Genetics: A colourful duplication

A genetic duplication event during evolution allowed male wood tiger moths to have either yellow or white patterns on their wings.
  1. Violaine Llaurens  Is a corresponding author
  1. Centre national de la recherche scientifique (CNRS), France
  2. Muséum national d'Histoire naturelle, France

The beautiful patterns found on the wings of moths and butterflies can provide important insights into adaptive evolution (Orteu and Jiggins, 2020). Natural selection exerted by predators, and sexual selection exerted by females, have led to the emergence of an incredible diversity of new colours and patterns (Briolat et al., 2019; Robertson and Monteiro, 2005). While some of the genes involved in this diversification have recently been identified (Van’t Hof et al., 2016; Livraghi et al., 2021), it is still unclear whether the emergence of new colours and patterns is generally driven by similar sets of genes or by the evolution of new ones.

Within some species, individuals can have strikingly different colour patterns on their wings. For instance, male wood tiger moths can have either yellow or white hindwings, with both types of males usually occurring within the same geographical location (Figure 1A). Understanding the genetic mechanisms that allow different coloured individuals to co-exist within a population – a phenomenon called colour polymorphism – can help identify how new traits emerged over the course of evolution (Llaurens et al., 2017). Now, in eLife, Chris Jiggins, Johanna Mappes and co-workers – including Melanie Brien (University of Helsinki) and Anna Orteu (University of Cambridge) as joint first authors – report which genes determine whether a male wood tiger moth will develop white or yellow hindwings (Brien et al., 2023).

Finding the gene responsible for colour polymorphism in wood tiger moths.

(A) The proportion of male wood tiger moths that have yellow or white hindwings varies between geographical locations. For instance, 40–70% of males living in Finland and 97% of males living in Estonia have white hindwings, whereas all male moths in Scotland have yellow hindwings. (B) To investigate if the gene valkea was responsible for this colour polymorphism, Brien et al. used the genetic tool CRISPR-Cas9 to modify its sequence in wild-type (wt) moths with white hindwings (top left). This caused the mutant males to display yellow instead of white on the back (bottom left) and front (bottom right) of their hindwings, similarly to wild-type yellow moths (top right). The forewings of the genetically modified moths were also more yellow than wild-type white males, which is likely due to the CRISPR-Cas9 modification also introducing a mutation in to the full-length copy of the yellow-e gene.

Image credit: Adapted from Figure 1 and Figure 4 of Brien et al., 2023.

Like detectives working on a complex case, the team patiently gathered several lines of evidence to find the genetic variations responsible for this colour polymorphism. By crossing yellow females with white males, they were able to identify a region of the genome that is associated with colour differences in male offspring. This region contains 21 genes, including four from the yellow gene family, and is a different size in yellow and white males. In white males, this part of the genome consists of a large duplicated area which contains both a full-length copy and truncated copy of the yellow-e gene. Brien et al. hypothesized that the truncated gene is responsible for the white phenotype in the wood tiger moth, and named the suspected gene valkea, the Finnish word for white.

Next, Brien et al. studied the genes expressed in the wings of caterpillars and pupae before they grow into adult wood tiger moths. Several genes were found to be differentially expressed in the white and yellow moths: as expected, valkea was only turned on in white males. Interestingly, the full-length copy of the yellow-e gene was also overexpressed in the wings of the white males during this phase of development.

To confirm that valkea controls wing colour, Brien et al. introduced a ‘guide’ that allowed the gene editing tool CRISPR-Cas9 to specifically modify the DNA sequence of the valkea gene. More than 1000 eggs from white moths were injected with the valkea-specific guide, but only six individuals reached adulthood, with four out of five male adults developing partially yellow hindwings (Figure 1B). Unfortunately, the guide also targeted the full-length copy of the yellow-e gene in addition to valkea, making it difficult to determine the respective role each of these genes play in colour polymorphism.

The findings of Brien et al. suggest that the hindwing colour of male wood tiger moths is determined by genes from the yellow family, which are known to regulate wing colour in other insects (Wittkopp et al., 2002). This highlights how the diverse range of colour patterns seen in winged insects are determined by only a small number of genes (Zhang et al., 2017). The results also confirm the important role of gene duplication in driving the evolution of new traits (Martin and Reed, 2010).

The re-use and duplication of the yellow-e gene can be interpreted as evolutionary tinkering (Jacob, 1977). The tinkering of such a small set of genes demonstrates how a few genetic variations can generate such a striking diversity of phenotypes. Nevertheless, the small set of genetic variations that can be targeted by selection also exert strong constraints on adaptive evolution, potentially limiting the range of colours and patterns that can emerge over the course of evolution.

Distinguishing the respective roles of similar genes is challenging. The work of Brien et al. is a promising step in investigating the exact changes within and among gene copies that led to individual members of a species developing one trait or another. This type of work on polymorphism could be combined with research investigating how gene duplications impact the evolution of phenotypes between different species. The results of these studies could highlight the different evolutionary paths responsible for the diverse colours and patterns seen on the wings of moths and butterflies.


Article and author information

Author details

  1. Violaine Llaurens

    Violaine Llaurens is at the Centre national de la recherche scientifique (CNRS), Paris, France, and the Muséum national d'Histoire naturelle, Paris, France

    For correspondence
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
    ORCID icon "This ORCID iD identifies the author of this article:" 0000-0003-1962-7391

Publication history

  1. Version of Record published: November 2, 2023 (version 1)


© 2023, Llaurens

This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.


  • 370
  • 21
  • 0

Views, downloads and citations are aggregated across all versions of this paper published by eLife.

Download links

A two-part list of links to download the article, or parts of the article, in various formats.

Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)

Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)

Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)

  1. Violaine Llaurens
Genetics: A colourful duplication
eLife 12:e92763.
  1. Further reading

Further reading

    1. Evolutionary Biology
    Raphael Aguillon, Mieka Rinsky ... Oren Levy
    Research Article

    The circadian clock enables anticipation of the day/night cycle in animals ranging from cnidarians to mammals. Circadian rhythms are generated through a transcription-translation feedback loop (TTFL or pacemaker) with CLOCK as a conserved positive factor in animals. However, CLOCK’s functional evolutionary origin and mechanism of action in basal animals are unknown. In the cnidarian Nematostella vectensis, pacemaker gene transcript levels, including NvClk (the Clock ortholog), appear arrhythmic under constant darkness, questioning the role of NvCLK. Utilizing CRISPR/Cas9, we generated a NvClk allele mutant (NvClkΔ), revealing circadian behavior loss under constant dark (DD) or light (LL), while maintaining a 24 hr rhythm under light-dark condition (LD). Transcriptomics analysis revealed distinct rhythmic genes in wild-type (WT) polypsunder LD compared to DD conditions. In LD, NvClkΔ/Δ polyps exhibited comparable numbers of rhythmic genes, but were reduced in DD. Furthermore, under LD, the NvClkΔ/Δ polyps showed alterations in temporal pacemaker gene expression, impacting their potential interactions. Additionally, differential expression of non-rhythmic genes associated with cell division and neuronal differentiation was observed. These findings revealed that a light-responsive pathway can partially compensate for circadian clock disruption, and that the Clock gene has evolved in cnidarians to synchronize rhythmic physiology and behavior with the diel rhythm of the earth’s biosphere.

    1. Computational and Systems Biology
    2. Evolutionary Biology
    Ryan T Bell, Harutyun Sahakyan ... Eugene V Koonin
    Research Article

    A comprehensive census of McrBC systems, among the most common forms of prokaryotic Type IV restriction systems, followed by phylogenetic analysis, reveals their enormous abundance in diverse prokaryotes and a plethora of genomic associations. We focus on a previously uncharacterized branch, which we denote coiled-coil nuclease tandems (CoCoNuTs) for their salient features: the presence of extensive coiled-coil structures and tandem nucleases. The CoCoNuTs alone show extraordinary variety, with three distinct types and multiple subtypes. All CoCoNuTs contain domains predicted to interact with translation system components, such as OB-folds resembling the SmpB protein that binds bacterial transfer-messenger RNA (tmRNA), YTH-like domains that might recognize methylated tmRNA, tRNA, or rRNA, and RNA-binding Hsp70 chaperone homologs, along with RNases, such as HEPN domains, all suggesting that the CoCoNuTs target RNA. Many CoCoNuTs might additionally target DNA, via McrC nuclease homologs. Additional restriction systems, such as Type I RM, BREX, and Druantia Type III, are frequently encoded in the same predicted superoperons. In many of these superoperons, CoCoNuTs are likely regulated by cyclic nucleotides, possibly, RNA fragments with cyclic termini, that bind associated CARF (CRISPR-Associated Rossmann Fold) domains. We hypothesize that the CoCoNuTs, together with the ancillary restriction factors, employ an echeloned defense strategy analogous to that of Type III CRISPR-Cas systems, in which an immune response eliminating virus DNA and/or RNA is launched first, but then, if it fails, an abortive infection response leading to PCD/dormancy via host RNA cleavage takes over.