The generation of naïve T lymphocytes is critical for immune function yet the mechanisms governing their maturation remain incompletely understood. We have identified a mouse mutant, bloto, that harbors a hypomorphic mutation in the zinc finger protein Zfp335. Zfp335bloto/bloto mice exhibit a naïve T cell deficiency due to an intrinsic developmental defect that begins to manifest in the thymus and continues into the periphery, affecting T cells that have recently undergone thymic egress. The effects of Zfp335bloto are multigenic and cannot be attributed to altered thymic selection, proliferation or Bcl2-dependent survival. Zfp335 binds to promoter regions via a consensus motif, and its target genes are enriched in categories related to protein metabolism, mitochondrial function, and transcriptional regulation. Restoring the expression of one target, Ankle2, partially rescues T cell maturation. These findings identify Zfp335 as a transcription factor and essential regulator of late-stage intrathymic and post-thymic T cell maturation.https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.03549.001
To defend our bodies against a variety of foreign microbes, our immune system makes cells called T cells that can identify these invaders and help to destroy them. There are several types of T cells that play different roles in the immune response: some activate other immune cells, while others destroy cells that have been infected by viruses or other pathogens.
T cells develop in a specialized organ called the thymus, where they go through a rigorous selection process before being released as mature T cells into the rest of the body. This selection process includes eliminating individual T cells that are found to be sub-standard, perhaps because they might mistake our own cells for enemy cells. However, many of the details of the later stages of T cell development are not fully understood.
Han et al. have now found that a protein called Zfp335 that is involved in the production of mature T cells. Mice carrying a mutation in the gene that makes this protein have fewer mature T cells than normal mice. Han et al. also reveal that Zfp335 is a transcription factor that can control whether or not other genes are expressed as proteins, and further show that one of these proteins, Ankle2, has an important role in the production of mature T cells.
A next step in the work is to define exactly how Zfp335 controls the expression of these genes. It will also be important to determine whether mutations in Zfp335 contribute to human T-cell immunodeficiency.https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.03549.002
In order to mount effective adaptive responses against a diverse range of pathogens and antigens, the immune system has to generate sufficient numbers of mature peripheral T cells that express functional T cell receptors (TCRs). T cell development is a complex and highly regulated process that involves multiple stages of selection and maturation, both within the thymus and after thymic export. In the thymus, productive rearrangement of the TCR β-chain in CD4−CD8− double negative (DN) thymocytes drives progression to the CD4+CD8+ double positive (DP) stage (Starr et al., 2003). After rearrangement of the TCR α-chain, DP thymocytes express mature TCRs which are then used to survey self-peptide/MHC complexes presented by specialized epithelial cells in the thymic cortex (cTECs) (Klein et al., 2014). A small percentage of DP thymocytes receive positively selecting TCR signals which promote their survival, in part through upregulation of IL-7Rα (Sinclair et al., 2011). Positively selected thymocytes become committed to either the CD4 or CD8 single-positive (SP) lineage and migrate to the thymic medulla, where they undergo further negative selection mediated by interactions with antigen-presenting cells such as dendritic cells (DCs) or AIRE-dependent medullary thymic epithelial cells (mTECs) (Hogquist et al., 2005; Klein et al., 2014), during which thymocytes expressing self-reactive TCRs either undergo apoptosis or are diverted to alternative fates, such as becoming regulatory T cells (Tregs) (Stritesky et al., 2012).
As SP thymocytes undergo maturation, expression of the surface marker CD24 is decreased while CD62L expression is upregulated. As such, SP thymocytes may be further divided into two phenotypically distinct populations, often referred to as semi-mature (CD62LloCD24hi) and mature (CD62LhiCD24lo). These phenotypic changes are associated with an important functional difference: semi-mature SP thymocytes are susceptible to apoptosis upon TCR stimulation, whereas mature SP thymocytes are not and respond instead by proliferating (Sprent and Kishimoto, 2002; Weinreich and Hogquist, 2008). In addition, only mature SP thymocytes upregulate sphingosine-1-phosphate receptor (S1PR1), which is required for egress from the thymus (Matloubian et al., 2004; Weinreich and Hogquist, 2008). The process of SP thymocyte maturation, from entry into the SP compartment to thymic egress, has been estimated to take 4–5 days (McCaughtry et al., 2007). New T cells, also referred to as recent thymic emigrants (RTEs), undergo a phase of post-thymic phenotypic and functional maturation before they are incorporated into the long-lived peripheral naïve T cell pool (Fink, 2012).
The transition from the semi-mature to mature stage of SP thymocyte development is marked by numerous changes in gene expression. Some of these changes, including the upregulation of S1PR1 and CD62L, are mediated by the transcription factor KLF2 (Carlson et al., 2006). In the periphery, the process of post-thymic maturation is also associated with transcriptional changes, though on a smaller scale (Mingueneau et al., 2013). For instance, an increase in IL-7Rα expression during this period has been shown to promote recent thymic emigrant (RTE) survival (Silva et al., 2014). Proper regulation of the transcriptional program underlying late-stage SP thymocyte and post-thymic T cell maturation is thus critically important for the establishment of a normal naïve T cell compartment. Multiple genes involved in NF-κB signaling have been reported to be required for the development of mature T cells (Guerin et al., 2002; Schmidt-Supprian et al., 2003; Sato et al., 2005; Zhang and He, 2005; Liu et al., 2006; Wan et al., 2006; Silva et al., 2014), primarily through mechanisms related to TCR signaling and protection from apoptosis. In addition, roles for the transcriptional repressor Nkap (Hsu et al., 2011) and chromatin remodeling factor Bptf (Landry et al., 2011) have been identified in recent years. However, the transcriptional regulators controlling these stages of T cell maturation remain largely unknown.
The C2H2 zinc finger family constitutes the largest class of transcription factors in mammalian genomes, and many key transcriptional regulators in immune cell development, such as Ikaros and Plzf, contain multiple C2H2 zinc fingers (Brayer and Segal, 2008). The C2H2 zinc finger fold is classically recognized to be a DNA-binding domain (Wolfe et al., 2000; Iuchi, 2005), although it may also participate in interactions with RNA (Brown, 2005) or other proteins (Brayer and Segal, 2008).
In this study, we identify a C2H2 zinc finger protein, Zfp335, as an essential regulator of T cell maturation. Zfp335, also known as NIF-1 (Mahajan et al., 2002; Garapaty et al., 2009), is ubiquitously expressed and is essential for early development, with homozygous deletion resulting in embryonic lethality at E7.5 (Yang et al., 2012). Here, we report that an ENU-induced mutant allele of Zfp335 results in defective accumulation of naïve T cells, largely as a consequence of impaired maturation in SP thymocytes and RTEs. We show that this maturation defect is independent of thymic selection or effects on proliferation, but is associated with reduced viability. We identify a set of Zfp335 target genes in thymocytes and present evidence that decreased Zfp335 occupancy at a subset of these targets alters gene expression in mutant thymocytes. Taken together, our findings provide evidence that Zfp335 functions as a transcription factor and key regulator of a transcriptional program required for T cell maturation.
As part of an N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU) mutagenesis screen (Nelms and Goodnow, 2001) for lymphocyte phenotypes, we identified a variant C57BL/6 mouse pedigree with decreased frequencies of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in peripheral blood (Figure 1A), which we named bloto (blood T cells low; allele henceforth designated blt). This trait was fully penetrant and occurred at a frequency consistent with recessive inheritance. Homozygotes were viable, fertile and displayed no gross external abnormalities.
Further characterization of the bloto mutant revealed a strong reduction in overall T cell frequencies in secondary lymphoid organs, especially in the CD62LhiCD44lo naïve T cell population (Figure 1B). Analysis of T cell development in the thymus revealed no significant decrease in frequencies or numbers of CD4−CD8− DN or CD4+CD8+ DP thymocytes of blt/blt mice relative to heterozygous controls (Figure 1C,D). However, blt/blt mice had slightly lower SP thymocyte frequencies, and subgating on semi-mature (CD62LloCD24hi) and mature (CD62LhiCD24lo) SP thymocytes showed significant underrepresentation of the mature subset (Figure 1C), with an approximately twofold decrease in the numbers of both CD4 and CD8 mature SP thymocytes (Figure 1D). In comparison, CD4+ and CD8+ naïve T cell numbers in the spleen were reduced about fivefold to eightfold (Figure 1E), suggesting both a thymic and peripheral component to the bloto T cell developmental defect. In mixed bone marrow chimeras, lower percentages of blt/blt as compared to wild-type cells were observed in the SP thymocyte and naïve T cell populations, demonstrating that the T cell phenotype is cell-intrinsic and recapitulating the progressive developmental defect seen in intact mice (Figure 1F). The decrease in blt/blt T cells in mixed chimeras was comparable to that in intact mice (Figure 1—figure supplement 1A), which indicates the lack of a competitive or rescue effect by wild-type cells. The bloto phenotype is a fully recessive trait with no evidence for haploinsufficiency or a dominant negative effect, since heterozygous mice exhibited no decrease in naïve T cells compared to wild-type controls (Figure 1—figure supplement 2A), and blt/+ T cells did not decline relative to wild-type cells even in a competitive mixed chimeric setting (Figure 1—figure supplement 2B).
Despite the strong defect in naïve T cells, we noted little difference in the number of T cells with an effector/memory phenotype (CD62LloCD44hi) (Figure 1—figure supplement 3A). This is likely due to homeostatic expansion of surviving cells in T cell-deficient blt/blt mice, as this increase in memory relative to naïve T cells was not observed in mixed chimeras in which the effects of T cell lymphopenia were alleviated by the presence of wild-type cells (data not shown). Non-conventional αβT cell lineages, such as Foxp3+ regulatory T cells and iNKTs, were also affected (Figure 1—figure supplement 3B), but not to a greater degree than conventional CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. However, there were no deficiencies in other major lymphocyte lineages such as NK cells (Figure 1F; Figure 1—figure supplement 3C), γδT cells, and B cells (Figure 1—figure supplement 3C), suggesting that the bloto mutation has a selective effect on αβT cells.
To identify the causative genetic lesion, the peripheral blood T cell deficiency was used to map the mutation in an F2 intercross to a genomic interval between 163.16 and 165.88 Mb on chromosome 2 (Figure 2—figure supplement 1A). Whole-exome sequencing of DNA from an affected mouse identified a single novel single-nucleotide variant within the interval of interest: a C to T missense mutation in exon 21 of Zfp335 (Figure 2A). This results in the replacement of a positively charged Arg residue at position 1092 (henceforth referred to as R1092) by Trp, a bulky non-polar amino acid.
Zfp335 is a 1337-amino acid protein containing 13 predicted C2H2 zinc finger domains (Figure 2B). Its role as a transcriptional regulator in neurogenesis and neuronal differentiation has recently been described (Yang et al., 2012), but any immunological function has thus far been unknown. The R1092W mutation falls within the 12th zinc finger (ZF12) near the C-terminus (Figure 2B), at a position that is highly conserved across vertebrate evolution (Figure 2C). Homology modeling places R1092 in the ZF12 α-helix at position +6 (Figure 2—figure supplement 2A,B), one of the canonical positions mediating DNA base recognition by C2H2 zinc fingers (Wolfe et al., 2000). The presence of a TNEKP linker between ZF12 and ZF13 (Figure 2—figure supplement 2A) and its similarity to the conserved TGEKP linker, a key structural feature of DNA-binding C2H2 zinc fingers (Wolfe et al., 2000), further hint at the possibility that R1092 may play a direct role in DNA binding by Zfp335.
Zfp335 transcript levels were not decreased in blt/blt thymocytes and T cells; in fact, a slight increase was observed relative to blt/+ controls, particularly in the most mature subsets (Figure 2D). Western blotting analysis of thymocytes showed no reduction in the amount of Zfp335 protein (Figure 2E), indicating that the R1092W mutation had no adverse effect on protein expression or stability. Confocal imaging of sorted mature SP thymocytes showed that both wild-type and mutant Zfp335 localized to the nucleus, forming punctate foci within regions of euchromatin (Figure 2F). No detectable differences in subnuclear distribution were observed. These data suggest that the bloto mutation is hypomorphic rather than null, as it results in normal levels of stable protein that can localize appropriately to the nucleus but has impaired function due to the selective disruption of ZF12.
An in vivo gene complementation test was carried out by retroviral transduction of wild-type Zfp335 into blt/blt bone marrow for hematopoietic reconstitution of irradiated hosts. The T cell development block was strongly reversed in blt/blt cells transduced with wild-type Zfp335 but not control vector (Figure 2G,H), hence establishing that Zfp335R1092W was the causative mutation. Overexpression of Zfp335R1092W yielded an intermediate rescue effect (Figure 2H), suggesting that supraphysiological protein expression may partially compensate for impaired function caused by a hypomorphic mutation. Interestingly, we observed that transduction frequencies for Zfp335WT in DP thymocytes (Figure 2H) or non-T lymphocytes (data not shown) were typically low (<10%) compared to transduction frequencies achieved with Zfp335R1092W or other genes, suggesting that overexpression of Zfp335 may have an inhibitory effect on early hematopoiesis, leading to poorer reconstitution of transduced progenitors.
To further characterize the block in intrathymic development, we examined thymocyte populations by continuous in vivo bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) labeling, where the percentage of BrdU+ cells indicates population turnover. After 4 days of BrdU administration, when comparing blt/blt mice to heterozygous controls, the mature SP population showed a decrease in turnover, whereas thymocyte subsets from earlier stages of development labeled with similar kinetics (Figure 3A; Figure 3—figure supplement 1A). Genome-wide transcriptome analysis of sorted mature CD4SP thymocytes revealed a gene expression profile consistent with impaired SP thymocyte maturation; by showing, for instance, decreased expression of genes known to be upregulated during maturation (Teng et al., 2011) (Figure 3B). By comparing staining intensities of various surface markers associated with SP maturation (e.g., CD24, CD62L) in pre-gated mature SP subsets, we also observed a trend towards a less mature surface phenotype (data not shown). Taken together, these data suggest that blt/blt mice have decreased efficiency of entry into the mature SP compartment and progression through the final maturation stages within the mature SP thymocyte population.
As described earlier, blt/blt mice have a more severe defect in the accumulation of naïve T cells compared to that of mature SP thymocytes, suggesting that Zfp335R1092W-induced dysregulation extends to events in the periphery following thymic export. To assess the impact of Zfp335R1092W on naïve T cell homeostasis, we adoptively transferred blt/blt peripheral T cells together with wild-type controls into congenic lymphoreplete hosts and assessed their relative maintenance over 7 days. Surprisingly, blt/blt T cells persisted just as well as control wild-type T cells (Figure 3—figure supplement 1B), suggesting that Zfp335R1092W does not significantly impair the survival of the bulk naïve T cell population. This led us to hypothesize that the bloto defect may be largely confined to new T cells that have recently left the thymus, otherwise known as recent thymic emigrants (RTEs). In adult mice, these cells comprise a relatively small percentage of total naïve T cells and may therefore not be significantly represented in measurements involving the bulk naïve T cell population. We initially assessed the ability of SP thymocytes to survive once introduced into the periphery, in essence behaving as surrogate RTEs. Significantly, blt/blt cells decayed more rapidly than co-transferred controls, hinting that RTE survival may be impaired in blt/blt mice (Figure 3—figure supplement 1B).
In order to study the RTE population in blt/blt mice in greater detail, we crossed the blt/blt mutant to the Rag1-GFP reporter line (Kuwata et al., 1999). In these reporter mice, GFP signal intensity is inversely proportional to time spent in the periphery (Boursalian et al., 2004), allowing for the identification of RTEs as GFP+ cells within the naïve T cell population. We found that the GFPhi subset was significantly overrepresented in blt/blt naïve T cells and was skewed towards cells with the highest GFP signal intensities that have most recently exited the thymus, consistent with a partial block in post-thymic naïve T cell maturation (Figure 3—figure supplement 1C). To directly assess RTE maintenance in vivo, a test population of either Rag1-GFP blt/+ or Rag1-GFP blt/blt peripheral T cells was mixed with control non-fluorescent T cells and injected i.v. into congenic lymphoreplete hosts. Consistent with previous experiments (Figure 3—figure supplement 1B), there was no significant decline in relative numbers of total blt/blt naïve T cells recovered from the spleen 1, 3, and 5 days post-transfer (Figure 3C). However, the blt/blt Rag1-GFP+ population declined more rapidly than blt/+ Rag1-GFP+ controls, particularly within the first day of adoptive transfer (Figure 3C). Interestingly, in contrast to the spleen, we noted a small decrease in the maintenance of total blt/blt naïve T cells, relative to blt/+ cells, that were recovered from peripheral lymph nodes. Similarly, the lymph nodes exhibited a larger decline in blt/blt Rag1-GFP+ relative to blt/+ Rag1-GFP+ T cells (Figure 3D). These data suggest that some of the apparent decline in blt/blt RTEs (Figure 3D) may be due to less efficient short-term accumulation in lymph nodes. Nonetheless, the fact that we observe in both spleen and lymph nodes a higher rate of decay in the Rag1-GFP+ population as compared to the overall effect on the bulk naïve T cell pool strongly suggests that blt/blt RTEs survive less well than control RTEs.
In terms of absolute numbers, GFPhi RTEs in blt/blt mice were reduced by a magnitude largely matching that of GFP− mature naïve cells (Figure 3—figure supplement 1D), suggesting that most of the drop-off in cell numbers may have occurred at the earliest stages of RTE maturation. To test this hypothesis, we treated mice with FTY720, a potent inhibitor of thymic egress (Matloubian et al., 2004). This strategy ensured that new T cells, which would have otherwise been exported into the periphery, were trapped in the thymus where their accumulation could be measured. After 4 days of thymic egress blockade, blt/blt mice showed greatly impaired accumulation of SP cells with a mature CD62LhiCD24lo phenotype (Figure 3E), suggesting that most of the losses in RTEs take place within a short period after they enter the periphery. These data also indicate that the cell loss is due to intrinsic defects in the maturing T cells and is not dependent on their location in a particular lymphoid compartment.
In mice with a polyclonal TCR repertoire, we observed normal frequencies of positively selected DP thymocytes with a CD69hiTCRβint phenotype (Figure 4—figure supplement 1A), with no differences in CD5 surface expression on post-selection thymocytes (Figure 4—figure supplement 1B), suggesting that positive selection is not strongly impaired by the bloto mutation. Because compensatory TCR rearrangements may mask a potential positive selection defect, we examined thymic development in blt/blt mice expressing the class II MHC-restricted OTII TCR transgene, in which impaired positive selection would be expected to cause a dramatic reduction in CD4SP thymocytes. However, this was not observed in OTII blt/blt mice, which had only slightly lower CD4SP frequencies compared to controls and a fold reduction in CD4SP numbers (Figure 4A) similar to that seen in polyclonal blt/blt mice (Figure 1D).
Using the OTII/RIP-mOVA model of AIRE-dependent clonal deletion (Anderson et al., 2005), we found no evidence that blt/blt mice had altered negative selection (Figure 4B). Consistent with this conclusion, mRNA expression of Nur77, a key proapoptotic regulator induced during negative selection (Baldwin and Hogquist, 2007), was not elevated in blt/blt semi-mature SP thymocytes (Figure 4—figure supplement 1D). Hence, our data indicate that altered thymic selection does not contribute to the T cell deficiency in blt/blt mice.
The findings in Figure 3C,D and Figure 3—figure supplement 1B suggested decreased survival may at least in part explain why blt/blt T lymphocytes fail to accumulate normally. Consistent with this notion, blt/blt mature SP thymocytes showed a greater loss of viability in vitro over time compared to blt/+ controls, while a lesser effect was seen for blt/blt semi-mature SP cells (Figure 4C). Annexin V staining and measurement of active caspase 3 in freshly isolated thymocytes did not reveal differences between blt/blt and blt/+ mice (data not shown), likely because cells in the earliest stages of apoptosis are efficiently cleared in vivo (Surh and Sprent, 1994). To examine whether Bcl2-regulated apoptotic pathways were involved in promoting the loss of blt/blt T cells, we crossed blt/blt mice to a transgenic line expressing human BCL2 under control of the Lck promoter (Sentman et al., 1991). Overexpession of BCL2 failed to rescue the defect in peripheral naïve blt/blt T cells (Figure 4D), indicating that it is not due to reduced Bcl2-dependent survival. In addition, no differences in the expression of Bcl2 family pro- and anti-apoptotic genes were observed in blt/blt mature SP thymocytes (Figure 4—figure supplement 2A).
IL-7 is a critical regulator of naïve T cell homeostasis (Surh and Sprent, 2008); in particular, IL-7Rα expression is induced in new T cells and is required for their survival and integration into the peripheral pool (Silva et al., 2014). However, no significant differences in IL-7Rα expression were detected in blt/blt thymocytes and T cells, either at the transcript level (Figure 4—figure supplement 2B) or by surface receptor staining (Figure 4—figure supplement 2C). Furthermore, survival of blt/blt thymocytes and naïve T cells in the presence of IL-7 in vitro was comparable to that of co-cultured wild-type cells (data not shown), suggesting that the T cell defect is not due to the loss of IL-7R function.
Lastly, Zfp335R1092W had no significant effect on the fraction of thymocytes in cell cycle, as shown by short-term BrdU labeling (Figure 4—figure supplement 3A) and DNA content analysis (Figure 4—figure supplement 3B). Similarly, blt/blt naïve T cells were able to expand at a normal rate following TCR stimulation in vitro (Figure 4—figure supplement 3C), demonstrating that blt/blt T cells are not defective in their ability to undergo proliferation.
Zfp335 has recently been shown to bind a variety of gene promoters in mouse embryonic brain (Yang et al., 2012), but its genome-wide binding characteristics and targets relevant to its function in T cell development remain to be defined. In addition, because our structure-function predictions (Figure 2—figure supplement 2) led us to hypothesize a DNA-binding role for the mutated Arg, we wished to know if the R1092W mutation disrupted the ability of Zfp335 to bind to its targets in vivo.
To address these questions, we performed ChIP-seq analysis of Zfp335 binding sites in total thymocytes isolated from wild-type and blt/blt mice. ChIP-seq data sets were generated using two separate polyclonal antibodies and are referred to as ‘ChIP-C’ and ‘ChIP-N’ respectively. Using data obtained from wild-type thymocytes, peak calling with a q-value threshold of <0.05 identified 157 Zfp335-binding regions in the vicinity of 177 genes. Genome browser inspection of ChIP-seq signal tracks confirmed that these peaks, although fairly limited in number, represented regions of significantly enriched binding intensity. Genome-wide, Zfp335 peaks were strongly enriched in gene promoters (Figure 5A) and located upstream of transcriptional start sites (TSS) (Figure 5B). Zfp335-bound regions were associated with high levels of H3K4me3, a hallmark of active gene promoters, and low levels of the enhancer-associated modification H3K27ac and the repressive chromatin mark H3K27me3 (Figure 5C), consistent with Zfp335 functioning primarily as a regulator of promoter-dependent gene transcription. Zfp335 target genes were enriched for functional categories representing a diverse range of biological processes, including protein synthesis and metabolism, mitochondrial function, cell cycle regulation, RNA processing, and transcriptional regulation (Figure 5D; Supplementary file 4).
With the same q-value cutoff (<0.05) that yielded a total of 157 binding events for wild-type thymocytes, we detected 141 peaks in blt/blt thymocytes (Supplementary file 2,3). By visual inspection of ChIP-seq data on a genome browser, we determined that of the 28 peaks detected in wild-type but not blt/blt thymocytes, 22 showed a convincing loss of binding while the rest were false positives due to noise at low-confidence peaks. Of the nine peaks that were called for Zfp335R1092W but not Zfp335WT, four were not true binding events, but rather signal artifacts arising from repeat regions, while the remaining five were low-confidence peaks. This strongly suggests that the bloto mutation does not lead to the gain of novel binding sites, which is consistent with our hypothesis that it is a loss-of-function hypomorph.
Interestingly, we did not observe a global decrease in Zfp335 binding intensities across all target sites. Reduced binding was detected for a subset of target genes: Ankle2, Nme6, and Mrps5 are shown as representative examples (Figure 6A). However, at other target sites, such as Rbbp5, Polr2e, and Pes1, Zfp335 binding did not appear to be significantly impaired (Figure 6B). Only nine Zfp335-bound regions showed decreases in ChIP-seq peak intensities in blt/blt thymocytes that were robust enough to be detected across both sets of ChIP-C and ChIP-N replicates (Figure 6C). We performed ChIP-qPCR to validate a selection of target genes that we had identified as differentially bound by Zfp335R1092W, vs targets that showed normal binding, and found the ChIP-qPCR data to be in agreement with the ChIP-seq-based assessment (Figure 6D). Moreover, ChIP-qPCR analysis of sorted CD4SP thymocytes yielded similar results to the analysis with total thymocytes (Figure 6—figure supplement 1A).
To understand how reduced Zfp335 binding at a subset of direct targets in blt/blt thymocytes could be biologically significant, we integrated our ChIP-seq data with gene expression profiles that we had obtained for blt/blt and wild-type mature CD4SP thymocytes. Of the ten target genes listed in Figure 6C as having significantly reduced Zfp335R1092W binding, only three (Ankle2, Nme6, Cnpy2) were downregulated in expression by more than twofold (Figure 6E). Since our ChIP-seq results were derived from total thymocytes, of which only a small percentage are mature CD4SP, one caveat was that we might have missed gene expression changes in the larger population, so we sorted DP thymocytes (>90% of total) and tested them by RT-qPCR. Relative to blt/+ controls, blt/blt DP thymocytes had no detectable differences in the expression of Mrps5 and Rabggtb, even though these genes exhibit strongly reduced Zfp335 binding in blt/blt thymocytes (Figure 6—figure supplement 1B). This is not an unexpected finding given that transcription factors are known to bind sites which they do not functionally regulate (Smale, 2014). Nonetheless, we did observe deregulated expression of many Zfp335 target genes in our CD4SP array data, including many which did not exhibit reduced Zfp335 occupancy according to our stringent criteria (Figure 6—figure supplement 1C). For example, although Wdr47 failed to meet these criteria because it showed decreased Zfp335R1092W binding in the ChIP-C but not ChIP-N data set (Figure 6—figure supplement 1D,E), its expression was nonetheless significantly downregulated in blt/blt thymocytes (Figure 6E, Figure 6—figure supplement 1C,F). With the exception of a handful of strongly downregulated targets, gene expression changes were usually mild. Most deregulated target genes exhibited decreased expression, though a few were modestly upregulated (Figure 6—figure supplement 1C). Interestingly, this small group of upregulated targets include Zfp335 itself, which we confirmed by RT-qPCR (Figure 2D), suggesting that Zfp335 participates in an autoregulatory negative feedback loop. It is probably reasonable to assume that many of these differentially expressed genes do in fact have reduced Zfp335R1092W binding at their promoters, which we failed to detect owing to limitations in ChIP-seq sensitivity and/or the inability of our approach to identify differential binding events that are not evident at the whole population level because they occur exclusively in mature CD4SP thymocytes.
As a member of the C2H2 zinc finger protein family, it is highly likely that Zfp335 interacts with its genomic targets through direct binding to a specific DNA sequence motif. Using a set of high-confidence peaks from our Zfp335WT ChIP-seq data, we performed de novo motif analysis and identified a novel 22 bp bipartite motif consisting of two conserved elements separated by a variable spacer (Figure 7A). The positional distribution of this putative consensus motif was unimodal and located near the centers of Zfp335 peaks (Figure 7B), consistent with the hypothesis that it is the direct DNA-binding motif. Motif sites found within Zfp335 peaks showed a distinct DNase I genomic footprint (Figure 7C) and strong sequence conservation across evolution (Figure 7D) compared with motif sites outside peaks, further suggesting that it is a functional DNA-binding motif for Zfp335.
To determine if Zfp335 was able to bind to this DNA sequence in vitro, we performed gel shift assays with labeled oligonucleotide probe containing the predicted consensus motif (Figure 7E) and 293T cell nuclear extracts ectopically expressing Zfp335 protein. We found that Zfp335 formed a gel shift complex with the labeled probe (Figure 7F). This complex increased in abundance proportional to the amount of Zfp335 protein and was eliminated by competition with excess unlabeled probe, demonstrating that it is sequence-specific and Zfp335-dependent (Figure 7F). Competition experiments with unlabeled probes containing mutations of conserved nucleotides (Figure 7E) showed that Zfp335 binding was abolished when both DNA elements of the bipartite motif were mutated, whereas mutations in either the first or second element had an intermediate effect, indicating that both parts of the consensus motif are required for full Zfp335 binding (Figure 7G). We noted a stronger effect on competition upon mutation of the first element compared to the second, suggesting that it makes a greater contribution to Zfp335 binding (Figure 7G). We also performed gel shift assays with an oligonucleotide containing the previously reported Zfp335 recognition motif (Yang et al., 2012), but failed to detect binding above the negative control (Ikaros binding site) (Figure 7—figure supplement 1). Re-analysis of the embryonic brain ChIP-Seq data published by Yang et al. according to the parameters we applied to our data set (see ‘Materials and methods’) identified the motif shown in Figure 7A. These observations suggest that the discrepancy between our and the previously reported motif arises from differences in motif finding strategy. Importantly, the identification of a common motif in these distinct data sets strongly suggests that this sequence element is recognized by Zfp335 in a diversity of cell types.
To understand which direct targets of Zfp335 were functionally relevant to the T cell maturation defect in blt/blt mice, we focused our efforts on a set of genes for which we had clear evidence of reduced Zfp335 occupancy and mRNA expression, the most prominent of which was Ankle2 (ankyrin repeat and LEM domain-containing protein 2). Zfp335 binding to the Ankle2 promoter was effectively abolished in blt/blt thymocytes (Figure 6A,D); this was accompanied by decreased transcript expression across multiple stages of T cell development (Figure 8A) and consequently, a virtual absence of Ankle2 protein (Figure 8B). Exogenous expression of Zfp335 significantly increased Ankle2 mRNA levels in blt/blt T cells (Figure 8C), providing evidence that Zfp335 is both necessary and sufficient for Ankle2 expression.
We were able to partially reverse the T cell maturation defect in the periphery by exogenously expressing Ankle2 in Rag1-GFP blt/blt cells (Figure 8D,E), as shown by the overall increase in representation of Ankle2-transduced (Thy1.1 reporter+) cells within the more mature Rag1-GFPlo naïve T cell subset compared to the less mature Rag1-GFPhi subset. However, overexpression of Ankle2 had a weaker effect compared to that achieved by Zfp335 (Figure 8E), consistent with the idea that Ankle2, though important, is but one of several downstream targets that are required for Zfp335-dependent T cell maturation. In addition to Ankle2, we tested five other Zfp335 target genes for their ability to rescue the T cell maturation defect in blt/blt bone marrow chimeras, but did not detect a significant effect for any of these genes (Figure 8—figure supplement 1).
In this study, we identify a novel role for Zfp335 as an essential regulator of T cell maturation. By analyzing mice with a hypomorphic missense mutation in a C2H2 zinc finger of Zfp335, we reveal a selective defect in the accumulation of naïve T cells resulting from a maturation block in SP thymocytes and recent thymic emigrants. In line with another recent study (Yang et al., 2012), we have shown that Zfp335 regulates transcription by binding to promoters of target genes. We have identified a set of direct targets in thymocytes and provide evidence that Zfp335 occupancy at a small subset of target sites was significantly decreased in mutant T cells. Zfp335 target genes were enriched in categories related to protein metabolism, mitochondrial function, and transcriptional regulation. In addition, we identified a new DNA recognition motif that is bound by Zfp335. Taken together, our findings suggest that Zfp335 acts as a novel transcription factor required for regulating expression of multiple genes required for late stage naïve T cell maturation.
We provide evidence that Zfp335 regulates T cell maturation in part by promoting Ankle2 transcription. A study in Caenorhabditis elegans and HeLa cells showed a role for Ankle2 in nuclear envelope reassembly by promoting dephosphorylation of BAF during mitotic exit (Asencio et al., 2012). As we found no significant defects in proliferation (Figure 4—figure supplement 3) and did not detect nuclear envelope abnormalities in blt/blt mature SP thymocytes by immunofluorescence microscopy (data not shown), it is likely that the requirement for Ankle2 is dependent on some other as-yet-unknown function of this protein. To our knowledge, this is the first time an in vivo role for Ankle2 has been reported, and a more detailed understanding of its function and mechanism of action in T cells will be an important subject for future studies.
The T cell deficiency in blt/blt mice does not appear to be a consequence of defects in thymic selection, proliferation, or IL-7Rα expression, but is associated with reduced viability of mature SP thymocytes and recent thymic emigrants. Our finding that BCL2 overexpression failed to rescue the relative deficiency in blt/blt T cells, together with the unaltered expression of Bcl2 family genes (Figure 4—figure supplement 2A) or other well-defined pro-apoptotic genes such as members of the death receptor family (data not shown), suggests Zfp335 has an indirect and likely multigenic pro-survival influence. Although our data do not provide support for altered thymic selection being an explanation for the reduced T cell numbers in blt/blt mice, we cannot exclude the possibility that the selection of some T cell specificities is affected by the Zfp335 mutation and future deep sequencing studies will be needed to fully address this issue. The intact proliferation of blt/blt T cells contrasts with the defective proliferation of human lymphoblastic cells and neuronal stem cells carrying a H1111R mutation in ZFP335 (ZNF335) (Yang et al., 2012). We suspect that this difference is a consequence of the almost complete loss of protein caused by the H1111R mutation, compared to the more subtle influence of the R1092W mutation studied here.
Naïve T cell deficiencies have been observed in several mouse lines with deletions in genes related to NF-κB signaling, such as RelB (Guerin et al., 2002), NEMO (Schmidt-Supprian et al., 2003), c-FLIP (Zhang and He, 2005), TAK1 (Sato et al., 2005; Liu et al., 2006; Wan et al., 2006), and IKK2 (Schmidt-Supprian et al., 2003; Silva et al., 2014). However, the expression of these genes was not altered in blt/blt T lymphocytes and we did not detect enrichment for NF-κB targets in the gene expression analysis (data not shown). Two other genes known to be required for T cell maturation are the transcriptional repressor Nkap (Hsu et al., 2011) and Bptf, a component of the ISWI-containing chromatin remodeling complex NURF (Landry et al., 2011). Similar to what we observed in blt/blt mice, the maturation block in Nkap- and Bptf-deficient T cells was not caused by altered thymic selection and could not be rescued by Bcl2 overexpression. However, neither Nkap nor Bptf showed significant expression changes in blt/blt T lymphocytes. Moreover, we did not find a strong correlation between the expression profiles of blt/blt and Bptf-deficient SP thymocytes (unpublished observation). Nonetheless, this does not exclude the possibility of a partial overlap between genes regulated by Bptf and Zfp335—one potential mechanism could be that Bptf-dependent nucleosome repositioning is required for efficient Zfp335 binding to some of its target sites.
A small number of studies have shown that autophagy plays a role in mature T cell survival (Pua et al., 2007; He et al., 2012; Parekh et al., 2013), possibly by ensuring the clearance of excess mitochondria to minimize the harmful impact of reactive oxygen species (ROS) as newly mature cells transition from the thymus to the periphery (Pua et al., 2009). Although we observed genes involved in oxidative phosphorylation enriched amongst Zfp335 targets, our gene expression data did not reveal a clear autophagy signature, and initial experiments found no significant differences in mitochondrial content or ROS levels in blt/blt mature SP thymocytes (data not shown). However, we cannot rule out the possibility that other autophagy-dependent processes may be affected by Zfp335 deficiency.
From our microarray analyses, we found that most gene expression changes in blt/blt T lymphocytes were subtle. In our mature CD4SP thymocyte data set, of the 1504 genes passing a p-value threshold of <0.05, only 16 genes, or 1% of the total had a twofold or greater change in expression, while the vast majority (93%) showed a less than 1.5-fold difference between blt/blt and WT. This may not be a surprising result, given that we were only able to detect strongly diminished Zfp335R1092W occupancy at a limited subset of target sites. However, due to the highly conservative criteria used and other technical limitations discussed earlier, this is most likely an underestimate of the true degree of differential binding, which may affect a broader range of target genes and account for many of the more subtle changes in gene expression. Consistent with this notion, we observed that 33 direct Zfp335 targets, representing ∼20% of the total, were differentially expressed in mature CD4SP thymocytes (p < 0.05), and of these genes, only four (Ankle2, Cnpy2, Nme6, Tbck) met our differential binding criteria. Furthermore, several known or putative transcriptional regulators are among genes directly targeted by Zfp335 (Supplementary file 4) or differentially expressed in blt/blt thymocytes and RTEs (Supplementary file 1), suggesting that Zfp335 operates within the context of a broader gene regulatory network. It is likely that the T cell maturation defect arises from the cumulative effects of relatively small gene expression changes within the Zfp335 regulatory network, possibly resulting in mild perturbations of multiple pathways whose functional consequences may not be individually significant but in combination may negatively impact overall T cell fitness.
It is interesting to note that survival of mature naïve T cells appears to be intact, despite RT-qPCR evidence indicating that a number of Zfp335 target genes found to be downregulated in blt/blt mature SP thymocytes and RTEs (Ankle2, Cnpy2, Sep15, and Wdr47) are similarly downregulated in the total naïve T cell population (Figure 8A and data not shown). If we extend this observation to the genome-wide level to assume that Zfp335R1092W-induced transcriptional dysregulation in mature naïve T cells approximates the situation in RTEs, one way to explain why mature T cells are less affected could be that the deregulated genes and their associated pathways are most critical during late-thymic to early post-thymic maturation, after which they become dispensable. In support of this concept, it has been reported that IKK2 is required transiently in RTEs but not in mature T cells for normal IL-7Rα upregulation and homeostasis (Silva et al., 2014), although we have no evidence that this pathway is affected in blt/blt T lymphocytes. Alternatively, stochastic variations in gene expression or upregulation of compensatory mechanisms may have resulted in comparatively ‘fitter’ cells being preferentially selected into the mature naïve T cell pool.
Zfp335 is broadly expressed in hematopoietic cells (Heng et al., 2008) and in a variety of non-lymphoid tissues such as brain, kidney, heart, and lung (Wu et al., 2009). Given its widespread expression and the early embryonic lethality resulting from its complete ablation (Yang et al., 2012), it is highly likely that Zfp335 serves wider developmental roles. The poor contribution of Zfp335-overexpressing cells to hematopoietic lineages in BM chimeric mice also hints at a wider role. It may therefore seem remarkable that a mutation in such a ubiquitously expressed gene could produce a defect that appears to be selective for this particular stage of T cell development. It is possible that the loss of Zfp335 binding to the target sites described in our study may be unique to T lymphocytes, resulting in T cell-specific dysregulation; however, this hypothesis is not favored by preliminary evidence showing that target genes such as Ankle2 were also downregulated in B cells (data not shown). As discussed earlier, our data that only a small number of target genes are significantly deregulated suggests that other aspects of the Zfp335-dependent transcriptional program may remain sufficiently intact to allow most developmental processes, except for T cell maturation, to proceed relatively normally. For future studies, it will be important to test whether a null allele has additional consequences for immune regulation beyond the selective T cell maturation effects revealed by the bloto mutation.
Genome-wide, we estimate that there are more than 2000 promoter regions containing Zfp335 motif sites. Our study detected approximately 150 ChIP-seq peaks in thymocytes, consistent with the generally accepted principle that additional molecular requirements beyond DNA sequence preference determine the stability of transcription factor binding to a given site. At this early stage, it is not known what these requirements are for Zfp335, but they are likely to involve local chromatin context and interactions with co-binding partners which remain to be defined. It is also unclear whether Zfp335 displays cell type-specific binding patterns, which may allow Zfp335 to fulfill various developmental roles by regulating different gene expression programs. Finally, although it has been proposed that Zfp335 activates target genes by recruiting H3K4 methyltransferases (Yang et al., 2012), it is not clear if this is the sole mechanism, or that Zfp335 functions exclusively as a transcriptional activator. Consistent with the view that Zfp335 drives transcriptional activation, we observed that most target genes with deregulated expression in blt/blt thymocytes tended to be downregulated. However, we have noted exceptions in which some target genes—including Zfp335 itself—were modestly upregulated, suggesting the possibility that Zfp335 may also act as a repressor. Further investigations will be needed to identify the interaction partners with which Zfp335 cooperates to control gene expression.
To conclude, our findings regarding Zfp335R1092W add to other recent work (Hsu et al., 2011; Landry et al., 2011; Silva et al., 2014) to highlight unique gene expression requirements in late stage thymocytes and recent thymic emigrants for the formation of a normal sized naïve T cell compartment. In this regard, the function of Zfp335 is similar to its action in the brain where it is needed for the formation of a normal sized forebrain structure (Yang et al., 2012). In future work, it will be important to build from these findings to understand how this broad set of gene expression changes are integrated to promote formation of a normal sized compartment of cells. It will also be important to understand whether Zfp335 acts constitutively during late stages of T cell development or whether its function is regulated by external inputs and thus serves as a checkpoint that can influence the size and properties of the naïve T cell compartment.
The Zfp335bloto strain was established through ethylnitrosourea (ENU)-mediated mutagenesis of C57BL/6 (B6) mice at the Australian National University using methods previously described (Randall et al., 2009). Putative mutants were identified as having blood CD4+ and CD8+ T cell frequencies more than one standard deviation below the mean. CD45.1+ congenic mice were from the National Cancer Institute (01B96; B6-LY5.2/Cr). CD45.1+CD45.2+ mice were generated by crossing B6 and Boy/J (Jackson Laboratory, 002014; B6.SJL-PtprcaPepcb/BoyJ) mice. OTII TCR transgenic mice (Tg[TcraTcrb]426-6Cbn) were from an internal colony. Rag1-GFP transgenic mice were provided by N Sakaguchi (Kumamoto University, Kumamoto, Japan) (Kuwata et al., 1999). Lck-BCL2 transgenic mice were generated by S Korsmeyer (Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, MA) (Sentman et al., 1991) and provided by A Winoto (University of California Berkeley, Berkeley, CA). RIP-mOVA transgenic mice (Tg[Ins2-OVA]59Wehi) were provided by S Sanjabi (University of California San Francisco). Mice were housed in specific pathogen-free conditions, and all experiments were done according to the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee guidelines of the University of California San Francisco.
Affected bloto mice were crossed onto the CBA/J background to generate heterozygous F1 mice. F1 mice were intercrossed to yield F2 progeny homozygous for the bloto mutation and carrying a mix of C57BL/6 and CBA/J single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). SNP mapping using an Amplifluor assay (EMD Millipore, Billerica, MA) with Platinum Taq (Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA) was carried out on genomic DNA isolated from affected and unaffected mice. Exome enrichment was performed using the SeqCap EZ Mouse Exome kit (Roche Nimblegen, Basel, Switzerland), followed by 75 bp paired-end sequencing on the Illumina Genome Analyzer IIx platform (Illumina, San Diego, CA). Computational analysis to detect novel single-nucleotide variants was done as previously described (Andrews et al., 2012). The affected exon was PCR-amplified from genomic DNA and Sanger sequencing (TACGen, Richmond, CA) was carried out to confirm the mutation.
Zfp335bloto mice were genotyped by allele-specific PCR using the following primers: WT-F: 5ʹ-AGAACAAGAAGGATCTGAGGC-3ʹ; bloto-F: 5ʹ-AAGAACAAGAAGGATCTGAGGT-3ʹ; common-R: 5ʹ-GGCTCGGGCTGTAGAAGT-3ʹ. WT and bloto allele-specific primers were run in separate reactions with GoTaq Hot Start polymerase (Promega, Madison, WI).
Full-length Zfp335 was cloned from cDNA into an MSCV retroviral vector containing a Thy1.1 (CD90.1) reporter downstream of an internal ribosome entry site (IRES). The bloto mutation (c.3274C > T) was introduced by site-directed mutagenesis. For use in transfections, WT and bloto Zfp335 inserts were subcloned into a pcDNA3.1 vector (Life Technologies) with a FLAG epitope tag at the N-terminus. Ankle2, Cnpy2, Nme6, Sep15, Tbck, and Wdr47 were PCR amplified from mouse cDNA and cloned into the MSCV-IRES-Thy1.1 vector. All constructs were verified by sequencing. Reference sequences used in this study are as follows—protein: Zfp335 (NP_950192.2); mRNA: Zfp335 (NM_199027.2), Ankle2 (NM_001253814.1), Cnpy2 (NM_019953.1), Nme6 (NM_018757.1), Sep15 (NM_053102.2), Tbck (NM_001163455.1), Wdr47 (NM_181400.3).
Cells were isolated from thymus, spleen, and lymph nodes by mechanical disaggregation through a 40-μm nylon sieve and stained as described (Schmidt et al., 2013). Antibodies were as follows: anti-CD4 (GK1.5, RM4-5), CD8 (53–6.7) (Biolegend, San Diego, CA; Tonbo Biosciences, San Diego, CA); CD62L (MEL-14), CD44 (IM7), CD69 (H1.2F3), CD24 (M1/69), CD45.1 (A20), CD45.2 (104), TCRβ (H57-597), CD19 (6D5), TCRγδ (GL3), Thy1.1 (OX-7), CD25 (PC61) (Biolegend); NK1.1 (PK136), Vα2 (B20.1), CD5 (53-7.3) (BD Biosciences, San Jose, CA); IL-7Rα (A7R34), Foxp3 (FJK-16 s), BrdU (BU20A) (eBioscience, San Diego, CA); mCD1d/PBS-57 tetramer (NIH Tetramer Core Facility). 4ʹ,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI) was used for dead cell exclusion. For all intracellular staining, cells were stained for surface antigens before fixation. Foxp3 was stained using the Foxp3 Staining Buffer Set (eBioscience). BrdU staining was performed as per manufacturer's guidelines (BD Biosciences). For cell cycle analysis by DNA content, cells were fixed with BD Cytofix/Cytoperm Buffer and stained with 5 μM DAPI in Perm/Wash buffer (BD Biosciences). Annexin V staining was performed using the Annexin V-PE Apoptosis Detection kit (BD Biosciences) according to manufacturer's instructions. Samples were acquired on an LSRII cytometer (BD Biosciences) and analyzed with FlowJo software (TreeStar, Ashland, OR).
For microarray analysis, hematopoietic chimeras were generated with a mix of CD45.1+CD45.2+ Rag1-GFP WT and CD45.2+ Rag1-GFP blt/blt bone marrow. Thymocytes were isolated in MACS buffer (PBS +2% FBS, 2 mM EDTA), incubated with anti-CD8 microbeads (Miltenyi Biotec, Bergisch Gladbach, Germany), and MACS-depleted to enrich for CD4SP thymocytes, after which cells were stained with anti-CD45.1, CD4, CD8, CD69, and CD62L. Mature CD4SP thymocytes (GFPhiCD4+CD8−CD62LhiCD69lo) were sorted into WT (CD45.1+) and blt/blt (CD45.1−) subsets. For RTE sorting, spleen, and lymph node cells were pooled and erythrocytes were lysed in a solution of Tris-buffered NH4Cl. Cells were labeled with anti-CD45.1, CD4, CD8, CD62L, and CD44. RTEs were sorted as CD4+CD62LhiCD44lo Rag1-GFPhi CD45.1+ (WT), and CD45.1− (blt/blt) subsets. Dead cells were excluded with DAPI. Samples were sorted on a FACSAria with ≥98% purity.
Mature CD4SP thymocytes were sorted and allowed to adhere to poly-L-lysine-coated glass slides (P0425; Sigma–Aldrich, St. Louis, MO). Cells were then fixed with 4% PFA in PBS and permeabilized with 0.1% Triton X-100 for 10 min on ice, followed by blocking (5% normal goat serum, 2% BSA in PBS) and staining (2% goat serum, 0.1% BSA, 0.1% Tween-20 in PBS). For Zfp335 detection, slides were incubated at RT with primary antibody (A300-797A, A300-798A; Bethyl Laboratories, Montgomery, TX) for at least 3 hr, followed by biotin goat anti-rabbit (BD Biosciences) and lastly SA-Cy3 (Jackson Immunoresearch, West Grove, PA). Slides were counterstained with 1 μM DAPI and mounted with Fluoromount-G (Southern Biotech, Birmingham, AL). Confocal imaging was performed on a Leica SP5 inverted microscope with a 63× oil immersion objective. Images were processed with Leica LAS software.
Mixed bone marrow chimeras were generated by intravenously transferring 3 × 106 to 5 × 106 cells from the following mixes into lethally irradiated (2 × 450 rads, 3 hr apart) CD45.1+ congenic mice: blt/blt CD45.2+: WT CD45.1+CD45.2+; blt/+ CD45.2+: WT CD45.1+CD45.2+, at a 50:50 ratio. For OTII/ RIP-mOVA experiments, bone marrow from OTII blt/+ or OTII blt/blt mice was incubated with biotin-anti-CD3, CD4, and CD8 followed by anti-biotin microbeads (Miltenyi Biotec) and T cells were depleted by MACS prior to transfer into lethally irradiated WT B6 or RIP-mOVA recipients. Retroviral transduction of bone marrow from blt/blt or Rag1-GFP blt/blt mice was performed as described (Green et al., 2011) using the Platinum-E packaging cell line. Chimeric mice were analyzed at least 8 weeks after reconstitution.
For peripheral T cell transfers, spleen and lymph node cells were harvested from WT (control) or blt/blt mice and RBC-lysed. For thymocyte transfers, bulk thymocytes were prepared from blt/+ (control) or blt/blt mice. To distinguish between the two populations, either control or blt/blt cells were labeled with 1 μM CFSE (Life Technologies) for 10 min at 37°C before they were mixed and intravenously injected into lymphoreplete Boy/J (CD45.1+) mice. Recipients were analyzed at days 1 and 7 post-transfer and the percentage of blt/blt naïve T cells in the CD45.2+ donor population was determined. For Rag1-GFP T cell transfers, spleen and lymph node cells were harvested from Rag1-GFP blt/+ or Rag1-GFP blt/blt mice and RBC-lysed. Non-transgenic CD45.2+ blt/+ cells were used as a mixing control. Either control or Rag1-GFP cells were labeled with 10 μM CellTrace Violet (Life Technologies) for 20 min at 37°C before mixing and intravenous transfer into Boy/J recipients. At days 1, 3, and 5 post-transfer, Rag1-GFP blt/+ or Rag1-GFP blt/blt naïve T cells were assessed as a proportion of the total CD45.2+ donor population.
For BrdU experiments, mice received two intraperitoneal (i.p.) injections of 1 mg BrdU spaced 2 hr apart and were euthanized 4 hr after the first dose, or were fed 1 mg/ml BrdU in drinking water for longer-term labeling. To block thymic egress and induce mature SP thymocyte accumulation, mice were injected i.p. twice with FTY720 (Cayman Chemical, Ann Arbor, MI) dissolved in saline at a dose of 1 mg/kg body weight on days 0 and 2, and sacrificed on day 4.
FACS-purified CD4+ naïve T cells were labeled with 5 μM CFSE for 10 min at 37°C, quenched with fetal bovine serum (FBS) and washed in 10% FBS. Labeled cells were stimulated with plate-bound anti-mouse CD3 (clone 2C11; 1 μg/ml) and anti-mouse CD28 (clone 37.51; 1 μg/ml) for 3 days. For in vitro cell viability assays, semi-mature and mature CD4SP thymocytes were sorted from chimeras reconstituted with a mix of either blt/+ and WT or blt/blt and WT BM. Sorted cells were cultured in a 96-well plate at a density of 6–10 × 104 cells per well. All cells were cultured at 37°C in 5% CO2, using RPMI media supplemented with 10% FBS, L-glutamine, β-mercaptoethanol, penicillin, and streptomycin.
Thymocytes were lysed in RIPA buffer containing protease inhibitor cocktail (EMD Millipore). Samples were resolved on NuPAGE Bis-Tris gels (Life Technologies) and transferred to Immobilon-FL membranes (EMD Millipore). Primary antibodies used: anti-Zfp335 (A300-797A, A300-798A; Bethyl Laboratories), anti-actin (A2066, Sigma–Aldrich), and anti-FLAG M2 (F1804, Sigma–Aldrich). Ankle2 was detected using rabbit antiserum raised against human ANKLE2, provided by I Mattaj (EMBL, Heidelberg, Germany) (Asencio et al., 2012). Secondary antibodies used: goat anti-mouse IRDye 800CW, donkey anti-rabbit IRDye 700DX (Rockland Immunochemicals, Gilbertsville, PA). Blots were scanned using the Odyssey Infrared Imaging System (LI-COR Biosciences, Lincoln, NE).
HEK293T cells were transfected with FLAG-tagged WT or bloto Zfp335 (cloned as described) and nuclear extracts prepared using a modified Dignam protocol. Relative protein amounts were determined by Western blot using anti-Zfp335 (A300-797A). Gel mobility shift assays were performed as described (Lo et al., 1991). Briefly, nuclear extracts were mixed with 10 mM HEPES pH 7.9, 0.1 mM EDTA, 10% glycerol, 0.5 mM DTT, 0.1 mM PMSF, 0.08 mg/ml BSA, 0.04 mg/ml poly dI/dC, 0.4 mM ZnCl2, and 1ʹ mM biotin-labeled probe and incubated at room temperature for 20 min. For experiments using competitor oligos, 20- (Figure 7F) or 50-fold (Figure 7G) molar excess of unlabeled probe was pre-incubated with nuclear extracts on ice for 30 min before adding biotinylated probe. Samples were loaded on a 4% polyacrylamide gel with 3.5% glycerol in 0.25X TBE and run at constant voltage in 0.25X TBE running buffer, then transferred to Biodyne B nylon membranes (Pall Corporation, Port Washington, NY) in 0.5X TBE at 380 mA for 1 hr. Signal was detected with LightShift Chemiluminescent Nucleic Acid Detection Module kit (Thermo Scientific, Waltham, MA). All probes were derived from synthetic double-stranded 5ʹ-biotinylated oligonucleotides, listed in Supplementary file 5 (Integrated DNA Technologies, San Jose, CA).
Total RNA was isolated using the RNeasy Micro Kit (Qiagen, Venlo, The Netherlands); cDNA was synthesized using MMLV reverse transcriptase and random primers (Life Technologies) according to manufacturer's instructions. Real-time PCR was carried out using a StepOnePlus real-time PCR system (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA) with SYBR Green PCR Master Mix (Applied Biosystems) and the appropriate primer pairs (Supplementary file 6; Integrated DNA Technologies). Relative mRNA abundance of target genes was determined by subtracting the threshold cycle for the internal reference (Hprt1) from that of the target. Primer pairs were tested for linear amplification over two orders of magnitude.
For microarray analysis, cDNA was prepared using the Ovation Pico WTA System V2 and labeled using the Encore Biotin Module (NuGEN, San Carlos, CA). Labeled cDNA libraries were hybridized to Affymetrix Mouse 1.0 ST arrays (Affymetrix, Santa Clara, CA) and scanned with the Affymetrix GeneChip Scanner 3000 7G System. Raw data were normalized by RMA and probesets mapped to unique Entrez Gene IDs using a custom Brainarray CDF. The limma R package was used for analyzing differential gene expression. GENE-E software (Broad Institute) was used for heat map generation and hierarchical clustering.
Total thymocytes (20 × 106) or CD4SP thymocytes (4–10 × 106) were harvested from WT and blt/blt mice, cross-linked in 1% formaldehyde for 10 min at room temperature, quenched with 125 mM glycine and washed twice in ice-cold PBS. Cells were lysed in buffer containing 20 mM Tris–HCl (pH 8.0), 85 mM KCl, 0.5% Nonidet-P40, followed by nuclear lysis buffer (50 mM Tris–HCl pH 8.0, 10 mM EDTA, 1% SDS). Chromatin was sonicated with a Bioruptor (Diagenode, Liège, Belgium), cleared by centrifugation and diluted in buffer containing 20 mM Tris–HCl (pH 8.0), 1.1 mM EDTA, 140 mM NaCl, 0.01% SDS, and 1.1% Triton X-100. Diluted chromatin was incubated overnight at 4°C with antibody bound to Protein A Dynabeads (Life Technologies). All buffers up to this point were supplemented with protease inhibitors. Beads were washed in low salt buffer (10 mM Tris–HCl pH 8.0, 150 mM NaCl, 1 mM EDTA, 1% Triton X-100), high salt buffer (20 mM Tris–HCl pH 8.0, 500 mM NaCl, 2 mM EDTA, 1% Triton X-100, 0.1% SDS), LiCl buffer (10 mM Tris–HCl pH 8.0, 250 mM LiCl, 1 mM EDTA, 0.5% sodium deoxycholate, 0.5% Nonidet-P40), and TE buffer. Protein/DNA complexes were eluted (50 mM Tris–HCl pH 8.0, 10 mM EDTA, 1% SDS) at 65°C for 30 min with shaking on a Thermomixer (Eppendorf). Eluted complexes were reverse-crosslinked overnight at 65°C and then treated with RNase A (Sigma-Aldrich) and proteinase K (Life Technologies). ChIP DNA was purified using the QIAquick PCR purification kit (Qiagen) and quantitative PCR was performed using SYBR Green PCR Master Mix (Applied Biosystems) and primer pairs listed in Supplementary file 7. For Zfp335 ChIP, a polyclonal antibody specific for a C-terminal epitope (A300-798A; Bethyl Laboratories) was used.
ChIP was performed with total thymocytes (60 × 106 cells) as described above. Two antibodies were used: one raised against a C-terminal epitope (A300-798A; Bethyl Laboratories) and the other against an N-terminal epitope (A300-797A; Bethyl Laboratories) of ZNF335. 7–10 ng ChIP DNA and 10 ng input DNA were used for library preparation, performed according to Illumina's TruSeq protocol with some modifications. DNA clean-up, removal of adapter dimers, and size selection were done using Agencourt AMPure XP beads (Beckman Coulter, Brea, CA). Libraries were checked for quality using the High Sensitivity DNA Bioanalyzer kit (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA), quantified with the Qubit dsDNA HS Assay kit (Life Technologies), and sequenced as 50 bp single-end reads on the Illumina HiSeq 2000 platform.
Illumina adapter sequences were removed using the cutadapt tool. Trimmed reads were aligned to the mm9 reference genome using bwa, allowing for a maximum of two mismatches. Reads aligned with a MAPQ score of less than 20 were filtered out using samtools. Basic peak calling was performed with MACS2 (parameters: -g mm --bw = 300 –q 0.05). Peaks were annotated with their nearest RefSeq TSS using HOMER. Genomic feature annotation summary statistics were generated using the Galaxy/Cistrome CEAS module (version 1.0.0), and the full set of target genes (n = 177) defined as having a TSS within 1 kb of high-confidence peaks were identified using the BETA-minus module (version 1.0.0). To call differential binding events, samtools rmdup was first used to remove duplicate reads, after which regions of differential enrichment were identified using the MACS2 callpeak and bdgdiff modules. Normalized pileup tracks were generated from nonredundant reads using MACS2 callpeak--SPMR (fragment pileup per million reads) and converted to the bigWig format for visualization on the UCSC Genome Browser. The C-terminal antibody (A300-798A) was found to give better enrichment so we based our analyses of general Zfp335 binding properties on the ChIP-C WT data set, unless otherwise stated. H3K4me3, H3K27ac, and H3K27me3 ChIP-seq data for mouse thymus were downloaded from ENCODE/LICR (ENCODE Project Consortium, 2012), and aggregate density profiles were computed using bwtool.
Gene ontology enrichment analysis of Zfp335 binding regions was performed using the Genomic Regions Enrichment of Annotations Tool (GREAT). Each ChIP-seq peak was associated with the two nearest genes within 10 kb.
400 bp sequences centered on peak summits were extracted from the 119 top-scoring WT Zfp335 peak regions, repeat-masked and used for de novo motif discovery with MEME (parameters: min. width = 6, max. width = 30, zero or one instances of a given motif per sequence). The top-scoring motif obtained with MEME was replicated using HOMER's motif finding function. HOMER was used to detect Zfp335 motif occurrences and locations within defined genomic regions. HOMER was used to generate a histogram of motif density (bin size = 50 bp) for a region from −500 bp to +500 bp of Zfp335 ChIP-seq peaks. DNase I-seq signal and phyloP conservation scores for motifs occurring within Zfp335 peaks or ±2 kb of RefSeq TSS were aggregated using bwtool. The DNase I digital genomic footprinting (DGF) signal track for mouse thymus was obtained from ENCODE/UW (ENCODE Project Consortium, 2012); sequence conservation tracks were downloaded from UCSC Genome Browser (Raney et al., 2014).
Software tools used:
affy R package (Gautier et al., 2004)
limma R package (Smyth, 2004)
Brainarray custom CDF (mogene10st_Mm_ENTREZG_17.1.0) (Dai et al., 2005)
cutadapt 1.4.1 (Martin, 2011)
bwa 0.7.7 (Li and Durbin, 2009)
samtools 0.1.18 (Li et al., 2009)
bedtools 2.17.0 (Quinlan and Hall, 2010)
bwtool (Pohl and Beato, 2014)
MACS 2.0.10 (Zhang et al., 2008)
MEME 4.9.1 (Bailey et al., 2009)
HOMER 4.5 (Heinz et al., 2010)
GREAT 2.0.2 (McLean et al., 2010)
GSEA 2.0.14 (Subramanian et al., 2005)
Galaxy/Cistrome (Liu et al., 2011)
A homology model was generated by SWISS-MODEL utilizing using the known structure of a designed DNA-binding zinc finger protein (Protein Data Bank ID: 1MEYC) as template. Figures were created using MacPyMOL (version 126.96.36.199).
Data were analyzed with Prism 5 (GraphPad Software). The two-tailed non-parametric Mann–Whitney test was used for comparison of two unpaired groups for all data sets unless otherwise indicated.
Microarray and ChIP-seq data sets generated in this study were deposited to NCBI's Gene Expression Omnibus under SuperSeries GSE58293.
MEME SUITE: tools for motif discovery and searchingNucleic Acids Research 37:W202–W208.https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkp335
Transcriptional analysis of clonal deletion in vivoThe Journal of Immunology 179:837–844.https://doi.org/10.4049/jimmunol.179.2.837
Continued maturation of thymic emigrants in the peripheryNature Immunology 5:418–425.https://doi.org/10.1038/ni1049
Keep your fingers off my DNA: protein–protein interactions mediated by C2H2 zinc finger domainsCell Biochemistry and Biophysics 50:111–131.https://doi.org/10.1007/s12013-008-9008-5
Targeting of Ikaros to pericentromeric heterochromatin by direct DNA bindingGenes & Development 14:2146–2160.https://doi.org/10.1101/gad.816400
The Biology of recent thymic emigrantsAnnual Review of Immunology 31:31–50.https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-immunol-032712-100010
Identification and characterization of a novel nuclear protein complex involved in nuclear hormone receptor-mediated gene regulationThe Journal of Biological Chemistry 284:7542–7552.https://doi.org/10.1074/jbc.M805872200
RelB reduces thymocyte apoptosis and regulates terminal thymocyte maturationEuropean Journal of Immunology 32:1–9.https://doi.org/10.1002/1521-4141(200201)32
Macroautophagy in T Lymphocyte development and functionFrontiers in Immunology 3:22.https://doi.org/10.3389/fimmu.2012.00022
The immunological genome project: networks of gene expression in immune cellsNature Immunology 9:1091–1094.https://doi.org/10.1038/ni1008-1091
Central tolerance: learning self-control in the thymusNature Reviews Immunology 5:772–782.https://doi.org/10.1038/nri1707
NKAP is required for T cell maturation and acquisition of functional competencyJournal of Experimental Medicine 208:1291–1304.https://doi.org/10.1084/jem.20101874
C2H2 Zinc Fingers As DNA Binding Domains7–13, Boston, MA, Springer US.
Positive and negative selection of the T cell repertoire: what thymocytes see (and don't see)Nature Reviews Immunology 14:377–391.https://doi.org/10.1038/nri3667
Cutting edge: absence of expression of RAG1 in peritoneal B-1 cells detected by knocking into RAG1 locus with green fluorescent protein geneThe Journal of Immunology 163:6355–6359.
Chromatin remodeling complex NURF regulates thymocyte maturationGenes & Development 25:275–286.https://doi.org/10.1101/gad.2007311
Essential role of TAK1 in thymocyte development and activationProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of USA 103:11677–11682.https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0603089103
LyF-1, a transcriptional regulator that interacts with a novel class of promoters for lymphocyte-specific genesMolecular and Cellular Biology 11:5229–5243.
GREAT improves functional interpretation of cis-regulatory regionsNature Biotechnology 28:495–501.https://doi.org/10.1038/nbt.1630
The transcriptional landscape of αβ T cell differentiationNature Immunology 14:619–632.https://doi.org/10.1038/ni.2590
The Ikaros gene encodes a family of functionally diverse zinc finger DNA-binding proteinsMolecular and Cellular Biology 14:8292–8303.
A critical role for the autophagy gene Atg5 in T cell survival and proliferationJournal of Experimental Medicine 204:25–31.https://doi.org/10.1084/jem.20061303
Autophagy is essential for mitochondrial clearance in mature T lymphocytesThe Journal of Immunology 182:4046–4055.https://doi.org/10.4049/jimmunol.0801143
Dock8 mutations cripple B cell immunological synapses, germinal centers and long-lived antibody productionNature Reviews Immunology 10:1283–1291.https://doi.org/10.1038/ni.1820
ENCODE Data in the UCSC Genome Browser: year 5 updateNucleic Acids Research 41:D56–D63.https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gks1172
Essential function for the kinase TAK1 in innate and adaptive immune responsesNature Immunology 6:1087–1095.https://doi.org/10.1038/ni1255
NF-kB signaling mediates homeostatic maturation of new T cellsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of USA 111:E846–E855.https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1319397111
Transcriptional regulation in the immune system: a status reportTrends in Immunology 35:190–194.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.it.2014.03.003
Linear models and empirical bayes methods for assessing differential expression in microarray experimentsStatistical Applications in Genetics and Molecular Biology, 3, 10.2202/1544-6115.1027.
Positive and negative selection of T cellsAnnual Review of Immunology 21:139–176.https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.immunol.21.120601.141107
Selection of self-reactive T cells in the thymusAnnual Review of Immunology 30:95–114.https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-immunol-020711-075035
Gene set enrichment analysis: a knowledge-based approach for interpreting genome-wide expression profilesProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of USA 102:15545–15550.https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0506580102
Thymic emigration: when and how T cells leave homeThe Journal of Immunology 181:2265–2270.https://doi.org/10.4049/jimmunol.181.4.2265
An essential role for c-FLIP in the efficient development of mature T lymphocytesThe Journal of Experimental Medicine 202:395–404.https://doi.org/10.1084/jem.20050117
Michel NussenzweigReviewing Editor; Rockefeller University, United States
eLife posts the editorial decision letter and author response on a selection of the published articles (subject to the approval of the authors). An edited version of the letter sent to the authors after peer review is shown, indicating the substantive concerns or comments; minor concerns are not usually shown. Reviewers have the opportunity to discuss the decision before the letter is sent (see review process). Similarly, the author response typically shows only responses to the major concerns raised by the reviewers.
Thank you for sending your work entitled “Zinc finger protein Zfp335 is required for formation of the naïve T cell compartment” for consideration at eLife. Your article has been favorably evaluated by Tadatsugu Taniguchi (Senior editor), a member of our Board of Reviewing Editors, and 3 reviewers.
The referees’ comments, shown below, were both positive and constructive. After consultation, Michel Nussenzweig, our Reviewing editor, has decided that the conditional KO experiment suggested by referee #3 is not necessary.
This work from Dr. Cyster’s group has identified Zfp335 as a novel regulator of naive T cell maturation. The authors have elegantly combined forward genetics, immune assays and transcriptional analysis, and the experiments were designed and performed well with convincing results presented. This is certainly an interesting study, but I have the following comments for the authors to address.
1) Although the mutant mice have reduced peripheral cells, the physiological consequences on immune responses are unclear. The authors should test this in models of T cell-dependent immune responses.
2) In Figure 3, the authors showed that thymic but not peripheral naive T cells have defects in the maintenance upon adoptive transfer. They then described defect in RTE as a likely mechanism, but have not directly tested the survival or maintenance of RTE cells. This needs to be done.
3) In Figure 4, the authors measured expression of Bcl2 family proteins to exclude a role of cell apoptosis. They should directly measure cell apoptosis, e.g. by caspase staining.
4) In Figure 5, the authors used ChIP-Seq on total thymocytes to identify Zfp335 targets. Since the most relevant cell type is mature thymocytes, they need to validate the target genes by performing ChIP experiment using mature thymocytes followed by qPCR of the targets.
The manuscript by Han et al. describes the finding of a new Zinc finger protein Zfp335 in the development of mature thymocytes and peripheral T cells from the analysis of a mouse strain from ENU-mutagenesis. The developmental defects of T cells are restricted to the stages after DP thymocytes, particularly to mature SP, RTE, and peripheral T cells.
The causative gene was found to be a hypomorphic mutation of Zfp335 from the experiment by bone marrow reconstitution by retroviral transduction of the wild type and mutant Zfp335. By very extensive analyses using various TCR-Tg mouse models and systems, the authors suggested that the developmental defect could not be attributed to the impaired selection, cell survival, and thymic egress. To elucidate the defect by identifying the target genes of Zfp335, the authors found several possible target genes that Zfp335 directly binds. However, none of them could explain the developmental defect. One target gene Ankle2 may partly restore mature T cells.
Overall the analysis of the mutant mouse and gene demonstrated a critical role of Zfp335 in development of T cells and identify the target genes, but failed to neither reveal the mechanism of the developmental defect nor identify the function of Zfp335 gene.
1) Although Zfp335 restored mature T cell development by bone marrow reconstitution, it is recommended to confirm by the knock-in of Zfp335 because the mice may still contain other mutations and the heterogeneity of chimeric mice does not prove full restoration of development.
2) Thymic selection using OTII-Tg mice showed significant defect of development of mature TCR + T cells, the author might not simply neglect the effect on thymic selection.
3) The data for the effect of Ankle2 in the reconstitution experiment was complicated such as the analysis of Rag-GFPhigh and low population (for example why Thy1.1 expression levels were so different between Ankle2 vs. control). Simpler experiment and expression should be taken to show significant restoration from developmental arrest.
In this manuscript, Han et al., describe the analysis of the T cell compartment in the mouse mutant bloto, carrying a hypomorphic mutation in the zinc finger protein gene Zfp335. The authors identify a missense mutation in Zfp335 that alters zinc finger 12 and affects the DNA-binding ability of the protein. Homozygous bloto mice show a defect in the formation of the naive T cell compartment that cannot be attributed to altered thymic selection, cell proliferation or survival. ChIP-seq and microarray analyses to identify Zfp335-occupied and -regulated genes indicate that a very small number of genes are differentially bound and regulated in mutant and wild type thymocytes. Overexpression of one of these targets, Ankle2, in Rag1-GFP+ naive T cells showed a partial rescue of the mutant phenotyope.
The extensive analysis of the T cell defect of Zfp335bloto mice and the molecular examination of the defect in DNA binding and gene transcription are interesting and extend previous work on the function of Zfp335 in neural stem cells (Cell 151, 1097, 2012). The data are convincing and well presented. In particular, the partial rescue of the mutant phenotype by the overexpression of one of the identified Zfp335 targets provides strong evidence for the functional role of this Zfp335-regulated gene. However, the study would gain additional significance by the analysis of mice carrying a conditional null allele of Zfp335. Such mice have been published, and ES cells that harbor a conditional null allele of Zfp335 are available from a mutant mouse repository.
1) The authors need to address and/or discuss the discrepancies between the previous and current studies of Zfp335. For example, in Figure 4S3 the authors show that cell proliferation and survival are not affected by the bloto mutation. However, the previous analysis of lymphoblastic cells of humans carrying a hypomorphic H111R mutation shows an impaired growth of mutant cells.
2) In the ChIP-seq analysis, shown in Figures 5 and 6, the authors used the same anti-Zfp335 antibodies as the previous study. However, the authors identified a different sequence motif than the previously reported. Which parameters were used in the MEME analysis? What are the other significantly enriched motifs? Did the analysis detect the motif described in the Cell paper? If the motif width range is adjusted, is the other motif detected? I appreciate the inclusion of an electrophoretic mobility shift assay, which provides strong evidence for the newly identified sequence motif. The authors should also include the previously reported motif in this analysis.
3) One of the strongest points of the paper is the partial rescue of the T cell defect in bloto mice by the overexpression of Ankle2 (Figure 8). It would be of interest to examine the phenotype of an Ankle2 knock-down.https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.03549.030
- Jason G Cyster
- Jason G Cyster
- Brenda Y Han
- Chuan-Sheng Foo
- Chris C Goodnow
The funders had no role in study design, data collection and interpretation, or the decision to submit the work for publication.
We thank A Winoto (University of California Berkeley) and S Sanjabi (University of California San Francisco) for mice, J Landry (Virginia Commonwealth University) for sharing Bptf−/− expression data, H Schjerven, G Yeh, and S Smale (University of California Los Angeles) for EMSA protocols and advice, P Hartley and E Dang for ChIP-seq protocols, and M Thomson and A Marson (University of California San Francisco) for bioinformatics discussion. We acknowledge the ENCODE Consortium for histone ChIP-seq and DNase I-seq data sets, and the NIH Tetramer Core Facility (contract HHSN272201300006C) for provision of the mCD1d/PBS-57 tetramer. Special thanks to M Ansel for critical reading of the manuscript, Y Xu and J An for technical assistance, and members of the Cyster lab for helpful discussion.
Animal experimentation: All animal handling and experimentation were performed according to approved Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) protocols of the University of California San Francisco (UCSF; approval number AN087331-03) and of the Australian Phenomics Facility and the Australian National University (ANU; approval number A201¼6).
- Michel Nussenzweig, Reviewing Editor, Rockefeller University, United States
- Received: June 1, 2014
- Accepted: September 24, 2014
- Version of Record published: October 24, 2014 (version 1)
© 2014, Han et al.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.