Animal Locomotion: The benefits of swimming together
When a fish beats its tail, it produces vortices in the water that other fish could take advantage of to save energy while swimming.
- Department of Collective Behaviour, Max Planck Institute of Animal Behavior, Germany
- Centre for the Advanced Study of Collective Behaviour, University of Konstanz, Germany
- Department of Biology, University of Konstanz, Germany
Around half of all fish species spend a portion of their lives as part of a group or ‘school’ (Shaw, 1978). Swimming together offers a wide range of benefits, such as improved sensing, decision-making and navigation (Berdahl et al., 2013). It has also long been thought that moving in a school could reduce the energy expended by the fish as they swim. However, proving that swimming with others does save energy – and, if it does, how – has been challenging.
In many species, the tail of the fish produces a pattern of swirling vortices when it beats, with each vortex rotating in the opposite direction to the one that came before. The water in these ‘thrust wakes’ exhibits, on average, faster flow than the water in free streams in which no fish or other objects are present. A similar phenomenon occurs when water flows past a physical object; in this case, however, the pattern of vortices is different and results in ‘drag wakes’, and the average speed of water (with respect to the flow direction) is slower than it is in a free stream (Figure 1).
Figure 1
Swimming in drag wakes and thrust wakes.
When water flows (grey arrows) past a physical object (light blue; top), it forms a pattern of swirling vortices in which the water rotates in either a clockwise direction (green arrows) or an anticlockwise direction (purple arrows). The arrangement of the vortices (which is called a ‘drag wake’ or a von Kárman vortex street) means that a fish swimming towards the object encounters water that is flowing slower on average than it would be if the object was not there. When a fish beats its tail (blue; bottom), it also produces a pattern of swirling vortices. In this case, however, the arrangement of the vortices (which is called a ‘thrust wake’ or a reverse von Kárman vortex street) means that a second fish swimming behind the first fish encounters water that is flowing faster on average than it would be if the first fish was not there. Thandiackal and Lauder used a hybrid robotic-animal experimental set-up to study fish swimming in thrust wakes.
Image credit: Iain D Couzin and Liang Li (CC BY 4.0).
Previous studies have shown that fish can save energy by synchronising the wave-like motion of their body, also known as undulations, to drag wakes (Liao et al., 2003). Remarkably, even dead fish can synchronise in this way and use the reduced flow of oncoming water to continue moving upstream, albeit momentarily (Beal et al., 2006). It has been proposed that thrust wakes also benefit fish in a similar way, but direct experimental evidence in support of this idea has been lacking (Maertens et al., 2017; Kurt and Moored, 2018). Now, in eLife, Robin Thandiackal and George Lauder from Harvard University report the results of experiments on fish swimming in thrust wakes (Thandiackal and Lauder, 2023).
Since it is not practical to produce well-controlled vortices using real fish, the researchers turned to an elegant engineering solution to study what happens when one fish swims behind another: they replaced the fish in front with a robotic flapping foil that can produce vortex patterns comparable to those produced by a real fish (see also Harvey et al., 2022), and then introduced a live brook trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) into the flow tank. Thandiackal and Lauder observed that this fish deliberately swam within the thrust wake generated by the foil. This suggests that unlike cyclists – who cycle behind one another to benefit from the reduced air flow in the drag wake – fish deliberately move into regions where the flow of water is higher rather than lower.
When swimming in a thrust wake the trailing fish synchronises its body undulations to the pattern of vortices. The specific timing of the undulations, together with a detailed analysis of the fluid flow patterns around the fish, suggests they are exhibiting a strategy termed vortex phase matching – an energy-saving behaviour that has also been observed in pairs of real fish (Li et al., 2020). Fish rely on a system called the lateral line organ to detect changes in the water around them but, surprisingly, the study of pairs of real fish found that they did not rely on this organ to perform vortex phase matching: rather, they appeared to rely on proprioception (that is, signals from neurons within their muscles and joints).
This study by Thandiackal and Lauder goes further than the work of previous groups in multiple ways. First, it shows that the oscillating motion of the head of the trailing fish allows it to intercept oncoming vortices in way that reduces the average force exerted by the water that has been pushed over its head (termed pressure drag). The researchers suggest that this is achieved through the motion of the fish’s head allowing them to ‘catch’ the vortices better, which is consistent with previous results (Maertens et al., 2017; Harvey et al., 2022). Second, their work provides the first quantitative visualisation of the hydrodynamics around fish during vortex phase matching. The data suggest that a fish exploits thrust wakes by allowing the energy from the vortices to ‘roll’ down both sides of its body when it is directly behind the foil, or only roll down one side when the fish is slightly to one side rather than directly behind. Together these effects mean a fish swimming behind the foil can maintain a certain speed while beating its tail less frequently than it would have to do if it were not swimming behind the foil. This suggests the fish needs to use less energy than if it were swimming alone.
By developing a precise mechanistic framework, Thandiackal and Lauder provide new insights into why some fish swim one behind another. Furthermore, their hybrid robotic-animal approach offers exciting opportunities for future research; for example, it could help researchers to evaluate other swimming configurations, and to study what happens when fish transition from swimming in pairs to swimming in larger schools. It could also be used to measure the energy expenditure associated with different swimming strategies more directly by incorporating physiological measurements, such as heart rate. It is clear that we have much more to learn about why fish tend to swim together.
References
-
Passive propulsion in vortex wakesJournal of Fluid Mechanics 549:385.https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022112005007925
-
Vortex phase matching as a strategy for schooling in robots and in fishNature Communications 11:5408.https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-19086-0
-
Optimal undulatory swimming for a single fish-like body and for a pair of interacting swimmersJournal of Fluid Mechanics 813:301–345.https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2016.845
Article and author information
Author details
Publication history
Copyright
© 2023, Couzin and Li
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.
Metrics
-
- 1,988
- views
-
- 161
- downloads
-
- 2
- citations
Views, downloads and citations are aggregated across all versions of this paper published by eLife.
Download links
A two-part list of links to download the article, or parts of the article, in various formats.
Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)
Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)
Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)
Animal Locomotion: The benefits of swimming together
eLife 12:e86807.
https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.86807
Further reading
-
- Cell Biology
- Physics of Living Systems
The endoplasmic reticulum (ER), the largest cellular compartment, harbours the machinery for the biogenesis of secretory proteins and lipids, calcium storage/mobilisation, and detoxification. It is shaped as layered membranous sheets interconnected with a network of tubules extending throughout the cell. Understanding the influence of the ER morphology dynamics on molecular transport may offer clues to rationalising neuro-pathologies caused by ER morphogen mutations. It remains unclear, however, how the ER facilitates its intra-luminal mobility and homogenises its content. It has been recently proposed that intra-luminal transport may be enabled by active contractions of ER tubules. To surmount the barriers to empirical studies of the minuscule spatial and temporal scales relevant to ER nanofluidics, here we exploit the principles of viscous fluid dynamics to generate a theoretical physical model emulating in silico the content motion in actively contracting nanoscopic tubular networks. The computational model reveals the luminal particle speeds, and their impact in facilitating active transport, of the active contractile behaviour of the different ER components along various time–space parameters. The results of the model indicate that reproducing transport with velocities similar to those reported experimentally in single-particle tracking would require unrealistically high values of tubule contraction site length and rate. Considering further nanofluidic scenarios, we show that width contractions of the ER’s flat domains (perinuclear sheets) generate local flows with only a short-range effect on luminal transport. Only contractions of peripheral sheets can reproduce experimental measurements, provided they are able to contract fast enough.
-
- Biochemistry and Chemical Biology
- Physics of Living Systems
For drugs to be active they have to reach their targets. Within cells this requires crossing the cell membrane, and then free diffusion, distribution, and availability. Here, we explored the in-cell diffusion rates and distribution of a series of small molecular fluorescent drugs, in comparison to proteins, by microscopy and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP). While all proteins diffused freely, we found a strong correlation between pKa and the intracellular diffusion and distribution of small molecule drugs. Weakly basic, small-molecule drugs displayed lower fractional recovery after photobleaching and 10- to-20-fold slower diffusion rates in cells than in aqueous solutions. As, more than half of pharmaceutical drugs are weakly basic, they, are protonated in the cell cytoplasm. Protonation, facilitates the formation of membrane impermeable ionic form of the weak base small molecules. This results in ion trapping, further reducing diffusion rates of weakly basic small molecule drugs under macromolecular crowding conditions where other nonspecific interactions become more relevant and dominant. Our imaging studies showed that acidic organelles, particularly the lysosome, captured these molecules. Surprisingly, blocking lysosomal import only slightly increased diffusion rates and fractional recovery. Conversely, blocking protonation by N-acetylated analogues, greatly enhanced their diffusion and fractional recovery after FRAP. Based on these results, N-acetylation of small molecule drugs may improve the intracellular availability and distribution of weakly basic, small molecule drugs within cells.
