Biochemical and structural insights into the auto-inhibited state of Mical1 and its activation by Rab8

Reviewer #1 (Public review):

The manuscript describes comprehensive structure-function studies combining structural studies, Alphafold2-based modelling, and extensive structural validation by mutagenesis and biochemical experiments. Consequently, a sophisticated activation mechanism of Mical1 as a representative of the MICAL family is elucidated at the molecular level. Since MICAL proteins are important regulators of membrane trafficking and cytoskeleton dynamics, the study is of high relevance for many groups. Structural data are of high quality, the modelling data appear to be sound, and the subsequent biochemical analyses are carried out in great detail, yielding a complete story. I have little to criticize on this beautiful work.

Reviewer #2 (Public review):

Summary:

Rai and coworkers have studied the regulation of the MICAL-family of actin regulators by Rab 8 family GTPases. Their work uses a combination of structural biology, biochemistry, and modelling approaches to identify the regions and specific residues interacting with Rabs and understand the consequences of MICAL1 regulation. The study extends previous work on individual domains by incorporating analysis of the full-length MICAL1 protein and provides compelling evidence for allosteric regulation by Rab binding to two low and high-affinity regulatory sites.

Strengths:

Excellent biochemical and structural analysis.

Weaknesses:

Additional data to test the model for Rab regulation of MICAL1 in the actin-pelleting assay would enhance the study.