In this study, we used five species of Xenopus including X. laevis. Advertisement calls from the males of all five species are shown in Figure 1A as in vivo calls. The click rates and the number of clicks contained in advertisement calls of each species are summarized in Figure 1B and C as in vivo data. Out of the males of five species we studied, two species produced advertisement calls that contained clicks repeated only at rates >50 Hz (i.e. monophasic calls as previously described) – X. amieti (mean ± s.e., 143.0±2.90 Hz), X. cliivi (59.82±6.50 Hz), one species produced advertisement calls containing clicks repeated only at rates <35 Hz – X. tropicalis (31.9+1.18 Hz), and two species produced advertisement calls with both fast (>50 Hz) and slow (<35 Hz) clicks (i.e. biphasic calls as previously described) – X. petersii (69.9+2.02 Hz, 31.3+1.99 Hz), and X. laevis (58.3+2.47 Hz), 38.4+2.98 Hz.

Figure 1 with 1 supplement see all

Download asset Open asset

Next, we developed a method to obtain fictive vocalizations from isolated brains of the males of all the Xenopus species used in this study. Previous studies had shown that application of serotonin (5HT) to the isolated brains of male X. laevis and X. petersii readily elicited fictive advertisement calls (Rhodes et al., 2007; Barkan and Zornik, 2019). In this study, we found that we could also induce fictive advertisement calls from the isolated brains of three additional species (Figure 1A, right column), but the types of stimuli required varied depending on species. For instance, 5HT alone did not elicit fictive calls from the brains of X. tropicalis (Figure 1—figure supplement 1A, n=7), but a combination of 5HT and N-methylaspartate (NMA, Figure 1A, right column, Figure 1—figure supplement 1A) was effective. In contrast, neither 5HT alone nor 5HT and NMA together induced fictive calls from the isolated brains of X. amieti and X. cliivi (Figure 1—figure supplement 1B, top trace, for example). However, trains of electrical pulses delivered to the rostral-lateral cerebellum (RLCB, Figure 1D) readily evoked fictive advertisement calls (Figure 1A, right column, Figure 1—figure supplement 1B). The RLCB is the region in the brain where the ascending and descending axons of the projection neurons in the parabrachial nucleus (PB) and the nucleus ambiguus (NA) are located close to the surface of the brain. Dextran dye injected into NA that labeled anterograde and retrograde axons allowed us to visualize this location (Figure 1D). Electrically stimulating RLCB likely activates a previously unidentified component of the central vocal pathways that initiates vocalizations. Interestingly, electrical stimulation delivered to the RLCB was effective in evoking fictive advertisement calls from all males tested in this study (Figure 1—figure supplement 1C, for example), except for male X. tropicalis (Figure 1—figure supplement 1A, n=6). The stimulus pulse duration used was 40us with a frequency ranging from 10 to 100 Hz, amplitudes varying from 0.7 to 6mA, and a pulse count ranging from 3 to 30. Effective stimulus parameters varied greatly between preparations, and there was no observable difference in the effective parameters between species.

The temporal structure of fictive advertisement calls closely resembled the calls recorded in vivo, as shown by comparing the sound amplitude envelope (top traces for each species) on the left column and the fictive call traces on the right column in Figure 1A. Although the exact rate of compound action potentials (CAPs) is significantly slower (Figure 1B) and the number of CAPs contained in fictive calls differ from the calls recorded in vivo in some species (Figure 1C), the overall temporal structure is well preserved in all species.

Previously, we found that in male X. laevis, the parabrachial nucleus (PBN) is active during fictive fast trills, but remains inactive or exhibits minimal activity (less than twice the amplitude of the noise) during fictive slow trills. (Yamaguchi et al., 2017; Figure 2Aiv). Here, we investigated whether this observation applies to males of other species including X. amieti, X. cliivi, X. petersii, and X. tropicalis. The results showed that in all these species, the PBN was predominantly active during fictive calls that contain compound action potentials (CAPs) repeated at rates faster than 50 Hz (indicated by traces with a green background in Figure 2A), but not during fictive calls containing CAPs repeated at rates below 35 Hz (indicated by traces with blue background in Figure 2A). In male X. amieti, X. cliivi, and X. petersii a PBN local field potential (LFP) showed phasic activity that correlated with the CAPs during fictive calls containing CAPs faster than 50 Hz, similar to what was observed in male X. laevis during fictive fast trills (indicated by all traces with green background in Figure 2A). The mean power spectral density (PSD) of the PBN LFP waveform (normalized to the maximum power for each animal) showed a clear peak at the frequency corresponding to the CAP repetition rates, as was also observed in male X. laevis (Figure 2C). However, in specie with slow clicks in their advertisement calls (slow trills of male X. petersii and the advertisement calls of male X. tropicalis), the PBN activity was mostly absent during fictive slow clicks (Figure 2A, traces with blue background). In a few brains, some PBN LFP phase-locked to CAPs was observed during slow CAPs (Figure 2A, see LFP during slow trills of male X. petersii and male X. laevis), but the LFP amplitude was significantly lower than that during fictive fast clicks (Figure 2A, see the amplitude of LFP during slow trills of male X. petersii and male X. laevis compared to that during fast trills). Consequently, the mean normalized PSD of the PBN LFP recorded during fictive slow clicks showed no clear peak (Figure 2B).

Figure 2

Download asset Open asset

For brevity, we will refer to all clicks and compound action potentials (CAPs) repeated at a rate >50 Hz as ‘fast clicks/CAPs’, and the species that generate them (male X. amieti, X. cliivi, X. petersii, and X. laevis) as ‘fast clicker’ even if their advertisement calls also include slow clicks (i.e. male X. petersii and male X. laevis). Similarly, we refer to all clicks and CAPs repeated at a rate <35 Hz as ‘slow clicks/CAPs’ and the species that produce only slow clicks (i.e. male X. tropicalis) as ‘slow clickers’.

It is important to note that the vocal repertoire of Xenopus species includes calls other than advertisement calls. Male X. laevis, for example, produce amplectant clicks (10 Hz) when clasping gravid females (Tobias et al., 2004) and ‘ticking’ when clasped by a male (Tobias et al., 2014). In this study, we discovered that male X. cliivi and X. amieti produce novel calls containing clicks repeated at 6–20 Hz (with single or double clicks as repetition units) in the presence of conspecific males. We named these calls ‘long-slow calls’ (Figure 3A and C). Fortuitously, we recorded these fictive calls containing slower CAP rates generated spontaneously from isolated brains, including long-slow calls from one male X. amieti (Figure 3B) and two male X. cliivi brains (Figure 3D), amplectant clicks from four male X. laevis (Figure 3E left), and ticking from three male X. laevis (Figure 3E middle). When PBN LFP recordings during these slow fictive calls were examined, we found that the PBNs were either silent (Figure 3B and E amplectant call) or showed activity (Figure 3D and E, release calls) significantly lower in amplitude than activity accompanying fictive fast clicks (Figure 3B, D and E right panels). These results suggest that, regardless of the vocal repertoire of the species, the PBN does not play a significant role, if any, in producing fictive slow clicks (<35 Hz) compared to its role in producing fast clicks (>50 Hz).

Figure 3

Download asset Open asset

Previously, we showed that adult female X. laevis, which normally produce release calls containing clicks trains at a rate of ~6 Hz (Figure 4A), can generate male-like advertisement calls within 1–3 months of testosterone treatment (Figure 4B; Potter et al., 2005). Our objective was to determine whether female X. laevis use slow trill-like central pattern generators (CPGs), like those observed in male X. laevis, to produce release calls. Additionally, we aimed to determine if females acquire fast trill-like CPGs or continue to use the existing slow trill-like CPGs to produce masculinized fast click calls. To this end, we examined the activity of parabrachial nucleus (PBN) during vocal production in control and testosterone-treated female X. laevis.

Figure 4

Download asset Open asset

The application of serotonin (5HT) elicited fictive release calls and advertisement calls from the isolated brains of control and testosterone-treated female X. laevis, respectively (Figure 4D and E). In testosterone-treated females, electrical stimulation delivered to the rostral-lateral cerebellum (RLCB) also elicited fictive advertisement calls. Although the exact rate and the number of compound action potentials (CAPs) in the fictive calls are significantly different in some cases (Figure 4C), the overall temporal structure resemble those of calls recorded in vivo (Figure 4A, B, D and E). In control females, the PBN remained silent during fictive release calls in all animals tested (n=13, Figure 4D bottom trace). The mean power spectral density (PSD) of the PBN local field potential (LFP) during fictive release calls showed no peak (Figure 4F). In contrast, in testosterone-treated female X. laevis, the PBN showed phasic activity coinciding with CAPs during fast trills, but not during slow trills (Figure 4E), similar to male X. laevis. The mean PSD of the PBN LFP during fast trills had peaks between 50 and 60 Hz (Figure 4G left graph) while no peak is evident during slow trills (Figure 4G right graph), like male X. laevis (Figure 2A and C). Thus, we conclude that testosterone enables the recruitment of female PBNs to generate the phasic activity that accompanies fictive fast trills. Results obtained from males and females Xenopus show that the presence of PBN activity is associated with the CAP repetition rates. During fictive calls with CAP rates greater than 50 Hz, PBN shows activity phase-locked to the CAPs, whereas during fictive calls with CAP rates slower than 35 Hz, the PBN shows almost no activity in all species and sexes examined. Throughout the rest of our analyses, we refer to control and testosterone-treated female X. laevis as slow and fast clickers, respectively.

Previously, we showed that transected left and right hemi-brains of male X. laevis can generate both fast and slow trills, indicating that there are pairs of fast and slow trill central pattern generators (CPGs) in the left and right brainstem (Figure 5A, left schematic; Yamaguchi et al., 2017). When we unilaterally transected the projections between the parabrachial nucleus (PBN) and the nucleus ambiguus (NA) (Figure 5B, left schematic), the brain still produced fictive advertisement calls, but the compound action potentials (CAPs) from the two nerves desynchronize during fast trill only, not during slow trills (Figure 5B and C Yamaguchi et al., 2017). Based on these results, we concluded that the fast trill CPGs span between the PBN and NA (Figure 5A left, green oscillators), whereas the slow trill CPGs are confined to the caudal brainstem (Figure 5A left, blue oscillators). When fast trill CPGs on the transected side become dysfunctional, signals from the functional fast trill CPGs on the intact side are transmitted to the non-functional side during fast trills, causing a delay in the production of the CAPs on the transected side compared to the intact side (Figure 5B and C; Yamaguchi et al., 2017). However, CAPs during slow trills of the transected brain remain unaffected since slow trill CPGs on both sides are functional. Here, we investigated the effect of unilateral transection between the PBN and NA on CAP synchrony in fast and slow clickers to determine if fast trill-like and slow trill-like CPGs are present in the brains of fast and slow clickers.

Figure 5

Download asset Open asset

First, we confirmed that CAPs recorded from the left and right laryngeal nerves are synchronous during fictive calls (a measure of CAP synchrony, see Methods). When the maximum lag time between the left and right CAPs (a measure of synchrony, see Materials and methods) during both fictive slow and fast clicks were compared, they did not differ significantly from zero (slow clicks: one-sample sign test, p=0.557, n=26 including 11 male X. tropicalis, 4 male X. petersii, 9 female X. laevis, and 2 testosterone-treated female X. laevis Figure 6G control, fast clicks: P>0.790, n=14 including 4 male X. amieti, 3 male X. cliivi, 5 male X. petersii, and 2 testosterone-treated female X. laevis, Figure 7E control), indicating that CAPs recorded from the two nerves are synchronous during both fast and slow clicks in all intact brains. We also verified the completeness of the unilateral transection anatomically (Figure 6A) by depositing fluorescent dextran into the NA post-hoc and checking the absence of the labeled soma and axon terminals in the PBN on the transected side (Figure 6B).

Figure 6

Download asset Open asset

Figure 7

Download asset Open asset

During fictive slow clicks (male X. tropicalis advertisement call, male X. petersii slow clicks, testosterone-treated female X. laevis slow clicks, and female X. laevis release calls), the unilateral transection did not significantly change the mean maximum lag time between the CAPs recorded from the two nerves (Figure 6, Wilcoxon signed rank test, Z=–0.417, p=0.677, n=25 including 11 male X. tropicalis, 3 male X. petersii, 9 female X. laevis, 2 testosterone-treated female X. laevis), suggesting that the projections between the PBN and the ipsilateral NA are not necessary for the function of the slow click CPGs.

During fast clicks, in contrast, the CAPs became desynchronized after the transection, with the CAPs recorded from the nerve on the transected side lagging behind those recorded from the intact side (Figure 7A - D). The mean maximum lag time between the two nerves increased significantly after the transection (Figure 7E, Wilcoxon signed rank test, Z=–2.93, p=0.003, n=11 including 3 male X. amieti, 2 male X. cliivi, fast clicks of 4 male X. petersii, and fast clicks of 2 testosterone-treated female X. laevis), with the mean lag between the CAPs on the intact and transected side increased by 1.53+0.344 ms (mean ± s.e., n=11) after the transection. These results support the notion that fast clicks are mediated by central pattern generators (CPGs) that span between PBN and NA, whereas slow clicks are generated by CPGs located caudal to the transection. In other words, anatomically distinct fast and slow trill-like CPGs found in male X. laevis appears to be conserved across species to generate fast and slow clicks, respectively.

To determine if the lag between the compound action potentials (CAPs) recorded on the two nerves after the transection is due to the time it takes for signal from the parabrachial nucleus (PBN) on the intact side to cross the midline to contralateral motoneurons on the transected side, we stimulated the intact-side PBN before and after the transection and measure the latency between the stimulus onset and the peak of the CAPs recorded from the two nerves (Figure 7F). In intact brains of fast clickers, a train of stimulus (40usec pulses, 30 Hz) delivered to the PBN elicits CAPs from both nerves simultaneously with a latency of ~6.5 ms that did not differ between the two nerves (Wilcoxon signed rank test, Z=–1.60, p=0.101, n=9 including 1 male X. laevis, 3 male X. amieti, 2 male X. cliivi, 1 male X. petersii, and 2 testosterone-treated female X. laevis). After the unilateral transection, PBN stimulation on the intact side still elicited CAPs from both nerves. However, the amplitude of CAPs recorded on the transected side was significantly lower than before the transection, whereas no significant change was detected on the intact side (data not shown). In addition, the latency of the CAPs on the intact side remained unchanged after the transection (Figure 7G, left graph, Wilcoxon signed rank test, Z=–0.178, p=0.859, n=9 including 1 male X. laevis, 3 male X. amieti, 2 male X. cliivi, 1 male X. petersii, and 2 testosterone-treated female X. laevis). After the unilateral transection, PBN stimulation on the intact side still elicited CAPs from bo, but on the transected side, the transection significantly elongated the latency (Figure 7G, right graph, Wilcoxon signed rank test, Z=–2.67, p=0.008, n=9), with an average increase of 1.79±0.49 ms (mean ± s.e.). Importantly, the increase in the PBN-evoked CAP latency on the transected side was not significantly different from the lag between the right and left CAPs during fictive fast clicks after the transection (Figure 7H, Mann-Whitney U test, Z=–1.254, p=0.210, n=20). These results show that the signals from the PBN on the intact side can reach the contralateral laryngeal motoneurons on the transected side, with a delay similar to those observed during fictive fast clicks. Therefore, the CAPs recorded from the nerve on the transected side during fictive fast clicks are likely driven by the fast trill-like CPGs on the intact side.

Previously, it was shown that the synapses between the projection neurons in the parabrachial nucleus (PBN) and the laryngeal motoneurons in male X. laevis are glutamatergic and strong (Zornik and Kelley, 2008). Here, we determined if the synapses from the PBN to laryngeal motoneurons exhibit similar properties in all fast clickers.

To address this question, we first characterized the synapses between the PBN and the laryngeal motoneurons in male X. laevis by unilaterally stimulating the PBN while recordings are obtained from both laryngeal nerves. We found that in11 out of 13 male X. laevis brains, compound action potentials (CAPs) were recorded from both nerves (Figure 8A), while the remaining animal showed CAPs only from either contralateral or ipsilateral nerve. A stimulus train at a frequency below 10 Hz did not elicit any CAPs (Figure 8D, see 1 Hz stimulation), but at a frequency above 10 Hz, we observed a train of CAPs that progressively potentiated and later plateaued in amplitude (Figure 8A, D and E) while gradually diminishing and leveling off in latency (defined as the time between the stimulus onset and the CAP peak as indicated as a double arrow in Figure 8D and E). These changes in CAP amplitude and latency were successfully fitted with exponential curves (mean ± s.e. cross-correlation coefficient of the fit = 0.781 ± 0.029 for CAP amplitude, 0.938+0.01 for CAP latency, Figure 8E) with mean τ of 6.90±0.995 pulses for CAP amplitude and 3.64±.515 (mean ±s.e.) pulses for CAP latency that was independent of stimulus frequencies (Table 1). In other words, when PBN was stimulated at stimulus frequency >10 Hz, 95% of the maximum CAP amplitude was reached within ~21 pulses and 95% of the latency was reached within 11 pulses (Figure 8E). These progressive changes in amplitude and latency likely represent the increasing recruitment of motoneurons and synaptic facilitation, respectively. Interestingly, the CAP latency recorded from the ipsilateral and contralateral nerves (measured in response to stimulus frequency >10 Hz after the 11th stimulus pulse) was similar (Figure 8B, Wilcoxon Signed Rank test, Z=–0.706, p=0.480, n=12), indicating the presence of bilateral projections from PBN to left and right laryngeal motoneurons driving synchronous firing of motoneurons on both sides (Zornik and Kelley, 2007). Importantly, the maximum amplitude of the CAPs evoked in response to PBN stimulation was comparable to those observed during fictive fast trills (Figure 8C, Wilcoxon signed rank test, Z=–1.68, p=0.093, n=8), indicating that the electrical stimulus delivered to the PBN at >10 Hz was as effective in recruiting the laryngeal motoneurons as activating fictive calling with 5HT or electrical stimulation.

Figure 8

Download asset Open asset

To determine if the connections between the PBN neurons and the laryngeal motoneurons are monosynaptic, we repeated the experiments in high-divalent cation (Hi-Di) saline. We observed CAPs from both nerves in all animals in Hi-Di saline (n=7, Figure 8D middle column, F), but a higher stimulus amplitude was required to elicit CAPs in all cases (168+11.5% of the original stimulus amplitude). In addition, the amplitude of the CAPs was smaller in some cases (Figure 8D and Hi–Di column, 50 Hz), and sometimes pulses failed to evoke CAPs when stimulus frequency was >40 Hz (Figure 8D see Hi-Di column at 60 Hz, for example). The reduced responsiveness of the motoneurons to unilateral PBN stimulation is likely due to an increased spike threshold of neurons under the Hi-Di conditions (Blitz and Nusbaum, 1999). We, therefore, conclude that the synapse between the PBN and the laryngeal motoneurons are monosynaptic.

Zornik and Kelley, 2008 previously showed that the synaptic transmission between the PBN projection neurons and the ipsilateral laryngeal motoneurons is mediated by glutamate and AMPA receptors. Here, we repeated this experiment to determine if the contralateral synapses between PBN projection neurons to the laryngeal motoneurons are also mediated by AMPA receptors by adding NBQX to the recording chamber. The results showed that the application of NBQX eliminated all PBN-evoked CAPs from both nerves (Figure 8G), indicating that glutamate and AMPA receptors mediate the synaptic transmission between the parabrachial neurons and the laryngeal motoneurons.

Next, we extended the experimental approaches to other fast clickers to characterize their synapses between the PBN and the laryngeal motoneurons. Unilateral PBN stimulation evoked CAPs from both nerves in 88% of the fast clickers (78% of male X. amieti, n=9, 100% of male X. cliivi, n=3, 100% of X. petersii, n=10, and 75% of testosterone-treated female X. laevis, n=4) (Figure 9A), with the remaining preparations showing CAPs from either the ipsilateral or contralateral nerve. The mean minimum frequency of stimulus train required to elicit CAPs was 13.8±2.56 Hz (mean ±s.e., n=26 including 8 male X. amieti, 3 male X. cliivi, 11 male X. petersii, and 4 T-female X. laevis), which did not differ from that of male X. laevis (Mann Whitney U test, Z=01.445, p=0.120), and did not differ significantly across species (ANOVA F_{3, 22} = 0.541, p=0.659). Similar to male, X. laevis, a stimulus train elicited a train of CAPs with progressive change in the amplitude and latency that could be fitted with exponential curves (mean ± s.e. cross-correlation coefficient of the fit = 0.784 ± 0.010 for CAP amplitude, 0.915+0.008 for CAP latency, Figure 9B, male X. amieti as an example). Mean τ for CAP amplitude potentiation and latency attenuation for all the fast clickers were 5.15±0.735 pulses, and 2.69±0.332 pulses (mean ± s.e.), respectively. The τ values for CAP amplitude and latency were frequency-independent in all species (Table 1), did not differ significantly from those of male X. laevis (Mann Whitney U test, Z=–1.69,–1.254, p=0.0918, 0.210 for amplitude and latency tau, respectively), and did not differ across species (ANOVA, F_3.17 = 1.75, F_3.15 = 3.24, p=0.195, 0.0521 for CAP amplitude and latency tau, respectively). Thus, in other fast clickers, the CAP amplitude reaches 95% of the maximum within ~ 17 pulses, and the CAP latency reaches 95% of the minimum within ~ 8 pulses. As in male X. laevis, latency for CAPs evoked from the ipsi- and contralateral nerves were similar in all fast clickers (Figure 9C, Wilcoxon signed rank text, Z=–1.13, p=0.260, n=23 including 8 male X. amieti, 3 male X. cliivi, 9 male X. petersii, and 3 testosterone female X. laevis), indicating that bilateral projections from PBN to the right and left laryngeal motoneurons are common in fast clickers, enabling synchronous activation of the motoneurons from each PBN. Similar to male X. laevis, the maximum CAP amplitude achieved in response to unilateral PBN stimulation was similar to those recorded during fictive advertisement calls (Figure 9D, Wilcoxon signed rank test, Z=–1.16, p=0.245, n=16 including 5 male X. amieti, 3 male X. cliivi, 6 male X. petersii, and 2 testosterone-female X. laevis), indicating that unilateral stimulation of PB was effective in recruiting a comparable number of laryngeal motoneurons to those recruited during fictive vocal production.

Figure 9

Download asset Open asset

We next repeated the experiment in Hi-Di saline and in NBQX. In Hi-Di saline, CAPs persisted in all animals (Figure 9E and F, n=6 male X. amieti, 2 X. cliivi, 5 X. petersii, and 3 T-treated female X. laevis), although increased stimulus amplitude was required to evoke CAPs in some brains (mean stimulus amplitude, 154+20% of control amplitude). In response to application of NBQX, PBN-evoke CAPs from both nerves were eliminated in all animals (n=3 male X. amieti, 2 male X. cliivi, 4 male X. petersii, 2 T-female X. laevis). These results indicate that the synapses between the PBN projection neurons and bilateral laryngeal motoneurons of all fast clickers including testosterone-treated females are monosynaptic and mediated by glutamate and AMPA receptors. Thus, the synapses between the PBN and laryngeal motoneuron of all fast clickers share similar characteristics.

Lastly, we examined the property of parabrachial nucleus (PBN) to nucleus ambiguus (NA) synapses in slow clickers. Because the synapses are crucial in producing fast clicks (Zornik and Yamaguchi, 2012), we reasoned that the presence of synapses resembling those found in fast clickers in the brains of slow clickers provides evidence to support the idea that fast click central pattern generators (CPGs) are inherited, but remain latent in these species. When PBN of slow clickers were unilaterally stimulated, only about half of the brains responded with compound action pontentials (CAPs) from either one or both nerves (45% of female X. laevis, n=11, 57% of male X. tropicalis, n=7, Figure 10A). In the remaining preparations, there was either no response or tonic activity from the laryngeal nerves in response to PBN stimulation (Figure 10B). Even in the brains from which CAPs were elicited, some pulses within a stimulus train failed to evoke CAPs (Figure 10A), unlike in fast clickers where CAPs are elicited in response to almost every stimulus pulse (compare to male X. laevis Figure 8D left column). The mean minimum frequency required to elicit CAPs were >10.6 + 3.86 Hz in female X. laevis, and >30.0 + 8.17 Hz in male X. tropicalis. More importantly, in two female X. laevis brains and in one male X. tropicalis brain PBN needed to be stimulated at 20 Hz and 50 Hz, respectively, both of which are significantly higher than click rates of their vocalizations (female X. laevis ‘rapping’ contain clicks repeated at <20 Hz, and the advertisement call of male X. tropicalis contains clicks at ~30 Hz). Moreover, PBN-evoked CAP amplitudes of male X. tropicalis and female X. laevis were significantly lower and higher than those observed during fictive calling, respectively (male X. tropicalis: Figure 10C, left graph, Wilcoxon Signed rank test, Z=–2.02, p=0.043, female X. laevis: Figure 10C, Wilcoxon Signed rank test, Z=–2.02, p=0.043), indicating that PBN-evoked CAPs differ from those produced during fictive calling. The amplitude of PBN-evoked CAPs in slow clickers were significantly smaller than those of fast clickers (Figure 10D, ANOVA F_{1, 50} = 8.766, p=0.0047), and the stimulus amplitude required to elicit CAPs from the laryngeal nerves was significantly higher in the slow clickers than in fast clickers (Figure 10E, ANOVA, F_{1, 52} = 30.52, p<0.0001), indicating that synapses between the PBN and the laryngeal motoneurons of slow clickers are weaker than those of fast clickers. We did not determine whether the synapses were monosynaptic and glutamatergic because PBN-evoked CAPs in the slow clickers were variable and unreliable. Finally, we found that the properties of synapses between the PBN and the laryngeal motoneurons changed dramatically in response to testosterone in female X. laevis, suggesting that female X. laevis acquire fast trill-like CPGs in response to testosterone. To summarize, our results suggest that slow clickers lack the strong synapses between the PBN and the laryngeal motoneurons that are observed in the fast clickers.

Figure 10

Download asset Open asset

Our results show that slow and fast clicks are generated by distinct central pattern generators (CPGs) across species; slow clicks repeated at rates <35 Hz are produced by slow trill-like CPGs contained in the caudal brainstem, whereas fast clicks (>50 Hz) are generated by fast trill-like CPG that span between the parabrachial nucleus (PBN) and nucleus ambiguus (NA). The results indicate that the basic architecture of the neural circuitry used to generate courtship advertisement calls appears to be conserved across species, even though the advertisement calls of each species differ in click repetition rates and the number of clicks within each call (in addition to the frequencies (i.e. pitch) of each click dictated by the anatomy of the larynx Kwong-Brown et al., 2019).

The use of different populations of neurons to generate rhythmic motor programs at different frequencies may be common in vertebrates. For instance, in the zebrafish swimming network and mice locomotory network, which varies greatly in oscillatory frequency, interneurons in the locomotory circuits are recruited in a rate-dependent manner (McLean et al., 2007; McLean et al., 2008; Rancic et al., 2020; Song et al., 2020). Specifically, in zebrafish, three different populations of interneurons that are recruited at slow, intermediate, and fast frequencies of undulations have been identified (Song et al., 2020), and similar results are reported in mice (Rancic et al., 2020). The recruitment of PBN neurons to generate fast, but not slow clicks in Xenopus may parallel the recruitment of fast-swim and slow-swim interneurons in zebrafish swim circuits. The use of different populations of interneurons to generate distinct frequency of motor programs driving the same muscle groups may be the most efficient strategy in vertebrates.

All the fast clickers included in this study use calls containing clicks repeated at a slow (<35 Hz) rate such as amplectant clicks, release calls, and long-slow clicks. In contrast, the slow clickers (male X. tropicalis and female X. laevis) never generate calls containing fast clicks (>50 Hz). This disparity in the frequency range of vocal repertoires may be due to differences in the effective organ of fast and slow clickers. Male X. laevis (fast clicker) laryngeal muscles have faster contractile properties compared to female X. laevis (slow clicker), corresponding with the differences in the click rates produced by each sex. The half-relaxation time of a single twitch of female laryngeal muscles is six times that of male laryngeal muscles (Potter et al., 2005), which means the female larynx is incapable of generating fast clicks even if the motoneurons fire at a high rate. To maintain fast twitch muscles, specialized mechanisms including increased expression of Ca2+-ATPase by the sarcoplasmic reticulum are required to handle high levels of myoplasmic Ca2+ (Rome and Klimov, 2000), which may come at a high cost. Therefore, if slow clicks are sufficient to fulfill the primary purpose of acoustic communication, such as attracting females, it may be cost-effective use slow clicks exclusively.

Biphasic callers, including male X. laevis and X. petersii, produce fast and slow trills that are mutually exclusive. Although coordination of multiple oscillators has been extensively studied in other species, neural mechanisms that coordinate the timing of fast and slow trills are yet to be determined. In lampreys, swimming oscillators in each segment of the spinal cord operate at same frequency generate undulatory motion (Grillner et al., 1995) and their coordination are explained by mathematical theory of phase-coupled oscillators are coupled with a fixed-phase difference to generate undulatory motion (Marder et al., 1997; Sigvardt and Miller, 1998). Similarly, in crustaceans, two CPGs controlling chewing and food filtering that operate at two distinct frequencies modulate each other (Weimann et al., 1991; Thuma and Hooper, 2002; Bucher et al., 2006). In particular, synaptic connections between the two CPGs in Jonah crab (Cancer borealis) have been shown to coordinate rate and timing of both oscillators through fixed-latency coupling (Bartos et al., 1999). The fast and slow CPGs of Xenopus operate alternately, which distinguishes them from the oscillators described above that operate simultaneously. Nonetheless, it is possible that reciprocal inhibition, a core building block of most CPGs (Marder and Bucher, 2001), may play a role in coordinating the timing of fast and slow CPGs. In the future, high-density recordings from the calling brain of biphasic species hold the potential to detect the presence of such neurons.

Determining which of the central pattern generators (CPGs) in the genus Xenopus is more ancestral is not straightforward because both fast and slow clickers are widely distributed across clades (Tobias et al., 2011; Evans et al., 2015). Studies on sound-producing fishes have shown that the neurons in the vocal CPGs in the caudal brainstem originate from rhombomere 8 (Bass and Chagnaud 2012). Although the exact location of the slow click CPGs in Xenopus is not known, it is possible that neurons derived from rhombomere 8 constitute the slow click CPGs in Xenopus, suggesting that the slow CPGs may be more ancestral than the fast CPGs. Although we did not test whether all fast clickers have slow CPGs in their brainstem in this study, they generate calls that consist of slow clicks, suggesting that slow CPGs may be inherited by all species of Xenopus.

In contrast, the parabrachial nucleus (PBN), which develops from rhombomere 0 and 1 (Karthik et al., 2022), is a part of the central vocal pathways (Smotherman et al., 2006; Hage, 2020) in mammals, and its contribution to vocal production is also suggested in birds (Wild et al., 2009). Given the involvement of PBN in coordinating vocal and respiratory systems (Smotherman et al., 2006; Smotherman and Metzner, 2010; Barkan and Zornik, 2020), its use is considered to be an adaptation in terrestrial species to power their vocalizations through respiration. Interestingly, the PBN is active during fictive advertisement calling in a terrestrial frog, Rana pipiens (Schmidt, 1992), suggesting that PBN may have been recruited into the central vocal pathways early in the evolution of tetrapod.

Although most species of frogs are terrestrial, Xenopus has returned to an aquatic life and produces vocalizations exclusively under water using a specialized larynx that does not require the respiratory system (Yager, 1992; Kwong-Brown et al., 2019). Air breathing occurs entirely at the water surface, making calling and breathing mutually exclusive in Xenopus. There is even some evidence of reciprocal inhibition between the two systems (Yamaguchi unpublished data). Xenopus likely inherited their fast CPGs, which include PBN, from ancestral terrestrial frog that used respiratory system to vocalize. They then modified these CPGs so that the vocal and respiratory activities occur in antiphase instead of in phase. Taken together, we speculate that Xenopus inherited the ancient pacemaker that existed in the caudal brainstem of fishes, which has evolved into slow click CPGs that may be shared by all species of Xenopus. Additionally, Xenopus likely inherited neural networks, including the PBN, from more recent terrestrial species that generate vocalizations using the respiratory system, which has evolved into fast click CPGs that are selectively shared by fast clicker species.

In invertebrates, the divergent evolution of central pattern generators (CPGs) has been studied extensively (reviewed by Sakurai and Katz, 2015; Katz, 2016; Roberts et al., 2022). Results from these studies suggest that there arereveal three main strategies employed in this process: synaptic rewiring, changes in neuromodulation, and alteration in CPG neurons.

Synaptic rewiring involves changes in the connectivity of CPG neurons can result in behavioral divergence through evolutionary time. This process has been observed in various species including the pharyngeal pumping CPGs of nematodes (Bumbarger et al., 2013), the song CPGs of Drosophila (Ding et al., 2019) and crickets (Jacob and Hedwig, 2019; Lin and Hedwig, 2021), and has been implicated in the evolution of the unique locomotory CPGs of the Icelandic horse (Andersson et al., 2012). Molecular mechanisms underlying synaptic rewiring include modification of genes controlling axon guidance (Andersson et al., 2012) or synaptic development (Charrier et al., 2012; Schmidt et al., 2021), differential expression of surface molecules by synaptic target neurons (Hong et al., 2012), and the presence or absence of microRNA (Johnston and Hobert, 2003). It is important to note that synaptic rewiring can occur without changing the behavioral output, indicating that natural selection can act upon the neural circuitry and motor outputs independently (Sakurai et al., 2011; Sakurai et al., 2014; Katz, 2016).

Neuromodulators can alter the output of the CPGs by altering the intrinsic properties of the constituent neurons and their synaptic connectivity (Katz, 1998; Harris-Warrick, 2011; Miles and Sillar, 2011; Golowasch, 2019; Blitz, 2023). Changes in the types, concentration, or the expression patterns of neuromodulators or receptors can all result in divergent behavioral output. For instance, the divergence of chewing and food filtering behavior generated by CPGs of two crustacean species is explained by changes in the type of neuromodulators (Meyrand et al., 2000).

Intrinsic properties of neurons that constitute CPGs can be modified by various mechanisms, including changes in the ionic conductance, receptor expression, and downstream signaling pathways (Roberts et al., 2022), and lead to divergent evolution. Divergence of key CPG neurons has been observed in the song/vocal CPGs of crickets (Jacob and Hedwig, 2019) and Xenopus (see below Barkan et al., 2018).

Although the exact location of slow click CPGs is not known, we have better understanding of the location and function of the fast click CPGs in Xenopus. However, we do not yet know whether synaptic wiring and changes in neuromodulations contribute to the divergence of fast clicks across species due to the insufficient resolution to detect subtle differences in synaptic wiring, and the use of a single type of neuromodulator (i.e. 5HT) to determine its impact on the CPG in this study. Nevertheless, we showed that, at a gross anatomical level, synapses between the parabrachial nucleus (PBN) and nucleus ambiguus (NA) are conserved across all fast clicker species. Additionally, we found that 5HT has species-specific effectiveness in activating fictive advertisement calls, indicating possible contribution of neuromodulators in the vocal divergence. In contrast, there is strong evidence that the intrinsic properties of a particular type of neuron in the fast CPG have diverged across species. Male X. laevis, X. petersii, and X. victorianus produce fast trills repeated at ~60 Hz with species-specific duration in their advertisement calls. Fast Trill Neurons identified in the parabrachial nucleus of these species fire at 60 Hz and exhibit long-lasting depolarization mediated by NMDA receptor activation, coinciding with the species-specific duration of fast trills (Zornik and Yamaguchi, 2012; Barkan et al., 2017; Barkan et al., 2018), indicating that the neurons code for the duration and click rates of fast trills in each species. Therefore, it is likely that fast click CPGs diverged across species by altering the intrinsic properties of key neurons in the parabrachial nucleus while conserving the basic synaptic wiring.

In this study, we found that when adult female X. laevis were treated with testosterone, their central vocal pathway transformed to resemble that of males. This included the activation of parabrachial nucleus (PBN) during fictive fast trills and the emergence of male-like synapses between PBN and laryngeal motoneurons. However, this effect of testosterone appears to be limited to the fast clicker species. Male X. tropicalis, a slow clicker species, has been shown to have comparable plasma levels of testosterone to male X. laevis (mean plasma levels of testosterone of male X. laevis: 13–22 ng/ml Hecker et al., 2005; Hayes et al., 2010, male X. tropicalis:~20 ng/ml Olmstead et al., 2009), yet the synapses between the PBN and laryngeal motoneurons in male X. tropicalis remained weak, and PBN showed little activity during fictive advertisement calls. These results suggest that testosterone acts differently on the central vocal pathways of fast and slow clickers, promoting the emergence of fast trill-like CPGs in X. laevis but not in X. tropicalis. Although further experiments with controlled testosterone levels are necessary to validate these results, we hypothesize that changes in the androgen receptors (e.g. expression patterns, ligand affinity) may have contributed to the divergence of fast and slow clickers. In line with this hypothesis, species-specific sensitivity to the gonadal hormones has been reported in a few species of Xenopus (Leininger et al., 2015).

Latent neural networks, which are considered evolutionary remnants, have been observed in various animals. For example, female Drosophila melanogaster, which do not produce male-typical courtship songs, still possess song neural networks that can be artificially activated (Clyne and Miesenböck, 2008). Similarly, flight neural networks are present in flightless grasshoppers (Arbas, 1983). Given that fast trill-like CPGs in the genus Xenopus are likely ancestral, wIn this study, we asked if the fast trill-like CPGs are inherited by all species within the genus Xenopus, despite being latent in slow clickers. Although we did not observe any fictive fast clicks from the brains of male X. tropicalis and female X. laevis, we could not rule out the possibility that the motor programs were not elicited because we failed to provide appropriate stimuli. To address this question, we examined the synaptic properties between the parabrachial nucleus and the laryngeal motoneurons, which are crucial for the fast trill-like central pattern generators (CPGs). Our results revealed that fast and potentiating synapses found in all fast clickers are absent in slow clickers. Instead, the synapses of slow clickers are weak and unreliable. Thus, we conclude that fast trill-like CPGs are present only in species that incorporate fast clicks in their vocal repertoire, possibly due to the high cost of maintaining such synapses (Figure 11). If slow clickers produce fast-trill like motor programs, which is unlikely due to the limitation of the laryngeal contractile properties discussed above, the underlying neural circuitries likely differ from the fast trill-like CPGs. It is important to note that the addition of fast trill-like CPGs to the central vocal pathways can occur rapidly within an individual, as seen in the transformation of the central vocal pathways in adult female X. laevis.

In summary, we compared the central vocal pathways of five Xenopus species to better understand neural mechanisms underlying divergence of courtship behavior. We found that fast and slow trill-like CPGs have a conserved basic architecture across species. Fast trill-like CPGs are not shared by all Xenopus species, but present only in fast clickers. Exogenous testosterone appears to promote the acquisition of fast trill-like CPGs in fast clickers, but not in slow clickers. We suggest that changes in the role of testosterone in organizing the central vocal pathways resulted in the divergence between fast and slow clickers, and the alteration of the intrinsic properties of Fast Trill Neurons in the parabrachial nucleus led to species-specific rate and duration of clicks among fast clickers. Our findings indicate that courtship behavior in vertebrates can diverge across species even though the underlying neural circuits inherited through an evolutionary lineage are conserved. This behavioral divergence is likely achieved through species-specific modifications in the intrinsic properties of neurons, and potential changes in responsiveness to gonadal hormones.

Fifty-nine male X. laevis, 39 female X. laevis, 24 male X. tropicalis obtained from Nasco (Fort Atkinson, WI, average +std weight = 42.59 ± 3.04 g, 54.83±4.79 g, 10.13±0.32 g, length = 6.99 ± 0.18 cm, 7.63±0.20 cm, 4.48±0.05 cm), 13 male X. petersii obtained from the National Xenopus Resource (Woods Hole, MA, weight = 16.49 ± 0.70, length = 4.22 ± 0.09 cm), and 12 male X. amieti, 3 male X. cliivi generously provided by Dr. Darcy Kelley (Columbia University, weight = 7.24 ± 1.23 g, 16.4±0.144 g, length = 3.87 ± 0.2 cm, 5.33±0.2 cm) were used for this study. This study was performed in strict accordance with the recommendation in the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals of the National Institute of Health. All the animals were handled according to approved institutional animal care and use committee (IACUC) protocols (#00001989) of the University of Utah. The protocol was approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at the University of Utah and complied with National Institute of Health guidelines. All surgery was performed under tricaine methanesulfonate (MS-222) anesthesia, and every effort was made to minimize suffering.

Eleven adult female X. laevis (average + std weight=64.39 + 6.43 g, length = 8.08 + 0.26 cm) were anesthetized with MS-222 (ethyl 3-amino benzoate methanesulfonic acid, Sigma Aldrich) and were ovariectomized by removing ovaries and fat bodies using a cauterizer through a small incision (~1 cm) in the abdomen. Immediately after ovary removal, testosterone-filled (4-androsten-17β-ol-3-one, Sigma Aldrich T-1500) Silastic tubes (2.16 OD x 1.02 ID; 0.5 mg/g body weight) were implanted into the ventral lymph sacs of females. This treatment is known to elevate plasma levels of testosterone from female-typical levels (1.1–2.3 ng/ml, Kang et al., 1995) to levels about 70% higher than those of reproductively receptive males (44 ng/ml) for >1 year (Watson and Kelley, 1992; Kang et al., 1995). After 13 weeks, vocal recordings were obtained from the testosterone-treated female X. laevis (Potter et al., 2005). Once they were verified to produce male-like advertisement calls, the animals were used for electrophysiological experiments.

Eight male X. tropicalis, 5 female X. laevis, 6 male X. amieti, 5 male X. laevis, 5 testosterone-treated female X. laevis, 3 male X. cliivi, and 6 male X. cliivi were used for vocal recordings. Sound recordings were obtained from all animals with hydrophones (Aquarian Audio Hydrophone H1a, Anacortes, WA) suspended 2 cm below the surface level in the center of a plastic 12 liter tank filled with 10 liters of water. Vocal recordings were obtained using a voice-activated recording system (Sound Analyses Pro, http://soundanalysispro.com/). Advertisement calls of the males of all species and testosterone-treated females were recorded when housed individually. To facilitate vocal production in female X. laevis that did not produce release calls when housed solo, they were co-housed with male X. laevis (the vocalizations of the two sexes can be easily distinguished based on the click rate and the sound frequency of the clicks). All sound recordings were obtained at 19–22 ⁰C in the dark overnight.

Ten sound files were sampled randomly for analysis from each animal. To characterize the temporal morphology of the calls, the inter-click interval, and the number of clicks per call (or fast and slow trill vocal phases in the case of male X. laevis, X. petersii, and testosterone-treated female X. laevis) were measured using Raven software (Cornell University Bioacoustics Laboratory, Ithaca, NY). To characterize the central tendency of click rates for each individual, we carried out the following analysis. First, normalized frequency histograms of instantaneous click rates (1/inter-click interval in seconds) were plotted with a bin width of 1 Hz for each individual. Each histogram was fitted with either a unimodal (for animals that produce monophasic calls; male X. amieti, male X. cliivi, male X. tropicalis, and female X. laevis) or a bimodal (for animals that produce biphasic calls; male X. laevis, male X. petersii, and testosterone-treated female X. laevis) Gaussian distribution using the Levenberg-Marquardt method to search for a model and the sum of squared errors method to identify the model that best fit the data. The mean value for µ (for monophasic calls), or µ1 and µ2 (for biphasic calls) were used to represent the central tendency of click rates of each individual.

The methods for isolating a brain were described elsewhere (Rhodes et al., 2007; Zornik and Yamaguchi, 2012). Briefly, animals were anesthetized with subcutaneous injection (0.3 mL 1.3%) of tricaine methanesulfonate (MS-222; Sigma), decapitated on ice, and brains were removed from the skulls in a dish containing cold saline (in mM: 96 NaCl, 20 NaHCO₃, 2 CaCl₂, 2KCl, 0.5 MgCl₂, 10 HEPES, and 11 glucose, pH 7.8 oxygenated with 99% O₂/1% CO₂). Brains were then brought back to room temperature (22 °C) over the next hour and then transferred to a recording chamber which was superfused with oxygenated saline at 100 ml/hour at room temperature.

Fictive calls were recorded from 8 male X. tropicalis, 7 female X. laevis, 4 X. amieti, 5 male X. laevis, 3 testosterone-treated female X. laevis, 2 male X. cliivi and 5 male X. petersii. After fictive calls were recorded from intact brains, unilateral transections between the PBN and the NA on either the left or the right side were made using a scalpel in some brains. To prevent the neurons from excessive firing during transection, brains were first chilled by superfusing with ice-cold saline to bring the temperature of the tissues to ~5 °C, and a cut was made posterior to cranial nerve VIII from the midline to the lateral edge of the brains on either the left or the right side of the brainstem. After the transection, the brains were gradually warmed up by superfusing with room-temperature saline at 100 ml/hr. To confirm the completeness of the transection, Texas red dextran and fluorescein dextran (both 3000 mw, Thermo Fisher, Waltham, MA) were deposited into the nucleus ambiguus (NA) on each side using minutien pins after the completion of the electrophysiological recordings, and the brain was incubated at 4 °C for 48 hr, fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde, sectioned into 40 um thickness, and examined under the fluorescent microscope to verify that the no labeled soma or axons are seen in the PBN of the transected side.

Extracellular recordings of the left and right laryngeal nerves were obtained using suction electrodes placed over the cranial nerve IX-X. Signals were amplified (1000 X) and bandpass filtered (10–10 kHz) with a differential A-C amplifier (model 1700, A-M systems). Local field potential (LFP) recordings from the parabrachial nucleus (PBN) were obtained using a 1 MΩ tungsten electrode (FHC, Bowdoin, ME) with its signal amplified (1000 X) and bandpass filtered (0.1–10 kHz) using an amplifier (model 1800, A-M systems). Both nerve and PBN LFP recordings were digitized at 10 kHz (Digidata 1440 A; Molecular Devices, San Jose, CA) and acquired with Clampex software (Molecular Devices).

Fictive calls were elicited using the following methods. For male, female, testosterone-treated female X. laevis, and male X. petersii, the bath application of 60 µM serotonin (5-HT, Sigma-Aldrich,) was effective in eliciting fictive calls. For male X. tropicalis, the bath application of 30 µM 5-HT together with 50 µM N-methyl-DL-aspartic acid (NMA, Sigma-Aldrich) was applied to the isolated brains. For male X. amieti and male X. cliivi, electrical pulses were delivered to either the left or right rostral-lateral cerebellum (RLCB, Figure 1D) via a concentric electrode (CBPH75, FHC, Bowdoin, ME) connected to an SIU (Iso-Flex, A.M.P.I, Jerusalem, Israel) driven by a stimulator (Master 8, A.M.P.I, Jerusalem, Israel) to elicit fictive advertisement calls. For the electrical stimulation, the stimulus pulse duration was 40 µs in all cases, but the pulse frequency, amplitude, polarity, and the total number of pulses per train necessary to elicit fictive calls were empirically determined for each preparation. Electrical stimulation of RLCB was also used to elicit fictive calls in some of the brains of other species in this study.

To functionally characterize the synapses between the NA projecting neurons in PBN and the laryngeal motoneurons, a 1 MΩ tungsten electrode (FHC, Bowdoin, ME) was inserted into either the left or right PBN and stimulus trains (40us pulse duration, frequency ranged from 1 to 100 Hz) were delivered via an SIU (Iso-Flex, A.M.P.I, Jerusalem, Israel) driven by a stimulator (Master 8, A.M.P.I, Jerusalem, Israel) while recordings are obtained from the left and right laryngeal nerves as described above. The minimum stimulus amplitude necessary to elicit compound action potentials was empirically determined first for each preparation. In some animals, the experiments were repeated in high-divalent cation (Hi-Di) saline to determine if the synaptic connections are monosynaptic. Hi-Di saline is a commonly used method to remove polysynaptic components to isolate monosynaptic components of the synapses (Nicholls and Purves, 1970). Hi-Di saline included four times the concentration of MgCl₂ (2 mM) compared to regular saline (0.5 mM), with the concentration of NaCl adjusted to maintain the constant osmolarity. To determine the role of AMPA receptors in mediating the synaptic transmission between PBN and laryngeal motoneurons, in some animals the PBN stimulation experiment was repeated in a bath with 2 µM NBQX added to the saline in some animals.

The local field potential (LFP) recordings obtained from the PBN contain phasic activity that correlated with >50 Hz compound action potentials (CAPs) recorded from the laryngeal nerve during CAPs repeated at rates >50 Hz. We used the power spectral density (PSD) of the LFP traces (Clampfit software, Molecular Devices). To calculate the mean PSD for each species, each PSD was normalized to its maximum value and averaged across individuals from recordings of the same length (to hold the spectral resolution constant) within each species.

The Xenopus larynx generates a click sound when both laryngeal muscles are activated simultaneously and pull apart a pair of arytenoid discs (Yager, 1992; Kwong-Brown et al., 2019). Accordingly, the central vocal pathways of intact Xenopus brains activate left and right laryngeal motoneurons synchronously. To quantify the synchronicity of the CAPs recorded from the left and right laryngeal nerves, cross-correlation coefficients between the two nerve recordings were calculated while sliding one nerve recording against the other across time (±10ms, except in female X. laevis where ± 50ms was used to accommodate their longer CAP duration). Specifically, 10 consecutive CAPs recorded during a fictive call from the left and right nerve of a brain were used to calculate cross-correlation coefficients, and the time at which the maximum cross-correlation coefficients was achieved was identified as ‘the maximum lag time’ for each brain. For biphasic callers, the maximum lag times were obtained for both fast and slow trills. A maximum lag time of zero indicates the synchronous activity of the two nerves. A maximum lag time value > 0 indicates a delay of the transected side relative to the intact side.

To determine if the temporal morphology of the vocalizations recorded in vivo differs significantly from the fictive vocalizations recorded in vitro, we compared the click/conmpound action potential (CAP) rates and the total number of clicks/CAPs per call/vocal phase (fast or slow trills) using a Wilcoxon signed rank test for each species.

To assess the synchronicity of CAPs produced by the left and right nerves in intact brain preparations, we used a one-sample sign test to determine if the maximum lag time differs from 0. To assess if CAPs desynchronize after brain transection, we used a Wilcoxon signed rank test to compare the maximum lag time before and after transection.

Unilateral stimulation of the parabrachial nucleus (PBN) elicited CAPs from both laryngeal nerves. When the connection between the PBN and its ipsilateral nucleus ambiguus (NA) was transected, stimulation delivered to the PBN on the intact side still elicited CAPs from both nerves. To determine if the latency between the stimulus onset and the peak CAP time is significantly increased after the unilateral transection, we compared the CAP latency (defined as the interval between the stimulus onset and the time of CAP peak) before and after the transection on the intact side and to the transected side using the Mann-Whitney U test.

Unilateral stimulation of the PBN elicited CAPs from both laryngeal nerves in most animals. The significance of the difference in latency between stimulus onset and peak CAP times recorded from ipsilateral and contralateral nerves was evaluated using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test was used. In addition, to model changes in CAP amplitude and latency in response to repetitive unilateral stimulation of the PBN, both variables were plotted against the stimulus pulse number, and exponential curves $f\left(t\right)$ = A (1-e^-t/τ)^a+C were fitted for every stimulus frequency above 10 Hz for each individual with Chebychev search method and sums of squared errors minimization method using Clampfit software (Molecular Devices, San Jose, CA). An ANOVA was used to determine if τ differs depending on the stimulus frequency. In all animals that showed CAPs in response to PBN stimulation, the maximum amplitude of the PBN-evoked CAPs was compared to those recorded during fictive calling using a Wilcoxon signed rank test. The minimum stimulus amplitude required for PBN stimulation to elicit CAPs and the maximum amplitude of PBN-evoked CAPs were compared across species using the Mann-Whitney U test. All statistical tests were carried out using StatView software (SAS Institute, Cary, NC).

The funders had no role in study design, data collection and interpretation, or the decision to submit the work for publication.

We thank Akemi Nguyen for the histological analyses, Michelle Tin, and Berlyn Prue for the help with data analyses, and Darcy Kelley, Erik Zornik, Matt Wachowiak, Paul Katz, and Francois Lambert for the comments on the earlier version of the manuscript. This work was supported by NSF IOS-1934386 (AY).

This study was performed in strict accordance with the recommendation in the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals of the National Institute of Health. All the animals were handled according to approved institutional animal care and use committee (IACUC) protocols (#00001989) of the University of Utah. The protocol was approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at the University of Utah and complied with National Institute of Health guidelines. All surgery was performed under tricaine methanesulfonate (MS-222) anesthesia, and every effort was made to minimize suffering.

© 2023, Yamaguchi and Peltier

This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.