Analysis of brain ultrastructure using electron microscopy typically relies on chemical fixation. However, this is known to cause significant tissue distortion including a reduction in the extracellular space. Cryo fixation is thought to give a truer representation of biological structures, and here we use rapid, high-pressure freezing on adult mouse neocortex to quantify the extent to which these two fixation methods differ in terms of their preservation of the different cellular compartments, and the arrangement of membranes at the synapse and around blood vessels. As well as preserving a physiological extracellular space, cryo fixation reveals larger numbers of docked synaptic vesicles, a smaller glial volume, and a less intimate glial coverage of synapses and blood vessels compared to chemical fixation. The ultrastructure of mouse neocortex therefore differs significantly comparing cryo and chemical fixation conditions.https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05793.001
For many years, scientists have used chemicals to preserve brain tissue to observe its fine structure using high power microscopes. Korogod et al. now show that these chemicals, or fixatives, cause the tissue to shrink, giving the false impression that the cells are tightly packed together. This has led to misinterpretations of how the brain is structured. For example, components such as the synapse, used by neurons to communicate with each other, are bathed in a watery environment, rather than being tightly enclosed by neighbouring cells as previously thought.
Electron microscopy is the only imaging method that is able to see the detailed structure of the nervous system, including synaptic connections. The technique fires a beam of electrons through a sample held in a vacuum and creates images at a higher magnification than light microscopes. However, the electron beam and the vacuum damages live cells and tissues. Therefore, samples must be ‘fixed’ to preserve them before they are imaged with these methods. However, the standard method for fixing brain tissue uses chemical ‘fixatives’, even though these cause shrinkage, and distort the cells.
Korogod et al. used an alternative method of fixation—freezing—to better preserve tiny pieces of mouse brain in their natural state. This was achieved with a technique called ‘high pressure freezing’ that combines jets of liquid nitrogen with very high pressures to instantaneously preserve small samples without causing damage through the formation of ice crystals, or any shrinkage and distortion. Once frozen, the samples of mouse brain are encased in resin, and then imaged with the electron microscope. A comparison between the two preservation techniques showed that chemical fixatives remove the watery environment, or extracellular fluid, that surrounds the cells in the brain, squashing them together.
The synapses were surrounded by large amounts of extracellular fluid, but cryo fixation also revealed that these sites of communication between neurons also contained many more vesicles—the packets containing the chemicals that pass signals across the synapse. Another type of cell, the glial cell, that supports and helps to maintain neurons, was also strongly distorted by the chemical fixation. These were understood to tightly wrap around synapses, as well as blood vessels, but cryo fixation showed this to be less prominent.
This study illustrates that our understanding of how brain's cells are arranged has ignored the effects of the chemicals used to preserve them. Although cryo fixation is only able to preserve tiny samples, it reveals a truer picture of their natural structure, giving scientists a better understanding of how the brain works.https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05793.002
The renewed interest in electron microscopy and the emergence of serial imaging approaches to capture volumes of biological tissues at an unprecedented scale (Briggman et al., 2011; Helmstaedter et al., 2013; Bock et al., 2011; reviewed by Briggman and Bock, 2012) have driven the re-examination of commonly used preparation methods (Mikula et al., 2012; Tapia et al., 2012). This has not only been necessary to help increase image contrast and improve imaging speed on a larger scale, but also to help computer vision research produce assisted segmentation approaches for reconstructing different features. However, with this re-invigoration of electron microscope technology, and the need for automation to reconstruct complex structures, it is important to understand how chemical fixation alters brain ultrastructure.
The distortion of cell morphology by immersing samples in fixative was apparent in the earliest electron microscopy investigations of the brain, leading to experiments that made detailed comparisons between preparation methods (Schultz et al., 1957). These paid careful attention to how different fixatives affected cell volume and preserved the ultrastructure. However, the need to consistently preserve entire organs soon led to cardiac perfusion of aldehydes, and staining with buffered osmium, which became the accepted approach for electron microscopy studies (Karlsson and Schultz, 1965, 1966), despite the tissue shrinkage it caused. The degree of shrinkage depends on differences in fixative composition, concentration (Hillman and Deutsch, 1978), and region (Kalimo, 1976). Shrinkage has significant implications for the measurement of parameters such as the density of structures; for example, synaptic contacts. Few studies have incorporated a shrinkage factor. Kalimo et al., adjusted for a 16% linear reduction (Kalimo, 1976), and Kinney et al. 15% shrinkage along each orthogonal axis (Kinney et al., 2013). Any correction is typically calculated on the basis of the changes that occur during the embedding process, with the assumption that no alterations occur during the initial tissue fixation. Using rudimentary indicators such as the position of lesion sites (Schüz and Palm, 1989), or observations of how the brain filled the skull (O’Kusky and Colonnier, 1982), gave no precise value for how any brain region changed in volume during the preservation process. In the current study, we made quantitative analyses of fresh and chemically fixed brain tissue using discrete landmarks that allow us to assess the extent of volume changes that occur in the somatosensory cortex.
A persistent concern of using chemical fixation has also been the discrepancy between what electron microscopy sees and physiological experiments measure, particularly in terms of extracellular space. Even prior to ultrastructural brain imaging, a measurement of ionic concentrations showed that around a fifth of the tissue volume was extracellular space (Allen, 1955). This was subsequently verified by various in vivo experiments, using techniques such as resistivity measurements and diffusion analysis. The amount of extracellular space varies between brain regions and the stage of development (Syková and Nicholson, 2008). In the neocortex of the adult rat, for example, it is 18–22%, and at postnatal day 4–7, 30% and 43%, depending on the cortical layer (Lehmenkühler et al., 1993). Yet standard electron microscopy of this tissue using chemical fixation shows considerably less. This mismatch led Anton Van Harreveld to explore this phenomenon, along with alternative methods of brain fixation.
To circumvent any reaction to the chemical fixatives, Van Harreveld introduced a method of rapid freezing of exposed live brain, followed by resin embedding at low temperatures, known as freeze substitution (Van Harreveld et al., 1965). This technique revealed the physiological levels of extracellular space. Here, we have revisited this method, using high-pressure freezing to preserve tissue volumes, and comparing how the different cellular compartments are affected with chemical fixation. Ultrastructural analysis using serial section electron microscopy showed that chemically fixed tissue has a reduced volume: a significant loss of extracellular space and a decrease in the volume of neurites. However, the volume fraction of astrocytic elements increased following chemical fixation. In cryo-fixed tissue astrocytes showed a less intimate association with synapses, and their endfeet have a reduced coverage of blood vessels. Differences in membrane arrangements were also apparent at the synapse with a lower density of vesicles along the presynaptic membrane in chemically fixed synapses.
We first analysed how chemical fixation altered the volume of the neocortex by comparing fresh and chemically fixed brain sections cut through mouse primary somatosensory barrel cortex (Figure 1A, Figure 1—figure supplement 1). Coronal and tangential sections show the distinctive barrel pattern in layer IV, corresponding to the arrangement of whiskers on the mouse's muzzle, enabling us to estimate the total volume change. The chemical fixation protocol was a standard cardiac perfusion with buffered paraformaldehyde and glutaraldehyde, used widely as a preparation method for electron microscopy of brain tissue. Fresh sections were prepared from brains that had been removed rapidly from the skulls of decapitated mice and harvested in the same manner as for electrophysiological experiments.
Chemically fixed coronal sections showed enlarged ventricles and a clear reduction in total area compared to the fresh sections (Figure 1A). The cortical thickness was reduced by 16%, as measured from the pial surface to the start of the white matter (fresh 1.13 ± 0.02 mm, N = 6 mice; chemically fixed 0.95 ± 0.07 mm, N = 14 mice; p = 0.00004, unpaired two-tailed Student's t-test). Tangentially cut sections showed 18% shrinkage along the rostrocaudal axis, measured along the barrel rows: A1–A4, B1–B4, C1–C4 and D1–D4 (fresh 0.90 ± 0.01 mm, N = 3 mice; chemically fixed 0.74 ± 0.03 mm, N = 3 mice; p = 0.006, one way ANOVA). However, no shrinkage was found along the barrel arcs, on the mediolateral axis: A1–D1, A2–D2, A3–D3, A4–D4, A1–D4, A4–D1 (fresh 1.18 ± 0.13 mm, N = 3 mice; chemically fixed 1.19 ± 0.11 mm, N = 3 mice; p = 0.942, one way ANOVA). Taken together, these changes indicate that chemical fixation induced total volume shrinkage in the somatosensory neocortex of 30%.
Using serial section electron microscopy, we compared the neuropil from the chemically fixed brains with tissue samples that had been rapidly excised and cryo fixed using high-pressure freezing (McDonald and Auer, 2006) and resin embedded by freeze substitution (Sosinsky et al., 2008). The chemically and cryo-fixed tissue samples were similarly stained with heavy metals giving a suitable contrast to identify all the membranes and large macromolecular structures (Figure 1C). Cryo-fixed neuropil appeared qualitatively different from the chemically fixed tissue. Neuronal and glial processes were smooth and round, appearing to float in extracellular space. With chemical fixation, the neuropil showed markedly less extracellular space with membranes tightly apposed to each other, often with complex concave and convex shapes. Quantification of serial section electron micrographs revealed that the volume fraction of extracellular space in cryo-fixed neuropil was six times more than chemically fixed samples (Figure 1D; cryo fixation, 15.4 ± 5.4%, N = 4 mice; chemical fixation, 2.47 ± 1.5%, N = 4 mice; p = 0.003, one way ANOVA).
Further analysis of these volumes measured the contribution of the different cellular compartments. This showed that the astrocytic volume fraction in the cryofixed neuropil was half of the value for chemical fixation (Figure 1E, Figure 1—figure supplement 1; cryo fixed, 7.4 ± 1.8%, N = 4 mice; chemical fixation, 14.4 ± 3.3%, N = 4 mice; p = 0.01, one way ANOVA). In contrast, the volume fraction occupied by axons and dendrites was similar between the fixation conditions (Figure 1—figure supplement 1; cryo fixed 76.7 ± 5.5%, N = 4 mice, chemically fixed 84.1 ± 4.1%, N = 4 mice; p = 0.074, one way ANOVA). Chemical fixation therefore appears to induce an increase in the astrocytic volume fraction.
We next compared the structure of synapses under the two fixation conditions (Figure 2). Synapses were clearly visible in all material (Figure 2A), and measurements from serial images showed that chemically fixed neuropil had significantly higher synapse density than cryo fixed (Figure 2B; cryo fixed = 0.63 ± 0.11 µm−3; chemically fixed = 0.87 ± 0.15 µm−3, p = 0.042, one way ANOVA, N = 4 mice each group). The increased synapse density after chemical fixation is consistent with the overall volume shrinkage of the neocortex (Figure 1). Measuring the distance from the edge of spine synapses to the nearest cell membrane, showed a three times larger gap after cryo fixation compared to chemical fixation (Figure 2B; cryo fixation, 166 ± 18 nm, N = 3 mice; chemical fixation, 53 ± 5 nm, N = 3 mice; p = 2.7 × 10−8, unpaired two-tailed Student's t-test). As astrocytes are present at many synapses, where they play a role in glutamate uptake, extracellular space homeostasis, and contribute to the regulation of synaptic transmission (Ventura and Harris, 1999; Oliet et al., 2001), we counted the proportion of spine synapses enveloped, or partially enveloped, by their processes (Figure 2B). Astrocytic processes at these types of synapses were significantly fewer in cryo-fixed cortex (cryo fixation, 34.0 ± 11.0%, N = 4 mice; chemical fixation, 62.4 ± 1.9%, N = 3 mice; p = 0.008, one way ANOVA). The numbers found in the chemically fixed neuropil are in good agreement with previous measurements (somatosensory cortex [Genoud et al., 2006]; hippocampus [Harris and Stevens, 1989]). Cryo-fixed tissue, in which there is a greater preservation of the extracellular space, therefore, reveals larger volumes around synaptic clefts suggesting that neurotransmitters can diffuse into large volumes of extracellular fluid before encountering other cell membranes.
The astrocytic elements in chemically fixed neuropil typically show less stained material in their cytoplasm compared to neurons. Their membranes appear to lie against the membranes of the surrounding axons and dendrites, giving them concave shapes, with a space-filling appearance, and large numbers of small processes squeezed between the neurites (Figure 2C). Reconstructions showed that cryo-fixed astrocytic processes stained similarly to axons and dendrites and were more rounded in appearance compared to astrocytes after chemical fixation (Figure 2D).
The apparent difference in appearance and arrangement of the astrocytic processes between the two fixation conditions was also investigated at the level of the blood capillaries (Figure 3), where their close association is suggested to play an important role in the regulation of solutes entering through the blood–brain barrier by almost completely surrounding the endothelial cells that form the vessel lumen (Mathiisen et al., 2010). By measuring the proportion of vessels that were surrounded by astrocytic endfeet (Figure 3A,B), we found significantly less coverage in cryo-fixed tissue (Figure 3C; percentage astrocytic coverage: cryo fixed 62.9 ± 15.0%, n = 11; chemical fixation 94.4 ± 6.0%, n = 69; p < 0.0001, unpaired two-tailed Student's t-test). Cryo-fixed tissue therefore reveals reduced astrocytic coverage of blood vessels suggesting that the abluminal surface of the endothelial cell has far greater direct access via the extracellular space to the neural elements within the brain than previously thought.
Synapses in chemically fixed tissue can be classified according to their morphology, and in the CNS they are typically categorized as either type 1 or type 2 (Gray, 1959). Type 2 synapses, later characterized as GABAergic, are distinguishable by their pre- and post-synaptic densities showing equal thickness (Uchizono, 1965; Colonnier, 1968), and their vesicles appearing flattened with darkened centres (Figure 4A, Figure 4—figure supplement 1). Measurements of the long and short diameters of synaptic vesicles at type 2 synapses in chemically fixed tissue indicate their ovoid shape (Figure 4B; long diameter ‘y’, 41.0 ± 5.4 nm; short diameter ‘x’, 28.2 ± 3.7 nm). The glutamatergic type 1 synapses in chemically fixed tissue, in contrast, have an obvious asymmetry with larger postsynaptic densities, and round vesicles with clear centres (Figure 4—figure supplement 1; diameter y, 40.0 ± 3.8 nm; diameter x, 39.1 ± 3.7 nm). In cryo-fixed neocortex all synapses, on spines and dendritic shafts showed similar symmetry, and vesicle diameters indicated them all as spherical (Figure 4A,B; diameter y, 38.7 ± 4.3 nm; diameter x, 38.5 ± 4.1 nm). This suggests that the chemical fixation causes the structural changes that allow this morphological distinction to be made. To check this, and verify that it was not an effect of the dehydration and embedding process, chemically fixed samples were high-pressure frozen and embedded at low temperature, by freeze substitution (Sosinsky et al., 2008). This material contained both asymmetric synapses (vesicle diameter y, 39.2 ± 4.0 nm; diameter x, 38.9 ± 4.8 nm) and synapses with symmetric pre- and post-synaptic densities, and flattened vesicles (Figure 4; diameter y, 41.6 ± 5.3 nm; diameter x, 27.7 ± 3.4 nm). The hallmarks differentiating glutamatergic and GABAergic synapses would therefore appear to be induced by chemical fixation.
We next compared the arrangement of synaptic vesicles in the two fixation conditions, measuring the distance of all vesicles within 150 nm of the presynaptic membrane, for synapses found on dendritic spines, larger than 0.2 microns and cut perpendicularly to the synaptic cleft (Figure 5). The average size of the synapses was the same in each group (Figure 5—figure supplement 1). The overall density of vesicles, within 150 nm of the presynaptic membrane, was the same in each group (cryo fixed, 37.9 ± 2.4 µm−1, N = 3 mice; chemical fixed, 38.0 ± 2.6 µm−1; N = 3 mice, p = 0.85; one way ANOVA). There were, however, clear differences in their spatial distribution (Figure 5B). The synaptic vesicle density within 30 nm of the presynaptic membrane was significantly increased in the cryo-fixed samples (Figure 5B; cryo fixed, 10.46 ± 0.88 µm−1; chemical fixed, 2.99 ± 0.53 µm−1; p < 0.001, unpaired Student’s t-test). Between 30 and 60 nm this had decreased in cryo-fixed samples (Figure 5B; cryo fixed, 4.01 ± 0.56 µm−1; chemical fixed, 8.02 ± 0.87 µm−1; p < 0.001, unpaired Student’s t-test). Beyond 60 nm there were no differences comparing cryo-fixed and chemically fixed synapses. This suggests that cryo fixation exposes two groups of vesicles; a group lying along the presynaptic membrane, and a second lying further back, away from the site of release.
In this study, we quantified differences in the ultrastructure of the adult mouse neocortex comparing standard chemical fixation with cryo fixation. Although chemical fixation is used widely and gives good ultrastructural preservation, it is also known to reduce the extracellular space and cause tissue shrinkage. Cryo-fixed tissue is likely to more closely resemble the native structure of the neocortex, and it is therefore of interest to compare cellular compartments and synaptic structures after cryo vs chemical fixation.
The analysis of coronal slices at the level of the somatosensory cortex shows that chemical fixation reduced the tissue volume by 30%. This volume decrease would show an increase in synapse density of 43% (1/0.7). Our synaptic density measurements showed a 38% increase between the cryo-fixed and chemically fixed tissue. The difference between these two values (43% vs 38%) might be accounted for by the fact that synapses were only counted in the neuropil, whereas the cortical volume measurements are from the whole tissue that includes cell bodies and blood vessels. We also cannot rule out changes to the tissue that may occur during the freeze substitution procedure as the acetone replaces the water at low temperature prior to any fixation with the osmium.
The fact that the chemical fixation process is relatively slow, involving the diffusion of aldehydes from blood vessels into the surrounding tissue, may also raise questions as to whether the short period of ischemia may cause a rapid assembly or disassembly of synaptic contacts. Sustained occlusion of cerebral vessels eventually leads to cell death and removal of synapses (Kovalenko et al., 2006). However, correlative in vivo light and electron microscopy studies would argue against this as they show that any anoxic changes initiated by the chemical fixation procedure do not result in the appearances or disappearances of any synaptic features such as dendritic spines or axonal boutons (Trachtenberg et al., 2002; De Paola et al., 2006; Holtmaat et al., 2006; Knott et al., 2006). Additionally, imaging the protein PSD95 in vivo also pinpoints all ultrastructurally identified synaptic connections, imaged with retrospective 3D electron microscopy (Cane et al., 2014), suggesting that it is unlikely that any synaptic formation or removal is initiated by the chemical fixation process.
To check that the high-pressure freezing itself does not cause a significant alteration of the tissue morphology, we fixed acute slices, prepared in the same manner as for electrophysiological recording, with the cryo fixation or by immersion in the chemical fixative. Both groups showed similar tissue quality and levels of extracellular space, at least where ice crystal formation had not disrupted the ultrastructure (Figure 1—figure supplement 2).
In terms of how the different cellular compartments react to the chemical perfusion fixation, the earliest investigations were aware of the discrepancy between physiological and structural measurements. The ‘watery look of the astrocyte’ led to suggestions that if the physiological measurements of extracellular space were correct then ‘methods of fixation here applied must be erroneous…’ (Schultz et al., 1957). Observations like this and many others preceded cryo-fixation studies, first undertaken by Anton Van Harreveld. In Van Harreveld's experiments, exposed brain surfaces were instantaneously fixed, using cooled metal plates, to reveal a physiological level of extracellular space. However, Van Harreveld also found that delaying the process until after the onset of anoxia, preserved a neuropil similar to that seen with chemical fixation (Van Harreveld et al., 1965). This was the first illustration of how the extracellular space rapidly disappears once the heart has stopped. More recent live imaging of fluorescent diffusion markers showed a similar reduction (Thorne and Nicholson, 2006) suggesting that the process of cardiac perfusion for chemical fixation would induce a normal tissue response to anoxia resulting from the removal of the blood supply.
The reduction of extracellular space cannot account solely for the total tissue volume decrease seen after chemical fixation. Analyses to calculate the volume fractions of different cell components show that the neuronal part remains unchanged. However, considering the total tissue volume has shrunk by 30% the neuronal portion has therefore reduced similarly to maintain the same volume fraction. The doubling of the astrocytic volume fraction after chemical fixation could reflect how this cell type reacts in the aftermath of anoxia. Oxygen depletion elicits an energy reduction resulting in ions moving down their concentration gradients, with an increase in extracellular potassium, and wholesale depolarisation and spreading depression throughout the tissue (Van Harreveld and Malhotra, 1967; Lutz, 1992). The critical role that astrocytes play in buffering potassium in the extracellular space (Kofuji and Newman, 2004; Binder et al., 2006) and water movement during brain ischemia (Manley et al., 2004) point to these cells as playing the principal role in removing the extracellular space. The high concentrations of aquaporin transporters along their surfaces (Benfenati and Ferroni, 2010) suggest that astrocytes may be responsible for the removal of extracellular water ensuring that any changes in outside environment are rapidly neutralised. Cryo fixing brain tissue at different stages after the initiation of spreading depression, or ischemia, has shown similar astrocytic morphologies to those seen after chemical fixation (Van Harreveld and Malhotra, 1967).
The swelling of the astrocytic compartment, and removal of the extracellular space in response to chemical fixation, has important consequences for the interpretation of the ultrastructure. The perisynaptic region in chemically fixed tissue shows smaller spaces within which neurotransmitters can diffuse (Van Harreveld et al., 1965; Ohno et al., 2007) (Figure 1), with smaller distances between the edge of the synapse and surrounding elements. This region has variously been described at dendritic spines with a significant presence of astrocytes. In the neocortex, 60–70% of the bouton/spine interfaces are partially or completely surrounded with an astrocytic process (Genoud et al., 2006). A similar proportion was found in the hippocampus (Harris and Stevens, 1989). The larger perisynaptic space suggested by cryo fixation to exist in vivo would give neurotransmitters a greater opportunity to diffuse more rapidly out of the synaptic cleft, into the enlarged extracellular space where there would be a greater dilution, possibly leading to a slowing of their diffusion. The enlarged perisynaptic space could effectively act as a buffer zone, reducing extrasynaptic neurotransmitter concentrations, which could help isolate synapses, reducing the possibility that their activity would influence other extrasynaptic receptors, and minimising synaptic crosstalk. However, careful computational simulations (Rusakov and Kullmann, 1998; Hrabe et al., 2004) taking into account spatiotemporal dynamics, tortuosity, and binding/unbinding of neurotransmitters to various proteins (for example, glutamate transporters largely located on astrocytic membranes) are essential to gain a more detailed understanding of neurotransmitter diffusion, and how this would be affected by the differences in ultrastructure we found after cryo fixation compared to standard chemically fixed tissue. The reduced synaptic density in the cryo-fixed tissue also places them further from each other, adding to their anatomical isolation. Cryo fixation therefore appears to suggest a reduction in the influence of volume transmission revealing an ultrastructure that might favour wiring transmission (Kullmann, 2000).
A more direct access through an enlarged extracellular space was apparent at the blood capillaries, another site where astrocytic processes have a significant presence. Here, their endfeet completely enclose blood capillaries after chemical fixation (Mathiisen et al., 2010) but cryo fixation reveals a partial coverage of about two thirds (Figure 5). The abluminal surface of the endothelial cell, therefore, is less insulated from the neuronal elements suggesting that solutes passing through the capillary wall from the blood have more direct access to the neurons. Conversely, substances released from neurons have greater access to blood vessels, where they might contribute to controlling blood flow (Attwell et al., 2010).
Other changes in the ultrastructure were seen at the synaptic connections. The classical morphology of inhibitory and excitatory synapses: their differences in symmetry and vesicle shapes that have proved useful for classifying types of connections in electron microscopy studies were not apparent in the cryo-fixed tissue. The flattened appearance of synaptic vesicles in GABAergic boutons therefore appears to be induced by the chemical fixation process.
Previous studies have shown that delaying chemical fixation by a few minutes alters synaptic structure. Asymmetric and symmetric contacts showed greater curvature and thicker postsynaptic densities (Martone et al., 1999; Kovalenko et al., 2006; Tao-Cheng et al., 2007). Pre-synaptically, vesicles were located further from the active zone. Images of the frog neuromuscular junction showed that chemical fixation, unlike freezing, could not prevent the fusion of vesicles to the presynaptic membrane (Heuser et al., 1976). More recently, the use of high-pressure freezing, simultaneous to synapse stimulation, has revealed how the vesicles fuse and collapse into the pre-synaptic membrane within 30 ms of stimulation (Watanabe et al., 2013). Analyses of vesicle arrangement in cryo-fixed CNS synapses in cultured slices (Zhao et al., 2012) or synaptosome preparations (Fernández-Busnadiego et al., 2010) have revealed a high concentration of vesicles clustered at the pre-synaptic membrane with the lowest concentration immediately behind this zone, 50–70 nm further back. However, after stimulation, the lowest concentration is seen at the pre-synaptic membrane steadily increasing further away (Fernández-Busnadiego et al., 2010). A similar picture is seen in our comparison between chemical and cryo-fixed cortical synapses (Figure 3). After cryo fixation, the greatest density of synaptic vesicles is at the pre-synaptic membrane, but after chemical fixation the vesicle density increases away from the pre-synaptic membrane suggesting that chemical fixation is unsuitable for capturing all docked vesicles.
Cryo fixation is able to reveal two groups of synaptic vesicles: one close to the synaptic membrane, and the other further back, approximately a vesicle width away. This peak in vesicle density close to the presynaptic release site has also been seen at the calyx of Held synapse (Han et al., 2011). Whether this heterogenous distribution represents different functional pools is unproven. However, a functional analysis of calyx synapses showed that disruption to the pre-synaptic protein machinery results in less vesicular release, together with a concomitant reduction in the number of vesicles seen close to the presynaptic membrane (Han et al., 2011). This would support the idea that vesicles against the presynaptic membrane are docked and associated with their release machinery (Harlow et al., 2001) where they can be depleted within a few milliseconds (Felmy et al., 2003). This arrangement of vesicles with cryo fixation could be revealing the readily releasable pool; those aligned tightly along the membrane. And the second grouping, further back from those in a docked position may, therefore, be those of the recycling and reserve pool, immobilized and clustered together within the body of the bouton by proteins such as actin or synapsin (Hilfiker et al., 1999; Siksou et al., 2007).
Cryo fixation, therefore, can provide a view of tissue ultrastructure that is closer to its natural state. This increases the relevance of morphological analyses by revealing an arrangement of cell membranes that more closely matches functional measurements. However, although these analyses highlight how the exquisite organization of the brain's cellular elements is acutely sensitive to chemical fixation, there are difficulties in cryo preserving large volumes of brain tissue. The high water content of the CNS appears to limit the depth to which vitrification can occur (less than 10–20 microns in our hands at least) before ice crystal formation causes significant damage to the structure. Large-scale preservation for ultrastructural analysis will therefore continue to rely on chemical fixation approaches.
Adult mice (C57 BL/6, 7–10 weeks old) were decapitated, and the brain immediately removed. This was then immersed in ice-cold artificial cerebrospinal fluid (ACSF) composed of (in mM): 125 NaCl, 25 NaHCO3, 1.25 NaH2PO4, 2.5 KCl, 0.1 CaCl2, 3 MgCl2, 25 glucose, 3 myo-inositol, 2 Na-pyruvate, 0.4 ascorbic acid, pH 7.4 which was bubbled with 95% O2 and 5% CO2. Slices were made with a vibratome (Leica Microsystems VT1200) at 150 microns thickness in the coronal or tangential plane. After cutting, each slice was then transferred immediately to a Petri dish containing the same medium and photographed with a stereo microscope (Leica Microsystems M205C).
For cryo fixation, immediately after decapitation, the brain was exposed using blunt surgical tweezers, and a piece of the somatosensory cortex cut from the brain using a razor blade. The tissue was then further sliced, and pieces, approximately 200-µm thick, were placed inside a 6 mm diameter aluminium sample holder with a 200-µm deep cavity. To ensure that no air bubbles became trapped inside the sample holder with the tissue, a small drop of 1-hexadecene was added. This was then high-pressure frozen using a Leica EM HPM100 (Leica Microsystems). This entire procedure was completed as rapidly as possible, in less than 90 s from the moment of decapitation. The frozen samples were then stored in liquid nitrogen until further processing.
The animals were deeply anesthetized with pentobarbitone (0.05 mg g−1) and perfused via the heart, using a perfusion pump, at a speed of 7 ml/min with 2.5% glutaradehyde, and 2% paraformaldehyde, in phosphate buffer (0.1 M, pH 7.4, 250–300 ml per animal). The tubing used for perfusion was back filled initially with 5 ml of 0.1 M PBS (pH 7.4) to help remove all blood from the circulatory system before the fixative entered. After perfusion, the animal was left for 1 hr and the brain was removed. 70-µm thick slices were vibratome sectioned in PBS (0.01 M, pH 7.4). These slices were then stained and embedded using previously described methods (Knott et al., 2011). Briefly, the slices were washed in cacodylate buffer (0.1 M, pH 7.4, 3 × 5 min), post fixed in 1% osmium tetroxide and 1.5% potassium ferrocyanide in cacodylate buffer (0.1 M, pH 7.4, 40 min). They were then stained with 1% osmium tetroxide in cacodylate buffer (0.1 M, pH 7.4) for 40 min, and then in 1% uranyl acetate for 40 min before being dehydrated in a graded alcohol series, 3 min each change, and embedded in Durcupan resin.
Frozen tissue was stained, dehydrated, and embedded at low temperature using a low temperature-embedding device (AFS2; Leica Microsystems). Frozen samples were transferred to this device in liquid nitrogen and were then initially exposed to 0.1% tannic acid in acetone, for 24 hr at −90°C, followed by 12 hr in 2% osmium tetroxide in acetone at −90°C. The temperature was then raised over 4 days to −30°C, and then the liquid replaced with pure acetone and the temperature increased to −10°C over 16 hr. Finally, the tissue samples were mixed with increasing concentrations of resin over 8 hr whilst the temperature rose to 20°C. They were then added to 100% resin for 2 hr and then placed in silicon moulds for 24 hr at 65°C for the resin to harden.
Cryo-fixed tissue that showed no artifacts of fixation, such as ice crystal damage, was selected by cutting semi-thin (0.5 mm thick) sections (2 × 2 mm) of the resin-embedded material and staining these with toluidine blue. With transmitted light microscopy, an area of well-fixed tissue could be identified and these regions were further trimmed and either used for TEM or FIBSEM.
Ribbons of serial sections (50–100 sections) were mounted onto single slot copper grids holding a polymer (pioloform) support film. Serial images were collected using a Tecnai Spirit (FEI Company) 120 kV transmission electron microscope operating at 80 kV, with an Eagle 4k × 4k CCD camera. Electron tomography imaging was performed on single, 200 nm thick sections using a Tecnai F20 (FEI Company) transmission electron microscope.
Some of the material was imaged with FIBSEM (Zeiss NVision40) using the same preparation and imaging technique as described previously (Knott et al., 2011). Briefly, the trimmed blocks were mounted with conductive paint to aluminium stubs and gold coated (Cressington). This was then placed inside the microscope, and after ion milling to expose the required region, an imaging electron beam of 1.6 kV was used with a milling beam of 30 kV and 800 pA. Each milling and imaging cycle took approximately 90 s, with a pixel dwell time for the electron beam of 10 microseconds. Six hundred to a thousand images were collected by sequentially milling and imaging, with final image sizes of 2048 by 1536 pixels. Each pixel was 5 by 5 nm.
All quantitative analysis of the serial images was carried out using the FIJI software (http://pacific.mpi-cbg.de/wiki/index.php/Fiji). Image alignments were performed using the stackreg plug-in.
Synapse density measurements were carried out using serial images through volumes of neuropil, containing no cell bodies or blood vessels. The images were displayed in the TrakEM2 software within FIJI (Cardona et al., 2012) and counted when they were completely contained within the displayed volume or were touching the left, top, and upper sides of the counting frame. Those touching the right, bottom, and lower sides were excluded. The section thickness was measured by using the mitochondria as cylindrical objects, and counting over how many sections they were present when lying parallel to the imaging plane (Fiala and Harris, 2001).
Measurements of volumes occupied by the different compartments were made by manually segmenting each of the different elements in the serial images using the TrakEM2 software. Area lists were made of the different compartments; neurites (axons and dendrites), astrocytes, and extracellular space, and drawn in each of the serial images. Distance measurements of cortical shrinkage, glial coverage of blood vessels, synapse and vesicle sizes, and vesicle and membrane separations were made using the same software.
Models of cellular elements shown in Figure 3 were made using the interactive segmentation tool in the ilastik software (www.ilastik.org) from serial FIBSEM images (Straehle et al., 2011). These models were then imported into the 3D modelling software Blender (www.blender.org) for final composition and rendering.
Extracellular space in the central nervous systemAMA Arch Neurol Psychiatry 73:241–248.https://doi.org/10.1001/archneurpsyc.1955.02330080119021
Volume electron microscopy for neuronal circuit reconstructionCurrent Opinion in Neurobiology 22:154–161.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.conb.2011.10.022
The relationship between PSD-95 clustering and spine stability in vivoThe Journal of Neuroscience 34:2075–2086.https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3353-13.2014
Quantitative analysis of the native presynaptic cytomatrix by cryoelectron tomographyThe Journal of Cell Biology 188:145–156.https://doi.org/10.1083/jcb.200908082
Axo-somatic and axo-dendritic synapses of the cerebral cortex: an electron microscope studyJournal of Anatomy 93:420–433.
Dendritic spines of CA 1 pyramidal cells in the rat hippocampus: serial electron microscopy with reference to their biophysical characteristicsThe Journal of Neuroscience 9:2982–2997.
Preservation of synaptic structure by rapid freezingCold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology 40:17–24.https://doi.org/10.1101/SQB.1976.040.01.004
Synapsins as regulators of neurotransmitter releasePhilosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences 354:269–279.https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.1999.0378
A model of effective diffusion and tortuosity in the extracellular space of the brainBiophysical Journal 87:1606–1617.https://doi.org/10.1529/biophysj.103.039495
The role of the blood-brain barrier in perfusion fixation of the brain for electron microscopyThe Histochemical Journal 8:1–12.https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01004000
Fixation of the central nervous system from the electron microscopy of aldehyde perfusion. I. Preservation with aldehyde perfusates versus direct perfusion with osmium tetroxide with special reference to membranes and the extracellular spaceJournal of Ultrastructure Research 12:160–186.https://doi.org/10.1016/S0022-5320(65)80014-4
Extracellular sheets and tunnels modulate glutamate diffusion in hippocampal neuropilThe Journal of Comparative Neurology 521:448–464.https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.23181
Spine growth precedes synapse formation in the adult neocortex in vivoNature Neuroscience 9:1117–1124.https://doi.org/10.1038/nn1747
Focussed ion beam milling and scanning electron microscopy of brain tissueJournal of Visualized Experiments e2588.https://doi.org/10.3791/2588
Potassium buffering in the central nervous systemNeuroscience 129:1045–1056.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroscience.2004.06.008
Spillover and synaptic cross talk mediated by glutamate and GABA in the mammalian brainProgress in Brain Research 125:339–351.https://doi.org/10.1016/S0079-6123(00)25023-1
Mechanisms for anoxic survival in the vertebrate brainAnnual Review of Physiology 54:601–618.https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.ph.54.030192.003125
Modification of postsynaptic densities after transient cerebral ischemia: a quantitative and three-dimensional ultrastructural studyThe Journal of Neuroscience 19:1988–1997.
Staining and embedding the whole mouse brain for electron microscopyNature Methods 9:1198–1201.https://doi.org/10.1038/nmeth.2213
A laminar analysis of the number of neurons, glia, and synapses in the adult cortex (area 17) of adult macaque monkeysThe Journal of Comparative Neurology 210:278–290.https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.902100307
Extracellular space in mouse cerebellar cortex revealed by in vivo cryotechniqueThe Journal of Comparative Neurology 505:292–301.https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.21498
Extrasynaptic glutamate diffusion in the hippocampus: ultrastructural constraints, uptake, and receptor activationThe Journal of Neuroscience 18:3158–3170.
Electron microscopy of neurons and neuroglia of cerebral cortex and corpus callosumThe American Journal of Anatomy 100:369–407.https://doi.org/10.1002/aja.1001000305
Density of neurons and synapses in the cerebral cortex of the mouseThe Journal of Comparative Neurology 286:442–455.https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.902860404
Three-dimensional architecture of presynaptic terminal cytomatrixThe Journal of Neuroscience 27:6868–6877.https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1773-07.2007
Carving: scalable interactive segmentation of neural volume electron microscopy imagesMedical Image Computing and Computer-assisted Intervention 14:653–660.
Structural changes at synapses after delayed perfusion fixation in different regions of the mouse brainThe Journal of Comparative Neurology 501:731–740.https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.21276
In vivo diffusion analysis with quantum dots and dextrans predicts the width of brain extracellular spaceProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of USA 103:5567–5572.https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0509425103
A study of extracellular space in central nervous tissue by freeze substitutionThe Journal of Cell Biology 25:117–137.https://doi.org/10.1083/jcb.25.1.117
Extracellular space in the cerebral cortex of the mouseJournal of Anatomy 101:197–207.
Three-dimensional relationships between hippocampal synapses and astrocytesThe Journal of Neuroscience 19:6897–6906.
Structural plasticity of hippocampal mossy fiber synapses as revealed by high-pressure freezingThe Journal of Comparative Neurology 520:2340–2351.https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.23040
Michael HäusserReviewing Editor; University College London, United Kingdom
eLife posts the editorial decision letter and author response on a selection of the published articles (subject to the approval of the authors). An edited version of the letter sent to the authors after peer review is shown, indicating the substantive concerns or comments; minor concerns are not usually shown. Reviewers have the opportunity to discuss the decision before the letter is sent (see review process). Similarly, the author response typically shows only responses to the major concerns raised by the reviewers.
Thank you for sending your work entitled "Native ultrastructure of the mammalian neocortex revealed by cryo fixation" for consideration at eLife. Your article has been favorably evaluated by a Senior editor, a Reviewing editor, and two reviewers.
The following individuals responsible for the peer review of your submission have agreed to reveal their identity: Michael Häusser (Reviewing editor) and Tom Bartol (peer reviewer). A further reviewer remains anonymous.
The Reviewing editor and the reviewers discussed their comments before we reached this decision, and the Reviewing editor has assembled the following comments to help you prepare a revised submission.
The reviewers agreed that this study nicely highlights the changes that can occur when nervous tissue is chemically fixed by transcardial fixation. As an alternative, to circumvent tissue shrinkage and the potential redistribution of the extracellular space and cellular processes or synaptic vesicles, the authors used high-pressure freezing of the tissue. This method is advantageous since no aldehydes are applied that cause tissue shrinkage but is disadvantageous with respect to the study of larger tissue samples. Only small tissue blocks, such as brain slices, can be subjected to high-pressure freezing. When comparing cryofixed tissue with chemically fixed tissue the authors did indeed find considerable differences.
This is an important and timely analysis as new large-scale, high-throughput methods for 3D reconstructions of neuropil are becoming available. While the problem addressed in this manuscript has been a focus of discussion in the field for many years, the authors have managed to shed significant new light on this issue. Overall the manuscript is clearly written and the analysis and figures present the case very well. However, there was one major concern, described in detail below, which will require a comparison of aldehyde-fixed brain slices and high-pressure frozen slices.
The authors compared tissue fixed by transcardial perfusion of aldehyde solution with fresh tissue that was taken out of the brain and sectioned prior to high-pressure freezing. Although there is rapid sealing of cell membranes, previous light and EM studies have shown that there is swelling of the tissue following slice preparation. This is not surprising since thousands of dendritic and axonal processes were transected and damaged during slice preparation. In contrast, perfusion fixation leaves all elements in place and there is no transection of unfixed cellular processes. How can the authors exclude that the changes they observed did not derive – at least in part – from the damage to fresh tissue during slice preparation? I wonder why the authors did not compare brain slices that were chemically fixed after slice preparation with those that were subjected to high-pressure freezing. There is in fact evidence from recent literature that the extracellular space is enlarged in acute hippocampal slices subjected to high-pressure freezing when compared to high-pressure frozen slice cultures. In contrast to acute slices, there is reorganization of the tissue and removal of debris in slice cultures incubated for several days or even weeks (Studer et al., 2014) Capture of activity-induced ultrastructural changes at synapses by high-pressure freezing of brain tissue. Nature Protoc 9:1480-1495). In conclusion, the authors should strengthen their study by comparing acute brain slices that were chemically fixed after slice preparation with acute slices subjected to high-pressure freezing.https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05793.017
The authors compared tissue fixed by transcardial perfusion of aldehyde solution with fresh tissue that was taken out of the brain and sectioned prior to high-pressure freezing. Although there is rapid sealing of cell membranes, previous light and EM studies have shown that there is swelling of the tissue following slice preparation. This is not surprising since thousands of dendritic and axonal processes were transected and damaged during slice preparation. In contrast, perfusion fixation leaves all elements in place and there is no transection of unfixed cellular processes. How can the authors exclude that the changes they observed did not derive – at least in part – from the damage to fresh tissue during slice preparation? I wonder why the authors did not compare brain slices that were chemically fixed after slice preparation with those that were subjected to high-pressure freezing. There is in fact evidence from recent literature that the extracellular space is enlarged in acute hippocampal slices subjected to high-pressure freezing when compared to high-pressure frozen slice cultures. In contrast to acute slices, there is reorganization of the tissue and removal of debris in slice cultures incubated for several days or even weeks (Studer et al., 2014) Capture of activity-induced ultrastructural changes at synapses by high-pressure freezing of brain tissue. Nature Protoc 9:1480-1495). In conclusion, the authors should strengthen their study by comparing acute brain slices that were chemically fixed after slice preparation with acute slices subjected to high-pressure freezing.
The reviewers are correct to point out that we do not know how closely the cryo fixed tissue resembles the native brain structure. We have therefore changed the Title of the manuscript and the text.
However, we think there is good reason to think that cryo fixation reveals ultrastructure that more closely resembles native brain structure because:
1) Cryo fixed brain tissue shows an extracellular space similar to that measured in vivo.
2) Cryo fixed brain tissue shows synaptic vesicles clustered near the presynaptic membrane.
Across the biological samples where it has been applied, there is general agreement that cryo fixation preserves ultrastructure in a near-physiological state, and we think the same is likely to be true under our experimental conditions investigating mouse neocortex.
The reviewers suggests that there might be ”swelling of the tissue following slice preparation”. Our measurements of cryo fixed tissue do not indicate swelling after cryo fixation, but rather suggest that astrocytes swell during chemical fixation. We would like to point out that we did not use the normal protocol for preparing acute slices, as detailed in Studer et al. (2014), and in being able to measure the same amount of extracellular space (ECS) as physiological studies, we think it is likely that our rapid extraction method, prior to freezing, was fast enough to limit the possible changes.
The reviewers suggest that we examine differences in chemical versus cryo fixation of acute brain slices, prepared in the same way as for electrophysiological experiments. This would check whether the changes we are seeing are not due to the influence of the different fixation methods themselves rather than the physiological state of the tissue.
We have carried out these experiments using the standard approach for slice preparations, as described by Studer et al., although we used 6 week old animals, and not ‘pups’ (Studer et al., 2014).
These slices were either dropped into chemical fixative or cryo fixed, after they had first been allowed to recover in medium for 40 min at 30°C. This warming is common practice in the preparation of acute slices ready for electrophysiology experiments. Electron microscopy shows that irrespective the fixation method, both preparations show large amounts of ECS (see Figure 1–figure supplement 2A, B, C and D). Therefore, this would suggest that the removal of ECS that we see in the perfusion fixed material is not due to the fixation method itself, but rather its physiological state. If we chemically fix a slice prior to the recovery period, immediately after vibratome slicing (Author response image 1; after step 19, Studer et al., 2014) the morphology is very similar to what we find after the perfusion fixation with a reduced extracellular space. It is also the same when cryo fixation is performed 5 min after the heart has stopped, and the same as described by Van Harreveld and Khattab (1967) after spreading depression.
The amount of ECS that we see in these acute ‘recovered’ slices appears to be far greater than ever seen in freshly extracted tissue. This observation though comes from only looking within the first 10 microns of the cryo fixed tissue (Figure 1–figure supplement 2B). We were not able to find well-preserved tissue deeper into the slice without considerable ice crystal damage (Figure 1–figure supplement 2D). We think that this is because of the excessive amounts of watery solution that surrounds the cellular elements making the tissue difficult to vitrify to any significant depth.
As for carrying out a detailed morphological analysis of acute slices that have either been chemical or cryo fixed. It is clear that we are not able to preserve slices to any significant depth with cryo fixation. We must also recognise that these slices are bathed in an artificial CSF that does not exactly replicate in vivo conditions. Therefore, our analysis would only show the fixation differences within a severely disrupted region of brain tissue in an artificial environment.
The tests we show here (Figure 1–figure supplement 2A, B, C and D) suggest that chemical or cryo fixation can reveal similar morphologies, but they also show that the levels of ECS can be influenced by the medium in which they are placed. Here, we find a level that appears to be excessively high.
The goal of our study was to compare the widely recognised standard fixation approach for brain tissue; namely chemical fixation via cardiac perfusion, with a rapid cryo fixation method of the fresh tissue. Our reasoning was that all large scale connectomics analyses of mammalian central nervous systems use chemical fixation, but to date there is little consideration for the natural state of the ultrastructure. We would like to draw the attention of the reviewers also to the recent paper by Mikula and Denk (Nature Methods, 2015), that illustrates why perfusion fixation of the brain is an important process for preserving the neural circuits of connectomics. It is therefore important to understand what changes occur to brain ultrastructure during chemical perfusion fixation, and we think our study makes important advances towards this goal.https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05793.018
- Carl CH Petersen
- Carl CH Petersen
- Carl CH Petersen
The funders had no role in study design, data collection and interpretation, or the decision to submit the work for publication.
We thank Thorben Kroeger, Christoph Straehle, and Fred Hamprecht for help with using Ilastik software; Marco Cantoni and Davide Demurtas at the Centre of Electron Microscopy, EPFL, for help with FIBSEM imaging, and electron tomography. This work was funded by grants from EPFL-Stoicescu program (NK, CCHP, GK); Swiss National Science Foundation, SNSF (CCHP); Human Frontier Science Program, HFSP (CCHP); and European Research Council Advanced Grant, ERC (CCHP).
Animal experimentation: All experiments were carried out in accordance with protocols approved by the Swiss Federal Veterinary Office (Canton of Vaud authorisation 1889.2).
- Michael Häusser, University College London, United Kingdom
- Received: November 27, 2014
- Accepted: July 3, 2015
- Version of Record published: August 11, 2015 (version 1)
© 2015, Korogod et al.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.
Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)
Download citations (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)
Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)
Somatic expansion of the Huntington’s disease (HD) CAG repeat drives the rate of a pathogenic process ultimately resulting in neuronal cell death. Although mechanisms of toxicity are poorly delineated, transcriptional dysregulation is a likely contributor. To identify modifiers that act at the level of CAG expansion and/or downstream pathogenic processes, we tested the impact of genetic knockout, in HttQ111 mice, of Hdac2 or Hdac3 in medium-spiny striatal neurons that exhibit extensive CAG expansion and exquisite disease vulnerability. Both knockouts moderately attenuated CAG expansion, with Hdac2 knockout decreasing nuclear huntingtin pathology. Hdac2 knockout resulted in a substantial transcriptional response that included modification of transcriptional dysregulation elicited by the HttQ111 allele, likely via mechanisms unrelated to instability suppression. Our results identify novel modifiers of different aspects of HD pathogenesis in medium-spiny neurons and highlight a complex relationship between the expanded Htt allele and Hdac2 with implications for targeting transcriptional dysregulation in HD.
Mechanistic modeling in neuroscience aims to explain observed phenomena in terms of underlying causes. However, determining which model parameters agree with complex and stochastic neural data presents a significant challenge. We address this challenge with a machine learning tool which uses deep neural density estimators—trained using model simulations—to carry out Bayesian inference and retrieve the full space of parameters compatible with raw data or selected data features. Our method is scalable in parameters and data features and can rapidly analyze new data after initial training. We demonstrate the power and flexibility of our approach on receptive fields, ion channels, and Hodgkin–Huxley models. We also characterize the space of circuit configurations giving rise to rhythmic activity in the crustacean stomatogastric ganglion, and use these results to derive hypotheses for underlying compensation mechanisms. Our approach will help close the gap between data-driven and theory-driven models of neural dynamics.