D’ mark gaps in the Wg stripe.
Figure S7. TaiPPxA is able to induce Dlp expression in the midline region. Dlp signal (greyscale) in (A-A”) control (en>GFP,RFP) or (B-B”) TaiPPxA expressing (en>taiPPxA,GFP) discs. Yellow arrows in A’ mark Dlp exclusion from cells in either side of the DV margin; arrow in B’ points to excess Dlp filling this region.
Supplemental Table 1: A genetic screen reveals dominant modifiers of tailow cell death. Heterozygous candidate alleles selected from various pathways were placed in the background of a mosaic eyFlp; Tailow eye, and positive screen “hits” were determined based on increased recovery of Tailow clones (orange). An allele of hid, as well as the H99 deletion (reaper, hid, grim) enhanced recovery of Tailow cells. Other suppressors included wtsx1, a loss of function allele of the core Hippo pathway kinase and an allele of Adenomatous polyposis coli (Apc), a key inhibitor of the conserved Wg/Wnt pathway. Refer to Key Resources Table for information about alleles used.
References
- 1.Myc-driven endogenous cell competition in the early mammalian embryoNature 500:39–44https://doi.org/10.1038/nature12389
- 2.Epiblast Formation by TEAD-YAP-Dependent Expression of Pluripotency Factors and Competitive Elimination of Unspecified CellsDev Cell 50:139–54https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2019.05.024
- 3.Minutes: mutants of drosophila autonomously affecting cell division rateDev Biol 42:211–21https://doi.org/10.1016/0012-1606(75)90330-9
- 4.An ancient defense system eliminates unfit cells from developing tissues during cell competitionScience 346https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1258236
- 5.Spatially Restricted Regulation of Spatzle/Toll Signaling during Cell CompetitionDev Cell https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2018.08.001
- 6.The Taiman Transcriptional Coactivator Engages Toll Signals to Promote Apoptosis and Intertissue Invasion in DrosophilaCurr Biol 29:2790–800https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2019.07.012
- 7.Yorkie drives supercompetition by non-autonomous induction of autophagy via bantam microRNA in DrosophilaCurr Biol 32:1064–76https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2022.01.016
- 8.Cell Competition Is Driven by AutophagyDev Cell 51:99–112https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2019.08.018
- 9.The ligand Sas and its receptor PTP10D drive tumour-suppressive cell competitionNature 542:246–50https://doi.org/10.1038/nature21033
- 10.Flower forms an extracellular code that reveals the fitness of a cell to its neighbors in DrosophilaDev Cell 18:985–98https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2010.05.010
- 11.Drosophila SPARC is a self-protective signal expressed by loser cells during cell competitionDev Cell 19:562–73https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2010.09.004
- 12.Elimination of unfit cells maintains tissue health and prolongs lifespanCell 160:461–76https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2014.12.017
- 13.Cells compete for decapentaplegic survival factor to prevent apoptosis in Drosophila wing developmentNature 416:755–9https://doi.org/10.1038/416755a
- 14.dMyc transforms cells into super-competitorsCell 117:117–29
- 15.The ecdysone receptor coactivator Taiman links Yorkie to transcriptional control of germline stem cell factors in somatic tissueDev Cell 34:168–80https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2015.05.010
- 16.Cell Competition Drives the Growth of Intestinal Adenomas in DrosophilaCurrent biology : CB 26:428–38https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2015.12.043
- 17.Steep differences in wingless signaling trigger Myc-independent competitive cell interactionsDev Cell 21:366–74https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2011.06.021
- 18.The Toll pathway inhibits tissue growth and regulates cell fitness in an infection-dependent mannereLife 7https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.39939
- 19.A potential link between p53, cell competition and ribosomopathy in mammals and in DrosophilaDev Biol 446:17–9https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ydbio.2018.11.018
- 20.Supercompetitor status of Drosophila Myc cells requires p53 as a fitness sensor to reprogram metabolism and promote viabilityCell Metab 19:470–83https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2014.01.012
- 21.A role for Flower and cell death in controlling morphogen gradient scalingNat Cell Biol 24:424–33https://doi.org/10.1038/s41556-022-00858-3
- 22.Inter-Organ Growth Coordination Is Mediated by the Xrp1-Dilp8 Axis in DrosophilaDev Cell 49:811–8https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2019.03.016
- 23.Genetic control of programmed cell death (apoptosis) in DrosophilaFly (Austin 3:78–90https://doi.org/10.4161/fly.3.1.7800
- 24.Taiman acts as a coactivator of Yorkie in the Hippo pathway to promote tissue growth and intestinal regenerationCell Discovery 2https://doi.org/10.1038/celldisc.2016.6
- 25.The Hippo signaling pathway coordinately regulates cell proliferation and apoptosis by inactivating Yorkie, the Drosophila Homolog of YAPCell 122:421–34https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2005.06.007
- 26.The wing imaginal discGenetics 220https://doi.org/10.1093/genetics/iyac020
- 27.Scott MP. naked cuticle encodes an inducible antagonist of Wnt signallingNature 403:789–95https://doi.org/10.1038/35001615
- 28.Blair SS. wingless refines its own expression domain on the Drosophila wing marginNature 384:72–4https://doi.org/10.1038/384072a0
- 29.The Wingless morphogen gradient is established by the cooperative action of Frizzled and Heparan Sulfate Proteoglycan receptorsDev Biol 276:89–100https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ydbio.2004.08.023
- 30.Spatial regulation of Wingless morphogen distribution and signaling by Dally-like proteinDev Cell 7:513–23https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2004.08.004
- 31.Drosophila glypicans Dally and Dally-like shape the extracellular Wingless morphogen gradient in the wing discDevelopment 132:667–79https://doi.org/10.1242/dev.01636
- 32.In vivo role of lipid adducts on WinglessJ Cell Sci 121:1587–92https://doi.org/10.1242/jcs.015958
- 33.Roles of N-glycosylation and lipidation in Wg secretion and signalingDev Biol 364:32–41https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ydbio.2012.01.009
- 34.Pentagone internalises glypicans to fine-tune multiple signalling pathwayseLife 5https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.13301
- 35.Direct and widespread role for the nuclear receptor EcR in mediating the response to ecdysone in DrosophilaProc Natl Acad Sci U S A 116:9893–902https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1900343116
- 36.The core protein of glypican Dally-like determines its biphasic activity in wingless morphogen signalingDev Cell 17:470–81https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2009.09.001
- 37.Wingless gradient formation in the Drosophila wingCurr Biol 10:293–300https://doi.org/10.1016/s0960-9822(00)00378-x
- 38.Genome-wide RNAi screen identifies networks involved in intestinal stem cell regulation in DrosophilaCell reports 10:1226–38https://doi.org/10.1016/j.celrep.2015.01.051
- 39.Regulation of invasive cell behavior by taiman, a Drosophila protein related to AIB1, a steroid receptor coactivator amplified in breast cancerCell 103:1047–58
- 40.Wingless Signaling: A Genetic Journey from Morphogenesis to MetastasisGenetics 208:1311–36https://doi.org/10.1534/genetics.117.300157
- 41.Drosophila Glypicans Regulate Follicle Stem Cell Maintenance and Niche CompetitionGenetics 209:537–49https://doi.org/10.1534/genetics.118.300839
- 42.Structure of a biologically active estrogen receptor-coactivator complex on DNAMol Cell 57:1047–58https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molcel.2015.01.025
- 43.Steroid Hormone Signaling Is Essential to Regulate Innate Immune Cells and Fight Bacterial Infection in DrosophilaPLoS Pathogens 9https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.ppat.1003720
- 44.Control of Drosophila wing size by morphogen range and hormonal gatingProc Natl Acad Sci U S A 117:31935–44https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2018196117
- 45.The Ecdysone receptor constrains wingless expression to pattern cell cycle across the Drosophila wing margin in a Cyclin B-dependent mannerBMC Dev Biol 13https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-213X-13-28
- 46.Visualization and Quantitation of Wg trafficking in the Drosophila Wing Imaginal EpitheliumBio Protoc 11https://doi.org/10.21769/BioProtoc.4040
Article and author information
Author information
Version history
- Preprint posted:
- Sent for peer review:
- Reviewed Preprint version 1:
Copyright
© 2024, Schweibenz et al.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.
Metrics
- views
- 194
- downloads
- 4
- citations
- 0
Views, downloads and citations are aggregated across all versions of this paper published by eLife.