Cave Bacteria: Illuminating a new path to multicellularity

A new species of multicellular bacteria broadens our understanding of prokaryotic multicellularity and provides insight into how multicellular organisms arise.
  1. Sayantan Datta  Is a corresponding author
  2. William C Ratcliff  Is a corresponding author
  1. Interdisciplinary Graduate Program in Quantitative Biosciences, Georgia Institute of Technology, United States
  2. School of Biological Sciences, Georgia Institute of Technology, United States

Billions of years before eukaryotes took their first multicellular steps, prokaryotes such as bacteria and archaea began exploring their own multicellular lifestyles. These included chain-forming cyanobacteria that formed softball-sized spheres, packs of bacteria hunting mobile prey together, and filamentous bacteria dividing labor to saturate their growth substrate with antibiotics to protect their aerial spores from threats as they develop (Dodds et al., 1995; Fortezza et al., 2022; Zhang et al., 2020).

Fossils of large, strangely shaped colonial organisms and tunnel systems point to a renaissance of prokaryotic multicellularity around two billion years ago, during a short period of elevated oxygen (El Albani et al., 2010; El Albani et al., 2019). Over time, countless other prokaryotes have evolved transient multicellular phases in their life histories, allowing them to gain some of the benefits of multicellularity without fully committing to this strategy (Shapiro, 1998). Now, in eLife, Kouhei Mizuno (National Institute of Technology), Kazuya Morikawa (University of Tsukuba) and colleagues at various institutes in Japan report on a previously unknown form of bacterial multicellularity (Mizuno et al., 2022).

Deep in a limestone cave system in northern Kyushu Island, Japan, growing alongside a river that periodically fills the cave chamber, they discovered a new species of bacteria, Jeongeupia sacculi sp. nov. HS-3. This bacterium forms well-ordered sheets of cells, which ultimately develop into a bulbous structure that actively releases germ-like, single celled propagules when submerged. This type of multicellularity has little precedent, though it somewhat resembles puffball fungi, which also form propagules within an enclosed multicellular structure, ejecting them into the environment when mechanically disturbed.

When grown in the laboratory, most bacteria multiply in a disordered manner and form opaque colonies. HS-3, in contrast, built transparent ones with an iridescent hue. Further investigation revealed that HS-3 multiplied in a highly regulated manner, first creating short, pill-shaped cells (termed coccobacilli), which then elongated to form a single layer of tightly packed filamentous cells. Mizuno et al. showed that the unusual appearance of HS-3 was due to the regularity of their cellular packing: HS-3 cells lined up in parallel, forming a nematic liquid crystal. For the next two days, the colonies continued to increase in size and to add layers of packed, almost coiled, filamentous cells. They then ceased growing, with no apparent change for another next two to three days.

But HS-3 was not idle – it was simply shifting into the reproductive phase of its life cycle. In the center of the colony, between stacks of tightly packed filamentous cells, HS-3 began to form large numbers of coccobacilli. When immersed in water, the coccobacilli were rapidly ejected from a pore in the colony’s center. Given the location of their discovery, Mizuno et al. infer that HS-3 colonies are regularly immersed in water when the cave floods; coccobacilli propagules would then be dispersed by the river, some presumably would find new patches of cave wall to inhabit, and the multicellular life cycle would start again (Figure 1).

Cartoon representation of the life cycle of Jeongeupia sacculi sp. nov. HS-3's in an underground cave system.

[1] The bacterium grows on cave walls in flat, liquid crystal colonies (Inset: colony morphology at expanding edge). [2] Production of coccobacilli causes the colonies to swell (Inset: cross-section of a colony showing coccobacilli stored internally). [3] Rising river levels submerge the colony, causing coccobacilli to be released (Inset: coccobacilli streaming from the colony center). [4] Coccobacilli are dispersed by water currents and deposited on cave walls, starting the life cycle over again.

The work of Mizuno et al. helps us to understand how multicellularity can evolve. The first step in this transition is for groups of cells to become distinct evolutionary units (Ratcliff et al., 2012). Once groups are able to reproduce and possess heritable variation in traits that affect their fitness, they can start to acquire group-level adaptations that allow them to become more integrated and organismal (Rose and Hammerschmidt, 2021).

The ecological scaffolding hypothesis argues that multicellular life cycles, which allow groups to become evolutionary units, could have first been created by the environment rather than being encoded developmentally within the life cycle of a species (Black et al., 2020). So far, however, we have been unable to determine if ecological scaffolding has played a role in the evolution of multicellularity, as we know little about the environmental conditions in which most multicellular lineages first evolved.

HS-3, in contrast, is a strong candidate for ecological scaffolding. Before multicellularity evolved in this species, single cells deposited on a cave wall by receding flood waters could have divided into clonal colonies. These would have been redispersed by the next flood, generating a simple multicellular life cycle. It is easy to imagine how mutations affecting multicellular development could have been selected for under these conditions, gradually paving the way for genetically-regulated developmental control.

Whether prokaryotes such as HS-3 truly are multicellular has long been a source of controversy (Shapiro, 1998), in part because ‘multicellularity’ is a poorly defined term. Using the presence of specific traits to define this evolutionary transition often fails to be sufficiently general; instead, it may be more accurate to use evolutionary dynamics as an indicator. Specifically, when groups of cells gain adaptations due to group-level selection, they can be considered a multicellular individual (Rose and Hammerschmidt, 2021). Key traits of HS-3, including coordinated colony growth, differentiation, and dispersal upon submersion, all appear to be multicellular adaptations to a reliably fluctuating environment – though Mizuno et al. did not formally test adaptive hypotheses.

People often ask why prokaryotes, which unambiguously evolved multicellularity billions of years before eukaryotes, nonetheless remained ‘simple’. We should not be too quick to accept this premise. As this remarkable study demonstrates, prokaryotic multicellularity may often be context-dependent, and not immediately obvious to an observer. Prokaryotes represent a vast and relatively untapped reservoir of multicellular innovation, whose study can shed light on the diverse routes to increasingly complex life. Who knows what strange, remarkable multicellular creatures may be lurking in the deep dark recesses of the world, awaiting discovery?


  1. Book
    1. Fortezza ML
    2. Schaal KA
    3. Velicer GJ
    Group formation: on the evolution of aggregative multicellularity
    In: Herron MD, Conlin PL, Ratcliff WC, editors. The Evolution of Multicellularity. CRC Press. pp. 1595–1600.

Article and author information

Author details

  1. Sayantan Datta

    Sayantan Datta is on the Interdisciplinary Graduate Program in Quantitative Biosciences and in the School of Biological Sciences, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, United States

    For correspondence
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
    ORCID icon "This ORCID iD identifies the author of this article:" 0000-0002-0529-4402
  2. William C Ratcliff

    William C Ratcliff is in the School of Biological Sciences, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, United States

    For correspondence
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
    ORCID icon "This ORCID iD identifies the author of this article:" 0000-0002-6837-8355

Publication history

  1. Version of Record published: October 11, 2022 (version 1)


© 2022, Datta and Ratcliff

This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.


  • 2,779
    Page views
  • 282
  • 0

Article citation count generated by polling the highest count across the following sources: Crossref, PubMed Central, Scopus.

Download links

A two-part list of links to download the article, or parts of the article, in various formats.

Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)

Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)

Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)

  1. Sayantan Datta
  2. William C Ratcliff
Cave Bacteria: Illuminating a new path to multicellularity
eLife 11:e83296.
  1. Further reading

Further reading

    1. Ecology
    2. Evolutionary Biology
    Zinan Wang, Joseph P Receveur ... Henry Chung
    Research Article

    Maintaining water balance is a universal challenge for organisms living in terrestrial environments, especially for insects, which have essential roles in our ecosystem. Although the high surface area to volume ratio in insects makes them vulnerable to water loss, insects have evolved different levels of desiccation resistance to adapt to diverse environments. To withstand desiccation, insects use a lipid layer called cuticular hydrocarbons (CHCs) to reduce water evaporation from the body surface. It has long been hypothesized that the waterproofing capability of this CHC layer, which can confer different levels of desiccation resistance, depends on its chemical composition. However, it is unknown which CHC components are important contributors to desiccation resistance and how these components can determine differences in desiccation resistance. In this study, we used machine learning algorithms, correlation analyses, and synthetic CHCs to investigate how different CHC components affect desiccation resistance in 50 Drosophila and related species. We showed that desiccation resistance differences across these species can be largely explained by variation in CHC composition. In particular, length variation in a subset of CHCs, the methyl-branched CHCs (mbCHCs), is a key determinant of desiccation resistance. There is also a significant correlation between the evolution of longer mbCHCs and higher desiccation resistance in these species. Given that CHCs are almost ubiquitous in insects, we suggest that evolutionary changes in insect CHC components can be a general mechanism for the evolution of desiccation resistance and adaptation to diverse and changing environments.

    1. Evolutionary Biology
    Min Wang, Thomas A Stidham ... Zhonghe Zhou
    Research Article

    The independent movements and flexibility of various parts of the skull, called cranial kinesis, are an evolutionary innovation that is found in living vertebrates only in some squamates and crown birds and is considered to be a major factor underpinning much of the enormous phenotypic and ecological diversity of living birds, the most diverse group of extant amniotes. Compared to the postcranium, our understanding of the evolutionary assemblage of the characteristic modern bird skull has been hampered by sparse fossil records of early cranial materials, with competing hypotheses regarding the evolutionary development of cranial kinesis among early members of the avialans. Here, a detailed three-dimensional reconstruction of the skull of the Early Cretaceous enantiornithine Yuanchuavis kompsosoura allows for its in-depth description, including elements that are poorly known among early-diverging avialans but are central to deciphering the mosaic assembly of features required for modern avian cranial kinesis. Our reconstruction of the skull shows evolutionary and functional conservation of the temporal and palatal regions by retaining the ancestral theropod dinosaurian configuration within the skull of this otherwise derived and volant bird. Geometric morphometric analysis of the palatine suggests that loss of the jugal process represents the first step in the structural modifications of this element leading to the kinetic crown bird condition. The mixture of plesiomorphic temporal and palatal structures together with a derived avialan rostrum and postcranial skeleton encapsulated in Yuanchuavis manifests the key role of evolutionary mosaicism and experimentation in early bird diversification.