Heterogeneous levels of delta-like 4 within a multinucleated niche cell maintains muscle stem cell diversity
- The Eli and Edythe Broad Center for Regenerative Medicine and Stem Cell Research, Department of Orthopedic Surgery, University of California San Francisco, United States
- Department of Biomedical Sciences, University of North Dakota School of Medicine and Health Sciences, United States
- Departments of Surgery and Orofacial Sciences, Program in Craniofacial Biology, University of California San Francisco, United States
Abstract
The quiescent muscle stem cell (QSC) pool is heterogeneous and generally characterized by the presence and levels of intrinsic myogenic transcription factors. Whether extrinsic factors maintain the diversity of states across the QSC pool remains unknown. The muscle fiber is a multinucleated syncytium that serves as a niche to QSCs, raising the possibility that the muscle fiber regulates the diversity of states across the QSC pool. Here, we show that the muscle fiber maintains a continuum of quiescent states, through a gradient of Notch ligand, Dll4, produced by the fiber and captured by QSCs. The abundance of Dll4 captured by the QSC correlates with the protein levels of the stem cell (SC) identity marker, Pax7. Niche-specific loss of Dll4 decreases QSC diversity and shifts the continuum to cell states that are biased toward more proliferative and committed fates. We reveal that fiber-derived Mindbomb1 (Mib1), an E3 ubiquitin ligase activates Dll4 and controls the heterogeneous levels of Dll4. In response to injury, with a Dll4-replenished niche, the normal continuum and diversity of the SC pool is restored, demonstrating bidirectionality within the SC continuum. Our data show that a post-translational mechanism controls heterogeneity of Notch ligands in a multinucleated niche cell to maintain a continuum of metastable states within the SC pool during tissue homeostasis.
Editor's evaluation
This is a strategic paper of relevance to both muscle and stem cell biologists. It bears on the generation of muscle stem cell diversity, and the factors bearing on this. Specifically, this paper identifies a particular, Notch ligand Dll4, as a myofiber-derived regulator of muscle stem cells.
https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.68180.sa0Introduction
Adult muscle stem cells (SCs) are essential for muscle tissue repair. Subsets of the SC pool are endowed with self-renewal potential and others are restricted to differentiation (Rocheteau et al., 2012; Chakkalakal et al., 2014; Kuang et al., 2007; Scaramozza et al., 2019; Zammit et al., 2004; Olguin and Olwin, 2004). This is consistent with a unidirectional and hierarchical relationship between SCs. Intrinsic and extrinsic cues regulate cell fate decisions of activated SCs to self-renew or differentiate (Dumont et al., 2015; Kuang et al., 2008). Due to low muscle tissue turnover, SCs exist predominantly in a quiescent state for the majority of adult life. Through single-cell RNA-sequencing (scRNA-seq) and transgenic reporter mice it is appreciated that the quiescent muscle stem cell (QSC) pool is molecularly and phenotypically heterogeneous (Dell’Orso et al., 2019, De Micheli et al., 2020; Chakkalakal et al., 2014; Rocheteau et al., 2012; Kuang et al., 2007; Kimmel et al., 2020). These different cell states enable SCs to exhibit functional heterogeneity in response to activation and injury cues. It is not known how these diverse states are maintained across the QSC pool. SC quiescence is actively maintained by paracrine-acting cues from the muscle fiber, serving as a niche cell (Bischoff, 1990; Goel et al., 2017; Eliazer et al., 2019). In contrast to niche cells across many SC compartments, each muscle fiber is a multinucleated syncytium, that exhibits transcriptional diversity across the myonuclei to provide spatial control for specialized functions (Kim et al., 2020; Petrany et al., 2020). Does the multinucleated niche cell regulate the diversity of states across the QSC pool?
Results
Adult QSCs exist in a continuum of molecular cell states
We first asked whether the QSC pool is composed of a continuum of cell states during tissue homeostasis. We stained freshly isolated single muscle fibers from adult mice, with the SC identify marker, Pax7 (Sambasivan et al., 2011; von Maltzahn et al., 2013; Lepper et al., 2011) and Ddx6 (p54/RCK), an RNA helicase found enriched in P-bodies and stress granules (Buchan and Parker, 2009). Pax7 and Ddx6 are expressed in QSCs and decrease during activation and commitment (Crist et al., 2012; Zammit et al., 2006). A density map of Pax7 and Ddx6 expression shows a broad range of expression levels across the QSC pool (Figure 1A–C). A bivariate plot shows a positive correlation between Pax7 and Ddx6 (Figure 1D). Therefore, based on the expression profile of two different markers, the QSC pool is composed of a continuum of molecular states at tissue homeostasis. This supports models inferred from scRNA-seq analysis on QSCs (De Micheli et al., 2020; Dell’Orso et al., 2019, Kimmel et al., 2020).
Figure 1 with 1 supplement see all
Adult quiescent muscle stem cells (QSCs) exist in diverse cell states.
(A) Representative images of a high and low Pax7+ stem cell (SC) on a freshly isolated muscle fiber that has corresponding high and low levels of Ddx6 protein. (B) A density map of Pax7 intensity in QSCs (n = 3). (C) A density map of Ddx6 intensity in QSCs (n = 3). (D) A bivariate plot between Pax7 and Ddx6 intensity in QSCs (n = 2). (E) A bivariate plot between Pax7 and Notch reporter intensity in QSCs (n = 3). (F) Image of SC with high Pax7 expression that expresses high Notch activity and an SC with low Pax7 intensity displaying low Notch activity. Scale bars, 5 μm in (A) and (F).
-
Figure 1—source data 1
Adult QSCs exist in diverse cell states.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig1-data1-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 1—source data 2
Adult QSCs exist in diverse cell states.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig1-data2-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 1—source data 3
Adult QSCs exist in diverse cell states.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig1-data3-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 1—source data 4
Adult QSCs exist in diverse cell states.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig1-data4-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 1—source data 5
Adult QSCs exist in diverse cell states.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig1-data5-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 1—source data 6
Adult QSCs exist in diverse cell states.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig1-data6-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 1—source data 7
Adult QSCs exist in diverse cell states.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig1-data7-v1.xlsx
To determine the fate bias of cells along the continuum, we isolated Pax7high-, Pax7medium-, and Pax7low -expressing populations of SCs from Pax7-nGFP reporter mice (Rocheteau et al., 2012; Figure 1—figure supplement 1A–C), and analyzed cell cycle entry and differentiation. As expected, the Pax7low population entered cell cycle and differentiated faster than the Pax7high expressers, suggesting that Pax7high SCs are in a more dormant state and the Pax7low SCs exist in a primed state (Rocheteau et al., 2012). We find that the Pax7medium population is in an intermediate molecular and phenotypic state between the Pax7high and Pax7low QSCs (Figure 1—figure supplement 1D, E). Therefore, the QSC pool exists in a continuum of cell states that gives rise to a continuum of fates.
Heterogeneous expression of Dll4 in a multinucleated niche cell is coupled to QSC diversity
The multinucleated muscle fiber functions as a niche cell for the SC, regulating the depth of quiescence and rate of activation in response to injury (Eliazer et al., 2019). The Delta-Notch signaling pathway is an evolutionarily conserved intercellular signaling pathway for cell fate specification (Kopan and Ilagan, 2009). Adult muscle QSCs display active notch signaling (Bjornson et al., 2012; Mourikis et al., 2012; Fukada et al., 2011; Low et al., 2018; Verma et al., 2018). Overexpression of NICD1 increases Pax7 expression (Wen et al., 2012) and Rbpj, a transcriptional coactivator of the notch signaling pathway, maintains the SC pool by repressing differentiation (Bjornson et al., 2012; Mourikis et al., 2012). A transgenic notch reporter mouse line where green fluorescent protein (GFP) is under the control of C promoter-binding factor 1 (CBF1) (Duncan et al., 2005) exhibits variable levels of notch activity in QSCs (Bjornson et al., 2012). Using the same reporter, we find that notch activity levels exist on a continuum across the SC pool and positively correlates with Pax7 expression levels (Figure 1E, F), raising the possibility that Notch ligands maintain the continuum of diverse cell states across the QSC pool.
To identify notch ligands specifically expressed in adult myofibers, we first examined Notch ligands on isolated single muscle fibers from postnatal day 3 (p3), postnatal day 7 (p7), and adult through microarray analysis. Dll4 transcripts in the fiber showed the most enrichment as the SC transitioned from proliferating myogenic progenitors (postnatal) to becoming quiescent (adult) (Figure 2—figure supplement 1A). RT-qPCR(Real Time-quantiative PCR) on isolated adult single muscle fibers show the expression of Dll4 transcripts, which was confirmed by RNAscope and immunofluorescence (Figure 2—figure supplement 1B, C and Figure 2A; Kann and Krauss, 2019). Dll4 transcripts are expressed in less than 1% of QSCs (Kimmel et al., 2020; De Micheli et al., 2020), suggesting that the muscle fiber is a source of SC-bound Dll4. Since the QSC pool is distributed as a continuum of cell states, we hypothesized that Dll4 expression across the multinucleated niche cell is heterogeneous. Single muscle fibers stained with anti-Dll4 show that Dll4 protein formed clusters along the muscle fiber and were enriched around the QSCs. Further analysis revealed that heterogeneous spatial expression of Dll4 protein along the muscle fiber correlated with the amount of Dll4 captured by the SCs (Figure 2A, Figure 2—figure supplement 2). We observed a positive correlation between the amount of Dll4 foci on the fibers and the intensity of Dll4 present on the adjacent QSC (Figure 2B).
Figure 2 with 2 supplements see all
Heterogeneous expression of Dll4 on the muscle fiber correlates with stem cell (SC) diversity.
(A) Representative images of regions of muscle fiber expressing heterogeneous levels of Dll4 protein, which corresponds to the amount of Dll4 captured by the adjacent SC and the expression of Pax7. (B) A bivariate plot between the number of Dll4 foci on fiber adjacent to an SC and the intensity of Dll4 captured by the SC (n > 3 mice). (C) An XY plot on isolated wildtype quiescent muscle stem cells (QSCs) shows positive correlation between intensity of Dll4 captured by SC and its Pax7 intensity (n = 3 mice). (D) Freshly isolated green fluorescent protein (GFP) low, medium, and high expressing SCs from transgenic Pax7-nGFP reporter mice were stained for Dll4 (n = 3). (E) An XY plot shows positive correlation between intensity of Dll4 captured by SC and its GFP (Pax7) intensity (n = 3 mice). Error bars, mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM); ****p < 0.0001. Scale bars, 10 μm in (A).
-
Figure 2—source data 1
Heterogeneous expression of Dll4 on the muscle fiber correlates with SC diversity.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig2-data1-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 2—source data 2
Heterogeneous expression of Dll4 on the muscle fiber correlates with SC diversity.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig2-data2-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 2—source data 3
Heterogeneous expression of Dll4 on the muscle fiber correlates with SC diversity.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig2-data3-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 2—source data 4
Heterogeneous expression of Dll4 on the muscle fiber correlates with SC diversity.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig2-data4-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 2—source data 5
Heterogeneous expression of Dll4 on the muscle fiber correlates with SC diversity.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig2-data5-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 2—source data 6
Heterogeneous expression of Dll4 on the muscle fiber correlates with SC diversity.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig2-data6-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 2—source data 7
Heterogeneous expression of Dll4 on the muscle fiber correlates with SC diversity.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig2-data7-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 2—source data 8
Heterogeneous expression of Dll4 on the muscle fiber correlates with SC diversity.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig2-data8-v1.xlsx
To directly link Dll4 localization with SC diversity, we isolated and stained SCs for Dll4 and Pax7. A bivariate plot of Pax7 and Dll4 expression within SCs reveals a positive correlation between the Dll4 captured by the SC and Pax7 intensity (Figure 2C). Comparison between Dll4 protein and Pax7 levels using a Pax7-nGFP reporter, confirmed the positive correlation between Pax7 and Dll4 protein expression (Figure 2D, E). In contrast, the localization of Dll4 transcript on the muscle fiber did not correlate with Pax7 expression in the adjacent SC (Figure 2—figure supplement 1C and D).
We next asked about the distribution of Dll4 protein along muscle fibers. Quantification of Dll4 expression levels on single Extensor Digitorum Longus (EDL) muscle fibers showed that Dll4 expression is variable along the fiber, and not linked to the neuromuscular junction based on α-bungarotoxin expression or the myotendinous junction based on location (Figure 2—figure supplement 2). We find no consistent pattern of Dll4 protein along the fibers. Therefore, Dll4 spatial distribution does not map to these known anatomically defined regions of freshly isolated single muscle fibers. In addition, fewer than 10% of fibers are exclusively Dll4High or Dll4low, suggesting SC diversity is coordinated in a fiber-autonomous manner. Dll4 expression was also variable in regions devoid of SCs, suggesting the presence of an SC does not dictate Dll4 levels along muscle fibers. Instead, the intensity of Dll4 captured by SCs and the Pax7 expression correlated with the level of Dll4 expression along the muscle fiber (Figure 2—figure supplement 2). Therefore, spatial heterogeneity and levels of niche-derived Dll4 are coupled with a continuum of diverse molecular SC states that are biased to different phenotypic fates.
Niche-derived Dll4 maintains SC diversity
To determine if Dll4 from the muscle fiber controlled SC diversity, we deleted Dll4 (Hozumi et al., 2008) specifically in the adult muscle fibers using a tamoxifen (tmx)-inducible human ACTA-CreMer mouse line (McCarthy et al., 2012) (transgenic mice are herein called as MF-Dll4fl/fl) (Figure 3A). The abundance of Dll4 in the muscle fiber and captured by SCs decreased in MF-Dll4fl/fl compared to control, suggesting that the muscle fiber is the major source of SC-bound Dll4 in uninjured muscle (Figure 3B–D). It is possible that cell sources other than the muscle fiber could provide Dll4 to SCs in other contexts (Verma et al., 2018). We observed that Pax7 and Ddx6 expression in SCs from MF-Dll4fl/fl fibers decreased compared to controls (Figure 3E, G). Density maps reveal a shift in the distribution of expression levels of Pax7 and Ddx6. We calculated the variance of the expression levels to gauge the spread of the distribution. The decrease in variance in MF-Dll4fl/fl compared to controls, indicates reduced diversity across the QSC pool, effectively reducing the range of states across the continuum (Figure 3F, H). We observed a 50% decrease in the total number of Pax7+ SCs in MF-Dll4fl/fl fibers compared to controls (Figure 3—figure supplement 1A, B), suggesting a SC loss phenotype.
Figure 3 with 2 supplements see all
Muscle fiber-derived Dll4 maintains a continuum of diverse states in the quiescent muscle stem cell (QSC) pool.
(A) Schematic representation of the experimental design. (B–F) Representative images of Dll4 and Pax7 expression in Control and MF-Dll4fl/fl fibers and stem cells (SCs) (in B), quantification of Dll4 intensity in fibers (in C), intensity of Dll4 captured by SCs (in D), Pax7 intensity in SCs (in E), and a density map of Pax7 intensity in SCs (in F) (n = 3 mice). (G, H) Ddx6 intensity in SCs (in G) and density map of Ddx6 intensity in SCs (in H) on Control and MF-Dll4fl/fl fibers (n = 3 mice). (I) Notch reporter intensity levels in Control and MF-Dll4fl/fl SCs (n = 3). Error bars, mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM); ****p < 0.0001; scale bars, 10 μm in (B).
-
Figure 3—source data 1
Muscle fiber derived Dll4 maintains a continuum of diverse states in the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig3-data1-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 3—source data 2
Muscle fiber derived Dll4 maintains a continuum of diverse states in the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig3-data2-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 3—source data 3
Muscle fiber derived Dll4 maintains a continuum of diverse states in the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig3-data3-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 3—source data 4
Muscle fiber derived Dll4 maintains a continuum of diverse states in the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig3-data4-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 3—source data 5
Muscle fiber derived Dll4 maintains a continuum of diverse states in the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig3-data5-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 3—source data 6
Muscle fiber derived Dll4 maintains a continuum of diverse states in the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig3-data6-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 3—source data 7
Muscle fiber derived Dll4 maintains a continuum of diverse states in the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig3-data7-v1.xlsx
Deletion of Rbpj from SCs reduced SC population by over 95% (Bjornson et al., 2012; Mourikis et al., 2012). We wondered whether the partial SC ablation after Dll4 deletion was due to a more modest effect on notch signaling. To determine the contribution of niche-derived Dll4 to notch activity in SCs, we crossed mice harboring the notch reporter CBF1-GFP (Duncan et al., 2005) with MF-Dll4fl/fl. We observed a 95% decrease in notch reporter activity after Dll4 deletion from the niche (Figure 3I), suggesting that Dll4 from the fibers nonautonomously regulates Notch activity in the QSCs and that Dll4 from the muscle fiber is the dominant source of notch ligand. This argues against differential notch activity to explain the differences in SC loss phenotypes.
A decrease in SC diversity, number and Pax7 levels can be explained by a loss of Pax7high SCs (due to apoptosis or fusion), or a shift in the continuum toward a more committed fusion-competent state, followed by fusion of SCs expressing the lowest levels of Pax7. qRT-PCR on QSCs from control and MF-Dll4fl/fl revealed a decrease in Pax7 (SC marker) and an increase in Myod (activation marker) and Myog (differentiation marker) transcripts (Figure 5B). The simultaneous loss of Pax7 and induction of Myog a gene not normally expressed in QSCs suggests a shift in the QSC continuum. While a loss of Pax7high cells alone would not increase Myog expression, we cannot exclude a loss of Pax7high SCs in addition to the shift in continuum.
To resolve these possibilities, rather than deleting, we reduced Dll4 levels in the muscle fiber by injecting control and MF-Dll4fl/fl mice submaximal doses of tmx (75 mg/kg/day for seven consecutive days). Reducing Dll4 in fibers redistributed the SC population along the continuum toward lower Pax7 levels without decreasing their numbers (Figure 4). This suggests that heterogeneous levels of Dll4 in muscle fibers maintain a distribution of metastable states across the QSC pool during tissue homeostasis.
Figure 4
Reduction of Dll4 in the niche causes a shift in the continuum toward lower Pax7 levels.
(A–C) Quantification of the number of Pax7+ stem cells (SCs) (in A), Dll4 intensity in muscle fibers (in B), Pax7 intensity in SCs (in C) of Control mice compared to MF-Dll4fl/fl mice that were given low dose (75 mg/kg/day) or regular dose (150 mg/kg/day) of tmx to reduce or completely ablate the expression of Dll4, respectively. (D) Density plot of the Pax7 intensity in SCs of Control mice compared to MF-Dll4fl/fl mice that were given the two different doses of tmx (n = 3 mice). Error bars, mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM); ns, nonsignificant, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001.
-
Figure 4—source data 1
Reduction of Dll4 in the niche causes a shift in the continuum towards lower Pax7 levels.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig4-data1-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 4—source data 2
Reduction of Dll4 in the niche causes a shift in the continuum towards lower Pax7 levels.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig4-data2-v1.xlsx
Deletion of Dll4 in Pax7+ SCs using a Pax7-CreER transgenic mouse line (Nishijo et al., 2009) (referred to as SC-Dll4fl/fl) did not change Pax7+ SC number, compared to controls (Figure 3—figure supplement 2), suggesting that Dll4 does not have an autocrine role in QSCs. Together, these results suggest that Dll4 from the muscle fiber is required to maintain the continuum of diverse cellular states across the QSC pool.
Dll4 from the muscle fiber constrains the proliferative and commitment potential across the QSC pool
To analyze the phenotypic fates of the QSCs that remained in a Dll4-depleted niche, we cultured isolated single muscle fibers from control and MF-Dll4fl/fl mice and analyzed them at 0, 30, and 48 hr (Figure 5A). Quantification of SC numbers per fiber reveal that the differences observed between control and MF-Dll4fl/fl becomes narrow over time in culture (Figure 5C, Figure 5—figure supplement 1A). This observation is consistent with the result that SCs on a Dll4-depleted niche entered cell cycle faster than controls (Figure 5D, Figure 5—figure supplement 1B). The absolute number of Myogenin+ cells per fiber at 48 hr was increased, suggesting that a fraction of the remaining SCs on a Dll4-depleted niche rapidly entered the differentiation program when exposed to mitogen (Figure 5E). These data are consistent with a redistribution of the QSC pool along the continuum toward lower levels of Pax7 (Figure 1—figure supplement 1). Induction of Myogenin is consistent with the antidifferentiative role of Rbpj (Bjornson et al., 2012; Mourikis et al., 2012). Based on prior work, we would not have predicted an increase in SC proliferation in mitogen after niche depletion of Dll4 (Bjornson et al., 2012; Mourikis et al., 2012). This likely reflects the relative fraction of SCs that remain after Rbpj deletion in SCs versus Dll4 deletion from the niche.
Figure 5 with 2 supplements see all
Niche-derived Dll4 constrains the proliferative and commitment potential of the quiescent muscle stem cell (QSC) pool.
(A) Schematic representation of the experimental design. (B) qRT-PCR for Pax7, MyoD, and Myogenin transcripts in freshly isolated stem cells (SCs) from Control and MF-Dll4fl/fl fibers (n = 2). (C) Number of Pax7+ SCs at t0, t30, and t48 in cultured Control and MF-Dll4fl/fl fibers (n = 3). (D) Control and Dll4 deleted fibers were cultured in plating media containing EdU for 30 hr and the percent of EdU+ SCs per fiber were quantified (n = 3). (E) Control and MF-Dll4fl/fl fibers were cultured in vitro for 48 hr and the MyoG+ cells per fiber were quantified (n = 3). (F, G) Representative images (in F) and quantification (in G) of mean cross-sectional area of Control and MF-Dll4fl/fl tibialis anterior (TA) fibers, injured and regenerated for 14 days (n ≥ 4). (H, I) Density map of Pax7 intensity in SCs from Ctrl and MF-Dll4fl/fl contralateral TA (in H) and injured TA (in I), 14-day postinjury (n = 3). (J) Number of Pax7+ SCs in regenerated TA muscle, 14 days after injury (n ≥ 5). Error bars, mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM); ns, nonsignificant, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001; scale bars, 100 μm in (F).
-
Figure 5—source data 1
Niche derived Dll4 constrains the proliferative and commitment potential of the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig5-data1-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 5—source data 2
Niche derived Dll4 constrains the proliferative and commitment potential of the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig5-data2-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 5—source data 3
Niche derived Dll4 constrains the proliferative and commitment potential of the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig5-data3-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 5—source data 4
Niche derived Dll4 constrains the proliferative and commitment potential of the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig5-data4-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 5—source data 5
Niche derived Dll4 constrains the proliferative and commitment potential of the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig5-data5-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 5—source data 6
Niche derived Dll4 constrains the proliferative and commitment potential of the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig5-data6-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 5—source data 7
Niche derived Dll4 constrains the proliferative and commitment potential of the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig5-data7-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 5—source data 8
Niche derived Dll4 constrains the proliferative and commitment potential of the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig5-data8-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 5—source data 9
Niche derived Dll4 constrains the proliferative and commitment potential of the QSC pool.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig5-data9-v1.xlsx
We next examined the effect of a Dll4-depleted niche on fate potential of the remaining SCs in response to muscle injury. Using the tmx-inducible MF-CreMer/+ genetic model, the niche is genetically modified, but the SCs are genetically wildtype. The wildtype SCs reform the adult muscle fibers during regeneration (Eliazer et al., 2019). Therefore, any regenerative phenotype observed is directly due to the loss of Dll4 in the niche prior to injury. Fourteen days after injury, muscle fiber size in MF-Dll4fl/fl TA muscle was significantly smaller than controls (Figure 5F, G), consistent with the rapid entrance of some SCs into the differentiation program, as reported after deletion of Rbpj in SCs (Bjornson et al., 2012; Mourikis et al., 2012). The impaired differentiation phenotype in MF-Dll4fl/fl TA muscle is also seen 40 days after injury (Figure 5—figure supplement 2). The inability to repair muscle fibers after a loss in SC diversity suggests a reduced pool of fusion-competent progenitors.
We next asked whether the remaining population of Pax7+ SCs in a Dll4-depleted niche could reestablish the normal continuum of Pax7+ states in the injury model. In contrast to the contralateral uninjured muscle, the average Pax7 levels and the variance across the SC population was not different in a Dll4-replenished niche and control niche (Figure 5H, I). In addition, the number of Pax7+ cells was similar to control regenerated muscle (Figure 5J). This was unanticipated due to the decrease in Pax7 levels and a shift along the continuum toward a more committed state in the QSC pool (Rocheteau et al., 2012; Kuang et al., 2007). Therefore, SCs expressing modest levels of Pax7 have the potential to produce SCs with higher levels of Pax7, revealing an unappreciated level of plasticity and bidirectionality along the SC continuum during muscle regeneration.
Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4
Single nucleus RNA sequencing has uncovered substantial transcriptional diversity across muscle fibers (Kim et al., 2020; Petrany et al., 2020). However, Dll4 activity is regulated post-translationally. Mindbomb1 (Mib1), is an E3 ubiquitin ligase that activates all Notch ligands in the signal sending cell by adding mono-ubiquitin groups onto the ligands (Koo et al., 2005; Koo, 2007). Mib1 in the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) activates Notch signaling in the adjacent retinal progenitor cell (RPC) by localizing active Notch ligands in the RPE–RPC contacts (Ha et al., 2017). The hypothalamus–pituitary–gonadal axis has been shown to induce Mib1 in muscle fibers during development, thus activating notch signaling in juvenile SCs (Kim et al., 2016). To determine if the heterogeneous pattern of Dll4 on the adult muscle fiber is directed by Mib1, we analyzed the spatial expression of Mib1 on adult muscle fibers. We stained isolated single muscle fibers with Mib1 antibody and found heterogeneous expression pattern of Mib1 on individual muscle fibers. Similar to Dll4 expression, we observed a positive correlation between the intensity of Mib1 expression on muscle fibers and Pax7 intensity within the adjacent SC (Figure 6A, B). Formation of Dll4 clusters is a marker of the activated form of the ligand (Le Borgne and Schweisguth, 2003). To test whether Mib1 played a role in clustering and activating Dll4 on the muscle fibers, Mib1 floxed mice (Koo, 2007) were crossed with tamoxifen-inducible human ACTA1-CreMer mice (transgenic: hereafter called as MF-Mib1fl/fl). After a 30-day chase, the expression of Mib1 transcripts was decreased in the Mib1-depleted myofibers compared to controls (Figure 7A, B). Analysis of Dll4 expression in control and MF-Mib1fl/fl isolated single muscle fibers, revealed a loss of Dll4 clusters and a reduction in the intensity of Dll4 expression in Mib1-depleted niche (Figure 6C–E). Therefore, Mib1 directs the activation and heterogeneous patterning of Dll4 within a multinucleated niche cell.
Figure 6
Niche-derived Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4.
(A) Representative images of WT fibers showing regions of high and low Mib1 protein expression and the adjacent Pax7+ stem cell (SC). (B) A bivariate plot showing Mib1 intensity in the fiber and Pax7 intensity in the adjacent SC. (C–G) Representative images of Dll4 expression in fibers and Pax7 expression in adjacent SCs present on Control and MF-Mib1fl/fl fibers (in C), quantification of Dll4 intensity in fibers (in D), intensity of Dll4 captured by SCs (in E), Pax7 intensity in SCs (in F), and a density map of Pax7 intensity in SCs (in G) on Control and MF-Mib1fl/fl fibers (n = 3 mice). Error bars, mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM); ****p < 0.0001; scale bars, 5 μm in (A) and (C).
-
Figure 6—source data 1
Niche-derived Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig6-data1-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 6—source data 2
Niche-derived Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig6-data2-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 6—source data 3
Niche-derived Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig6-data3-v1.xlsx
Figure 7
Mib1 in the muscle fiber maintains quiescent muscle stem cells (QSCs) by inhibiting differentiation.
(A) Schematic representation of the experimental design. (B) qRT-PCR for mib1 transcripts in fibers of Control and MF-Mib1fl/fl normalized to GAPDH (n = 3). (C) Number of Pax7+ stem cells (SCs) in tibialis anterior (TA) muscle sections of Control and MF-Mib1fl/fl (n = 6). (D) qRT-PCR for Pax7, MyoD, and Myogenin transcripts in freshly isolated SCs from Control and MF-Mib1fl/fl fibers, normalized to GAPDH (n = 3). (E–G) Representative images of Sdc4 and MyoG expression in SCs from Control and Mib1-deleted fibers, cultured in vitro in plating media for 48 hr (in E), the number of Pax7+ SCs (in F), and the absolute number of MyoG+ cells (in G) per fiber were quantified (n = 3). (H, I) Representative images (in H) and quantification (in I) of mean cross-sectional area of Control and MF-Mib1fl/fl TA muscle fibers, injured and regenerated for 14 days (n ≥ 3). (J) Number of Pax7+ SCs in regenerated TA muscle, 14 days after injury (n = 5). Error bars, mean ± standard error of the mean (SEM); ns, nonsignificant, *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001; scale bars, 10 μm in (E) and 100 μm in (H).
-
Figure 7—source data 1
Niche-derived Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig7-data1-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 7—source data 2
Niche-derived Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig7-data2-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 7—source data 3
Niche-derived Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig7-data3-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 7—source data 4
Niche-derived Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig7-data4-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 7—source data 5
Niche-derived Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig7-data5-v1.xlsx
-
Figure 7—source data 6
Niche-derived Mib1 directs spatial patterning and activation of Dll4.
- https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/68180/elife-68180-fig7-data6-v1.xlsx
Niche-derived Mib1 maintains a continuum of states across the QSC pool
Based on the loss of SC-bound Dll4 after Mib1 deletion in the niche, we analyzed the levels and diversity of Pax7 across the QSC pool on a Mib1-depleted niche. Compared to controls, Pax7 levels decreased, the variance across the QSC pool was reduced and SC number was less in a Mib1-depleted niche (Figure 6C, F, G). RT-qPCR of myogenic markers shows that Pax7 and Myod transcript levels did not change. However, Myog was upregulated in the SCs remaining on a Mib1-depleted niche (Figure 7D). In response to activation cues, SCs on a Mib1-depleted niche proliferate faster and upregulate Myogenin compared to the SCs on control muscle fibers, indicating that the remaining SCs are primed for proliferation and differentiation (Figure 7E–G). In response to muscle injury, the size of regenerating muscle fibers was smaller than the control muscle fibers, although the number of Pax7+ SCs is the same as control in the regenerated muscle (Figure 7H–J). Therefore, the effect of Mib1 deletion from the niche mimics that of Dll4 deletion. In conclusion, niche-derived Mib1 expressed in a heterogeneous pattern along the muscle fiber maintains the normal continuum of diverse QSC states during tissue homeostasis.
Discussion
The composition and location of niche cells are critical for SC regulation. The multinucleated muscle fiber acts as a niche cell to maintain the QSC pool in a continuum of diverse states through the heterogeneous patterning of the E3 ligase, Mib1 and activation of Dll4, in a fiber-autonomous manner. Therefore, niche-derived Dll4 acts as a rheostat, placing a cell along a continuum of states that are fate biased (Figure 8).
Figure 8
Model depicting heterogeneous levels of Dll4/Mib1 in the niche regulates a continuum of metastable stem cell (SC) states.
(A) Top: During tissue homeostasis, Notch ligand Dll4 is present in a heterogeneous manner along the length of the muscle fibers that maintains the size of the SC pool and a continuum of quiescent metastable cell states. Middle: A reduction in Dll4/Mib1 levels does not change the number of SCs, but causes a shift in metastable states toward activation and commitment. Bottom: Complete ablation of Dll4/Mib1 in the muscle fibers results in a more dramatic shift in the metastable states away from quiescent self-renewing fates toward more proliferative and committed fates, and SC loss likely by fusion into muscle fibers. (B) Top: In the event of an injury, the SC metastable states are reformed on newly regenerated muscle fibers. Bottom: After injury to a Dll4/Mib1-depleted niche, wildtype SCs reform the niche, restoring the normal distribution of metastable SC states.
Our results provide the first direct demonstration of a Notch ligand from a specific cell type that is critical to maintain a continuum of metastable states within the QSC pool. This diversity and plasticity are important in the event of an injury, so that all the SCs are not equally lost to activation or differentiation. This continuum is actively maintained in uninjured muscle by the heterogeneous pattern (and levels) of Dll4 and Mib1 on the muscle fibers. Depletion of Dll4 and Mib1 in muscle fibers causes a contraction of the SC continuum toward more homogeneous committed states.
The spatial localization of the different factors in the cytoplasm of a single multinucleated cell governs the cell state of the SC pool. Expression of Wnt4 along the fiber is ubiquitous, thereby inhibiting proliferation of all SCs (Eliazer et al., 2019). The heterogeneous expression of Dll4 within the muscle fiber allows the maintenance of a continuum of differentiated states, with SCs in a region of low Dll4 expression are primed to proliferate and differentiate when subjected to injury in vivo or exposed to mitogen in vitro.
Although snRNA sequencing shows transcriptional heterogeneity within the myonuclei of single muscle fibers (Kim et al., 2020; Petrany et al., 2020), we show that the transcripts of Dll4 are uniformly expressed along the muscle fiber and the protein expression is heterogeneous. This highlights the importance of protein heterogeneity within single muscle fibers. The varied expression of Dll4 is established by the E3 ligase, Mib1 that adds ubiquitin groups to Dll4 and activates them by a process of endocytosis (Koo et al., 2005; Koo, 2007). The formation of endosomes might play a role in clustering the Dll4 ligand to present them to the adjacent receptors on the QSCs.
Previous work has shown that Mib1 is essential in postnatal developing muscle to convert proliferating SCs into a quiescent state. Sex hormones activate Notch signaling pathway during puberty, thereby driving SCs into quiescence (Kim et al., 2016). Here, we show a different function of Mib1 in adult muscle under homeostatic conditions. In adult muscle fibers, Mib1 regulates the spatial expression and levels of Dll4, and is required to maintain a gradient of commitment states within the QSC pool.
The deletion of Mib1 or Dll4 within the fiber resulted in a 50% diminution of the SC pool, whereas, deletion of Rbpj in adult SCs displayed a more robust depletion (>95%) (Bjornson et al., 2012; Mourikis et al., 2012). This suggests that Rbpj might have targets other than the Notch signaling pathway. Deletion of Rbpj in SCs also caused the SC pool to precociously differentiate. We propose that SCs sit along a continuum dictated by the levels of fiber-derived Dll4. Disruption of Dll4 and Mib1 levels in the muscle fiber repositions the SCs along the continuum, biasing cell fate outcomes of the whole population.
Notch ligands added to SCs in vitro promoted quiescence of myoblasts at the expense of differentiation, but did not restore stemness (Sakai et al., 2017). Therefore, quiescence is not equivalent to stemness; consistent with the observations that only subsets of QSCs possess self-renewal potential in transplantation assay (Rocheteau et al., 2012; Chakkalakal et al., 2012; Sacco et al., 2008). These data also raise the possibility that Notch signaling directly regulates differentiation potential of a QSC rather than direct regulation of the quiescent state.
scRNA-seq on cells from regenerating muscle suggests that Dll1 is expressed in a subset of differentiating, Myogenin+ cells and is important for self-renewal (Yartseva et al., 2020). Dll1 expressed in activated and differentiated myogenic cells regulates the self-renewal of neighboring myogenic cells through a process of lateral inhibition (Zhang et al., 2021). In vitro experiments using co-culture of primary myoblasts with 3T3 cells overexpressing Dll4 (Low et al., 2018), or with endothelial cells (Verma et al., 2018) suggests the importance of the Notch ligand Dll4 in self-renewal at the expense of differentiation. We posit that in the presence of extrinsic cues that drive cell cycle exit (quiescence or differentiation) cells will be fated to quiescence (self-renewal) or differentiation based on location along a continuum. Notch signaling maintains cells in metastable states competent for a return to quiescence.
Using a low-dose tamoxifen strategy, we were able to demonstrate that decreasing Dll4 shifted the continuum toward commitment, without any change in SC number in the absence of injury. Therefore, QSC pool exists in a series of metastable states that is under the control of niche-derived Dll4. Prior work demonstrated that SCs with low levels of Pax7 are less competent for self-renewal in vivo (Rocheteau et al., 2012). Based on the decrease in Pax7 levels after Dll4 depletion from the niche, we predicted a diminution of the SC pool in response to injury. Instead, the number of SCs and Pax7 levels was increased after injury; restoring them back to control levels (Figure 5H, I). This demonstrates a level of plasticity and bidirectional flow of SCs along the continuum to allow the reequilibrium of metastable states after tissue repair is complete. This interpretation is only possible because we developed an approach that allows for the transient loss of Dll4 in the niche prior to injury.
In the future, it will be interesting to investigate how distinct niche factors that control quiescence versus commitment are coordinated. Our findings provide proof-of-principle for niche-based strategies to modify the fate potential of SCs while residing in a quiescent state.
Materials and methods
Animals
Mice were housed and maintained in accordance with the guidelines of the Laboratory Animal Research Center (LARC) of University of California, San Francisco. C57BL/6 were obtained from Jackson Laboratory. Previously published Pax7-nGFP (Rocheteau et al., 2012), human ACTA1-CreMer (McCarthy et al., 2012), Dll4flox/flox (Hozumi et al., 2008), Mib1flox/flox (Koo, 2007), Pax7-CreER (Nishijo et al., 2009), and Notch reporter CBF1-GFP (Duncan et al., 2005) were used in this study. All mice used for experiments were adults, between 12 and 16 weeks of age. The control and experimental mice used are littermates in all experiments. Approximately equal numbers of male and female mice were used in all experiments. Animals were genotyped by PCR using tail DNA. Primer sequences are available upon request.
Animal procedures
Request a detailed protocolTamoxifen (tmx, Sigma) was dissolved in corn oil at a concentration of 20 mg/ml. Both control and experimental mice were administered tamoxifen at a concentration of 150 mg/kg/day for seven continuous days by intraperitoneal injection. The mice were left to chase for 30 days before analysis. To reduce (not ablate completely) the levels of Dll4 in the muscle fibers, tmx was IP injected at a concentration of 75 mg/kg/day for seven consecutive days.
Muscle injury
Request a detailed protocolControl and experimental mice were anesthetized by isofluorane inhalation and 50 µl of 1.2% BaCl2 was injected into and along the length of the tibialis anterior (TA) muscle. After 14 and 40 days of regeneration, mice were euthanized, the contralateral uninjured TA and injured TA muscle were fixed immediately in 4% PFA(Paraformaldehyde) and frozen in 20% sucrose/OCT medium. 8-µm cross-sections of the muscle were made and stained for anti-laminin. ×10 images were collected at three regions in the mid-belly of each muscle. Only mice that had more than 80% injury in their TA were analyzed. All the regenerating fibers in the entire TA section were analyzed for fiber size. The average cross-sectional area of the fibers was determined using ImageJ software.
Isolation of single muscle fibers
Request a detailed protocolSingle muscle fibers were isolated from the EDL muscle of the adult mouse as described previously (Eliazer et al., 2019). The single fibers were fixed immediately in 4% PFA for 10 min or cultured in plating media (DMEM(Delbecco's Modified Eagle Medium) with 10% horse serum).
For in vitro cell cycle entry assays, single muscle fibers from control and Myofiber-Dll4fl/fl mice were harvested and cultured in plating media containing EdU (10 µm; Carbosynth) for 30 hr. For in vitro differentiation assay, the single muscle fibers from control, Myofiber-Dll4fl/fl and Myofiber-Mib1fl/fl were cultured in plating media for 48 hr. The fibers were then fixed and stained for different antibodies. EdU staining was done using the Click-iT Plus EdU Alexa Fluor 594 Imaging Kit (Invitrogen) followed by staining with anti-Pax7 antibody.
Isolation of SCs and fluorescence-assisted cell sorting
Request a detailed protocolSatellite cells were isolated from hindlimb and forelimb muscles as previously described (Eliazer et al., 2019). The mononuclear muscle cells were stained for PE-Cy7 anti-mouse CD31 (clone 390; BD Biosciences), PE-Cy7 anti-mouse CD45 (clone 30-F11; BD Biosciences), APC-Cy7 anti-mouse Sca1 (clone D7; BD Biosciences), PE anti-mouse CD106/VCAM-1 (Invitrogen), and APC anti-α7 integrin (clone R2F2; AbLab). Fluorescence-assisted cell sorting (FACS) was performed using FACS Aria II (BD Biosciences) by gating for CD31−/CD45−/Sca1−/α7 integrin+/VCAM1+ to isolate SCs. SCs from Pax7-nGFP mouse were sorted for GFP fluorescence. The GFP+ gate was divided into top 15% (GFPhigh fraction), middle 45% (Pax7medium fraction), and bottom 15% (Pax7low fraction). The isolated SCs were fixed immediately at t0 or cultured in growth media (Ham’s F10 media, 20% fetal bovine serum, 5 ng/ml FGF2) containing 10 μm EdU for 60 hr (cell cycle entry assay) or cultured in plating media (DMEM with 10% horse serum) for 3 days (differentiation assay).
Immunostaining
Request a detailed protocolFixed myofibers were permeabilized with 0.2% Triton X-100/phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) and blocked with 10% goat serum/0.2% Triton X/PBS. Primary antibodies used in this study were: mouse anti-Pax7 (DSHB), rabbit anti-Laminin (Abcam), rabbit anti-Dll4 (Thermo Fisher Scientific), rabbit anti-Mib1 (Sigma), rabbit anti-Syndecan4 (Abcam), rabbit anti-DDX6 (Bethyl Laboratories Inc), rabbit anti-Myogenin (Santa Cruz Biotechnology), and DAPI(4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole) (Life Technologies). Primary antibodies were visualized with fluorochrome conjugated secondary antibodies (Invitrogen). The stained fibers were mounted in Fluoromount-G mounting medium (SouthernBiotech). For most of the staining, the images were taken using a ×20 Plan Fluor objective of the Nikon Eclipse Ti microscope. Anti-Pax7 and anti-Ddx6 stained images were obtained with a ×40 Plan Fluor objective of the same microscope. Dll4 and Mib1 stained images were taken with ×40 oil objective of Leica DMi8 Confocal Microscope. 15 μm z-stacks around the Pax7+ SC were taken and the sum projection of the images was obtained. The filter settings, gain and exposure values were kept constant between experiments. The intensity of expression is determined by manually drawing a region of Interest (ROI) on a Pax7-positive SC. This will give the mean pixel intensity of the ROI in all the channels. The ROI is copied onto another region where there is no Pax7-positive cell to calculate the background intensity. The background intensity is subtracted and the mean intensity is plotted with GraphPad Prism 7. To determine the intensity of Dll4 captured by SC, a ROI is drawn around the Pax7+ SC. To determine the intensity of Dll4 in the muscle fibers adjacent to the SCs, a ROI is drawn in an area of 100 μm2 surrounding the SC. Representative images for antibody staining were taken using Leica DMi8 Confocal Microscope.
RNAscope
Request a detailed protocolRNAscope for Dll4 was performed on fixed myofibers as previously described (Kann and Krauss, 2019). Briefly the single muscle fibers are isolated, fixed with 4% PFA and dehydrated with 100% methanol. The fibers are then rehydrated with a series of decreasing concentrations of methanol and PBS with 0.1% Tween 20 followed by protease digestion, hybridization of the RNA probe, amplification of signal and conjugation with fluorophore.
Quantitative PCR
Request a detailed protocolTotal RNA was isolated from single muscle fibers (from EDL muscle), or SCs using Trizol (Invitrogen) according to the manufacturer’s protocol. The RNA was DNAse treated using Turbo DNA free kit (Life Technologies). cDNA was synthesized from RNA using the Superscript First Strand Synthesis System (Invitrogen). Quantitative PCR (qPCR) was performed in triplicates from 5 ng of RNA per reaction using Platinum SYBR Green qPCR Super Mix-UDG w/ROX (Invitrogen) on a ViiA7 qPCR detection system (Life Technologies). All reactions for RT-qPCR were performed using the following conditions: 50°C for 2 min, 95°C for 2 min, 40 cycles of a two-step reaction of denaturation at 95°C for 15 min, and annealing at 60°C for 30 s. The mean Ct values from triplicates were used in the comparative 2−ΔΔCt method. To analyze the expression of Notch ligands on the adult muscle fiber, 2−ΔCt method was used. The results were normalized to GAPDH mRNA controls. The primers used in this study are listed in Supplementary file 2.
Microarray
Request a detailed protocolTotal RNA was isolated from single muscle fibers of the EDL muscle from postnatal day 3 (p3), postnatal day 7 (p7), and adult mouse hindlimb using TRIzol reagent (Invitrogen). The processing of RNA, hybridization, and analysis is previously described (Eliazer et al., 2019). The expression values for Notch ligands are log2 transformed and listed in Supplementary file 1.
Quantification and statistical analysis
Request a detailed protocolThe density maps for Pax7 and Ddx6 intensity were drawn using R. The variance of Pax7 and Ddx6 intensity levels across the SC pool is calculated as the square of standard deviation. The statistical details of experiments can be found in the figure legends. No statistical methods were used to predetermine sample size. The investigators were not blinded to allocation during experiments and outcome assessment. No animal was excluded from analysis. All data are represented as mean ± standard error of the mean. Significance was calculated using the two-tailed unpaired Student’s t-tests (GraphPad Prism 7). The number of replicates (n) for each experiment is indicated in the figure legends. Differences were considered statistically different at p < 0.05.
Data availability
We have cited a data repository in our data availability statement, 'The microarray data generated during this study is available at NCBI GEO: GSE135163'. It is a microarray dataset from postnatal d3, d7, and adult purified single muscle fibers.
-
NCBI Gene Expression OmnibusID GSE135163. Expression data from wild-type single muscle fibers.
References
-
Single cell analysis of adult mouse skeletal muscle stem cells in homeostatic and regenerative conditionsDevelopment (Cambridge, England) 146:dev174177.https://doi.org/10.1242/dev.174177
-
Integration of Notch and Wnt signaling in hematopoietic stem cell maintenanceNature Immunology 6:314–322.https://doi.org/10.1038/ni1164
-
Delta-Like 4 is indispensable in thymic environment specific for T cell developmentThe Journal of Experimental Medicine 205:2507–2513.https://doi.org/10.1084/jem.20080134
-
Sex hormones establish a reserve pool of adult muscle stem cellsNature Cell Biology 18:930–940.https://doi.org/10.1038/ncb3401
-
Notch signaling: endocytosis makes delta signal betterCurrent Biology 13:R273–R275.https://doi.org/10.1016/s0960-9822(03)00199-4
-
Biomarker system for studying muscle, stem cells, and cancer in vivoFASEB Journal 23:2681–2690.https://doi.org/10.1096/fj.08-128116
-
Constitutive Notch activation upregulates Pax7 and promotes the self-renewal of skeletal muscle satellite cellsMolecular and Cellular Biology 32:2300–2311.https://doi.org/10.1128/MCB.06753-11
-
Muscle satellite cells adopt divergent fates: a mechanism for self-renewal?The Journal of Cell Biology 166:347–357.https://doi.org/10.1083/jcb.200312007
-
Pax7 and myogenic progression in skeletal muscle satellite cellsJournal of Cell Science 119:1824–1832.https://doi.org/10.1242/jcs.02908
Decision letter
-
Christopher L-H HuangReviewing Editor; University of Cambridge, United Kingdom
-
Mone ZaidiSenior Editor; Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, United States
-
Robert S KraussReviewer; Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, United States
-
Bradley B OlwinReviewer; University of Colorado Boulder, United States
Our editorial process produces two outputs: (i) public reviews designed to be posted alongside the preprint for the benefit of readers; (ii) feedback on the manuscript for the authors, including requests for revisions, shown below. We also include an acceptance summary that explains what the editors found interesting or important about the work.
Decision letter after peer review:
Thank you for submitting your article "Spatial heterogeneity of Dll4 within a multinucleated niche cell maintains muscle stem cell diversity" for consideration by eLife. Your article has been reviewed by 3 peer reviewers, and the evaluation has been overseen by a Reviewing Editor and Mone Zaidi as the Senior Editor. The following individuals involved in review of your submission have agreed to reveal their identity: Robert S. Krauss (Reviewer #1); Bradley B Olwin (Reviewer #3).
The reviewers have discussed their reviews with one another, and the Reviewing Editor has drafted this to help you prepare a revised submission.
Eliazer et al. report that the Notch ligand Dll4 produced by myobers regulates the fate of muscle stem cells. Identification of such stem cell niche factors is important, and the results are interesting and beneficial to the field. The conclusion that heterogeneous distribution of Dll4 on myofibers maintains a continuum of muscle stem cell fates is, however, not sufficiently supported by the data and therefore premature. While some additional experimentation is asked for, this and most other comments by the reviewers can be addressed by alterations to the text.
Essential revisions:
1) Changes to the text are necessary to temper the conclusion that Dll4 signals to maintain a continuum of SC fates and raise alternative interpretations to the data. Additionally, prior work demonstrating that Pax7 protein levels are variable and that the level of Pax7 affects satellite cell fate has been published and specific early papers should be cited (Zammit, JCB 2004; and Olguin, Dev Bio 2004). The title should also be reworded to reflect these changes. Please see the individual reviews for more specific comments on how to address this issue.
2) Mib1 regulates multiple Notch ligands. Could Mib1 deletion affect Notch ligands other than Dll4 that are also expressed by myofibers? This can be addressed by IF of single myofibers for additional Notch ligands reported in Figure S2B.
3) Expression of Notch pathway target genes should be examined in satellite cells from control and MF-Dll4 mice by qRT-PCR. This will presumably validate Dll4's expected role in maintaining quiescence-promoting Notch signaling and help address the observation that the MF-Dll4 phenotype is less pronounced than the satellite cell-specific RBP-J knockout phenotype.
4) Additional changes to the text are requested in the comments from individual reviewers.
Reviewer #1 (Recommendations for the authors):
1. Given the known role of Dll4 as a Notch ligand, it is highly likely that the non-autonomous SC phenotypes are a consequence of reduced Notch pathway activity in these cells. It is important to show that reduced Notch pathway activity has actually occurred. I suggest that the authors FACS sort SCs from control and MF-Dll4 mice and measure the levels of Notch target genes by qRT-PCR. This technique was used in the paper, and a number of validated Notch target genes in SCs have been published.
2. The conclusions that the amount of Dll4 surrounding individual SCs correlates with Pax7 levels, and that the distribution of Pax7 levels is left-shifted in the absence of Dll4 in fibers, are convincing. High Pax7 levels, as measured with a Pax7-nGFP transgene, have been reported to correlate with greater SC dormancy (Rocheteau et al.). However, the various cells measured in this paper were tested in vitro and not in vivo for true stem cell activity, including self-renewal. Therefore, the conclusion about Dll4 controlling "a continuum of quiescent cell states ranging from deep quiescent, non-committed states to more committed states" (lines 238-239 in the Discussion) seems too strong. Simply tempering the conclusion would suffice.
3. Figure S1 and Materials and methods: Figure S1D shows that Pax7-nGFP(High) cells incorporate EdU less efficiently than the (Medium) or (Low) cells. A very small percentage of cells overall incorporated EdU. The legend say the cells were in plating medium (10% horse serum) but the Methods section says they were in growth medium (20% FBS plus FGF2). Which is correct? The low percentage of EdU+ cells is more consistent with the former. If so, have the authors tried the latter?
4. Figure 4 and lines 155-163: Numbers of SCs on single fibers from control and MF-Dll4 mice are similar after culture for 48 hr in 10% serum-containing medium (Figure 4E). Based on the Methods section, I assume this is 10% horse serum (which is mitogen poor), rather than growth medium. The authors conclude that there was compensatory cell proliferation of remaining MF-Dll4 SCs, as there are fewer of these at 30 hr. However, the SC numbers at 48 hr average 5-6 per EDL fiber, which is a typical number found associated with freshly isolated EDL fibers. After 30 hr, the numbers are similar (there are slightly fewer SCs on MF-Dll4 fibers but the difference is small – about one SC per fiber less, on average). It seems to me that there may be very little cell proliferation occurring at all on these fibers, consistent with use of horse serum (if that is indeed the case). It would also be consistent with the published in vivo phenotype of mice lacking RBP-J in SCs. RBP-J-null SCs often incorporate EdU but withdraw from the cell cycle prior to dividing, express myogenin, and precociously differentiate. This phenotype seems more consistent with the data on MF-Dll4 SCs in Figures 4B-F, and would further link the similarity between loss of fiber Dll4 and loss of Notch signaling in SCs.
5. Figure 5: The area of high Mib1 protein seems wide relative to the intensity of Dll4 around SCs but still correlates with Pax7 levels in "adjacent" SCs. What area defines "adjacent"?
6. The textbook view of Mib1 is that it monoubiquitylates Notch ligands in complex with Notch, leading to ligand endocytosis and Notch receptor activation. In this case, it also seems to play a major role in overall Dll4 localization. It would be worth citing another example of this, as it is not always the case (see for example, Cell Reports 19, 351-363, 2017).
7. Lines 264-265: Because the MF-Dll4 phenotype is less pronounced than the SC RBP-J knockout phenotype, the authors suggest that RBP-J may have targets other than the Notch pathway. Doesn't it seem more likely that Dll4 is not the only relevant Notch ligand produced by the fiber? Figure S2B shows similar levels of mRNA for additional Notch ligands ae expressed by fibers. The experiment requested in comment 1 will help here too. If reduction of Notch target gene expression is incomplete in MF-Dll4 SCs (relative to that reported with RBP-J removal from SCs), it would be consistent with additional ligands playing a role. If reduction of Notch target gene expression was similar between the two, it would be more consistent with an additional role for RBP-J.
Reviewer #2 (Recommendations for the authors):
1. A conclusive demonstration demonstration that spatial distribution of Dll4 and Mib1 in myofibers regulate diversity of MuSC state is lacking. While the authors show that such diverse spatial distribution of the two of factors exist in myofibers, that data that they are responsible for determining MuSC heterogeneity are correlative. While genetic deletion of Dll4 or Mib1 in myofibers resulted in a loss of MuSC diversity and premature activation, this approach complete deletes expression of the proteins, it does not modulate the diversity of Dll4 protein distribution on the myofiber. The resulting effect is that MuSC are prematurely activated due to loss of Dll4-mediated Notch signaling, but it is unclear if this is due to loss of spatial distribution of the proteins as suggested by the authors.
2. Mib regulates multiple Notch ligands. Does Mib1 deletion affects other Notch ligands, beyond Dll4, in myofibers?
3. The authors state "Dll4 expression was also variable in regions devoid of SCs, suggesting the presence of a SC does not dictate Dll4 levels along muscle fibers". What is the frequency of Dll4 diversity independent of MuSC? Is it a rare event or is as frequent as the one correlated to the presence of MuSC on the myofiber?
4. While the authors found no correlation with the distance from the NMJ, this does not necessarily mean that there is no correlation with anatomically defined regions of the myofiber. in vivo, different regions of the myofiber are exposed to different local microenvironments, thus it cannot be rule out the possibility that such a correlation exists with other anatomical locations, that are lost upon myofiber isolation from the tissue.
5. Distinction between Dll4 on myofiber and Dll4 captured by MuSC: it would be useful if the authors would include in the methods how they distinguish Dll4 on myofiber from the Dll4 captured by MuSC.
6. In Figures 3I, 4K and S5J, it would be useful to include representative image of tissue sections, to support the quantification shown.
Reviewer #3 (Recommendations for the authors):
If the authors widen their potential interpretations and do not argue that Dll4 regulates the relative levels of Pax7, I would be open to publishing without additional experiments. The primary observations are highly interesting and I feel the data are over interpreted.
https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.68180.sa1Author response
Eliazer et al. report that the Notch ligand Dll4 produced by myobers regulates the fate of muscle stem cells. Identification of such stem cell niche factors is important, and the results are interesting and beneficial to the field. The conclusion that heterogeneous distribution of Dll4 on myofibers maintains a continuum of muscle stem cell fates is, however, not sufficiently supported by the data and therefore premature. While some additional experimentation is asked for, this and most other comments by the reviewers can be addressed by alterations to the text.
We would like to thank the reviewers for recognizing that identification of Dll4 as a stem cell niche factor is important to the field. We show in this manuscript that the heterogeneous distribution of Dll4 on the muscle fibers maintain stem cell diversity as a continuum of stem cell states (based on Pax7 and Ddx6 levels), that are biased to differential cell fates. What has been shown so far in the literature is the presence of Pax7high and Pax7low states. We show in this manuscript that there is a range of cell states from high to low based on two different stem cell markers Pax7 and Ddx6 and these states are maintained by the levels of Dll4 in the muscle fiber.
We have now performed an additional experiment where we manipulate the levels of Dll4 on the fibers by reducing the amount of tamoxifen that is given to the mice. Reducing the levels of Dll4 on the fibers, not completely deleting it, causes a leftward shift (or reduction) in the continuum of quiescent stem cell states (Figure 4-) without a diminution of stem cells.
Essential revisions:
1) Changes to the text are necessary to temper the conclusion that Dll4 signals to maintain a continuum of SC fates and raise alternative interpretations to the data.
We have tempered some of the conclusions and discussed alternative interpretations. The changes are outlined below in the comments to individual reviewers.
Additionally, prior work demonstrating that Pax7 protein levels are variable and that the level of Pax7 affects satellite cell fate has been published and specific early papers should be cited (Zammit, JCB 2004; and Olguin, Dev Bio 2004).
The omission of these two seminal papers was a massive oversight on our behalf. They have now been included.
The title should also be reworded to reflect these changes.
We have modified the title to remove the spatial component of heterogeneity and to refocus on heterogeneous levels of Dll4. The original title doesn’t mention fate, rather stem cell diversity- we believe this accurately reflects the data.
The current title is: Heterogeneous levels of Δ-like 4 Within a Multinucleated Niche Cell Maintain Muscle Stem Cell Diversity.
Please see the individual reviews for more specific comments on how to address this issue.
2) Mib1 regulates multiple Notch ligands. Could Mib1 deletion affect Notch ligands other than Dll4 that are also expressed by myofibers? This can be addressed by IF of single myofibers for additional Notch ligands reported in Figure S2B.
It is widely accepted that Mib1 genetic deletion abrogates the expression of all Notch ligands at the level of post-translational regulation (Koo, B. K., et al., 2005; Koo, B. K., et al., 2007). Therefore, we suggest that Mib1 is regulating the Notch ligands that are expressed in muscle fibers. Unfortunately, the antibodies for Notch ligands other than DLL4 are either not available or not validated. Hence, it is not possible to analyze Notch ligand expression after Mib1 deletion.
3) Expression of Notch pathway target genes should be examined in satellite cells from control and MF-Dll4 mice by qRT-PCR. This will presumably validate Dll4's expected role in maintaining quiescence-promoting Notch signaling and help address the observation that the MF-Dll4 phenotype is less pronounced than the satellite cell-specific RBP-J knockout phenotype.
To address this question, we crossed a transgenic mouse line harboring a Notch reporter with MF-Dll4 mice to analyze Notch signaling in SCs on isolated single muscle fibers. The first experiment we performed with this reporter was to correlate the levels of Pax7 and Notch signaling on a cell-by-cell basis. In control mice, we found a linear positive relationship between the levels of Pax7 and the Notch reporter (Figure 1E, 1F). Consistent with previous reports, Notch signaling is heterogeneous.
Next, we compared Notch reporter levels in control versus Dll4-null mice. Notch reporter levels decreased to below detectable levels in Dll4 null muscle (Figure 3I). Therefore, Dll4 acts non-autonomously to regulate Notch signaling in SCs during homeostasis. Moreover, Dll4 is likely the dominant source of Notch ligands. Therefore, the residual levels of Notch signaling does not explain the milder phenotypes in the two niche depletion models (Dll4 and Mib1) compared to SC-specific Rbpj deletion. These data are consistent with the idea that Rbpj might have targets other than the Notch signaling pathway. We mention this in the discussion.
4) Additional changes to the text are requested in the comments from individual reviewers.
We have addressed the comments below.
Reviewer #1 (Recommendations for the authors):
1. Given the known role of Dll4 as a Notch ligand, it is highly likely that the non-autonomous SC phenotypes are a consequence of reduced Notch pathway activity in these cells. It is important to show that reduced Notch pathway activity has actually occurred. I suggest that the authors FACS sort SCs from control and MF-Dll4 mice and measure the levels of Notch target genes by qRT-PCR. This technique was used in the paper, and a number of validated Notch target genes in SCs have been published.
To address this question, we crossed a transgenic mouse line harboring a Notch reporter with MF-Dll4 mice to analyze Notch signaling in FACs sorted SCs. The first experiment we performed with this reporter was to correlate the levels of Pax7 and Notch signaling on a cell-by-cell basis. In control mice, we found a linear positive relationship between the levels of Pax7 and the Notch reporter (Figure 1E, 1F). Consistent with previous reports, Notch signaling is heterogeneous.
Next, we compared Notch reporter levels in control versus Dll4-null. We observed that Notch reporter decreased to below detectable levels in Dll4 null muscle (Figure 3I). Therefore, Dll4 acts non-autonomously to regulate Notch signaling in SCs during homeostasis. Moreover, Dll4 from the muscle fiber is the dominant source of Notch ligands.
2. The conclusions that the amount of Dll4 surrounding individual SCs correlates with Pax7 levels, and that the distribution of Pax7 levels is left-shifted in the absence of Dll4 in fibers, are convincing. High Pax7 levels, as measured with a Pax7-nGFP transgene, have been reported to correlate with greater SC dormancy (Rocheteau et al.). However, the various cells measured in this paper were tested in vitro and not in vivo for true stem cell activity, including self-renewal. Therefore, the conclusion about Dll4 controlling "a continuum of quiescent cell states ranging from deep quiescent, non-committed states to more committed states" (lines 238-239 in the Discussion) seems too strong. Simply tempering the conclusion would suffice.
We were careful to not discuss self-renewal potential of the SC subsets because we did not perform the necessary experiments. However, we do clearly show that there is a continuum of states existing in a linear relationship between Pax7 and Ddx6 levels (Figure 1D). This is evidence of a continuum of different states. We used these two markers based on previous work showing their expression is high in quiescent states and decreased early during activation (Crist, C. G., et al., 2012; Zammit, P. S., et al., 2006). In addition, we provide complementary evidence that cell cycle activation rate (S-phase entry) and subsequent induction of Myogenin is related to Pax7 levels at time of isolation (Figure 1—figure supplement 1). These data mirror what was demonstrated by Rocheteau, P., et al., 2012. We have modified this sentence to “Our results provide the first direct demonstration of a Notch ligand from a specific cell type that is critical to maintain a continuum of states within the QSC pool”.
3. Figure S1 and Materials and methods: Figure S1D shows that Pax7-nGFP(High) cells incorporate EdU less efficiently than the (Medium) or (Low) cells. A very small percentage of cells overall incorporated EdU. The legend say the cells were in plating medium (10% horse serum) but the Methods section says they were in growth medium (20% FBS plus FGF2). Which is correct? The low percentage of EdU+ cells is more consistent with the former. If so, have the authors tried the latter?
Apologies for the discrepancy in the text. The Pax7-nGFP high, medium and low expressers were plated in growth medium (Ham’s F10 media containing 20% FBS and 5ng/ml FGF2). We have corrected the text in the figure legend. In addition, we have repeated the experiment with cells in culture for a longer time-point: 60h. This experiment shows that quiescent SCs sit on a continuum in a linear relationship between Pax7 expression and the time to reach S-phase when activated. This readout is often used as a surrogate for depth of quiescence (Tajbakhsh, Rando and Brack labs). Pax7-nGFP low expressers are faster to enter cycle, followed by the medium and then high GFP expressers. While the Pax7 high and low data was anticipated based on Rocheteau, P., et al., 2012, the Pax7 mid fraction was not examined in their work. Therefore, our work demonstrates a continuum based on Pax7 levels and other quiescent state markers. This new data replaces the previous figure (Figure 1—figure supplement 1D).
4. Figure 4 and lines 155-163: Numbers of SCs on single fibers from control and MF-Dll4 mice are similar after culture for 48 hr in 10% serum-containing medium (Figure 4E). Based on the Methods section, I assume this is 10% horse serum (which is mitogen poor), rather than growth medium. The authors conclude that there was compensatory cell proliferation of remaining MF-Dll4 SCs, as there are fewer of these at 30 hr. However, the SC numbers at 48 hr average 5-6 per EDL fiber, which is a typical number found associated with freshly isolated EDL fibers. After 30 hr, the numbers are similar (there are slightly fewer SCs on MF-Dll4 fibers but the difference is small – about one SC per fiber less, on average). It seems to me that there may be very little cell proliferation occurring at all on these fibers, consistent with use of horse serum (if that is indeed the case). It would also be consistent with the published in vivo phenotype of mice lacking RBP-J in SCs. RBP-J-null SCs often incorporate EdU but withdraw from the cell cycle prior to dividing, express myogenin, and precociously differentiate. This phenotype seems more consistent with the data on MF-Dll4 SCs in Figures 4B-F, and would further link the similarity between loss of fiber Dll4 and loss of Notch signaling in SCs.
I appreciate the argument the reviewer is trying to make, but we are hesitant to compare absolute SCs numbers in our experiments with those from other labs, because of the many confounding factors that will impact SC number per fiber, including genetic strain, isolation approach and batch of serum, just to name a few.
In our experiments, we find that the initial decrease in SC number at homeostasis (50%) catches up over 48 hours in mitogen. This is consistent with the increased fraction of EdU+/SCs during this window. We have reconfigured the data to help with the comparison (Figure 5C- 5D, Figure 5—figure supplement 1). If the results mimicked Rbpj, there would be a significant difference in SC number between control and null after 48 hours in culture. Therefore, deletion of Dll4 from the niche does not phenocopy SC deletion of Rbpj.
5. Figure 5: The area of high Mib1 protein seems wide relative to the intensity of Dll4 around SCs but still correlates with Pax7 levels in "adjacent" SCs. What area defines "adjacent"?
To measure the expression of Dll4 and Mib1 on the muscle fiber we cover an area of 100μm2 around the SC. This is now stated in the methods. This region was determined empirically based on our qualitative observations. In Figure 2—figure supplement 2, we show the distribution of Dll4 across the entire fiber, we find no evidence that our standardized method biases the result.
6. The textbook view of Mib1 is that it monoubiquitylates Notch ligands in complex with Notch, leading to ligand endocytosis and Notch receptor activation. In this case, it also seems to play a major role in overall Dll4 localization. It would be worth citing another example of this, as it is not always the case (see for example, Cell Reports 19, 351-363, 2017).
We thank the reviewer for the suggestion, we have incorporated this reference in the manuscript.
7. Lines 264-265: Because the MF-Dll4 phenotype is less pronounced than the SC RBP-J knockout phenotype, the authors suggest that RBP-J may have targets other than the Notch pathway. Doesn't it seem more likely that Dll4 is not the only relevant Notch ligand produced by the fiber? Figure S2B shows similar levels of mRNA for additional Notch ligands ae expressed by fibers. The experiment requested in comment 1 will help here too. If reduction of Notch target gene expression is incomplete in MF-Dll4 SCs (relative to that reported with RBP-J removal from SCs), it would be consistent with additional ligands playing a role. If reduction of Notch target gene expression was similar between the two, it would be more consistent with an additional role for RBP-J.
As addressed in essential revisions comment #3 and in Reviewer 1 comment #1, we cannot exclude that other Notch ligands regulate SC quiescence during homeostasis. However, we now demonstrate that deletion of Dll4 in the muscle fibers leads to a loss of detectable Notch signaling (Figure 3I). Together, with the data showing that Mib1 deletion in the fibers has a similar phenotype to Dll4, we conclude that Dll4 from the muscle fiber plays a dominant role in maintaining SCs during tissue homeostasis. The data is consistent with an additional role for Rbpj.
Reviewer #2 (Recommendations for the authors):
1. A conclusive demonstration demonstration that spatial distribution of Dll4 and Mib1 in myofibers regulate diversity of MuSC state is lacking. While the authors show that such diverse spatial distribution of the two of factors exist in myofibers, that data that they are responsible for determining MuSC heterogeneity are correlative. While genetic deletion of Dll4 or Mib1 in myofibers resulted in a loss of MuSC diversity and premature activation, this approach complete deletes expression of the proteins, it does not modulate the diversity of Dll4 protein distribution on the myofiber. The resulting effect is that MuSC are prematurely activated due to loss of Dll4-mediated Notch signaling, but it is unclear if this is due to loss of spatial distribution of the proteins as suggested by the authors.
The reviewer is correct, complete ablation of DLL4 does not modulate spatial diversity. To test spatial regulation, one would have to flip regions from Dll4 high to Dll4 low and vice versa. This is not possible with current genetic approaches. As such we have modified the title to “Heterogeneous levels of Δ-like 4 Within a Multinucleated Niche Cell Maintain Muscle Stem Cell Diversity”.
To further address the relationship between heterogenous levels of Dll4 and stem cell diversity, we used a low dose TMX approach to reduce (not delete) Dll4 levels. The rationale is that we would retain spatial heterogeneity but with a compressed distribution of Dll4 levels. Compared to controls, we find reduced levels of Dll4 and Pax7 (Figure 4B, 4C), without a change in SC number (Figure 4A). This provides further evidence that SCs sit on a continuum based on Dll4 levels.
2. Mib regulates multiple Notch ligands. Does Mib1 deletion affects other Notch ligands, beyond Dll4, in myofibers?
It is widely accepted that Mib1 genetic deletion abrogates the expression of all Notch ligands at the level of post-translational regulation (Koo et al., 2005, Koo et al., 2007). Therefore, we suggest that Mib1 is regulating the Notch ligands that are expressed in muscle fibers. Unfortunately, the antibodies for Notch ligands other than DLL4 are either not available or not validated. Hence, it is not possible to analyze Notch ligand expression after Mib1 deletion.
3. The authors state "Dll4 expression was also variable in regions devoid of SCs, suggesting the presence of a SC does not dictate Dll4 levels along muscle fibers". What is the frequency of Dll4 diversity independent of MuSC? Is it a rare event or is as frequent as the one correlated to the presence of MuSC on the myofiber?
A similar range of values and variability is observed in non-MuSC regions. We have stated this in the results.
4. While the authors found no correlation with the distance from the NMJ, this does not necessarily mean that there is no correlation with anatomically defined regions of the myofiber. in vivo, different regions of the myofiber are exposed to different local microenvironments, thus it cannot be rule out the possibility that such a correlation exists with other anatomical locations, that are lost upon myofiber isolation from the tissue.
Yes, we agree with the reviewer. In this manuscript, we focused on the NMJ and MTJ due to their well-defined positions and markers. We have re-written this to be more explicit: We find no consistent pattern of Dll4 protein along the fibers. Therefore, Dll4 spatial distribution does not map to these known anatomically defined regions of freshly-isolated single muscle fibers.
5. Distinction between Dll4 on myofiber and Dll4 captured by MuSC: it would be useful if the authors would include in the methods how they distinguish Dll4 on myofiber from the Dll4 captured by MuSC.
We appreciate the reviewer recommendation. The methods are now included in the manuscript.
6. In Figures 3I, 4K and S5J, it would be useful to include representative image of tissue sections, to support the quantification shown.
We have included representative images of Pax7 (SC) and laminin (basal lamina) stains in Figure 3—figure supplement 1.
https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.68180.sa2Article and author information
Author details
Funding
National Institutes of Health (R01AR060868)
- Andrew S Brack
National Institutes of Health (R01AR061002)
- Andrew S Brack
National Institutes of Health (R01AR076252)
- Andrew S Brack
National Institutes of Health (F32AR067594)
- Susan Eliazer
National Institutes of Health (P30 DK063720)
- Andrew S Brack
NIH (S10 1S10OD021822-01)
- Andrew S Brack
The funders had no role in study design, data collection, and interpretation, or the decision to submit the work for publication.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Drs. Karyn Esser, Charles Keller, Young-Yun Kong, and Sonoko Habu for providing transgenic mice. We would like to thank Hallie Nelson for technical assistance, and members of the Brack laboratory for critical discussions during the preparation of this manuscript. We acknowledge the UCSF Parnassus Flow Cytometry Core (RRID:SCR_018206) supported in part by Grant NIH P30 DK063720 and by the NIH S10 Instrumentation Grant S10 1S10OD021822-01. This work was supported by NIH grants (R01AR060868, R01AR061002, R01AR076252) to ASB, and (F32AR067594) to SE.
Ethics
This study was performed in strict accordance with the recommendations in the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals of the National Institutes of Health. All of the animals were handled according to approved institutional animal care and use committee (IACUC) protocols (#AN174604, #AN176815) of the University of California San Francisco. Every effort was made to minimize suffering.
Senior Editor
- Mone Zaidi, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, United States
Reviewing Editor
- Christopher L-H Huang, University of Cambridge, United Kingdom
Reviewers
- Robert S Krauss, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, United States
- Bradley B Olwin, University of Colorado Boulder, United States
Version history
- Preprint posted: October 20, 2020 (view preprint)
- Received: March 8, 2021
- Accepted: December 19, 2022
- Version of Record published: December 30, 2022 (version 1)
Copyright
© 2022, Eliazer et al.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.
Metrics
-
- 733
- Page views
-
- 112
- Downloads
-
- 1
- Citations
Article citation count generated by polling the highest count across the following sources: Crossref, PubMed Central, Scopus.
Download links
A two-part list of links to download the article, or parts of the article, in various formats.
Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)
Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)
Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)
Heterogeneous levels of delta-like 4 within a multinucleated niche cell maintains muscle stem cell diversity
eLife 11:e68180.
https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.68180
Further reading
-
- Cell Biology
- Developmental Biology
Cylicins are testis-specific proteins, which are exclusively expressed during spermiogenesis. In mice and humans, two Cylicins, the gonosomal X-linked Cylicin 1 (Cylc1/CYLC1) and the autosomal Cylicin 2 (Cylc2/CYLC2) genes, have been identified. Cylicins are cytoskeletal proteins with an overall positive charge due to lysine-rich repeats. While Cylicins have been localized in the acrosomal region of round spermatids, they resemble a major component of the calyx within the perinuclear theca at the posterior part of mature sperm nuclei. However, the role of Cylicins during spermiogenesis has not yet been investigated. Here, we applied CRISPR/Cas9-mediated gene editing in zygotes to establish Cylc1- and Cylc2-deficient mouse lines as a model to study the function of these proteins. Cylc1 deficiency resulted in male subfertility, whereas Cylc2-/-, Cylc1-/yCylc2+/-, and Cylc1-/yCylc2-/- males were infertile. Phenotypical characterization revealed that loss of Cylicins prevents proper calyx assembly during spermiogenesis. This results in decreased epididymal sperm counts, impaired shedding of excess cytoplasm, and severe structural malformations, ultimately resulting in impaired sperm motility. Furthermore, exome sequencing identified an infertile man with a hemizygous variant in CYLC1 and a heterozygous variant in CYLC2, displaying morphological abnormalities of the sperm including the absence of the acrosome. Thus, our study highlights the relevance and importance of Cylicins for spermiogenic remodeling and male fertility in human and mouse, and provides the basis for further studies on unraveling the complex molecular interactions between perinuclear theca proteins required during spermiogenesis.
-
- Cell Biology
- Structural Biology and Molecular Biophysics
Previously we showed that 2D template matching (2DTM) can be used to localize macromolecular complexes in images recorded by cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) with high precision, even in the presence of noise and cellular background (Lucas et al., 2021; Lucas et al., 2022). Here, we show that once localized, these particles may be averaged together to generate high-resolution 3D reconstructions. However, regions included in the template may suffer from template bias, leading to inflated resolution estimates and making the interpretation of high-resolution features unreliable. We evaluate conditions that minimize template bias while retaining the benefits of high-precision localization, and we show that molecular features not present in the template can be reconstructed at high resolution from targets found by 2DTM, extending prior work at low-resolution. Moreover, we present a quantitative metric for template bias to aid the interpretation of 3D reconstructions calculated with particles localized using high-resolution templates and fine angular sampling.
