Eco-evolutionary dynamics of adapting pathogens and host immunity

Reviewer #1 (Public Review):

In this work, the authors study the dynamics of fast-adapting pathogens under immune pressure in a host population with prior immunity. In an immunologically diverse population, an antigenically escaping variant can perform a partial sweep, as opposed to a sweep in a homogeneous population. In a certain parameter regime, the frequency dynamics can be mapped onto a random walk with zero mean, which is reminiscent of neutral dynamics, albeit with differences in higher order moments. Next, they develop a simplified effective model of time dependent selection with expiring fitness advantage, and posit that the resulting partial sweep dynamics could explain the behaviour of influenza trajectories empirically found in earlier work (Barrat-Charlaix et al. Molecular Biology and Evolution, 2021). Finally, the authors put forward an interesting hypothesis: the mode of evolution is connected to the age of a lineage since ingression into the human population. A mode of meandering frequency trajectories and delayed fixation has indeed been observed in one of the long-established subtypes of human influenza, albeit so far only over a limited period from 2013 to 2020. The paper is overall interesting and well-written. Some aspects, detailed below, are not yet fully convincing and should be treated in a substantial revision.

Major points

(1) The quasi-neutral behaviour of amino acid changes above a certain frequency (reported in Fig, 3), which is the main overlap between influenza data and the authors' model, is not a specific property of that model. Rather, it is a generic property of travelling wave models and more broadly, of evolution under clonal interference (Rice et al. Genetics 2015, Schiffels et al. Genetics 2011). The authors should discuss in more detail the relation to this broader class of models with emergent neutrality. Moreover, the authors' simulations of the model dynamics are performed up to the onset of clonal interference \rho/s_0 = 1 (see Fig. 4). Additional simulations more deeply in the regime of clonal interference (e.g. \rho / s_0 = 5) show more clearly the behaviour in this regime.

In this context, I also note that the modelling results of this paper, in particular the stalling of frequency increase and the decrease in the number of fixations, are very similar to established results obtained from similar dynamical assumptions in the broader context of consumer resource models; see, e.g., Good et al. PNAS 2018. The authors should place their model in this broader context.

(2) The main conceptual problem of this paper is the inference of generic non-predictability from the quasi-neutral behaviour of influenza changes. There is no question that new mutations limit the range of predictions, this problem being most important in lineages with diverse immune groups such as influenza A(H3N2). However, inferring generic non-predictability from quasi-neutrality is logically problematic because predictability refers to individual trajectories, while quasi-neutrality is a property obtained by averaging over many trajectories (Fig. 3). Given an SIR dynamical model for trajectories, as employed here and elsewhere in the literature, the up and down of individual trajectories may be predictable for a while even though allele frequencies do not increase on average. The authors should discuss this point more carefully.

(3) To analyze predictability and population dynamics (section 5), the authors use a Wright-Fisher model with expiring fitness dynamics. While here the two sources of the emerging neutrality are easily tuneable (expiring fitness and clonal interference), the connection of this model to the SIR model needs to be substantiated: what is the starting selection s_0 as a function of the SIR parameters (f, b, M, \epsilon), the selection decay \nu = \nu(f, b, M, \epsilon, \gamma)? This would enable the comparison of the partial sweep timing in both models and corroborate the mapping of the SIR onto the simplified W-F model. In addition, the authors' point would be strengthened if the SIR partial sweeps in Fig.1 and Fig.2 were obtained for a combination of parameters that results in a realistic timescale of partial sweeps.

Reviewer #2 (Public Review):

Summary:

This work addresses a puzzling finding in the viral forecasting literature: high-frequency viral variants evince signatures of neutral dynamics, despite strong evidence for adaptive antigenic evolution. The authors explicitly model interactions between the dynamics of viral adaptations and of the environment of host immune memory, making a solid theoretical and simulation-based case for the essential role of host-pathogen eco-evolutionary dynamics. While the work does not directly address improved data-driven viral forecasting, it makes a valuable conceptual contribution to the key dynamical ingredients (and perhaps intrinsic limitations) of such efforts.

Strengths:

This paper follows up on previous work from these authors and others concerning the problem of predicting future viral variant frequency from variant trajectory (or phylogenetic tree) data, and a model of evolving fitness. This is a problem of high impact: if such predictions are reliable, they empower vaccine design and immunization strategies. A key feature of this previous work is a "traveling fitness wave" picture, in which absolute fitnesses of genotypes degrade at a fixed rate due to an advancing external field, or "degradation of the environment". The authors have contributed to these modeling efforts, as well as to work that critically evaluates fitness prediction (references 11 and 12). A key point of that prior work was the finding that fitness metrics performed no better than a baseline neutral model estimate (Hamming distance to a consensus nucleotide sequence). Indeed, the apparent good performance of their well-adopted "local branching index" (LBI) was found to be an artifact of its tendency to function as a proxy for the neutral predictor. A commendable strength of this line of work is the scrutiny and critique the authors apply to their own previous projects. The current manuscript follows with a theory and simulation treatment of model elaborations that may explain previous difficulties, as well as point to the intrinsic hardness of the viral forecasting inference problem.

This work abandons the mathematical expedience of traveling fitness waves in favor of explicitly coupled eco-evolutionary dynamics. The authors develop a multi-compartment susceptible/infected model of the host population, with variant cross-immunity parameters, immune waning, and infectious contact among compartments, alongside the viral growth dynamics. Studying the invasion of adaptive variants in this setting, they discover dynamics that differ qualitatively from the fitness wave setting: instead of a succession of adaptive fixations, invading variants have a characteristic "expiring fitness": as the immune memories of the host population reconfigure in response to an adaptive variant, the fitness advantage transitions to quasi-neutral behavior. Although their minimal model is not designed for inference, the authors have shown how an elaboration of host immunity dynamics can reproduce a transition to neutral dynamics. This is a valuable contribution that clarifies previously puzzling findings and may facilitate future elaborations for fitness inference methods.

The authors provide open access to their modeling and simulation code, facilitating future applications of their ideas or critiques of their conclusions.

Weaknesses:

The current modeling work does not make direct contact with data. I was hoping to see a more direct application of the model to a data-driven prediction problem. In the end, although the results are compelling as is, this disconnect leaves me wondering if the proposed model captures the phenomena in detail, beyond the qualitative phenomenology of expiring fitness. I would imagine that some data is available about cross-immunity between strains of influenza and sarscov2, so hopefully some validation of these mechanisms would be possible.

After developing the SIR model, the authors introduce an effective "expiring fitness" model that avoids the oscillatory behavior of the SIR model. I hoped this could be motivated more directly, perhaps as a limit of the SIR model with many immune groups. As is, the expiring fitness model seems to lose the eco-evolutionary interpretability of the SIR model, retreating to a more phenomenological approach. In particular, it's not clear how the fitness decay parameter nu and the initial fitness advantage s_0 relate to the key ecological parameters: the strain cross-immunity and immune group interaction matrices.

Reviewer #3 (Public Review):

Summary:

In this work the authors start presenting a multi-strain SIR model in which viruses circulate in an heterogeneous population with different groups characterized by different cross-immunity structures. They argue that this model can be reformulated as a random walk characterized by new variants saturating at intermediate frequencies. Then they recast their microscopic description to an effective formalism in which viral strains lose fitness independently from one another. They study several features of this process numerically and analytically, such as the average variants frequency, the probability of fixation, and the coalescent time. They compare qualitatively the dynamics of this model to variants dynamics in RNA viruses such as flu and SARS-CoV-2

Strengths:

The idea that a vanishing fitness mechanisms that produce partial sweeps may explain important features of flu evolution is very interesting. Its simplicity and potential generality make it a powerful framework. As noted by the authors, this may have important implications for predictability of virus evolution and such a framework may be beneficial when trying to build predictive models for vaccine design. The vanishing fitness model is well analyzed and produces interesting structures in the strains coalescent. Even though the comparison with data is largely qualitative, this formalism would be helpful when developing more accurate microscopic ingredients that could reproduce viral dynamics quantitatively.
This general framework has a potential to be more universal than human RNA viruses, in situations where invading mutants would saturate at intermediate frequencies.

Weaknesses:

The authors build the narrative around a multi-strain SIR model in which viruses circulate in an heterogeneous population, but the connection of this model to the rest of the paper is not well supported by the analysis.
When presenting the random walk coarse-grained description in section 3 of the Results, there is no quantitative relation between the random walk ingredients - importantly P(\beta) - and the SIR model, just a qualitative reasoning that strains would initially grow exponentially and saturate at intermediate frequencies. So essentially any other microscopic description with these two features would give rise to the same random walk.

Currently it's unclear whether the specific choices for population heterogeneity and cross-immunity structure in the SIR model matter for the main results of the paper. In section 2, it seems that the main effect of these ingredients are reduced oscillations in variants frequencies and a rescaled initial growth rate. But ultimately a homogeneous population would also produce steady state coexistence between strains, and oscillation amplitude likely depends on parameters choices. Thus a homogeneous population may lead to a similar coarse-grained random walk.

Similarly, it's unclear how the SIR model relates to the vanishing fitness framework, other than on a qualitative level given by the fact that both descriptions produce variants saturating at intermediate frequencies. Other microscopic ingredients may lead to a similar description, yet with quantitative differences.

At the same time, from the current analysis the reader cannot appreciate the impact of such a mean field approximation where strains lose fitness independently from one another, and under what conditions such assumption may be valid.

In summary, the central and most thoroughly supported results in this paper refer to a vanishing fitness model for human RNA viruses. The current narrative, built around the SIR model as a general work on host-pathogen eco-evolution in the abstract, introduction, discussion and even title, does not seem to match the key results and may mislead readers. The SIR description rather seems one of the several possible models, featuring a negative frequency dependent selection, that would produce coarse-grained dynamics qualitatively similar to the vanishing fitness description analyzed here.