Neural systems use homeostatic plasticity to maintain normal brain functions and to prevent abnormal activity. Surprisingly, homeostatic mechanisms that regulate circuit output have mainly been demonstrated during artificial and/or pathological perturbations. Natural, physiological scenarios that activate these stabilizing mechanisms in neural networks of mature animals remain elusive. To establish the extent to which a naturally inactive circuit engages mechanisms of homeostatic plasticity, we utilized the respiratory motor circuit in bullfrogs that normally remains inactive for several months during the winter. We found that inactive respiratory motoneurons exhibit a classic form of homeostatic plasticity, up-scaling of AMPA-glutamate receptors. Up-scaling increased the synaptic strength of respiratory motoneurons and acted to boost motor amplitude from the respiratory network following months of inactivity. Our results show that synaptic scaling sustains strength of the respiratory motor output following months of inactivity, thereby supporting a major neuroscience hypothesis in a normal context for an adult animal.https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.30005.001
Neurons in the brain communicate using chemical signals that they send and receive across junctions called synapses. To maintain normal behavior over time, circuits of neurons must reliably process these signals. A variety of nervous system disorders may result if they are unable to do so, as may occur when neural activity changes as a result of disease or injury.
The processes underlying the stability of a neuron’s synapses is referred to as “homeostatic” synaptic plasticity because the changes made by the neuron directly oppose the altered level of activity. In one form of homeostatic plasticity, known as synaptic scaling, neurons modify the strength of all of their synapses in response to changes in neural activity.
There is substantial experimental evidence to show that in young animals, neurons that communicate using a chemical called glutamate undergo synaptic scaling in response to artificial changes in activity. It had not been directly shown that synaptic scaling protects the neural activity of adult animals in their natural environments, in part, because neural activity in most healthy animals generally only goes through small changes. However, the neurons in the brain that cause the breathing muscles of bullfrogs to contract are ideal for studying homeostatic plasticity because they are naturally inactive for several months when frogs hibernate in ponds during the winter. During this time, the bullfrogs do not need to use their lungs to breathe because enough oxygen passes through their skin to keep them alive.
Santin et al. have now observed synaptic scaling of glutamate synapses in individual bullfrog neurons that had been inactive for two months. Further experiments that examined the activity of the breathing control circuit in the brainstem provided evidence that synaptic scaling leads to sufficient amounts of neural activity that would activate the breathing muscles when frogs emerge from hibernation. Therefore neural activity after prolonged, natural inactivity relies on synaptic scaling to preserve life-sustaining behavior in frogs.
These results open up new questions: mainly, how do synaptic scaling and other forms of homeostatic plasticity operate in animals as they experience normal variations in neural activity? Determining how homeostatic plasticity works normally in an animal will help us to understand what happens when plasticity mechanisms go wrong, as is thought to occur in several human nervous system diseases including nervous system injury, Alzheimer’s disease, and epilepsy.https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.30005.002
For the brain to work properly, neurons must employ compensatory mechanisms to retain information in synapses and to maintain normal circuit function. These compensatory mechanisms are considered homeostatic if they regulate firing frequency and/or circuit activity around a set-point, but they also may oppose disturbances to neuronal function without being firmly homeostatic (Turrigiano, 2012). Homeostatic and compensatory plasticity maintains neuronal function through a suite of synaptic and intrinsic mechanisms (Pozo and Goda, 2010; Schulz and Lane, 2017; Turrigiano, 2011), with the ultimate goal being preservation of normal network function. The most prominent mechanisms used to counter disturbances in neuronal activity include synaptic scaling, a slow and global form of synaptic plasticity where excitatory synaptic strength increases or decreases equally across all synapses (Turrigiano et al., 1998), modulation of presynaptic neurotransmitter release (Davis, 2013), and altering voltage-gated membrane conductances (e.g. Na+, K+, and Ca2+ channels) (Desai et al., 1999; Ransdell et al., 2012; Wilhelm et al., 2009).
Manipulations that perturb neuronal activity in vitro are, by far, the most common experimental approaches to evoke homeostatic plasticity (Williams et al., 2013), leaving many open questions as to what normal scenarios require homeostatic mechanisms to regulate circuit output and behavior. Only few physiological examples exist. In developing rodents, neurons in the visual cortex undergo synaptic scaling at the onset of visual experience (Desai et al., 2002). Also within the visual system, neurons in the retinotectal circuit of the aquatic frog, Xenopus laveis, homeostatically decrease their intrinsic excitability to compensate for developmental increases in excitatory synaptic inputs (Pratt and Aizenman, 2007). Additionally, plasticity in the dynamic regulation of synaptic strength seems to compensate for variability in neuron number in the crustacean stomatogastric ganglion (Daur et al., 2012). However, rather than uncovering responses to normal, expected physiological challenges, most investigations of homeostatic plasticity dramatically perturb neuronal activity with artificial (e.g. pharmacological and genetic manipulations) or pathological (e.g. sensory denervation/stimulation, injury) modalities. While these synthetic challenges evoke striking compensatory or homeostatic responses in neurons in vivo (Aizenman et al., 2003; Braegelmann et al., 2017; Echegoyen et al., 2007; Frank, 2014; Gonzalez-Islas and Wenner, 2006; Hengen et al., 2013; Kline et al., 2007; Knogler et al., 2010; Lambo and Turrigiano, 2013; Rajman et al., 2017), how stabilizing mechanisms activated by these kinds of disturbances relate to non-pathological physiological scenarios is unclear, especially in mature animals. Animals with life histories involving profound disturbances to neuronal activity may provide new insights into the physiological necessity of such mechanisms underlying stability of neurons in functional circuits.
Here, we take advantage of an adult animal (American bullfrogs, Lithobates catesbeianus) that normally undergoes drastic and prolonged reductions in neuronal activity to understand if compensatory mechanisms commonly evoked during artificial deprivation of neuronal firing occur in an environmentally relevant setting. We demonstrate that a well-described mechanism of homeostatic plasticity, up-scaling of excitatory synapses, occurs in motoneurons innervating a primary respiratory muscle from bullfrogs after 2 months in a submerged-aquatic, overwintering habitat: a natural environment that induces complete respiratory motor inactivity (Santin and Hartzler, 2017). Strikingly, we further identify that increased excitatory synaptic strength onto these motoneurons enhances population motoneuron output from the respiratory network, thereby acting to preserve respiratory motor drive to critical respiratory muscles under conditions when breathing would be obligatory at warm temperatures after 2 months without breathing movements (Santin and Hartzler, 2016a). As failure to stabilize motor output from the brainstem to respiratory muscles has fatal consequences, these results implicate up-scaling of excitatory synapses on respiratory motoneurons as a critical mechanism for an adult vertebrate experiencing prolonged bouts of neural inactivity in a natural context.
American bullfrogs often overwinter in ice-covered ponds with no need to use their lungs for breathing during cold winter months due to adequate skin gas exchange at low temperatures (Tattersall and Ultsch, 2008). Although frogs retain a relatively high locomotor capacity during overwintering submergence (Tattersall and Boutilier, 1999), important muscles of the respiratory apparatus, buccal floor constrictors and glottal dilators, are inactive during cold-submergence (Santin and Hartzler, 2017). Despite months of respiratory motor inactivity, upon forced emergence at warm temperature bullfrogs immediately exhibit breathing movements, ventilate to match resting metabolic demands, increase ventilation during exposure to low oxygen, and generate respiratory motor output from the brainstem (Santin and Hartzler, 2016a; Santin and Hartzler, 2016b). Largely normal ventilatory behaviors after months of motor inactivity led us to hypothesize that preservation of respiratory motoneuron output from the brainstem to breathing muscles may rely on slow acting, global mechanisms that compensate for neuronal inactivity (i.e. homeostatic plasticity). To test this hypothesis, we backfilled vagal motoneurons that innervate a primary respiratory muscle, the glottal dilator involved in regulating airflow into and out of the lung in frogs (Gans et al., 1969), with fluorescent dye (Figure 1). We then measured synaptic and intrinsic neuronal properties from fluorescently labeled respiratory motoneurons in brainstem slices at 23°C (a temperature requiring lung breathing) in control bullfrogs and those that experienced ~2 months of respiratory motor inactivity during overwintering-like conditions. This allowed us to determine the extent to which winter inactivity leads to expression of compensatory mechanisms in respiratory motoneurons.
Increases in excitatory synaptic transmission occur during inactivity/AMPA-glutamate receptor blockade in vitro (Fong et al., 2015; Turrigiano et al., 1998) and in vivo (Hengen et al., 2013; Knogler et al., 2010). Therefore, we first sought to determine whether winter inactivity results in a compensatory increase in excitatory synaptic transmission by assessing the quantal amplitude (i.e. the postsynaptic response to spontaneous release of neurotransmitter single vesicles recorded in voltage clamp, termed miniature excitatory post synaptic currents [mEPSCs]). Consistent with this hypothesis, the amplitude and charge transfer of mEPSCs mediated by AMPA-glutamate receptors were increased in respiratory motoneurons after overwintering inactivity (Figure 2A–D). In contrast, we did not observe changes in mEPSC frequency (Figure 2E), suggesting a similar number of glutamate release sites onto respiratory motoneurons in brainstem slices. Although the mEPSC amplitude is prone to dendritic filtering, charge transfer (i.e. mEPSC area) is more robust against space clamp errors (Spruston et al., 1993). Thus, increases in both amplitude and charge transfer of the mEPSC suggest an enhancement of post-synaptic AMPA receptor function rather than changes in dendritic filtering properties of motoneurons (Han and Stevens, 2009). Consistent with this assertion, parameters influencing and influenced by dendritic filtering, neuronal input resistance and mEPSC rise time, respectively, did not differ between control and winter inactivity motoneurons (Figure 2F–G). These results indicate that respiratory motoneurons have enhanced excitatory synaptic strength after winter inactivity presumably by up-regulating postsynaptic function of AMPA-glutamate receptors.
Increased excitatory synaptic strength of neurons responding to reductions in activity typically follows a multiplicative scaling relationship in dissociated culture (Fong et al., 2015; Turrigiano et al., 1998) and in vivo (Knogler et al., 2010; Lambo and Turrigiano, 2013), implying that all measurable synapses increase in strength relatively by the same extent. Thus, synaptic scaling maintains relative synaptic strength in the face of disturbances in neuronal activity. This is observed experimentally as a right-shift in the cumulative distribution of mEPSC amplitudes induced by inactivity that can be down-scaled mathematically by dividing the entire distribution of mEPSCs by a common scaling factor. The scaling factor is derived from the slope of a linear rank order plot of mEPSC amplitudes from control and activity-deprived distributions. In contrast to synaptic scaling, a rank order plot following long-term potentiation (LTP) - a rapid and synapse-specific form of synaptic plasticity- is better approximated by an exponential curve (Gainey et al., 2009). Do increases in the mEPSC amplitude scale multiplicatively following winter inactivity, an ecologically relevant, long-term perturbation of neuronal activity?
When rank ordering an equal number of mEPSC amplitudes from control and winter inactivity vagal respiratory motoneurons (black dots; 50 mEPSCs from 16 neurons in each group), the plot is well-fit by a linear regression (r2 = 0.99; Figure 3A; dashed blue line), rather than an exponential curve (r2 = 0.73; Figure 3A; dashed black line). If the slope of this line is greater than 1 (i.e., the unity line; Figure 3A; solid gray line), it suggests multiplicative scaling has occurred. We detected a slope of 1.51. The slope of the line from the regression is equal to the scaling factor, implying that all measurable excitatory synapses increased by a factor of 1.51 during winter inactivity. Indeed, when the right-shifted cumulative distribution of mEPSC amplitudes from winter inactivity motoneurons (Figure 3B; solid blue line; Kolmogorov-Smirnov test control vs. winter inactivity; p=2.2×10−16) is divided by the scaling factor, the ‘down-scaled’ winter inactivity distribution (Figure 3B; dashed blue line) overlaps the control mEPSC amplitude distribution (Figure 3B; solid green line; Kolmogorov-Smirnov test control vs. scale winter inactivity; p=0.1403). Therefore, excitatory synapses on inactive respiratory motoneurons ‘scale up’ during winter inactivity.
In addition to synaptic scaling, reduced activity may influence the function of intrinsic ion channels, including Na+, K+, Ca2+, and non-selective cation channels, to oppose reductions in neuronal and network activity. Compensatory changes in the intrinsic membrane currents carried by ion channels during inactivity typically manifest as enhanced excitability in response to injected current (Desai et al., 1999; Echegoyen et al., 2007; Lambo and Turrigiano, 2013; Wilhelm et al., 2009). Therefore, we evaluated action potential firing in respiratory motoneurons to determine whether intrinsic changes, in addition to synaptic scaling, may be involved in the compensatory response to winter inactivity. To assess intrinsic excitability, we measured firing frequency of respiratory motoneurons in response to step increases in injected current. Figure 4A shows example recordings of responses to current injections from control (green traces; top) and winter inactivity (blue traces; bottom) motoneurons. We did not observe differences in firing frequency at any amount of current (Figure 4B). The frequency-current (F-I) gain did not differ between both groups of motoneurons (Figure 4B–C). Additionally, resting membrane potential did not differ between control and winter inactivity motoneurons (control: −57.62 ± 1.74 mV vs. winter inactivity: −57.13 ± 1.41 mV; p=0.8269; T30 = 0.2206). These results suggest that these motoneurons do not enhance their excitability in response to winter inactivity.
Thus far, our results indicate that up-scaling of AMPA glutamate-receptors increases the synaptic strength of respiratory motoneurons in response to winter inactivity. How may this affect respiratory behavior immediately following overwintering? In bullfrogs and other vertebrate animals, central pattern generating (CPG) networks in the brainstem underlie the neural activity of respiratory movements (Baghdadwala et al., 2015; Feldman et al., 2013). This respiratory CPG activity is transmitted to cranial and spinal motoneurons, in part, via excitatory glutamatergic synapses (Greer et al., 1991; Kottick et al., 2013) to produce the motor output that activates respiratory muscles. We hypothesized that synaptic scaling on respiratory vagal motoneurons receiving respiratory CPG input could increase the reliance of AMPA-receptor transmission of the vagal respiratory motor outflow in bullfrogs after winter inactivity. To test this possibility, we extracellularly recorded respiratory-related vagal motoneuron population discharge from the cut nerve root (i.e. fictive breaths exiting the brainstem via the axons of vagal motoneurons) in rhythmically-active, in vitro brainstem-spinal cord preparations (Figure 5A); a preparation that produces respiratory motor output similar to that observed in intact bullfrogs (Hedrick, 2005). In rhythmic respiratory preparations, synaptic properties of motoneurons (and premotoneurons) can be determined by assessing relative changes in the amplitude of the integrated fictive breath after application of receptor antagonists, while the activity of the rhythm generating circuits can be assessed through the frequency of fictive breaths (for example Greer et al., 1991; Johnson et al., 2002). Using the same in vitro preparation from bullfrogs, Chen and Hedrick (2008) showed that a low concentration of AMPA-receptor antagonist does not influence the amplitude of fictive breaths, while the frequency is more sensitive to inhibition of AMPA-receptors. To test the hypothesis that winter inactivity enhances the reliance of AMPA-receptor transmission on vagal motoneurons and to explore the possibility of altered AMPA-receptors in rhythm generating circuits, we measured the amplitude and frequency of fictive-breaths via vagal motoneurons to assess differences in the sensitivity to an AMPA receptor antagonist, DNQX, between control and winter inactivity bullfrogs. To be consistent with our results demonstrating up-scaling of AMPA receptors at the level of the vagal motoneuron after winter inactivity (Figures 2–3), the amplitude fictive breath carried by vagal motoneurons should be more sensitive to inhibition of AMPA receptors.
First, we analyzed the amplitude of the integrated motoneuron population discharge of the vagus nerve (cranial nerve X; CN X) during lung-related respiratory bursts (Figure 5A) to infer whether or not scaling of AMPA-receptors on vagal motoneurons increased the reliance of AMPA-receptors for transmitting respiratory output. An inherent limitation to measuring the amplitude of the extracellular integrated motoneuron population discharge from the cut nerve root in vitro is that only relative comparisons can be made. This precludes us from comparing absolute fictive breath amplitudes at baseline between control and winter inactivity frogs. Therefore, we rely on relative changes in burst amplitude in response to a low concentration of DNQX that did not silence respiratory bursts (4 μM) to infer differences in the reliance on AMPA-receptors for producing ‘normal,’ baseline respiratory motoneuron population amplitude in each group of frogs. In control bullfrogs, AMPA-receptor inhibition did not change the amplitude and area of the respiratory-related CN X population discharge (Figure 5B,C–D; green traces and bars), corroborating previous results in bullfrogs (Chen and Hedrick, 2008). This was not the case for bullfrogs following winter inactivity. In stark contrast, CN X population output underwent a reduction in amplitude and area during exposure to AMPA-receptor blockade (Figure 5B,C–D, blue traces and bars) and tended to recover toward baseline values following ~1 hr of DNQX washout (Figure 5—figure supplement 1). These results indicate that full transmission of respiratory CPG activity to vagal motoneurons requires an increase in synaptic strength following winter inactivity. With respect to fictive breathing frequency, brainstem-spinal cord preparations from winter inactivity bullfrogs produced an elevated number of respiratory bursts at baseline compared to control bullfrogs (Figure 5B & E2). During exposure of the brainstem-spinal cord preparations to a low concentration of DNQX, both control and winter inactivity bullfrogs decreased fictive-breathing frequency by ~80% (Figure 5 E1), suggesting AMPA receptor-sensitive components of the respiratory rhythm generator did not differ. Collectively, our findings imply that up-scaling of AMPA-glutamate receptors on vagal motoneurons preserves respiratory motor output because, in its absence (i.e., AMPA-receptor inhibition), the amplitude of vagal motoneuron population discharge was approximately 40% less than baseline on average, while respiratory motor amplitude was unaffected by the same concentration of AMPA receptor blocker in control bullfrogs.
The mechanisms underlying how stable neuronal function emanates from inherently unstable components have been of intense interest to neuroscientists for over two decades (Abbott and LeMasson, 1993; Siegel et al., 1994; Turrigiano et al., 1994). There has been an explosion of mechanisms - postsynaptic, presynaptic, cell-autonomous, non-neuronal, etc - generated by in vitro, in vivo, and in silico approaches that paint an immensely complex picture of the genesis and maintenance of stable neuronal function (O'Leary et al., 2014; Schulz and Lane, 2017; Stellwagen and Malenka, 2006; Turrigiano, 2012). A sobering reality is that only a few studies experimentally relate mechanisms of homeostatic plasticity to the stabilization of behaviorally relevant circuit function [e.g. (Gonzalez-Islas and Wenner, 2006; Knogler et al., 2010; Lane et al., 2016). Of such studies, most opt for tractability at the expense of reality by using drastic experimental perturbations that most organisms will never experience. Although these mechanistic studies are critical, it is worth considering how animals experiencing analogous situations utilize those mechanisms for survival in their environments. After all, it is the animal in its natural environmental which natural selection acts upon.
Because respiratory motor output of bullfrogs is silent under submerged-overwinter conditions (Santin and Hartzler, 2017), they provided an ideal platform to test whether mechanisms that stabilize neuronal output over chronic time scales respond to prolonged inactivity experienced normally by an animal. In a sense, this serves as a natural analogue for experiments that dramatically reduce neural activity via pharmacological tools or injury because bullfrogs do not use neural mechanisms of ventilatory control for potentially several months during overwintering submergence. We found that respiratory vagal motoneurons underwent up-scaling of excitatory synapses in response to winter inactivity. This result is intriguing because up-scaling commonly occurs in response to experimental decreases in neuronal activity and/or synaptic transmission (Fong et al., 2015; Lambo and Turrigiano, 2013; Turrigiano et al., 1998), indicating that up-scaling of AMPA-receptors in response to inactivity-related stimuli is a physiologically relevant response in an animal normally experiencing extremely low levels of neuronal activity. Strikingly, we also observed that vagal motoneuron population output driven by respiratory CPG activity was ~40% less than baseline when we, presumably, blocked the effects of scaling with a sub-saturating concentration of AMPA-receptor antagonist after winter inactivity. This contrasts with no effect of AMPA-receptor block on respiratory motor amplitude in control bullfrogs (Figure 5). Given that amplitude of population motoneuron firing corresponds with drive to respiratory muscles in vivo (Sakakibara, 1984b), up-scaling seems to ensure adequate motor output to critical breathing muscles. Since lung ventilation satisfies gas exchange requirements immediately after winter inactivity in intact, unrestrained bullfrogs (Santin and Hartzler, 2016a), our findings suggest that scaling of AMPA receptors on respiratory motoneurons may contribute to normal ventilation after months without lung breathing.
Several lines of evidence suggest this is the case. First, we observed an increase in mEPSC amplitude and charge transfer without changes in neuronal input resistance and mEPSC rise time, indicating that increased function of AMPA-glutamate receptors, rather than differences in electrotonic properties, explain the increase in mEPSC amplitude (Figure 2) (Han and Stevens, 2009). Whether post-synaptic enhancement of AMPA-receptor function (via elevated expression or post-translational modification) or a presynaptic synaptic mechanism (Liu et al., 1999) causes the larger mEPSC remains an open question. Second, ranked ordered mEPSCs from control and winter inactivity distributions were well-fit by a linear regression, a hallmark of synaptic scaling, instead of an exponential curve, which describes the rank order relationship following LTP (Figure 3A) (Gainey et al., 2009). Third, dividing the winter inactivity mEPSC amplitude distribution by the scaling factor obtained from the linear fit of ranked order mEPSC amplitudes produced a ‘down-scaled’ distribution that overlays the control mEPSC amplitude distribution (Figure 3B) (Turrigiano et al., 1998). Points two and three imply that AMPA-receptors scaled slowly and globally throughout the duration of winter inactivity, rather than rapidly through LTP-like mechanisms during the time between removal of the frog from the simulated winter environment and ~3 hr later when the recordings were made. However, the timing of induction and completion of up-scaling in vagal respiratory motoneurons during the course of the 2-month period without breathing is unresolved. Finally, increased synaptic strength enhanced the contribution of AMPA-receptors for producing respiratory motoneuron discharge. Unlike control bullfrogs, vagal motoneurons receiving respiratory CPG input reduced motoneuron population amplitude by ~40% after winter inactivity upon exposure to a low concentration of AMPA-receptor antagonist (Figure 5). Consistent with a compensatory or homeostatic response, this result suggests that respiratory output leaving the brainstem through the vagus nerve would have been absolutely smaller in bullfrogs after winter inactivity if scaling did not occur. Since motoneuron population discharge increases proportionally with outflow to respiratory muscles in vivo (Sakakibara, 1984b), we collectively interpret our results to mean that scaling of AMPA-receptors on respiratory motoneurons is part of a strategy used to preserve respiratory motor output that produces appropriate lung breathing after winter inactivity.
Although the amplitude of vagal motoneuron output became increasingly reliant on AMPA-receptors following winter inactivity, upregulation of AMPA-receptors probably does not underlie the facilitation of fictive-breathing frequency that we observed (Figure 5E present study, Santin and Hartzler, 2016b). This implies that respiratory rhythm generating circuits use distinct mechanisms of compensation to enhance the frequency of respiratory-related discharge following winter inactivity. Although the mechanisms are presently unknown, several, potentially interacting, processes could underlie enhanced burst frequency in vitro after winter inactivity. These mechanisms may include, but are not limited to (1) decreasing the inhibitory GABA/glycinergic tone within rhythm generating circuits (Straus et al., 2000), (2) altering the neuromodulatory state of rhythm generating circuits, and (3) decreasing the O2 sensitivity of the respiratory control system that may act to tonically depress fictive lung bursts (Santin and Hartzler, 2016b; Winmill et al., 2005). Although the mechanisms leading to enhanced fictive lung burst frequency remain untested, it is apparent that a rich repertoire of compensatory mechanisms may ensure reliable action of the different components of the respiratory control system after months of inactivity.
Exciting questions remain for homeostatic plasticity that can only be understood using animals in natural environments; mainly, how do such compensatory mechanisms operate in natural contexts? An inability to understand principles linking induction and maintenance of these compensatory mechanisms with normal physiological challenges makes it difficult to imagine that these mechanisms can be extrapolated and understood in the context of human pathologies for which they may play a role (Beck and Yaari, 2008; D'Amico et al., 2014; Rajman et al., 2017). Recently, factors associated with physiological state (e.g. sleep-wake) have been suggested to induce synaptic scaling (Diering et al., 2017) implying that neuronal circuits in intact animals use homeostatic and compensatory mechanisms that extend beyond the simple paradigms in which they are commonly studied. The respiratory motor network of bullfrogs following winter inactivity provides a tractable and ecologically relevant model to address major questions regarding preservation of nervous system output. For example, how do neurons ‘know’ when to scale their synapses during physiological challenges (or even when to stop scaling), do specific or multiple interacting stimuli trigger synaptic scaling during natural perturbations in vivo, and why do different components of a behavioral control system apparently use distinct compensatory mechanisms? Only considering mechanisms in the context of realistic challenges encountered by the animals in which they exist can the plethora of mechanisms underlying brain stability be brought to life.
Experiments were approved by the Wright State University Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (protocol number 1047).
Two groups of adult, female bullfrogs, Lithobates catesbeianus, were used in this study: (1) control frogs maintained at 22°C (n = 13) and (2) frogs experiencing an overwintering-like environment (n = 11). Control bullfrogs were maintained in a plastic tank containing 22°C aerated water, provided crickets two times per week, could access wet and dry areas, and were kept on a 12 hr:12 hr light:dark cycle. Control frogs were maintained in this environment for at least 1 week before experiments. Winter inactivity frogs were kept in a plastic tank under the same conditions as control frogs for ~1 week before water temperature was gradually cooled to 2°C over 6 weeks (~3.3°C decrease per week) in a walk-in, temperature-controlled environmental chamber. Frogs were fed twice per week during the cooling phase until water temperature reached ~7°C, and then food was withheld because frogs no longer ate. The light:dark cycle was gradually shifted from 12 hr:12 hr to 10 hr:14 hr over the 6-week cooling phase to simulate day length changes that occur during the winter. Once water temperature reached 2°C, air access was denied using a plastic screen placed in the tank. After 8 weeks of submergence, experiments commenced.
To generate brainstem slices containing vagal motoneurons, the brainstem-spinal cord was dissected as previously described (Santin and Hartzler, 2016b). The dissection was performed in bullfrog artificial cerebrospinal fluid (aCSF; concentrations in mM: 104 NaCl, 4 KCl, 1.4 MgCl2, 7.5 glucose, 40 NaHCO3, 2.5 CaCl2 and 1 NaH2PO4, and gassed with 90% O2, 1.3%CO2, balance N2; pH = 7.8; CO2/pH values reflect normal for bullfrogs). The glottal dilator muscle gates airflow into and out of the lungs during ventilation in anuran amphibians (Gans et al., 1969) and receives its innervation from the laryngeal branch of the vagus nerve that arises the fourth rootlet of the IX-X complex in anurans (Stuesse et al., 1984; Yamaguchi et al., 2003; Zornik and Kelley, 2007). The fourth root of the IX-X nerve is composed of axons mostly projecting to laryngeal muscles (Simpson et al., 1986). To label motoneurons involved in lung ventilation, following dissection of the brainstem-spinal cord, the 4th branch of the IX-X cranial nerve root was isolated from the rest of the root using fine, spring scissors and then cutting the first three branches close to their exit point from the brain. A similar preparation has been used in Xenopus laevis to prepare slices containing laryngeal motoneurons (Yamaguchi et al., 2003). The brainstem-spinal cord was then pinned to a 6 mL Sylard (Dow Corning, Midland, MI)-coated dish filled with aCSF. The 4th branch of the IX-X complex was drawn into a glass pipette using suction. aCSF was removed from the pipette using polyethylene 50 tubing connected to syringe and was replaced with 2–3 μL of 10% tetramethylrhodamine-dextran, 3000 MW (ThermoFisher Scientific, Waltham, MA). The dye was allowed to diffuse for 3 hr while the brain was superfused with gassed aCSF at 10 mL min−1. We found that 3 hr was sufficient to label motoneurons (Figure 1).
Following the 3 hr incubation period, we glued the brainstem to an agar block and then cut 300-μM-thick brainstem slices using a Vibratome tissue slicer (Leica Microsystems, Buffalo Grove, IL) in cold, gassed aCSF as previously described (Santin and Hartzler, 2016b). Given the complex organization of the cranial motor nuclei in amphibians (Matesz and Székely, 1978), we selected slices with a high probability to contain laryngeal motoneurons that drive the glottal dilator based on the following anatomical rationale. The 4th root of the IX-X complex contains the axons innervating the glottal dilator in anurans, but this root also contains axons projecting motoneuron other peripheral targets. However, there is less overlap in the caudal brainstem near the obex (Stuesse et al., 1984). Furthermore, laryngeal motoneurons are morphologically distinct from gastric and cardiac vagal motoneurons (double the soma diameter of the long axis) that reside in the same area (Matesz and Székely, 1996). To maximize the likelihood that we recorded from laryngeal motoneurons that innervate the glottal dilator muscle, we (1) used brainstem slices within 600 μm rostral to the obex (Stuesse et al., 1984) and (2) selected labeled neurons with a long soma diameter >20 μm as these neurons are not visceral motoneurons (Matesz and Székely, 1996). Slices were then transferred to the 0.5 mL recording chamber and were superfused with gassed aCSF at 1–2 mL min−1 during experiments. Preparation and neuron identification was the same for both groups of bullfrogs in this study.
Borosilicate glass pipettes were back-filled with intracellular solution containing (in mM): 110 potassium gluconate, 2 MgCl2, 10 Hepes, 1 Na2 -ATP, 0.1 Na2-GTP, 2.5 EGTA, pH 7.2 with KOH, and positioned over an AgCl2-coated Ag wire with a resistance of 2–4 MΩ. The recording chamber was located under a fixed-stage microscope with a (Nikon, Elgin, IL) where the slice was visualized at 4x magnification with a Nikon Cool Snap (Nikon) to roughly identify the location of the X motor nucleus. Individual neurons were identified in this area using at 60X and labeling with tetramethylrhodamine-dextran was determined by fluorescence imaging (Lambda LS Xenon Lamp House with liquid light guide, Lambda 25 mm excitation filter wheel with SmartShutter, and Lambda 10–3 controller; Sutter Instrument Company, Novato, CA; C-FL G-E/C TRITC Filter Block DM 565, EX 540/25 (528-553), BA 620/60 (590-650). The recording electrode was placed near the neuron using a Burleigh micromanipulator (PCS 5000; Thorlabs, Newton, NJ) while applying positive pressure through the pipette. The pipette offset was zeroed before contacting the neuron. When the pipette touched the neuron, positive pressure was removed and slight negative pressure was applied by mouth until the formation of a gigaohm seal. Rapid negative pressure was applied by mouth to break the gigaohm seal and obtain whole-cell electrochemical access. Data were low-pass filtered at 2 kHz and acquired at 10 kHz for current clamp experiments and 100 kHz for voltage-clamp experiments with an Axopatch 200B amplifier, Digidata 1440A A/D converter, and Molecular Devices P10 Clampex software (Molecular Devices, Sunnydale, CA). Current and voltage-clamp recordings were analyzed offline using LabChart 8 (AD Instruments Inc., Colorado Springs, CO). All voltages from voltage- and current-clamp experiments were corrected for a liquid junction potential of −12 mV (pipette relative to the bath). Neurons with membrane voltages more negative than −45 mV and that contained >50 mV action potentials were used in analysis.
Each neuron from both groups of bullfrogs (n = 16 neurons per group) was subjected to the same protocol. Once the neuron was determined to be viable in current clamp, a step protocol was applied to determine input resistance (Rin) and firing frequency-current relationship. The step protocol began with a 0.5 s, −150 pA step and then increased by 50 pA for a total of 24 steps (−150 pA to 1000 pA). After the step protocol, the neuron was voltage clamped at −80 mV and series resistance (Rs) was allowed to stabilize (control = 12.7 ± 4.7 MΩ vs. winter inactivity = 11.1 ± 4.2 MΩ;±1S.D.; p=0.3127; two-tailed, unpaired t test). Rs was not compensated, but if Rs changed by >20% during the recording or was large (>25 MΩ), the neuron was discarded from analysis. 500 nM tetrodotoxin (TTX) was bath applied for 5 min to block voltage-gated Na+ channels, and then 1 min of mEPSCs were recorded. Next, the neuron was superfused with 10 μM DNQX +500 nM TTX to confirm the AMPA-ergic identity of the mEPSCs. All mEPSCs from both groups of frogs recorded at – 80 mV were blocked by 10 μM DNQX.
The brainstem-spinal cord was dissected the same way as described for the preparation of the brainstem slices and pinned in a 6 mL, Sylgard-coated dish and superfused at 13 mL min−1. Spinal nerve II (SN II; the hypoglossal nerve in anuran amphibians) and cranial nerve X (CN X; vagus) contain branches that innervate the respiratory muscles of amphibians; therefore, spontaneous, rhythmic activity recorded through these cranial nerves corresponds with respiratory rhythm/pattern generator central nervous system activity that drives breathing in intact frogs (Sakakibara, 1984a). SN II was pulled into a borosilicate glass suction electrode, and another glass electrode was attached to the caudal portion of CN X to maximize coverage of the 4th root that supplies the glottis. Glass electrodes were pulled using a two-stage micropipette puller (PC-10; Narishige, East Meadow, NY), broken to size to fit each rootlet, and then fire polished. Nerve activity was amplified ×1000 using differential amplifiers (DP-311; Warner Instruments, Hamden, CT), filtered (100–1000 Hz), full-wave rectified, integrated (time constant, 60 ms) and recorded using the Powerlab 8/35 data acquisition system (ADInstruments Inc., Colorado Springs, CO). Data shown here are the integrated traces.
The preparation was allowed 1 hr to stabilize following dissection and then recording of baseline respiratory bursting in gassed aCSF occurred for 20–30 min. After this baseline period, the preparation was exposed to 4 μM DNQX for 40 min. Upon washing with aCSF following recovery from DNQX, preparations recovered toward baseline amplitude in winter inactivity preparations (Figure 5—figure supplement 1).
For voltage-clamp experiments, average amplitude (current measurement from baseline to peak), area (integral of the mESPC), rise time (time from baseline to peak), and frequency of mEPSCs (mEPSC per minute) (Figure 2) were analyzed from one minute of gap free recording following exposure to TTX using the peak analysis function on LabChart 8 (ADInstruments Inc., Colorado Springs, CO). We rejected events below 7.5 pA, as this value is about double the background noise and detection was unreliable. All events were inspected by eye to ensure the software detected mEPSCs. For rank ordering mEPSC amplitudes and construction of cumulative probability histogram (Figure 3), we used the first 50 mEPSCs from the minute of data obtained from each neuron. The amplitude average of the first 50 mEPSCs for each neuron was within ~1–2 pA of the average obtained using 1 mine of data. The winter inactivity distribution was downscaled by dividing all values in the distribution by the slope of the line of the rank order relationship (i.e. the scaling factor). We only included scaled values that were above the noise threshold of 7.5 pA, as mEPSC amplitudes below this value are not represented in the control distribution and would produce erroneous results in statistical analysis (Kim et al., 2012). For current-clamp experiments, input resistance was calculated as slope of the voltage-current relationship in response to negative current injections (−150 pA to 0 pA in 50 pA steps, 0.5 s steps). Membrane potential is reported as the voltage at the beginning of the step protocol. To establish the F-I gain, we averaged the firing frequency across the 0.5 s step from 0 pA to 1000 pA for each neuron. F-I gain for each neuron was also determined by taking the slope of the F-I relationship. For extracellular nerve recordings from the in vitro brainstem-spinal cord preparation, activity on the vagus nerve was classified as a respiratory burst if it occurred near-synchronously with the hypoglossal and if they were ~1 s in duration. We analyzed 10 min of burst data in control before application of 4 μM DNQX, the last 10 min of burst data after 40 min of exposure to 4 μM DNQX, and 10 min of data ~ 1 hr after washing DNQX. Burst properties were determined using LabChart 8 (ADInstruments Inc., Colorado Springs, CO, USA). Fictive-breath amplitude was analyzed as the maximum height subtracted from the baseline at the start of each burst of the integrated neurogram. Fictive-breath area was obtained from the area under the curve of the integrated nerve burst. Fictive-breath properties in DNQX and washout are expressed as a percent change from baseline or a percent of baseline.
The number of neurons (n = 16 per group) and/or animals (nine control frogs and seven winter inactivity frogs) studied in synaptic and firing frequency experiments are consistent with other studies determining compensatory changes in neurophysiological properties in response to activity perturbations (e.g. Wilhelm et al., 2009; Knogler et al., 2010; Lambo and Turrigiano, 2013). For in vitro brainstem experiments of rhythmic respiratory activity in response to AMPA-receptor inhibition, four brainstems per group were used. As fictive respiratory burst amplitude has been shown to be insensitive to low concentrations of AMPA receptor inhibition (Chen and Hedrick, 2008), any changes in this insensitivity compared to control (i.e. deviations from no change) following the simulated winter environment would have been apparent in our ‘before and after drug’ experimental design. Similar sample sizes have been used previously for understanding synaptic transmission in the respiratory network from various species when the relative changes induced by receptor antagonists were large (Greer et al., 1991; Johnson et al., 2002). For comparisons of unpaired data that were normally distributed, we used a two-tailed, unpaired t test. If variance between the two groups differed, a Welch’s correction was applied to the t test. Unpaired data that failed to meet the assumption of normality were compared using the Mann Whitney test on ranked data. Within preparation comparisons for recovery from DNQX were analyzed using a paired t test as this test has been shown to be robust for small sample sizes when the correlation coefficient is large (de Winter, 2013). For the mean F-I relationship of each group, we compared the mean slopes between each group with an analysis of covariance (ANCOVA). These analyses were performed using Graphpad Prism 6.01 (Graphpad Software, San Diego, CA). Cumulative distributions were compared with the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test using R (R Development Core Team, 2014) to compute exact p values. Detailed statistical information for each figure is provided in a table (Supplementary file 1). Error bars are presented as ±standard error of the mean unless otherwise specified. Statistical significance was accepted when p<0.05.
Analysis of neuron models with dynamically regulated conductancesNeural Computation 5:823–842.https://doi.org/10.1162/neco.19126.96.36.1993
Three brainstem areas involved in respiratory rhythm generation in bullfrogsThe Journal of Physiology 593:2941–2954.https://doi.org/10.1113/JP270380
Plasticity of intrinsic neuronal properties in CNS disordersNature Reviews Neuroscience 9:357–369.https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn2371
Role of glutamate and substance P in the amphibian respiratory network during developmentRespiratory Physiology & Neurobiology 162:24–31.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resp.2008.03.010
Recovery of neuronal and network excitability after spinal cord injury and implications for spasticityFrontiers in Integrative Neuroscience 8:36.https://doi.org/10.3389/fnint.2014.00036
Using the Student’s t-test with extremely small sample sizesPractical Assessment, Research, and Evaluation 18:1–12.
Critical periods for experience-dependent synaptic scaling in visual cortexNature Neuroscience 5:783–789.https://doi.org/10.1038/nn878
Plasticity in the intrinsic excitability of cortical pyramidal neuronsNature neuroscience 2:515–520.https://doi.org/10.1038/9165
Understanding the rhythm of breathing: so near, yet so farAnnual Review of Physiology 75:423.https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-physiol-040510-130049
Upward synaptic scaling is dependent on neurotransmission rather than spikingNature Communications 6:6339.https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms7339
Synaptic scaling requires the GluR2 subunit of the AMPA receptorJournal of Neuroscience 29:6479–6489.https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3753-08.2009
Role of excitatory amino acids in the generation and transmission of respiratory drive in neonatal ratThe Journal of Physiology 437:727–749.https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.1991.sp018622
Development of respiratory rhythm generation in ectothermic vertebratesRespiratory Physiology & Neurobiology 149:29–41.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resp.2005.03.019
Role of synaptic inhibition in turtle respiratory rhythm generationThe Journal of Physiology 544:253–265.https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.2002.019687
Synaptic scaling and the development of a motor networkJournal of Neuroscience 30:8871–8881.https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0880-10.2010
Neural organization of the ventilatory activity in the frog, Rana catesbeiana. IJournal of Neurobiology 25:1067–1079.https://doi.org/10.1002/neu.480250904
Transmission of the respiratory rhythm to trigeminal and hypoglossal motor neurons in the American Bullfrog (Lithobates catesbeiana)Respiratory Physiology & Neurobiology 188:180–191.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resp.2013.06.008
The motor column and sensory projections of the branchial cranial nerves in the frogJournal of Comparative Neurology 178:157–175.https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.901780109
Organization of the ambiguus nucleus in the frog (Rana esculenta)The Journal of Comparative Neurology 371:258–269.https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1096-9861(19960722)371:2<258::AID-CNE6>3.0.CO;2-1
R: A Language and Environment for Statistical ComputingR Foundation for Statistical Computing.
The pattern of respiratory nerve activity in the bullfrogThe Japanese Journal of Physiology 34:269–282.https://doi.org/10.2170/jjphysiol.34.269
Trigeminal nerve activity and buccal pressure as an index of total inspiratory activity in the bullfrogThe Japanese Journal of Physiology 34:827–838.https://doi.org/10.2170/jjphysiol.34.827
Control of lung ventilation following overwintering conditions in bullfrogs, Lithobates catesbeianusThe Journal of Experimental Biology 219:2003–2014.https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.136259
Activation of respiratory muscles does not occur during cold-submergence in bullfrogs, Lithobates catesbeianusThe Journal of Experimental Biology 220:1181–1186.https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.153544
Homeostatic plasticity of excitability in crustacean central pattern generator networksCurrent Opinion in Neurobiology 43:7–14.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.conb.2016.09.015
Origin and identification of fibers in the cranial nerve IX-X complex of Xenopus laevis: Lucifer Yellow backfills in vitroThe Journal of Comparative Neurology 244:430–444.https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.902440403
Organization within the cranial IX-X complex in ranid frogs: a horseradish peroxidase transport studyThe Journal of Comparative Neurology 222:358–365.https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.902220304
Physiological ecology of aquatic overwintering in ranid frogsBiological Reviews 83:119–140.https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-185X.2008.00035.x
Too many cooks? Intrinsic and synaptic homeostatic mechanisms in cortical circuit refinementAnnual Review of Neuroscience 34:89–103.https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-neuro-060909-153238
Homeostatic synaptic plasticity: local and global mechanisms for stabilizing neuronal functionCold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology 4:a005736.https://doi.org/10.1101/cshperspect.a005736
Development of the respiratory response to hypoxia in the isolated brainstem of the bullfrog Rana catesbeianaJournal of Experimental Biology 208:213–222.https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.01399
Breathing and calling: neuronal networks in the Xenopus laevis hindbrainThe Journal of Comparative Neurology 501:303–315.https://doi.org/10.1002/cne.21145
Yukiko GodaReviewing Editor; RIKEN, Japan
In the interests of transparency, eLife includes the editorial decision letter and accompanying author responses. A lightly edited version of the letter sent to the authors after peer review is shown, indicating the most substantive concerns; minor comments are not usually included.
Thank you for submitting your article "Synaptic up-scaling preserves motor circuit output after chronic, natural inactivity" for consideration by eLife. Your article has been reviewed by three peer reviewers, one of whom is a member of our Board of Reviewing Editors and the evaluation has been overseen by Eve Marder as the Senior Editor. The following individuals involved in review of your submission have agreed to reveal their identity: Carlos D Aizenman (Reviewer #2); Peter Wenner (Reviewer #3).
The reviewers have discussed the reviews with one another and the Reviewing Editor has drafted this decision to help you prepare a revised submission
All three reviewers find this study, which reports of synaptic scaling in a respiratory circuit in an adult animal that is driven by a natural environmental stress, to be very interesting and worthy of publication in eLife, pending revisions. The scaling data are compelling, and demonstration of synaptic scaling in a behaviorally relevant circuit under perturbation that naturally occurs in nature is timely and important. A major revision is requested concerning the data presented in Figure 4, which involves addition of new text, re-analysis of data and inclusion of new plots. Based on the larger sensitivity of fictive respiratory burst responses to AMPAR blockade in wintered preparations compared to controls, the authors argue for the contribution of prominent AMPAR scaling in wintered animals. Nevertheless, the rationale for the design of experiments has not been clearly explained, and the "n" is rather small.
1) Please provide a clearer explanation for this set of experiments, taking into consideration that there could have been other reasons why motor neurons scaled up their synaptic AMPAR (instead of ensuring proper breathing when the respiratory demand increases in the spring). Moreover, aside from respiratory motor neurons, other respiratory circuit component(s) could have also undergone some form of compensation during wintering. Finally, there needs to be a more coherent discussion of how/why scaling contributes to the recovery of overwintering respiration (which is actually higher at baseline). Is there an overwintering-induced change in the circuit that prevents normal respiratory activity once temperatures are increased, and could scaling compensate for this issue?
2) One should include a comparison of raw data (not normalized) along with normalized data. This might clarify the presence of AMPAR-independent component of adaptation in wintered preparation.
3) Please explain/justify the use of small "n" number.https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.30005.011
- Joseph M Santin
- Joseph M Santin
The funders had no role in study design, data collection and interpretation, or the decision to submit the work for publication.
We would like to thank the Department of Biological Sciences at Wright State University for the Biology Award for Research Excellence Grant and the Biomedical Sciences PhD program for stipend support (JS).
Animal experimentation: Experiments were approved by the Wright State University Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (protocol number 1047).
- Yukiko Goda, Reviewing Editor, RIKEN, Japan
© 2017, Santin et al.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.