Circadian oscillations in Trichoderma atroviride and the role of core clock components in secondary metabolism, development, and mycoparasitism against the phytopathogen Botrytis cinerea

  1. Marlene Henríquez-Urrutia
  2. Rebecca Spanner
  3. Consuelo Olivares-Yánez
  4. Aldo Seguel-Avello
  5. Rodrigo Pérez-Lara
  6. Hector Guillén-Alonso
  7. Robert Winkler
  8. Alfredo Herrera-Estrella
  9. Paulo Canessa  Is a corresponding author
  10. Luis F Larrondo  Is a corresponding author
  1. ANID – Millennium Science Initiative Program - Millennium Institute for Integrative Biology (iBio), Chile
  2. Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Biological Sciences Faculty, Molecular Genetics and Microbiology Department, Chile
  3. Centro de Biotecnología Vegetal, Facultad de Ciencias de la Vida, Universidad Andrés, Chile
  4. Department of Biotechnology and Biochemistry, Cinvestav Unidad Irapuato, Mexico
  5. Laboratorio de expresión génica y desarrollo en hongos, Unidad de Genómica Avanzada-LANGEBIO, Mexico

Abstract

Circadian clocks are important for an individual’s fitness, and recent studies have underlined their role in the outcome of biological interactions. However, the relevance of circadian clocks in fungal–fungal interactions remains largely unexplored. We sought to characterize a functional clock in the biocontrol agent Trichoderma atroviride to assess its importance in the mycoparasitic interaction against the phytopathogen Botrytis cinerea. Thus, we confirmed the existence of circadian rhythms in T. atroviride, which are temperature-compensated and modulated by environmental cues such as light and temperature. Nevertheless, the presence of such molecular rhythms appears to be highly dependent on the nutritional composition of the media. Complementation of a clock null (Δfrq) Neurospora crassa strain with the T. atroviride-negative clock component (tafrq) restored core clock function, with the same period observed in the latter fungus, confirming the role of tafrq as a bona fide core clock component. Confrontation assays between wild-type and clock mutant strains of T. atroviride and B. cinerea, in constant light or darkness, revealed an inhibitory effect of light on T. atroviride’s mycoparasitic capabilities. Interestingly, when confrontation assays were performed under light/dark cycles, T. atroviride’s overgrowth capacity was enhanced when inoculations were at dawn compared to dusk. Deleting the core clock-negative element FRQ in B. cinerea, but not in T. atroviride, was vital for the daily differential phenotype, suggesting that the B. cinerea clock has a more significant influence on the result of this interaction. Additionally, we observed that T. atroviride clock components largely modulate development and secondary metabolism in this fungus, including the rhythmic production of distinct volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Thus, this study provides evidence on how clock components impact diverse aspects of T. atroviride lifestyle and how daily changes modulate fungal interactions and dynamics.

Editor's evaluation

The article by Henríquez-Urrutia and colleagues aims to establish that the fungus Trichoderma atroviride, a major biocontrol agent, has a circadian clock and test if this clock plays a role in development, secondary metabolite production, and mycoparasitism. The study is an important contribution toward the development of a new system for understanding how circadian rhythms influence fungal–fungal interactions that rests on solid experimental evidence.

https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.71358.sa0

Introduction

Trichoderma species are cosmopolitan soil fungi found in several substrates, including decaying wood and fungal fruiting bodies, establishing beneficial interactions with plants (Carreras-Villaseñor et al., 2012; Kubicek et al., 2019; Vos et al., 2015), and negative ones with other microorganisms (Druzhinina et al., 2006; Guzman-Guzman et al., 2019; Harman et al., 2004; Sood et al., 2020). Trichoderma species are well-known mycoparasites as they can degrade, grow on other fungi, and even penetrate them, a distinctive feature that has been exploited in agriculture for their use as biocontrol agents of different phytopathogens, including Botrytis cinerea (Naglot et al., 2015; Rahman et al., 2009).

Trichoderma's mycoparasitic behavior starts with the secretion of low levels of cell wall degrading enzymes (CWDE) (Druzhinina et al., 2011; Seidl et al., 2009; Vos et al., 2015) that dismantle the fungal prey’s hyphae. Release of small molecules derived from the host can function as molecular signals in Trichoderma, allowing prey recognition (Zeilinger et al., 2005), redirecting hyphal growth, and initiating coiling around the host mycelium, followed by hyphal penetration. Indeed, the synergistic effect of enhanced CWDE and toxic secondary metabolite (SM) production allows Trichoderma’s hyphae to penetrate the prey’s lumen, achieving its killing (Belanger et al., 1995; Druzhinina et al., 2011; Sharma, 2011; Steyaert et al., 2003).

Trichoderma species present developmental responses to different stresses, of which conidiation induced by light and mechanical damage has been extensively studied (Casas-Flores and Herrera-Estrella, 2013). Physical damage of mycelia in Trichoderma atroviride triggers a developmental injury response, leading to conidia production in the injured area through the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and activation of MAPK signaling pathways (Hernández-Oñate et al., 2012; Medina-Castellanos et al., 2014). Additionally, light is also perceived as a stress signal, triggering conidiation: a light pulse (LP) given to a dark-grown T. atroviride generates several biochemical changes driving the formation of a green ring of conidia at the edge of the colony (Casas-Flores et al., 2004; Casas-Flores et al., 2006; Galun and Gressel, 1966; Schmoll et al., 2010). In T. atroviride, two genes called blue light regulators 1 and 2 (blr1 and blr2) were identified as responsible for light-induced conidiation. The BLR proteins are homologs of the transcription factors WC-1 and WC-2, which in Neurospora crassa form the white collar complex (WCC), responsible for light and circadian regulation in this fungus (Casas-Flores et al., 2004; Froehlich et al., 2002; Montenegro-Montero et al., 2015). Importantly, light can be directly perceived thanks to the presence of a light-oxygen-voltage (LOV) domain in WC-1/BLR1 (Corrochano, 2019). Furthermore, BLRs have been described as critical for the effect of light on growth, oxidative stress responses, and light-controlled gene expression (Cervantes-Badillo et al., 2013; Esquivel-Naranjo et al., 2016; Friedl et al., 2008a; Garcia-Esquivel et al., 2016). Studies on BLR1 and BLR2 and the presence of a frq homolog that is induced by light, and whose expression depends on BLR1 (Garcia-Esquivel et al., 2016; Steyaert et al., 2010a), suggest the presence of a functional clock and underlying circadian regulation in this fungus. However, to date, neither circadian oscillations of tafrq/TaFRQ levels nor circadian phenotypes have been reported in T. atroviride; meanwhile, various studies have failed at detecting overt or molecular circadian rhythms in several fungi across fungal clades (Cascant-Lopez et al., 2020; Hevia et al., 2016; Larrondo and Canessa, 2019).

Circadian rhythms have emerged as an adaptation to Earth’s rotation around its axis, allowing organisms to keep track of time, anticipating and adapting to periodic and predictable environmental changes through the temporal coordination of gene expression, metabolic pathways, physiological responses, and even behaviors (Bell-Pedersen et al., 2005; Hurley et al., 2016). Recent findings have shown that interactions between organisms may also be subjected to circadian regulation (reviewed in Hevia et al., 2016; Larrondo and Canessa, 2019). And while several reports have highlighted the importance of the plant clock in plant–pathogen interactions, there has been scarce information from the pathogen perspective. Yet, it has been reported that the interaction between the phytopathogenic fungus B. cinerea and Arabidopsis thaliana largely depends on the fungal functional circadian clock, with virulence reaching higher levels at nighttime (Hevia et al., 2015; Ingle et al., 2015).

The ascomycete N. crassa is a salient model in chronobiology due to its robust circadian phenotype of daily spore production at dawn and a wealth of molecular resources (Baker et al., 2012). Its central oscillator is based on a negative transcriptional–translational feedback loop (TTFL), a shared core architecture across phyla (Dunlap, 1999; Dunlap and Loros, 2017; Loros, 2020). In N. crassa, the WCC activates the expression of the TTFL-negative element, frequency (frq), which leads to increasing levels of the FRQ protein, that starts recruiting kinases and negatively regulates its own expression by phosphorylating and inactivating the WCC. FRQ itself is progressively modified until reaching its maximum phosphorylation state at nighttime, losing its affinity for WCC and allowing a new transcription/translation cycle to start. Both frq mRNA and FRQ protein levels oscillate during this process with a period close to 22.5 hr (Larrondo et al., 2015; Montenegro-Montero et al., 2015). Albeit wc-1, wc-2, and frq homologs are present in several fungi, the description of overt clock phenotypes, as the molecular characterization of circadian rhythms in fungal species besides N. crassa, has been limited (Montenegro-Montero et al., 2015; Salichos and Rokas, 2010). Indeed, despite different studies addressing the latter, there are seldom examples of characterized circadian oscillators in other fungi and few studies exploring fungal circadian phenomena and clock components. Among these is B. cinerea, where rhythms in BcFRQ1 levels were confirmed, along with BcFRQ1’s key role in conferring the daily difference on virulence potential. Remarkably, the evidence also suggests that in B. cinerea BcFRQ1 plays an extra-circadian role in developmental decisions as Δbcfrq1 displays altered developmental phenotypes observed even under conditions where the clock function is abolished, such as constant light, and in contrast to the phenotype observed in the absence of BcWCL1 (Hevia et al., 2015).

To deepen the role of circadian regulation in organismal interactions, and simultaneously evaluate the presence of a functional circadian clock in T. atroviride, we sought to assess the daily oscillations of TaFRQ expression under free-running conditions while assessing canonical clock properties and the clock’s ability to respond to environmental stimuli. By generating clock mutant strains, we evaluated the impact of core clock components in T. atroviride secondary metabolism, developmental programs, and on its mycoparasitic capabilities against different B. cinerea strains, including those deficient in circadian regulation. Overall, our results reveal the presence of a functional circadian clock in T. atroviride, a role of core clock components in the modulation of mycoparasitic interactions, and extra-circadian functions for TaFRQ.

Results

T. atroviride bears a functional circadian clock

We generated TaFRQLUC, a translational fusion reporter between luciferase and TaFRQ (Figure 1—figure supplement 1) to assess oscillations of this putative T. atroviride core clock-negative element and quantify bioluminescence levels under free-running conditions (DD). Monitoring LUC activity after 3 days of constant light (LL) or light-dark (LD) 12:12 hr entrainment cycles, at 25°C, failed to reveal oscillations in multiple tested growth media (Figure 1—figure supplement 2, Supplementary file 1) with only one exception: GYEC, where weak but distinguishable oscillations were observed (Figure 1A, Figure 1—figure supplement 3A). Under the rationale that culture media appeared to be critical for T. atroviride’s oscillations and considering that the fungus also interacts with plants, we decided to modify the GYEC media by adding plant-derived material, ground peas (GYEC+ peas), observing that the quality of the oscillations greatly improved (Figure 1B, Figure 1—figure supplement 3B). Notably, the results suggest that these rhythms are highly dependent on the nutritional composition of the media. The period estimation of those oscillations by fast Fourier transform nonlinear least squares (FFT-NLS) using BioDare (Zielinski et al., 2014) revealed an average period of 26.5 ± 0.36 hr. The phase of the first peak of TaFRQ expression occurs at DD 22, which corresponds to circadian time CT8, and is roughly similar (albeit slightly advanced) compared to the phase of FRQLUC expression (CT11) described in N. crassa (Larrondo et al., 2012). We could also observe oscillations (although weaker ones) by resetting the clock with 3 days in LL (Figure 1C) and also with a short 20 min LP after 48 hr in DD, which elevates TaFRQLUC levels, boosting sustained oscillations for at least 4 days (Figure 1D). Likewise, a low-temperature pulse of 4°C for 6 hr also served as a cue to reset the clock, shifting its phase almost 12 hr, similar to what can be seen in N. crassa when monitoring FRQLUC expression (Larrondo et al., 2012; Figure 1E). After both pulse protocols, the period also remained in the 26 hr range (26.30 hr and 26.49 hr, respectively), exhibiting even better oscillations after the perturbation, as previously observed for clock reporters under some conditions (Shi et al., 2007). These findings indicate that circadian oscillations of TaFRQ can be entrained by LD cycles or shifted by light and temperature pulses. Indeed, the analyses of these perturbations (Figure 1—figure supplement 4) revealed a mean phase delay of 4.29 hr between LD and LP entrainment and 10.85 hr between LL reset and 4°C pulses, further showing that these oscillations behave as one would expect from a circadian oscillator (Heintzen and Liu, 2007). To complement these results, we used a Western blot with anti-LUC antibodies to obtain evidence of TaFRQLUC oscillations in constant darkness over a 52 hr time course, further supporting the circadian variation of TaFRQ levels (Figure 1—figure supplement 5). Importantly, we also evaluated if the observed TaFRQLUC oscillations were temperature-compensated, meaning that they should maintain about the same period in a physiological range of temperatures. Thus, TaFRQLUC rhythms were assessed after 3 days in 12:12 LD entrainment regimes at 20, 22, 25, and 28°C and monitored in DD at the corresponding temperatures (Figure 1B and F–H, Figure 1—figure supplement 6). While low-amplitude oscillations were observed at 20°C, changes in TaFRQLUC levels exhibited higher amplitude at 22°C than at 25°C, whereas oscillations were lost at 28°C, indicating that of the tested temperatures the Trichoderma clock runs better at 22°C. To quantify the degree of temperature compensation, we calculated the Q10 between 20 and 25°C (Figure 1—figure supplement 7), obtaining a Q10 of 1.05 ± 0.07, which is in the range for temperature compensation described in other circadian systems (Anderson et al., 1985; Kusakina et al., 2014; Mattern et al., 1982). Thus, the results show that the T. atroviride’s TaFRQLUC circadian oscillations can compensate in a temperature range between 20 and 25°C, further supporting that a circadian clock is responsible for the observed rhythms.

Figure 1 with 8 supplements see all
Circadian oscillations of TaFRQLUC are reset by light and temperature and are temperature-compensated.

(A, B) Raw TaFRQLUC levels were quantified under DD in strains previously entrained for 3 days under LD (12:12 hr) cycles in GYEC (A) or GYEC+ peas (B) culture media. (C) Culture in LL (at 25°C) for 72 hr and then transferred to DD exhibit oscillations. (D) The effect of a 20 min. light pulse (blue arrow) was evaluated in DD on cultures that were also entrained in LD cycles as mentioned. (E) A 4°C temperature pulse efficiently resets rhythms, as shown in cultures grown for 48 hr in LL, cold pulsed in the dark for 6 hr, and then monitored in DD. (F–H) TaFRQLUC expression was monitored at 20 (F), 22 (G), and 28°C (H) to assess rhythmicity at different temperatures. GYEC+ peas media was used in all cases except in (A), and bioluminescence was recorded at 25°C except when indicated otherwise. In all cases, raw data’s mean values are presented from two biological and eight technical replicates each (SEM represented with the gray area). Source data can be found in Figure 1—source data 1.

Figure 1—source data 1

For each graph, source data of TaFRQLUC bioluminescence is provided as an .xlsx file.

Data is organized in individual sheets following the same order as in Figure 1.

https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/71358/elife-71358-fig1-data1-v2.xlsx

To test rhythmic regulation of putative clock-controlled genes (ccgs), we subjected luc expression under the control of four distinct T. atroviride promoters of interest. These were selected from homologs to N. crassa genes encoding trehalose synthase, glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase, superoxide dismutase, and CON-10, all of which have been reported as rhythmic in Neurospora and some even in other organisms (Lakin-Thomas et al., 2011; Lillo, 1993; Shinohara et al., 2002; Yoshida et al., 2008). Although in all cases we detected bioluminescence, no oscillations were identified in DD, at least under the tested culture conditions (Figure 1—figure supplement 8, Supplementary file 2). Despite the disappointing lack of oscillation of these putative ccgs reporters, this result reinforces the idea that the rhythms yielded by the TaFRQLUC reporter strains are of a circadian nature rather than spurious oscillations driven by external cues or rhythms in ATP levels.

Functional conservation of core clock elements between T. atroviride and N. crassa

In N. crassa, transcriptional activation of frq under constant darkness requires recognition, by the WCC, of the clock box (c-box) in its promoter. This cis-element is necessary and sufficient to generate and maintain frq daily rhythms (Froehlich et al., 2003). To evaluate the conservation of the circadian system of T. atroviride, we transformed this fungus with luc under the control of the N. crassa c-box (Ncc-box-luc). Notably, this reporter revealed clear rhythms of luc levels under free-running conditions (DD), which responded to light and temperature cues, and whose presence was also conditioned by culture media composition (Figure 2, Figure 2—figure supplement 1). The bioluminescent traces were analyzed using BioDare (Zielinski et al., 2014), revealing an average of 25.67 ± 1.01 hr period for two independent Ncc-box-luc strains, in close agreement with the TaFRQLUC data. This provides additional proof of a functional circadian clock in T. atroviride and demonstrates that a pivotal Neurospora cis-element (Ncc-box) can be recognized in T. atroviride. Albeit the measured period with this reporter is slighter shorter compared to the one obtained with TaFRQLUC, this also recapitulates what has been seen when comparing both types of reporters (translational and transcriptional) in N. crassa, which could occur due to discrete changes in FRQ structure/dynamics when analyzing this protein as a translational fusion (Larrondo et al., 2012). Notably, in response to an LP, a clear and acute augment in luc expression was seen, as observed for light-responsive elements in Neurospora, arguing that this Ncc-box could integrate light and clock information in T. atroviride. This hypothesis will be challenged in future experiments.

Figure 2 with 4 supplements see all
Functional conservation of circadian clock components between T. atroviride and N. crassa.

(A, B) Ncc-box-luc reporter strains were entrained for 3 days under LD (12:12 hr) cycles at 25°C and then transferred to DD where they were monitored unperturbed (A), or examined after a discrete light pulse (blue arrow), which produces a perceivable phase shift (B). (C) Strains were grown for 48 hr in LL and then transferred to DD, where a 4°C temperature treatment for 6 hr was applied. Then bioluminescence was monitored under constant darkness and 25°C. GYEC+ peas culture media was used in all cases. Raw data is presented with mean values of two biological replicates with three technical replicates each (SEM is represented with the gray area). (D, E) The expression of tafrq in N. crassa is able to restore circadian oscillation of a strain lacking its endogenous frq. The use of the transcriptional reporter frqc-box-luc reveals the presence of circadian rhythms in luciferase in the Δfrq::tafrq strain where Trichoderma FRQ was expressed. These oscillations have a longer period than WT N. crassa. Period determination was performed using BioDare 2.0, Linear Det, FFT-NLLS algorithm. A significant difference in period was found between WT N. crassa strain and the strain carrying T. atroviride FRQ (Mann–Whitney test, p-value=0.0055). Period ± SD. frqc-box-luc: WT: 20.6 ± 0,2; ΔNcfrq::tafrq: 25.9 ± 0.5. Source data can be found in Figure 2—source data 1.

Figure 2—source data 1

Source data of bioluminescence for each graph is provided as an .xlsx file.

Data is organized in individual sheets following the same order as in Figure 2.

https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/71358/elife-71358-fig2-data1-v2.xlsx

In order to provide additional and compelling evidence that the T. atroviride FRQ is a bona fide core clock component, we adopted a classic genetic approach, based on its ability to complement the lack of the endogenous FRQ protein in N. crassa. Thus, we complemented a Neurospora Δfrq strain, containing a circadian luciferase reporter (his-3::frqc-box-luc reporter), with the tafrq gene in which its expression was under the control of the native promoter and terminator of Neurospora (Figure 2—figure supplement 2A and B). The presence of TaFRQ in this Δfrq::tafrq strain yielded clear rhythmic levels of bioluminescence, in contrast to full arrhythmic and high levels of LUC in the recipient Δfrq strain (Figure 2D). Most notably, the analyses of the rhythms revealed a period of ~26 hr after 3 days of 12:12 hr LD entrainment (Figure 2E), further confirming that the long free-running period described in Trichoderma is a property encoded in the FRQ sequence, providing clear evidence of interspecies conservation of a phospho-code commanding period (Figure 2—figure supplement 3). However, no overt rhythmic conidiation was observed in these strains (Figure 2—figure supplement 4), with or without LD entrainment, suggesting that whilst the core clock may function, the normal outputs of the clock in N. crassa may no longer be responding. Finally, to get a first glimpse of TaFRQ expression in Neurospora, we conducted a short 12 hr time course, confirming that after an LL to DD transfer this heterologous clock component is degraded as expected (Figure 2—figure supplement 2C).

TaFRQ is required for proper conidiation in T. atroviride after light exposure and mechanical injury

While in Neurospora FRQ appears to solely act as a clock component, in B. cinerea BcFRQ1 exhibits extra-circadian roles, impacting developmental phenotypes. Indeed, enhanced microconidiation and sclerotia formation are observed in Δbcfrq1 (but not in Δbcwcl1) even in conditions where a fungal circadian clock does not run such as constant light (Hevia et al., 2015). This phenotype, which contrasts WT B. cinerea and Δbcwcl1 copious production of macroconidia in LL and LD, prompted us to ask whether tafrq might also serve a role in fungal development in T. atroviride. Therefore, we constructed tafrq deletions (Δtafrq) (Figure 3—figure supplement 1) and tafrq-overexpressing strains (OE::tafrq) (Figure 3—figure supplement 2) and evaluated light-induced conidiation for 7 days in LL. After 72 hr of cultivation in LL, T. atroviride displayed the characteristic green coloration as a result of regular conidia formation. In contrast, the Δtafrq strain exhibited a dark-green color not observed also in the OE::tafrq strains (Figure 3A). Notably, at 3 days post-inoculation (dpi), Δtafrq had produced fewer conidia, albeit this difference was no longer significant by day 7, indicating that conidiation in Δtafrq is delayed but not fully compromised. Furthermore, conidia formation in response to a discrete LP was significantly decreased in Δtafrq, regardless of the pulse duration (Figure 3C). In contrast, no significant differences were observed between TaWT and OE::tafrq in both types of analyses (Figure 3B and C). Importantly, although in the latter strain tafrq mRNA levels were not boosted dramatically, they were statistically higher compared to WT (Figure 3—figure supplement 2).

Figure 3 with 4 supplements see all
Effect of light and injury-induced in conidiation in clock component mutant strains of T. atroviride.

TaWT, Δblr1, Δtafrq, and OE::tafrq strains were grown in potato dextrose agar (PDA) at 25°C. (A) Sporulation was observed at 72 hr in LL, or after injury (mechanical damage) in DD conditions, as specified in ‘Materials and methods.’ (B) Conidia produced after 3 and 7 days of growth in LL. (C) Conidia production of Trichoderma’s strains after receiving a 1 and 60 min light pulse (LP). LP was applied to cultures previously grown for 36 hr in DD. (D) Conidia produced after mechanical damage. Strains were grown for 36 hr in DD, and injury was performed with a scalpel using a grid as reference. Later, damaged strains were kept in DD for 48 hr to allow conidia collection. Errors bars represent the mean ± SD of three biologicals for (B) and four for (C) replicates for each experiment. Different letters indicate significant differences based on Tukey’s test (p<0.05).

We also evaluated whether the injury-response mechanism that drives conidia formation in T. atroviride upon physical damage was affected in the mutant strains (Hernández-Oñate et al., 2012). We injured the WT and the aforementioned clock mutant strains in DD, including Δblr1, employing a sterile scalpel and quantified conidia formation 48 hr afterward. Interestingly, Δblr1 showed a 51% average reduction in conidia production compared to the TaWT strain, which had not been previously reported. In contrast, while the OE::tafrq showed no significant differences compared to TaWT, Δtafrq exhibited almost a 100-fold reduction in injure-triggered conidiation (Figure 3A and D). As expected, we were able to restore the injury-response conidiation when complementing Δtafrq with tafrq back at its endogenous locus (ΔtafrqC) (Figure 3—figure supplements 3 and 4). Importantly, the results obtained in LL suggest that TaFRQ has an underlying role in promoting conidiation, providing evidence of an additional role for TaFRQ in T. atroviride, besides its expected main function as a negative clock element. A similar conclusion can be drawn about response to an acute stress stimulus, such as mechanical damage, since even though this was done in DD conditions, sporulation per se does not appear to be under clock control in Trichoderma.

Light and core clock components regulate the interaction between T. atroviride and B. cinerea

To evaluate the role of T. atroviride core clock components in its mycoparasitic capabilities, we performed confrontations with B. cinerea, utilizing the corresponding clock mutant strains lacking wc-1 or frq homologs (Canessa et al., 2013; Hevia et al., 2015). Experiments were first conducted under LL and DD conditions, evaluating the mycoparasitic behavior of T. atroviride as its ability to overgrow B. cinerea, as shown in Figure 4A. Initially, we performed confrontations on GYEC and GYEC+ peas medium, but as both fungi grew as white mycelium we could not differentiate their respective growth front, making the observation of the overgrowth phenotype difficult. Therefore, we decided to perform the confrontations on PDA. Importantly, before performing the confrontation experiments, we first analyzed whether the growth of both fungi was altered under the tested culture conditions or whether, when growing on the same Petri dish before the physical encounter, there were growth delays that could affect data interpretation. Results showed that growth rates of each strain (alone or interacting) were not affected in any of these scenarios (Figure 4—figure supplement 1).

Figure 4 with 1 supplement see all
Core clock components, light, and darkness modulate the T. atroviride and B. cinerea interaction outcomes.

(A) Schematic representation of the experimental design (left) and confrontation assay (right). (B) After 7 days of cultivation in LL and DD conditions in potato dextrose agar (PDA) culture media, T. atroviride overgrowth was evaluated. Cultures were kept at 20°C during 7 days under the corresponding light regimes. Red dotted lines indicate the edge of Trichoderma over B. cinerea. A representative image of three biological replicates is shown. (C) Percentage of B. cinerea colony area covered by Trichoderma (percentage of overgrowth). Error bars represent the means ± SD of three biological replicates. Different letters indicate significant differences based on Tukey’s test (p<0.05).

In the TaWT–B05.10 interaction, T. atroviride displayed higher overgrowth over B. cinerea in DD than in LL (50% vs. 20%, respectively). Increased overgrowth in DD (90%) versus LL was also seen for Δblr1 against B05.10, being the most aggressive of the tested T. atroviride strains. At the same time, Δtafrq displayed similar behavior to TaWT in LL and DD against B05.10 (Figure 4B and C, Supplementary file 3). The confrontation of T. atroviride strains with B. cinerea Δbcfrq1 was similar to what was observed for B05.10 in LL and DD, except for the Δtafrq–Δbcfrq1 interaction in LL, where no overgrowth was observed. Finally, under LL, Botrytis Δbcwcl1 was easily overgrown by TaWT but not by the Δblr1 or Δtafrq Trichoderma mutants. However, in the absence of light, Δbcwcl1 was easily overgrown by ~80% by all Trichoderma strains (Figure 4B and C, Supplementary file 3). Overall, these results suggest that constant light inhibits the overgrowth capacity of T. atroviride irrespective of the presence of blr1, or that mycoparasitism is enhanced in darkness. Nevertheless, whether other photoreceptors are involved in this response remains to be investigated. Core clock components also modulate the outcome of these mycoparasitic interactions, suggesting an inhibitory role of BLR1, as its absence enhances overgrowth in DD against all B. cinerea strains.

In contrast, tafrq does not seem to have a relevant role in the outcome of the T. atroviride interaction with B05.10, albeit the mutant has a weaker mycoparasitic capacity when interacting in LL with Δbcwcl1 or Δbcfrq1. Similarly, the absence of B. cinerea bcfrq1 does not impact the interaction with TaWT. Still, the lack of bcwcl1 increases the susceptibility of B. cinerea to T. atroviride, suggesting a diminished capacity to respond to this biotic stress in the mutant.

Differential overgrowth capacity of T. atroviride against B. cinerea in light/dark cycles

To fully understand the role of core clock components in the interaction between T. atroviride against B. cinerea, we performed confrontations under circadian paradigm assays in LD 12:12 hr cycles. For this, strains were inoculated at ‘dawn’ when lights are turned on in the LD cycle (AM) or inoculated at ‘dusk’ before lights are turned off in the DL (PM) regime (Figure 5A). Confrontations were kept in their respective photoperiod cycles for 7 days, after which the degree of Trichoderma overgrowth over B. cinerea was evaluated for different strain combinations.

Core clock components of B. cinerea and T. atroviride have a role in the differential mycoparasitic interaction observed under LD cycles.

(A) Schematic representation of the experimental design (left) and confrontation assays (right) in which fungal strains were inoculated in potato dextrose agar (PDA) at dawn, that is, at lights on in the light:dark (LD or AM) cycle or at lights off in the dark:light cycle (DL or PM regime). In both cases, cultures were kept at 20°C during 7 days under the corresponding light regimes. (B) After 7 days of cultivation, overgrowth by T. atroviride was evaluated: red dotted lines indicate the edge of the latter over B. cinerea. A representative image of three biological replicates is shown. (C) Percentage of B. cinerea’s colony area covered by Trichoderma (percentage of overgrowth). Error bars represent the means ± SD of three biological replicates. Different letters indicate significant differences based on Tukey’s test (p<0.05).

In TaWT–B05.10 interactions under LD cycles, Trichoderma’s overgrowth was enhanced in plates inoculated at dawn (AM) rather than at dusk (PM) (Figure 5B and C, Supplementary file 3). The Δtafrq–B05.10 interactions behaved similarly to TaWT-B05.10, suggesting that TaFRQ does not cause the differential mycoparasitic behavior seen in LD (enhanced capacity under the AM inoculation protocol). In contrast, Δblr1 was capable of overgrowing WT Botrytis to the same extent in both AM and PM inoculation protocols, suggesting that indeed, BRL1 has a role in the differential outcome of interactions performed in LD cycles (Figure 5B and C, Supplementary file 3).

Centering the analysis on B. cinerea, Δbcfrq1 was overgrown by all Trichoderma strains to the same extent in both cycles (AM or PM), revealing the disappearance of the clock-related phenotypes observed for B05.10. Thus, frq mutants in Trichoderma and B. cinerea display major differences regarding their behavior. While the absence of TaFRQ does not alter the time-of-the-day difference in mycoparasitic interactions (against B05.10 and Δbcwcl1 strains), the lack of BcFRQ1 does, suggesting a major role for the latter in the outcome of the daily interactions. Regarding Δbcwcl1, it mimics the differences seen for B05.10 but is more aggressively overgrown by Trichoderma in the AM protocol. In total, these results show that both core clock components (WC-1 and FRQ) and the time of the day in which the interaction is staged affects the outcome of the fungal-fungal interactions, where the B. cinerea element (BcFRQ1), but not the T. atroviride TaFRQ element, appears as critical.

Secondary metabolism is affected in clock mutant strains of T. atroviride

Trichoderma species are prolific producers of SM that have been implicated in the effectiveness of mycoparasitism against pathogens (Reino et al., 2008). To identify whether the putative core clock components could affect SM production, we carried out a metabolic fingerprinting to obtain an overview of global SM produced by TaWT and core clock component mutant strains grown in PDA under LL, DD, and after a 4 hr LP.

Extracts of diffusible compounds were analyzed by direct injection to mass spectrometry. The production of 230 compounds was statistically different among strains and conditions (ANOVA p<0.05). The overview of diffusible compounds produced by TaWT, Δblr1, Δtafrq, and OE::tafrq in DD, LL, and LP (Figure 6A) indicates that production of diffusible compounds is particularly enhanced in Δtafrq in all conditions compared to TaWT, Δblr1, and OE::tafrq. In TaWT, 103 and 15 molecules showed a twofold induction in LL and LP compared to DD, respectively, which suggests that light induces the production of diffusible compounds in T. atroviride. A comparison of diffusible compound levels between TaWT and Δblr1 showed that 129 molecules were at least twofold reduced in LL in the mutant strain. Many compounds were induced after an LP and a few others in DD (Table 1).

Figure 6 with 1 supplement see all
Secondary metabolism is regulated by light conditions and T. atroviride core clock components.

A global overview of secondary metabolites produced by TaWT and clock mutant strains grown in LL, DD, and after a light pulse (LP) grown in potato dextrose agar (PDA) at 20°C. (A) Diffusible compounds are augmented in Δtafrq. (B) Normalized intensity values for two particular diffusible compounds are shown: 1679.08 m/z is light-induced in TaWT and light-repressed in Δblr1 and Δtafrq; 381.77 m/z showed enhanced production in Δtafrq and OE::tafrq in all culture conditions. (C) Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are induced by light in Δblr1 and Δtafrq. (D) Normalized intensity values for two VOCs: 6-PP (167.07 m/z) and 371.03 m/z. (E) For circadian VOCs production, TaWT and Δtafrq strains were grown in GYEC+ peas at 20°C during 3 days in LD 12:12 hr cycles and transferred to DD for circadian metabolic profiles. Samples were taken every 4 hr during 48 hr after the transition to DD. Circadian levels of ions 148.97 m/z and 81.59 m/z in TaWT, but arrhythmic in Δtafrq. Compounds 255.99 m/z and 110.94 m/z oscillate in neither strain.

Table 1
Induced and repressed diffusible and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in each mutant strain compared to TaWT in constant darkness (DD), constant light (LL), and light pulse (LP).
Diffusibles*VOCs
DDLLLPDDLLLP
IRIRIRIRIRIR
Δblr1/TaWT263-12966--517---
Δtafrq/TaWT67-1372218-2313162-10
OE::tafrq/TaWT34-38-128-----10-
  1. Data can be found in Table 1—source data 1.

  2. *

    Diffusible compounds with at least 2.0-fold change.

  3. Volatile organic compounds with at least 1.5-fold change.

  4. I=induced, R=repressed.

Table 1—source data 1

Fold changes of each comparison pair (Δblr1/TaWT, Δtafrq/TaWT and OE::tafrq/TaWT) can be found in a single individual sheet in the provided .xlsx file.

The table shows m/z value, fold change, and p-value for both diffusible and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) compounds produced in the three lighting conditions (LL, DD, and LP).

https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/71358/elife-71358-table1-data1-v2.xlsx

Among the diffusible compounds, the molecule 1679.08 m/z had an interesting behavior between strains and light conditions. In TaWT, this molecule showed the greatest fold induction in LL and LP compared to DD. On the contrary, in Δblr1, its production was reduced in LL, but it was high in DD compared to TaWT (Figure 6B). This suggests that BLR1 is necessary for light induction of several diffusible compounds in TaWT, including 1679.08 m/z, as their production is severely dampened in the Δblr1 mutant in LL. However, it seems that the production of a subset of diffusible molecules is either repressed in DD by BLR1 and/or additional photoreceptors are involved in light induction of diffusible molecules after an LP in Δblr1.

As mentioned, diffusible compounds are enhanced in Δtafrq, with several molecules showing at last a twofold induction compared to TaWT. The levels of some, like 381.77 m/z, appear downregulated in TaWT and Δblr1 but enhanced in Δtafrq (Figure 6A and B, Table 1). This suggests that TaFRQ represses the production of diffusible compounds under these conditions. On the contrary, TaFRQ could also have a positive role in the light-mediated biosynthesis of molecules such as 1679.08 m/z, which is one of the few downregulated compounds in Δtafrq in LL. Despite our findings, we did not observe a correlation between enhanced production of diffusible compounds with enhanced overgrowth of Trichoderma strains as Δtafrq has a weak overgrowth behavior (Figure 4). Finally, levels of the detected compounds in OE::tafrq are also high in the three experimental conditions compared to TaWT but less than in Δtafrq (Table 1). This suggests that the absence or misregulation of clock components causes an upregulation of SM, reinforcing the idea of extra-circadian roles for TaFRQ in secondary metabolism.

These analyses show that light induces the production of a group of diffusible compounds and that BLR1 and TaFRQ have distinct (opposite) roles in regulating such SMs.

As diffusible molecules represent only part of the metabolic complexity of Trichoderma, we also analyzed the profile of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) by measuring their production in vivo with a low-temperature plasma ionization MS (LTP-MS) under the same previously described conditions. The analyses revealed that the production of 131 compounds (in a 50–500 m/z range) was statistically different across all strains and growth conditions (ANOVA p<0.05). A global view of VOCs reveals an enhanced production in LL in Δblr1 and Δtafrq, with a group of VOCs mainly induced in Δblr1 and reduced in Δtafrq. On the contrary, in DD, many volatile compounds were upregulated in Δtafrq and downregulated in Δblr1 (Figure 6C).

As volatile compounds showed higher dispersion and a narrow range of variation, we analyzed molecules that were statistically different across strains and culture conditions, leading to over 1.5-fold change between TaWT and mutant strains. Comparison between Δblr1 and TaWT detected light-induced as well as dark-repressed compounds (Table 1) in Δblr1. In Δtafrq, several compounds were induced in DD and LL compared to TaWT, but also some compounds appeared as repressed in all three conditions for Δtafrq (Table 1). In Δtafrq, the compound 371.03 m/z had the highest production in DD compared to TaWT (Figure 6D). No significant differences were found between OE::tafrq and TaWT, except for enhanced production of few compounds after an LP in OE::tafrq (Table 1).

In TaWT, few VOCs depicted differences between light conditions, being one of them the well-known antifungal volatile compound 6-pentyl-α-pyrone (6-PP) (167.07 m/z). This compound showed to be induced in DD compared to LL, suggesting an inhibitory effect of light in 6-PP production (Figure 6D). In Δblr1, 6-PP production showed a 5.8-fold induction in LL, but no significant differences were observed in DD and LP compared to TaWT. A possible explanation is that BLR-1 could act as a repressor of 6-PP production in LL (which is consistent with the light repression of this molecule observed in TaWT and the augmented production in Δblr1 under LL); nevertheless, we cannot rule out that other photoreceptors could be involved in potentiating 6-PP production under LL in Δblr1 (Figure 6D). Interestingly, a dramatic reduction of 6-PP production was observed in Δtafrq in DD, LL, and LP (61, 10, and 3 negative fold change, respectively) (Figure 6D). These results clearly show that the profile of volatile compounds is also broadly altered in Δtafrq. The differences found in VOCs, particularly 6-PP production, correlate with (but cannot fully explain) the different biocontrol effectiveness of the tested strains in LL and DD conditions.

Finally, we performed a circadian metabolic profile measuring VOCs every 4 hr during 48 hr in DD conditions for TaWT and Δtafrq strains in GYEC+ peas plates. Rhythmicity of VOC levels was calculated using BioDare (with FFT-NLS and BD2eLTK cycle algorithms with a p-value<0.05), observing that 17 compounds exhibited a circadian profile with a calculated period between 24 and 26 hr in TaWT (Supplementary file 4). In Δtafrq, as expected, most compounds profiles (13 out of the 17) lost rhythmicity (see Supplementary file 4) and, importantly, the remaining four compounds (63.83 m/z, 90.83 m/z, 388.87 m/z, and 389.77 m/z) exhibited weak oscillatory behavior (e.g., reduced amplitude and altered phase) as determined after manual examination of compounds dynamics (Figure 6—figure supplement 1, Supplementary file 4). The circadian abundance of two ions (148.97 and 81.59 m/z) and two arrhythmic ions (259.99 and 110.94 m/z) are shown for comparison in Figure 6E. In total, these results suggest that the production of some VOCs in T. atroviride is under circadian control.

Discussion

While putative core clock components encoding genes can be found in fungi distributed between several orders (Montenegro-Montero et al., 2015; Salichos and Rokas, 2010), phenotypic description of fungal circadian phenomena has been less common, and the molecular characterization of those rhythms has been even scarcer. One of the few examples (besides N. crassa) is the characterization of the B. cinerea core clock and its effect on fungal virulence (Hevia et al., 2015). In our efforts to further understand the role of circadian clocks in fungal–fungal interactions, herein we provide evidence of a functional clock in the mycoparasitic fungus T. atroviride. TaFRQLUC reporter strains revealed circadian oscillations with a free-running period of ~26 hr, which could be entrained by LD cycles and reset by light and temperature pulses, consistent with what has been described in Neurospora and other organisms for bona fide circadian systems (Liu et al., 1998). These oscillations showed temperature compensation between 20 and 25°C, where, notably, the best rhythms in terms of amplitude were observed at 22°C, but they were lost at 28°C. While such a narrow range of temperatures allowing clear visualization of these molecular rhythms may be puzzling, it might also be associated with the environment in which Trichoderma is usually found – soil – in which temperature shifts are overall buffered (Rodriguez-Romero et al., 2010).

In the attempt to evaluate clock-controlled genes (ccg), we did not observe oscillations of additional luciferase transcriptional reporters of putative T. atroviride ccg promoters. This could be due to (i) the lack of circadian transcription of the assayed ccgs, (ii) the selected promoters fail to capture elements necessary for their circadian control, or (iii) the assay conditions were not appropriate to visualize their rhythmic expression (see below). Future analysis of the transcript levels of several ccgs will be performed under different culture conditions to confirm whether their expression is actually circadian in particular settings.

Interestingly, we found evidence of strong functional circadian conservation between Neurospora and Trichoderma. Firstly, conservation of clock cis-regulatory motifs, as the c-box sequence from the former is recognized in the latter fungus. As the DNA binding domains of WC-1 and BLR1 share a 97.2% aa identity, we hypothesize that the BRL1/BLR2 complex can recognize the Ncc-box element driving circadian oscillations and that a similar c-box sequence could be found in the tafrq promoter. Indeed, the high conservation of WC-1 and BLR1 DNA binding domains (Casas-Flores et al., 2004; Cervantes-Badillo et al., 2013; Froehlich et al., 2002) indicates that they are expected to recognize a similar motif considering general rules of eukaryotic transcription factor sequence specificity (Weirauch et al., 2014). Two putative light response elements in the tafrq’s promoter with a putative GATA box consensus sequence at proximal and distal locations (−355 to –319 and –1180 to –1171 from the TSS, respectively) have been postulated (Cervantes-Badillo et al., 2013), of which one of them could be acting as a putative Tacbox sequence.

We were able to generate ~26 hr rhythms in a Neurospora Δfrq strain complemented with the tafrq coding region, under the control of the Neurospora endogenous regulatory sequences. Comparison of the tafrq and ncfrq sequences informs a 54 and 50% of identity at the DNA and protein levels, respectively (using Clustal Omega multiple sequence alignment), which provides sufficient functional conservation to allow rescuing of the core clock function in a N. crassa arrhythmic strain. Most importantly, the fact that tafrq complements the function of the endogenous frq in Neurospora strongly validates the role of TaFRQ as a core clock circadian component. While we did not conduct some classic experiments such as the ones designed by Aronson et al., 1994, we present compelling evidence of the existence of such a functional circadian TTFL. Thus, in addition to the complementation itself, it is the fact that TaFRQ is indeed acting as a negative element in Neurospora, which can be clearly inferred by the overall decrease of WCC activity (as seen by the reduction in luciferase expression when compared to the recipient strain). Importantly, as we restored the core clock in Δfrq, the resulting oscillations reflected the endogenous ~26 hr period originally observed in T. atroviride, instead of the Neurospora WT rhythm of ~22 hr, implying that period determinants are encoded in the TaFRQ protein sequence and that they are ‘read’ by the rest of the circadian machinery in a proper manner, despite the phylogenetic distance of both genera. Thus, this not only further validates TaFRQ as a bona fide core clock component, but it also highlights how its sequence determinants modulate period. Additionally, we also confirmed that TaFRQ is phosphorylated and degraded as seen over a 12 hr time course, after a light to dark transfer, in accordance to Neurospora FRQ behavior. Recent studies have shown that the quality of FRQ regarding phosphorylation status rather than its stability or half-life is important for period length (Larrondo et al., 2015). Baker et al., 2009 partially characterized FRQ’s phosphocode in N. crassa, of which some mutations in these sites were experimentally shown to affect clock properties. In TaFRQ, 82.6% (19/23) of such sites are preserved, with the divergent ones all residing in the C-terminal portion of the protein, after the PEST-2 domain (Figure 2—figure supplement 3). The high conservation of known period-affecting phosphorylation sites could partially explain the ability of TaFRQ to function, whereas differential phosphorylation of TaFRQ compared to NcFRQ could potentially explain the longer period. Further analysis of TaFRQ characteristics and phosphorylation sites will shed additional light on the commonalities and peculiarities of the circadian clocks in these two fungi.

One of our study’s striking findings was the strong influence of culture media composition in allowing the visualization of molecular circadian oscillations. Indeed, rhythms in TaFRQLUC, or in Ncc-box-luc levels, were only observed in GYEC media and then further improved when plant-derived material was included. While the impact of nutrient availability in certain aspects of circadian rhythms has been observed from mammals to N. crassa (Bae et al., 2019; Oosterman et al., 2015), our results indicate an even bigger dependence on culture conditions in allowing molecular visualization of the Trichoderma clock. Thus, although the quality and other aspects of frq and clock-controlled genes can vary, depending on media characteristics in Neurospora (Díaz and Larrondo, 2020; Dunlap and Loros, 2017; Hurley et al., 2014; Larrondo et al., 2015; Olivares-Yañez et al., 2016) we were surprised to observe such a dramatic effect in Trichoderma: that is, an almost nutritional-conditional rhythmicity dependent on media-derived cues. Besides the puzzling and yet uncharacterized mechanism underlying this nutritional conditionality, we believe that this may serve as a cautionary tale for other attempts to characterize circadian rhythms in different fungi. If we had limited our analysis to a small set of media or higher temperatures, we would have been prone to conclude that there were no rhythms in Trichoderma TaFRQ levels. Yet, hitting the right conditions allowed us to confirm their existence and therefore the presence of a circadian oscillations in this organism. It is also provoking and an exciting lesson to consider that the addition of plant-derived material in a fungus that naturally interacts with plants has such a strong effect on visualizing these rhythms (see below).

In T. atroviride, the use of different carbon sources in culture media allows, in some cases, observation of photostimulation of growth and conidiation in the dark, processes in which BLR1 plays a critical role in carbon-source selectivity (Friedl et al., 2008a; Friedl et al., 2008b). Also, C:N ratios are relevant environmental factors influencing conidiation in Trichoderma (Steyaert et al., 2010b). Additionally, organic nitrogen sources in culture media have been described as important for fungal mycoparasitic behavior (Barnett, 1963). Also, nitrogen sources are known to affect growth in Trichoderma species (Danielson and Davey, 1973; Nolan and Nolan, 1972). Due to the importance of nutrients in such processes, we hypothesize that the high amounts of organic nitrogen found in GYEC media (derived from casamino acids and yeast extract, absent in the other tested media) to some extent may mimic the composition of Trichoderma’s natural niche, in which different nitrogen sources derived from its preys are available.

Moreover, the addition of peas could better resemble the nutrients or chemical features found in Trichoderma’s interaction with plants, including different sugars (Druzhinina et al., 2011; Steyaert et al., 2010b). The latter also raises fundamental questions about the importance of plant-derived signals in Trichoderma’s clock robustness and its role in the outcome of plant–fungal interactions. A complex temporal communication could be occurring during their interaction in the soil, affecting clock synchronization in Trichoderma. Indeed, the plant circadian clock could alter the composition and function of the rhizosphere microbiome as it has been observed in the rhizosphere of WT and long/short period mutants of A. thaliana (Hubbard et al., 2018). Rhythmically structured metabolic exchanges between the organisms in the community in collective benefit could be occurring (Sartor et al., 2019), although it still remains to be studied in this context.

These findings reinforce the importance of defined nutrient/temperature conditions to monitor the clockworks and help future fungal circadian studies visualize otherwise weak oscillations, like those observed in Pyronema confluens and Ophiocordyceps kimflemingiae (de Bekker et al., 2017; Traeger and Nowrousian, 2015). This could also help monitor frq molecular oscillations in fungi where previous attempts have failed, like in Verticillium dahliae, Aureobasidium pullulans, and Magnaporthe oryzae (Cascant-Lopez et al., 2020; Deng et al., 2015; Franco et al., 2017).

While frq in N. crassa does not have a described role outside the pacemaker (Aronson et al., 1994), in B. cinerea, it exhibits extra-circadian roles associated with developmental programs (Hevia et al., 2015). In T. atroviride, we observed that the core clock components play a role in development, secondary metabolism, and mycoparasitism. Thus, TaFRQ is critical for conidia formation after an LP and mechanical damage, showing a dramatic reduction of conidiation in the latter. In fungi, little is known about FRQ function besides N. crassa and B. cinerea. A recent study of frq in the phytopathogen V. dahliae found no significant phenotypic differences in the deletion strain regarding sporulation and microsclerotia formation in DD or LD (Cascant-Lopez et al., 2020). Similarly, in the entomopathogenic fungi Metarhizium robertsii, FRQ is necessary for ring formation under LD 12:12, although neither the WT nor the mutant strain displayed such rings under DD conditions. Besides this, M. robertsii FRQ is dispensable in almost all evaluated phenotypes (growth and conidiation in different stress conditions), including virulence against Galleria mellonella (Peng et al., 2022). Meanwhile, studies in Beauveria bassiana (in which two frq homologs exists) and M. oryzae strain Guy11 have shown that their frq knockouts exhibit diminished conidiation and virulence against G. mellonella (Tong et al., 2021) and rice seedlings (Shi et al., 2019), respectively. These findings pose new questions regarding the role in developmental decisions that FRQ may have acquired (or lost) across the fungal kingdom, raising questions about the extra-circadian role of clock negative elements in other organisms, including animals.

We found altered developmental responses and enhanced production of diffusible and volatile compounds in Δtafrq, suggesting a general repressor regulatory role of TaFRQ over secondary metabolism. Interestingly, the antifungal compound 6-PP, a key feature of Trichoderma species, was dramatically reduced in Δtafrq even in LL. The clock function is expected to be abolished in LL, suggesting, therefore, a potential TaFRQ extra-circadian activator role in 6-PP production.

SMs have been related to developmental programs in fungi and could have a role in response to damage in T. atroviride (Atriztán-Hernández et al., 2019; Schmoll et al., 2010; Tisch and Schmoll, 2010). Reports show that after injury and fungivory a group of VOCs, including 6-PP, increase in TaWT but not in the MAPK mutant Δtmk3 (Atriztán-Hernández et al., 2019), which shows diminished conidiation after an injury as observed in the Δtafrq mutant (Medina-Castellanos et al., 2014). Additionally, it was previously suggested that oxylipin could be involved in signaling after damage (Medina-Castellanos et al., 2014). We propose that the reduction of injury-induced conidiation in Δtafrq could be related to its dysregulated diffusible and VOC production profiles, in which further studies identifying those compounds could shed light on their role in injury-induced conidiation. On the contrary, Δblr1 showed repressed production of several compounds (diffusible and VOCs), suggesting a role of light perception in secondary metabolism regulation. This is consistent with the light-induced production of several compounds in TaWT.

Interestingly, Δblr1 produced higher amounts of 6-PP in DD and even in LL, whereas in TaWT, 6-PP production is inhibited by light. This suggests a repressor role of light and BLR1 in the production of 6-PP and other molecules, as seen for 1679.08 m/z, and that other photoreceptors could activate its production in the absence of BLR1 (Garcia-Esquivel et al., 2016). A light-repression effect on 6-PP production was also observed in T. atroviride P1 and IMI 206040 strains when 6-PP production was analyzed under LD and DD conditions (Speckbacher et al., 2020a; Contreras-Cornejo et al., 2022) and when grown in different light wavelengths (Moreno-Ruiz et al., 2020). We also observed differences in the SM profiles between LL and LP conditions, indicating that the duration of light stimuli differently activates/represses the production of several compounds. Whereas a short light exposure could be perceived as a strong environmental cue triggering the production of different metabolites, constant exposure to light could lead to a prolonged stress response marked by a different subset of metabolites. Light regulation of SMs has been reported in several fungi (Tisch and Schmoll, 2010) as the involvement of WC-1 homologs in Cercospora zeae-maydis and Fusarium graminearum as repressors of cercosporin and trichothecene production, respectively (Kim et al., 2014; Kim et al., 2011). Nevertheless, the involvement of TaFRQ in the production of SMs in T. atroviride (or FRQ of any other fungus) has not been reported to date.

In concordance with the circadian oscillations of TaFRQLUC, we observed rhythmic levels of volatile SMs in T. atroviride under constant conditions (DD) but not in Δtafrq, suggesting circadian control of the production of these volatile compounds. Our experimental approach showed that these molecules exhibited rhythmic levels. Nevertheless, it did not provide their molecular identity. We expect future work to dive into their chemical identification and their specific role in T. atroviride’s lifestyle.

Overall, our results reinforce the importance of environmental perception (including time) in Trichoderma’s biology, particularly in the production of SMs involved in several processes from development to mycoparasitism. On the contrary, in Neurospora how these daily rhythms impact metabolite levels has not been described so far, despite ample efforts that have systematically shown the clock’s influence on its transcriptome and proteome (Hurley et al., 2014; Hurley et al., 2018; Sancar et al., 2015), suggesting temporal compartmentalization of metabolism at large, with catabolic and anabolic reactions concentrated at dawn and dusk, respectively (Hurley et al., 2016). Thus, we present a proof of concept that a fungal circadian clock can also impact the production of SMs. These studies and future comprehensive analyses of circadian metabolic profiles in classic models such as Neurospora and other fungi will help to bridge the gap on how clock regulation impacts a fungus’s daily life, from physiology to organismal interactions.

Our study also provides new insights into the mycoparasitic interaction between T. atroviride and B. cinerea and how its outcome is regulated by core clock components and LD conditions. Δblr1 showed the strongest mycoparasitic behavior; in contrast, Δtafrq did not show significant differences to TaWT in most interactions, except a slightly weaker mycoparasitic behavior against Δbcwcl1 and Δbcfrq1 in LL. Trichoderma species' antagonistic capacity is correlated with their ability to produce 6-PP (Reino et al., 2008). The Δblr1 strain has higher amounts of this molecule, whereas, in Δtafrq, its production is severely dampened, consistent with their different mycoparasitic abilities. Trichoderma’s antagonist capacity was reduced in LL and enhanced in darkness, which could be due to differential metabolite profiles found in LL and DD. Similar inhibitory effects of light in mycoparasitism in T. atroviride have been reported against Fusarium oxysporum (Moreno-Ruiz et al., 2020; Speckbacher et al., 2020b), along with differential VOC production upon illumination during confrontation assays. High amounts of 2-heptanone are produced during the confrontation against F. oxysporum in a light-dependent manner that negatively correlates with Trichoderma antagonism, which proposes that 2-heptanone production was a result of a stress response elicited by F. oxysporum in the light.

Finally, mycoparasitic interactions under a circadian paradigm revealed an enhanced overgrowth of TaWT and Δtafrq over B05.10 and Δbcwcl1 when interactions started at dawn under LD cycles in contrast to a reduced overgrowth at dusk. We have previously observed differential interactions in the context of B. cinerea and A. thaliana, where fungal virulence was enhanced at dusk (Hevia et al., 2015). The differential effect on the Trichoderma–Botrytis dynamic was lost when Δblr1 was used against all B. cinerea strains. A similar phenomenon was observed by Hevia et al., 2015, when A. thaliana was infected with Δbcwcl1, which did not show circadian behavior. Disruption of BLR1 abrogates both light and circadian responses, so the effect observed for Δblr1 could also be due to a light-driven phenomenon (besides a circadian effect) because the absence of the blue-light perception overrides the differential effect observed in TaWT. Yet, it is noteworthy that Δtafrq yields result comparable to what is seen in TaWT, suggesting that – paradoxically – the observed time-of-the-day effect does not appear to strongly depend on the T. atroviride’s clock.

On the other hand, under LD cycles, the loss of BcWCL1 does not considerably affect these fungal dynamics, whereas, in Δbcfrq1, the differential outcome of the daily interaction disappears. Lack of BcFRQ1 implies that temporal perception in B. cinerea is absent, in concordance with the loss of the time-of-the-day observed phenotype, something that is not seen when Trichoderma lacks TaFRQ. This suggests that the B. cinerea clock is critical in the outcome of the interaction of tested organisms – both plants and fungi – suggesting a complex mechanism in which light and time perception interact, giving rise to the observed phenotypes. Even though we lack a precise molecular understanding underlying this phenomenon (and integrating the role of the different clock/light-perception components), this work constitutes the first description of an interplay of core and light regulation in a mycoparasitic interaction. In nature, organisms are usually exposed to light/dark transitions. Therefore, the differential outcome depending on the time (or the light/dark cycles) at which confrontations are established could impact biocontrol strategies in agriculture, optimizing the application of Trichoderma in crops.

Materials and methods

Fungal strains and culture conditions

Request a detailed protocol

T. atroviride IMI 206040, initially isolated from a plum tree of the Czar variety in an orchard in Urshult near Växjö in southern Sweden (EFSA European Food Safety, 2015), was used as wild-type strain (TaWT) and, along with Δblr1, described by Casas-Flores et al., 2004, were kindly provided by Dr. Alfredo Herrera-Estrella. Strains were maintained in potato dextrose agar (PDA) in constant light at 25°C. B. cinerea B05.10 Pers. Fr. [Botryotinia fuckeliana (de Bary) Whetzel] was initially isolated from Vitis vinifera (Germany) and was provided by the Tudzinsky laboratory (WWU, Germany). B. cinerea clock mutant strains Δbcwcl1 and Δbcfrq1 used in this study were described earlier (Canessa et al., 2013; Hevia et al., 2015). B. cinerea strains were cultivated in PDA at 20°C in LD 12:12 hr cycles. All fungal strains were grown in Percival incubators, equipped with cold white-light fluorescent tubes (light intensity up to 100 μM/m2s; wavelength 400–720 nm). The incubators were housed inside a darkroom equipped with safety-red lights to allow proper circadian experiments.

Generation of Δtafrq, ΔtafrqC, and OE::tafrq mutant strains

Request a detailed protocol

The tafrq ORF was replaced by the hygromycin resistance cassette (hph), as described (Canessa et al., 2013; Figure 3—figure supplement 1, Supplementary file 5). To generate the complemented Δtafrq strain (ΔtafrqC), we fused the tafrq ORF with a fleomycin resistance cassette (bleoR) and directed it back to its endogenous locus by homologous recombination (Figure 3—figure supplement 3, Supplementary file 5). To overexpress tafrq, we placed tafrq under control of the T. atroviride actin promoter (1210 bp) with hph as a selection marker. All constructions were assembled using yeast chromosomal recombination (Oldenburg et al., 1997). The OE::tafrq construct was integrated by homologous recombination into the intergenic blu17 region, previously demonstrated not to affect mycoparasitism behavior (Supplementary file 6; Balcazar-Lopez et al., 2016).

Generation of luciferase reporter strains

Request a detailed protocol

The TaFRQLUC strains were designed and generated, as previously reported by Larrondo et al., 2012. Briefly, the tafrq gene was fused by homologous recombination at its endogenous locus to an N. crassa codon-optimized luciferase gene (luc), and hph used as a selection marker (Figure 1—figure supplement 1, Supplementary file 7). On the other hand, the transcriptional reporter strain, termed ncc-box-luc, was designed as reported by Larrondo et al., 2015. We cloned a 505 bp sequence containing the c-box sequence from the N. crassa frq promoter to control luc expression, and the construct was integrated into the intergenic region of blu17 (Supplementary file 8; Balcazar-Lopez et al., 2016). To develop transcriptional reporters of hypothetical clock-controlled genes (ccg) in T. atroviride, we used a promoter region of different genes as follows: 768 bp from TRIATDRAF_77441, homologous to ccg-9 (trehalose synthase in N. crassa), 1159 bp from TRIATDRAF_297741, homologous to glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase of N. crassa, 485 bp from TRIATDRAF_298583 homologous to superoxide dismutase of N. crassa and 1000 bp from TRIATDRAFT_291013 homologous to con-10. The promoters were used to control luc expression, and the constructs were integrated into the intergenic blu17 region (Supplementary file 8; Balcazar-Lopez et al., 2016).

Heterologous expression of tafrq in N. crassa Δfrq strain

Request a detailed protocol

A construct containing a 5′ recombination flank (1000 bp), the native 5′UTR from N. crassa frq, the tafrq ORF followed by a V5-His6 tag, the native 3′UTR from frq, the bar cassette for resistance selection (Larrondo et al., 2009), and a 3′ recombination flank (1000 bp) was constructed using yeast recombination cloning (Oldenburg et al., 1997). The resulting construct was used to transform a N. crassa Δfrq strain containing a his-3::frqcbox-luc reporter (Figure 2—figure supplement 2). To obtain homokaryotic isolates, strains complemented with tafrq were crossed to a WT strain containing Neurospora frq (not associated with any marker or tag) and lacking a reporter. Ignite-resistant, luc+ progeny was selected out of the cross, and the targeted integration of tafrq (and absence of Neurospora frq) was confirmed by PCR (Supplementary file 9). Δncfrq:tafrq strains were assessed for conidial banding using race tubes grown in two different conditions, DD conditions for 8 days and LD (12:12 hr) for 5 days followed by DD for 3 days, alongside positive and negative controls, as described in Baker et al., 2012.

Transformation of T. atroviride

Request a detailed protocol

PEG-mediated protoplast transformation was performed as described by Casas-Flores et al., 2004 and Herrera-Estrella et al., 1990. All transformants were subjected to 3–5 rounds of single-spore isolation, and gene replacement and integration events were verified using Southern blot using the DIG Easy Hyb Hybridization solution (Roche) following the manufacturer’s instructions. The hph gene was used as a probe (Figure 1—figure supplement 1, Figure 3—figure supplement 1).

Assessment of luminescence in vivo

Request a detailed protocol

For evaluating rhythmic levels of bioluminescence produced by the different luciferase reporter strains in T. atroviride, spores from 7-day-old colonies were resuspended in sterile water, filtrated using sterile glass wool, and kept for 48 hr at 4°C. Then, 30 µL of spore suspension were inoculated in individual wells of 96-well plates containing different culture media (Supplementary file 1). Luciferin was added to each media to a final concentration of 2.5 mM. The reporter strains received LD 12:12 entrainment at 20, 22, 25, and 28°C. Luminescence traces were captured using a PIXIS 1024B CCD camera (Princeton Instruments) under constant darkness (DD) conditions at the indicated temperatures. For LL (constant light) resetting, strains were grown 72 hr in continuous light at 25°C before transferring to DD for bioluminescence measurements. For the 4°C pulses, strains were incubated for 48 hr in LL at 25°C and then moved to 4°C for 6 hr in complete darkness before measurements. For the LP experiments, strains were incubated for 48 hr in LL, transferred to DD for 24 hr, and then received a 20 min LP at 25°C, and transferred back to DD. Bioluminescence was acquired using the WinView software (version 2.5.23.0) and subsequently analyzed using ImageJ employing a custom-made macro. As indicated therein, we present raw or normalized data (align to mean) in different graphs. Circadian parameters, such as period and phase, were calculated using FFT-NLLS, which fits a sine wave to the data to estimate period, phase, and amplitude using the BioDare online platform (Zielinski et al., 2014).

The different tested culture media are indicated in Supplementary file 1. In particular to prepare GYEC+ peas (0.5% W/V), we extensively grind frozen commercial peas in a coffee grinder and saved it as a frozen powder.

For the evaluation of N. crassa luciferase reporter strains, spores from 5-day-old slant cultures containing minimal media were resuspended in sterile water. Then, 15 μL of spore suspension were inoculated in individual wells of 96-well plates containing LNN-CCD media (Larrondo et al., 2015) supplemented with quinic acid (QA, 0.01 M). Luciferin was added to each media to a final concentration of 25 μM. The reporter strains received LD 12:12 entrainment at 25°C for 72 hr prior to CCD monitoring.

Luciferase signals were acquired with a PIXIS 1024B camera (Princeton Instruments) and quantified with a customized macro developed for the ImageJ software; luminescent signals were recorded for 5 min, three times per hour for 5 days. Circadian parameters, such as period and phase, were calculated using fast Fourier transform nonlinear least squaresFFT-NLS, which fits a sine wave to the data to estimate period, phase, and amplitude using the BioDare 2.0 online platform (biodare2.ed.ac.uk; Zielinski et al., 2014). For N. crassa, linear detrending was performed before the period estimation.

RNA extraction and reverse transcription

Request a detailed protocol

For overexpression analysis of tafrq in T. atroviride, strains were grown in PDA cellophane-covered plates for 48 hr in LL or DD at 25°C. Approximately 10 mg of tissue was collected from each plate and snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen. Frozen mycelia were ground to powder and total RNA was extracted using TRIzol. Total RNA quantity and quality were determined using a NanoDrop spectrophotometer. Three independent biological replicates for each condition were analyzed.

Prior to cDNA synthesis, 3 μg of total RNA was treated with RQ1 RNase-free DNase and the absence of contaminating genomic DNA in the RNA samples was checked with real-time PCR (qPCR), with RNA as template (i.e., –RT control; data not shown). Reverse transcription was performed on 1 μg of total RNA using SuperScript III First-Strand Synthesis SuperMix for RT-qPCR.

Assay efficiency was assessed using serial dilutions (1/10) of a qPCR product (one product for each set of primers). Each dilution was used as a DNA template, and a standard qPCR reaction was performed. Primer efficiency was determined using the qPCR Software CFX Maestro (Bio-Rad). Specificity was evaluated by both melt curve and agarose gel analyses. All qPCR reactions were run in the CFX Real-Time PCR – Bio-Rad utilizing SensiMix SYBR Hi-ROX kit and primers for tafrq as well as normalizing genes (Supplementary file 10).

Protein extracts and immunoblots

Request a detailed protocol

To detect TaFRQLUC oscillations at protein levels, TaFRQLUC reporter strains were subjected to a time-course experiment in GYEC+ peas culture media, for which samples were taken every 4 hr for 52 hr, following a time-course protocol similar to the ones in Neurospora (Larrondo et al., 2015), except that T. atroviride cultures were kept in DD, and reset by a strong LP to mimic an LL to DD transition. Proteins were extracted as described by Kilani et al., 2020. Protein concentration was determined by the Bradford method, using the Bio-Rad Protein Assay (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc, CA). For immunoblot analyses, total protein extracts (50 μg of protein per lane) were separated in 4–15% Mini-PROTEAN TGX Precast gels (Bio-Rad #456-1086) and transferred to PVDF membranes (Bio-Rad) using the Trans-Blot Turbo RTA Transfer Kit (Bio-Rad #170-4272). The membranes were blocked overnight in phosphate-buffered saline solution (PBS-T: 137 mM NaCl, 2.7 mM KCl, 10 mM Na2HPO4, 2 mM KH2PO4, and 0.1% Tween-20) with 5% non-fat dried milk at 4°C. To detect FRQLUC protein, a luciferase antibody C-12 (sc-74548, Santa Cruz Biotechnology Inc, TX) was used at a 1:250 dilution and as secondary antibody Goat Anti-Mouse IgG(H+L)-HRP conjugate at a 1:5000 dilution.

For a mini time course of TaFRQ expression in N. crassa, 30 μL of resuspended spores from 5-day-old slant were inoculated in plates containing a liquid medium comprised of 1× Vogel’s salts, 2% sucrose, 0.5% arginine, and 50 ng/mL biotin for 2 days at 25°C in constant light conditions. From these pre-inoculates, tissue pads of 5 mm were cut and inoculated on plates with solid media using cellophane-covered Petri dishes with 25 mL LNN-CDD media supplemented with 0.01 M QA (Larrondo et al., 2015). For each short time course, plates were inoculated in triplicate per strain and incubated at 25°C in constant light. After 48 hr, the first cultures were harvested in light (time = 0 hr) while the others were transferred to dark conditions (25°C) and harvested every 2 hr under a safe red light. Samples were ground in liquid nitrogen and protein extracted as described above. As positive and negative controls, plates of N. crassa expressing FRQV5 (XC2116-10) and the Δfrq recipient (XC1783-4a) strains, respectively, were harvested after 48 hr in light.

For Western blot analysis, between 40 and 50 μg of total protein was loaded per lane after determination of concentration by Bradford assay (Bradford, 1976). Anti-V5 antibody (Invitrogen) was used at 1:5000 and a as secondary one we utilized Anti-Mouse IgG(H+L)-HRP (Thermo Fisher). SuperSignal West Pico ECL (Pierce Chemical, Rockford, IL) was used for signal development. For dephosphorylation reactions, lambda protein phosphatase (New England Biolabs, Cat# P0753L) was used according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

Confrontation assay between B. cinerea and T. atroviride

Request a detailed protocol

To evaluate the role of circadian regulation on B. cinerea and T. atroviride interactions, confrontations assays were conducted as a modified version of Bell, 1982. Overgrowth was calculated as the percentage of the B. cinerea colony that was covered by Trichoderma. TaWT and clock mutant strains of both fungi were grown in PDA at 20°C for B. cinerea and PDA and GYEC at 25°C for T. atroviride, during 3 days either in constant light (LL), darkness (DD) (Figure 4A), or in opposite LD cycles (LD AM and LD PM) (Figure 5A). Mycelial plugs of each strain were inoculated on opposite sides of 90 mm × 15 mm Petri dishes, 1 cm from the edge, and kept at 20°C in LL, DD, and LD conditions (as indicated in each case). Digital images were acquired after 7 days of interaction. The analyses of the photos were performed using the ImageJ software, employing an external calibration scale.

Conidiation response assays

Request a detailed protocol

For light-induced conidiation, we cultivated Trichoderma strains in PDA at 25°C in LL for 7 days and collected and quantified conidia at 3 and 7 days of growth. For LP conidiation assays, strains were grown in PDA at 25°C in DD for 36 hr. White LPs of 1 or 60 min were given, and cultures were maintained in DD for an additional 48 hr, after which conidia were quantified. For injury-induced conidiation, strains were grown in PDA at 25°C in DD for 32–36 hr and damaged with a scalpel in DD using a red safety light and incubated for an additional 48 hr in the dark. Subsequently, as in previous cases, conidia were collected in sterile water and quantified by direct counting in a Neubauer chamber. For statistical analyses, ANOVA was used, and significance was determined using Tukey’s test with a threshold of p<0.05.

Secondary metabolic fingerprinting

Request a detailed protocol

The effect of core clock components and light in Trichoderma SM profiles was determined by growing strains for 48 hr in PDA at 25°C in LL or DD. A group of dark-growing strains received a 4 hr LP. TaWT and Δtafrq strains were grown in GYEC with 0.5% peas during 3 days in LD 12:12 hr cycles and transferred to DD for circadian metabolic profiles. Samples were taken every 4 hr during 48 hr after the transition to DD.

Diffusible compounds analyses were carried out using direct liquid injection mass spectrometry (DLI-MS). Mycelia of the strains grown in PDA in LL, DD, and LP conditions, were harvested and extracted with 1 mL of a mix of high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)-grade ethyl acetate, methanol, and dichloromethane 3:2:1 with 1% formic acid. The samples were sonicated for 20 min at room temperature at 40 kHz and centrifuged at 15,000 rpm for 20 min. The supernatant was transferred to a clean Eppendorf tube, and the solvent was evaporated at room temperature. Extracts were weighed and resuspended in methanol to 0.05 mg/mL. A 1/10 dilution was injected in the DLI-MS in positive ESI mode using an LCQ Fleet ion trap mass spectrometer. The spectra were acquired in the positive mode in an m/z range of 500–2000. For VOC analysis, the LTP-MS device was used as described by Martínez-Jarquín et al., 2016 and Martínez-Jarquín and Winkler, 2013. The Petri dish was placed under the plasma. The spectra were acquired in the positive mode in an m/z range of 50–500. In both analyses (DLI and LTP MS), six biological replicates were used for each condition.

Data analysis

Request a detailed protocol

The mass spectra raw data were converted to mzML open format with ProteoWizard (Kessner et al., 2008) and analyzed in the R statistical programming language using the MALDIquant package (Gibb and Strimmer, 2012). All spectra were aligned and corrected for compiling a data matrix. For LL, DD, and LP culture conditions, data were filtered using interquartile range (IQR) and scaled using autoscaling (mean-centered and divided by each variable’s standard deviation). Significant differences in mean abundance among metabolites in different samples were assessed with ANOVA, and significance was determined using Tukey’s test with a threshold of p<0.05. A heatmap correlation matrix was built to visualize metabolic variations in all analyzed strains and experimental conditions with statistically significant metabolites (ANOVA). The Euclidean distance and Ward algorithm were used for clustering in the MetaboAnalyst platform (Pang et al., 2020). Fold change and t-test were calculated in pairs using the mean value of raw data for each comparison. A 2-fold change cutoff was established for diffusible and 1.5-fold change for volatile compounds.

For circadian VOC studies, a Bayesian analysis was executed using all 10 micro-scans taken as individual scans to identify ions related to the sample or noise (ambient noise and for GYEC+ 0.5% peas medium). The Bayesian analysis shows the percentage of the ion related to the sample: ions with 0% were eliminated. Adjustment of intensities was made on the spectra matrix made with means of the micro-scans. Determination of period and rhythmicity was carried out in the BioDare platform (Zielinski et al., 2014) using FFT-NLLS and BD2eJTK with p<0.05.

Data availability

All data generated and analyzed during this study are included in the manuscript and supporting files. Source data files have been provided for Figures 1 and 2 and Table 1.

References

  1. Book
    1. Casas-Flores S
    2. Herrera-Estrella A
    (2013) The influence of light on the biology of trichoderma
    In: Mukherjee PK, editors. Trichoderma: Biology and Applications. CABI. pp. 43–66.
    https://doi.org/10.1079/9781780642475.0043
    1. Oosterman JE
    2. Kalsbeek A
    3. la Fleur SE
    4. Belsham DD
    (2015) Impact of nutrients on circadian rhythmicity
    American Journal of Physiology. Regulatory, Integrative and Comparative Physiology 308:R337–R350.
    https://doi.org/10.1152/ajpregu.00322.2014

Decision letter

  1. Antonis Rokas
    Reviewing Editor; Vanderbilt University, United States
  2. Detlef Weigel
    Senior Editor; Max Planck Institute for Biology Tübingen, Germany
  3. Kevin Fuller
    Reviewer

In the interests of transparency, eLife publishes the most substantive revision requests and the accompanying author responses.

Decision letter after peer review:

Thank you for submitting your article "Circadian oscillations in Trichoderma atroviride and the role of core clock components in secondary metabolism, development, and mycoparasitism against the phytopathogen Botrytis cinerea" for consideration by eLife. Your article has been reviewed by 3 peer reviewers, and the evaluation has been overseen by a Reviewing Editor and Detlef Weigel as the Senior Editor. The following individual involved in review of your submission has agreed to reveal their identity: Kevin Fuller (Reviewer #2).

The reviewers have discussed their reviews with one another, and the Reviewing Editor has drafted this to help you prepare a revised submission.

Essential revisions:

The reviewers have made several constructive suggestions that you should carefully consider and address in a point-by-point reply. In particular, please pay particular attention to the following revisions:

1) Please perform experiments that demonstrate entrainment (as suggested by Reviewer #1).

2) Please perform the interaction assays across a range of environmental conditions (nutritional, temperature) to determine if the contributions of the clock proteins (in either organism) change accordingly (as suggested by Reviewer #2).

3) Please re-complement your mutants (as suggested by Reviewer #3).

Reviewer #1:

The goal of this study was to establish that the fungus Trichoderma atroviride, and important biocontrol agent, has a circadian clock, and to test if this clock plays a role in development, secondary metabolite production, and mycoparasitism. The authors clearly establish rhythms in the organism that are dependent on TcFRQ, a homolog of the core clock component FRQ in N. crassa, and show that TcFRQ and BRL1, the homolog of the blue light photoreceptor and core clock component WC-1 in N. crassa, play differing roles in development, metabolite levels, and mycoparasitism in laboratory conditions. However, the authors do not fully establish that the rhythms are controlled by a circadian clock , nor that TcFRQ is a core clock component. While aspects of this work will be of interest to circadian and fungal biologists, the not all of the aims were met, and the data do not fully support the conclusions.

Strengths: The circadian clock in the fungus N. crassa serves as an important model for understanding the mechanisms that keep time in eukaryotes, and how this clock controls daily rhythms in gene expression. However, little is known about clocks in other fungi, despite conservation of core clock components found in N. crassa, including fungal pathogens and biocontrol agents like Trichoderma. Thus, the strength of this work is in that it goes a long way to establish a clock in T. atroviride that is directly, or indirectly involved in controlling development, metabolism, and mycoparasitism. Importantly, this work opens up the opportunity to determine how the clock impacts fungal-fungal interactions, with the potential of using this to improve biocontrol.

Weaknesses: There are several weaknesses. The first is that while the authors established conditions to demonstrate two canonical properties needed to establish a circadian clock, a free running rhythm that is close to 24 h and temperature compensation, the authors did not fully test one of the cardinal properties of a circadian clock, entrainment. Second, the authors do not establish that TcFRQ is a core component of the clock oscillator. Third, the authors made conclusions from a strain that is supposed to overexpress TcFRQ from an actin promoter but, there is no data demonstrating that TcFRQ is actually overexpressed. Fourth, the rationale for concluding that TcFRQ has an extra-clock role, as opposed to a clock role, in development and metabolism is not clear Finally, a red safety light was used in all circadian experiments in constant dark; however, there is no data to support that T. atroviride is not responsive to red light.

Figure 1 While these data support the existence of a circadian clock in this organism based on free running rhythms and temperature compensation, it is important to provide additional data to demonstrate that the rhythm is entrained, one of the 3 criteria established in the field.

a. To demonstrate circadian entrainment, as opposed to a direct response to the environmental cues, specifically light, they need to examine different length LD cycles to demonstrate that the clock entrains to the different cycles. In addition, to demonstrate that an acute light or temperature pulse is resetting the clock, as opposed to masking, a a phase response curve is needed to show advances and delays. It is not clear what phase the light pulse was given in Figure 1D.

b. In the Supplement to Figure 2, several genes are arrhythmic under conditions in which TAFRQLUC is rhythmic. This is an important control to show, for example, that there is not a rhythm in ATP levels that might be driving the rhythm in the TAFRQLUC reporter. I would like to see this mentioned earlier in relation to Figure 1.

c. It would be helpful to know circadian time in Figure 1, and of interest to know if the peak time is similar to N. crassa FRQ.

Figure 2 demonstrates that the cis-acting promoter element of N. crassa frq that bound by the positive element, the WCC, is necessary for frq mRNA rhythms and functioning of the feedback loop, is sufficient to drive rhythms in luciferase in T. atroviride in DD, and is responsive to light and temperature pulses. This experiment suggests that there is conservation of the c-box, and raises the possibility that TAFRQ functions similarly in the T. atroviride clock as a negative element; however, this experiment raises more questions than it answers, and therefore seems premature. There are several instances in the paper where TaFRQ is called a core clock component, but there are no data to support this claim.

a. Is there a similar sequence present in the promoter of TAFRQ? If so, what happens if this sequence is mutated?

b. What happens to the rhythm, levels, of TAFRQ in a Blr1 deletion or mutated strain?

c. Additional experiments are needed to show that Blr1 binds to this sequence and to fully describe TAFRQ role in the clock mechanism.

In Supplementary file 1, 2A, B and C, they examine if TaFRQ has a role in development, and this is supported by the data presented by comparing WT versus TaFRQ deletion strains. They show that conidia formation is delayed in the mutant compared to WT, and decreased following light treatment or injury. In addition, they also examined a construct aimed at overexpressing TaFRQ (OE::TaFRQ) using the actin promoter. No differences were observed between WT and OE::TaFRQ; however, it is difficult to make any conclusions here because there were no experiments demonstrating that TaFRQ was actually overexpressed in this strain.

Figure 3 examines the ability of T. atroviride to overgrow B. cinerea under different lighting conditions and in mutants as an indicator of mycoparasitic behavior. The key findings were that constant light inhibits overgrowth, and that mutations in blr1 in T. atroviride enhances overgrowth in constant darkness. However, it is not clear how these data and those that follow establish and extra-clock role for TaFRQ in these processes.

Figure 4 looks at dawn and dusk confrontations between T. atroviride and B. cinereai in LD cycles. They found that WT T. atroviride and TaFRQ deletion strains had overgrowth that was enhanced at dawn, whereas deletion of TaBLR1 did not show a time of day difference. However, when frq was deleted in B. cinerea, all T. atroviride strains overgrew. These data supported that homologs of N. crassa clock components in T. atroviride and B. cinereai play differing roles in time of day specific interactions, and this information could prove useful in biocontrol measures in the future.

Figure 5 examines if T. atroviride FRQ and BLR1 mutants alter secondary metabolism by examining diffusible and volatile compounds in DD and LL, and following a light pulse. They found several differences, but were unable to correlate these with the overgrowth experiments in Figures 3 and 4. A circadian metabolic profile demonstrated that some compounds were rhythmic in WT and arrhythmic in taFRQ deletion cells. These data provide evidence to support a role for a clock in controlling metabolism in T. atroviride.

Discussion: The paper lacks definitive experiments to show that taFRQ is a core clock component, and therefore, it is not clear how these data support a extra-circadian role for taFRQ. In addition, aspects of the discussion are very lengthy, especially the section describing how this work could foster looking for clocks in other fungi.

Methods:

a. It is critical to show that T. atroviride is not sensitive to red light given red safety lights were used in circadian experiments.

b. The constructs used to examine potential rhythms in known fungal ccgs used the promoter, but not the 3' ends of the genes. The authors may want to consider adding this in the future.

Supplemental Figures

1.4 In part A, the light pulse did not seem to improve the rhythm similar to what was shown in Figure 1. What the light pulse given at the same time of day?

1.5. When was the light pulse given? These data should be plotted.

2.1. The data in A appear different from Figure 2A, although it appears to be the same experiment.

File 1. This figure is difficult to follow.

File 2: It is not clear if the plot in B represents 3 or 7 days after a light pulse.

Reviewer #2:

In this manuscript, Henríquez-Urrutia and colleagues establish the existence of a core circadian rhythm in the mycoparasitic fungus Trichoderma atroviride. Using both translational and transcriptional reporters for a core clock component, FRQ/frq, the authors demonstrate that the rhythm meets all the requirements of bona fide circadian oscillator, e.g. entrainment and temperature compensation. Interestingly and importantly, they demonstrate that the robustness of the oscillation is largely dependent on the nutritional environment; specifically, the rhythm was only discernable under growth conditions that likely resemble the natural environment of the fungus. This information will be of keen interest to the chronobiology community, particularly those that attempting to identify a clock in their microbe of interest. Moreover, the authors demonstrate that two processes are under control of the Trichoderma clock, or at least under the regulation of clock components: (1) secondary metabolism, and (2) the myoparasitic interaction with another fungus, Botrytis. Although the connection between those two phenomena in this study is unclear, together they demonstrate the importance of biological clocks in regulating fungal behaviors of interest. Understanding how the time-of-day influences fungal parasitism, for example, could inform the optimization of fungi as biocontrol agents in the agricultural setting. In conclusion, the work provided here is novel, the conclusions are supported by the data, the ideas are well-marshalled. Consequently, I believe this would be would be a good fit for eLife and its readership. However, the manuscript may be strengthened by an expanded discussion or additional experiments as outlined below.

1) The authors do an excellent job in defining how environmental parameters (e.g. nutrients and temperature), influence the robustness of Trichoderma core oscillation. It is therefore surprising that the Trichoderma/Botrytis interaction assays were not analyzed across a similar variety of conditions. For example, the authors performed the interaction assays on PDA media at 20C, the data from which support the conclusion the Trichoderma FRQ does not significantly influence its parasitism of Botrytis. However, what would these results look like on media in which the Trichoderma oscillator is more robust, i.e. on GYEC media at 22C? Conversely, how would these changing conditions influence the Botrtyis clock proteins and their role in the interaction? The inclusion of such data may strengthen the overall discussion of the fungal clock operating within stringent environmental conditions.

2) For the interaction assay, it is clear the inoculating the plates at dawn results in greater Trichoderma overgrowth compared to inoculation at dusk. However, the authors state in the discussion (pg 33, line 15), that "overgrowth is increased when the "interactions started at dawn…". Does the inoculation time really represent the time at which the fungal interaction take place? Surely there must be a lag that reflects the growth of the organisms towards each other. Perhaps the interaction begins 12 h after inoculation, i.e. at dusk. Relatedly, how does growth rate of the various mutant strains (of either species) under the various light conditions influence the time in the solar/circadian day in which the initial interaction takes place?

3) Much attention is given to circadian influence on Trichoderma secondary metabolism, which is indeed very interesting. However, the relationship between this and the Botrytis interaction results are fairly weak. Can the authors demonstrate that culture supernatants of Trichoderma taken at different times across the circadian day, or in DD v LL, have an differential impact on Botrytis growth or viability? Maybe this is an oversimplified expectation. In any case , it is noted that Botrytis proteins have the greatest impact on the interaction, which would suggest that the circadian regulation of Trichoderma metabolites may not be particularly important. Do the authors think the relative susceptibility of Botrytis to Trichoderma metabolites, or some other stressor, is regulated by the Bc clock proteins? In other words, some discussion about the fungal-fungal interaction from the Botrytis perspective may be welcomed.

4) Overall, the 'Introduction' and 'Discussion' sections are nicely written and easy to read. By contrast, the 'Results' section contains some phrasing and grammatical issues that should be revised.

This is a very interesting study and my major "concerns" are outlined above. I may have misunderstood key aspects of the experiments, in which case a clarifying statement in the rebuttal may suffice. However, I do think that the authors should clarify some things in the manuscript as outlined here.

1) Please describe the assay conditions more clearly throughout the manuscript. The assay medium for Figure 3, for example, is not mentioned in the results or figure legend. I can't even see a definitive mention of the medium in the methods. In fact, the figure 4 legend is the only place where PDA is explicitly stated. Similarly, it is unclear what media was used for the secondary metabolite profiles. Based on the language in the methods, it seems that the light experiments were performed on PDA and the circadian time course was on GYEC… is that correct? If so, why use different media? This conditions be clearly stated in the figure legends in any case.

2) To what extent does the relative growth rate of the two organisms influence the interaction? For example, if a particular B. cinerea (Bc) mutant were slow growing, would this make the apparent overgrowth of T. atroviride (Ta) seem larger? The methods state that the readout is based on percent overgrowth, but this isn't really obvious in most of the pictures. To me, and perhaps to many readers, the readout (dotted line) seems to reflect the point of contact between the two organisms, sort of like a mating assay, which would presumably be growth rate dependent.

– To perhaps clarify this issue, the authors might consider is showing the each strain (Ta and Bc) by itself on a plate under each of the conditions (e.g. DD, LL, LD, etc). This would allow the reader to better visualize the morphology and growth rate of each organism in isolation, and consequently interpret the interaction experiments better.

3) Pg. 13, line 12: "After 72 h of cultivation in LL, conidia in Δtafrq exhibited a dark-green color compared to the TaWT and the OE::tafrq strains (Supplementary file 2A) which displayed the characteristic T. atroviride green coloration."

– This sentence is a bit confusing. So "green" is normal, and "dark green" is abnormal? It may be helpful for the unfamiliar reader if the authors briefly describe basic Trichoderma colony morphology, i.e. what color are the condia and underlying hyphae.

4) Some specific areas in the 'Results' section that need revision include, but are not limited to, the following:

– Pg 13, line 8: "This distinctive phenotype…"

– Pg. 14, Line 15.

– Page 18, Line 2: "Regarding…"

5) Pg. 7, Line 14: "ostensibly" doesn't seem like the correct word here.

Reviewer #3:

The most obvious change during the course of a day is the dark-light cycle. Associated to light changes are changes in harmful UV light, in temperature, in humidity, the possibility for finding food or the orientation in the environment. Circadian clocks help organisms to adapt to these predictable periodic changes before they actually occur. E.g. for humans it was good to wake up during dusk and be alert before their predators are active. For microorganisms, like filamentous fungi, environmental parameters may be important for instance if they produce spores for distribution. It may be advantageous to produce them early in the morning, when the humidity is high, because spores are often produced at the surface of substrates and hence the mycelium is at risk for desiccation. In the case of plant-pathogenic fungi it may be advantageous to spread the spores at times where plants are more susceptible for a fungal attack. This had been shown before by the same research group in the case of Botrytis cinerea. The current paper is a continuation of the work on organismic interactions and highlights the role of a circadian clock in the mycoparasitic relationship between Trichoderma atroviride and the grey mold B. cinerea. They identified a circadian clock in T. atroviride and show that it influences spore and secondary metabolite production. In the mycoparasitic interaction the clock of the prey is important for the success of the intruder rather than the other way around. The downstream components of the circadian clock, which are important for the outcome of the mycoparasitic interaction, remain to be discovered.

The paper has many important implications. The molecular mechanism of circadian clocks has been studied extensively in Neurospora crassa, but only in a few other fungi so far. Many fungi seem to lack one of the central components of the N. crassa clock, namely the negative element frequency. Therefore, it is important to collect more examples for circadian mechanisms in fungi. In T. atroviride the clock mechanism appears to be conserved in comparison to N. crassa. A second important aspect is that T. atroviride is used as a biocontrol agent and hence the work may help to optimize the application of the fungus in the field. Last but not least, the paper shows that secondary metabolism is largely influenced by the clock, an aspect so far largely neglected. Given that filamentous fungi are important producers of secondary metabolites, such as penicillin or lovastatin, circadian clocks should be considered when optimizing production processes.

The first two chapters describe the characterization of the circadian clock of T. atroviride. The authors show that it can be entrained by light-dark cycles, that it can be reset by a light or temperature pulse, and it is temperature compensated in a range between 20 and 26{degree sign}C. The mechanism of clock functioning appears to be similar to the one in N. crassa with a conserved cis element in the promoter of the frequency gene. Interestingly, addition of pea powder significantly enhanced the amplitude of the clock-dependent reporter expression. Is this a specific effect of pea or do other plants or fruits serve the same function? This is especially important because this aspect is also highlighted in the Discussion.

I find it very surprising, but interesting at the same time, that several tested and known clock-controlled genes apparently are not clock-controlled in T. atroviride. The authors should look at some regulators of the pathways they identified as being under clock control. The candidates could be further analyzed for the identified cis element in their promoters.

Next, they tested a function of the frq gene outside the clock function, because such an additional function had been described before in B. cinerea. They found that indeed conidiation is delayed in a frq-deletion strain, independent of ligh-dark cycles. To verify these results the deletion strain should be re-complemented with a wild-type copy.

In the following chapters they focus on the mycoparasitic interaction and use frq and wc mutant strains of both fungi in confrontation assays. They first found that light inhibits the parasitic capacity of T. atroviride and that the WC-1 orthologue is required for the aggressive behavior of T. atroviride in the dark. Again in this series of experiments a T. atroviride frq re-complemented strain is missing. In light-dark cycles it turned out that the B. cinerea Frq protein is important for the outcome of the interaction. This shows that the interaction is clock-controlled, but on the prey side.

In the last chapter they analyzed the production of different secondary metabolites and found that the production is under light control. The WC orthologue and Frq are involved in the regulation, independent of their functions in the circadian clock. However, the authors also show that the production of some compounds is clock controlled, and most required Frq. I guess for specialists the source data tables are useful. I cannot evaluate them.

https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.71358.sa1

Author response

Essential revisions:

The reviewers have made several constructive suggestions that you should carefully consider and address in a point-by-point reply. In particular, please pay particular attention to the following revisions:

We appreciate the editor's comments, summarizing the primary considerations as well as the different comments raised by all reviewers. We provide a point-by-point rebuttal, and hope that now the manuscript meets all criteria for publication.

1) Please perform experiments that demonstrate entrainment (as suggested by Reviewer #1).

While we understand that Reviewer 1 requested this type of experiments to be fully convinced of the presence of a bona fide circadian clock, due to technical issues and additional complications associated with the extended pandemic, we could not perform those suggested experiments. Indeed, experimental work was severely hampered at our universities during most of 2021, as access was extremely restricted. Nevertheless, we generated new data that actually go towards that direction, providing additional proof that this is a proper circadian system (see response #1 to Reviewer 1). We truly appreciate the reviewer’s comments as they allowed us to strengthen the dataset regarding this point. We are convinced that the new results not only do that, but also provide new interesting observations included in the manuscript.

2) Please perform the interaction assays across a range of environmental conditions (nutritional, temperature) to determine if the contributions of the clock proteins (in either organism) change accordingly (as suggested by Reviewer #2).

In the new text we now provide an important technical aspect of the confrontation experiments, commenting that only PDA media provides proper conditions to clearly visualize overgrowth or Trichoderma mycelia over Botrytis, as in other media (such as GYEC) Botrytis behaves oddly in terms of mycelia consistence and coloration. Importantly, the main purpose of these experiments was not to systematically test the effect of different conditions on the interaction but instead, to provide a proof of concept that two variables – light (Figure 3), and time (Figure 4) – have a relevant effect modulating the outcome of the interaction. We anticipate that future work in our lab (and the labs of others) will examine the additional effects of other variables in combination with the abovementioned ones.

3) Please re-complement your mutants (as suggested by Reviewer #3).

We thank the reviewer for raising this observation. Accordingly, we have now included complementation experiments as depicted in (new figures: Figure 3—figure supplement 3 and 4) confirming that, as expected, one of the hallmark phenotypes of the mutant is reversed in the complemented strain. We have included information of the new experiments in the Materials and methods section.

Reviewer #1:

The goal of this study was to establish that the fungus Trichoderma atroviride, and important biocontrol agent, has a circadian clock, and to test if this clock plays a role in development, secondary metabolite production, and mycoparasitism. The authors clearly establish rhythms in the organism that are dependent on TcFRQ, a homolog of the core clock component FRQ in N. crassa, and show that TcFRQ and BRL1, the homolog of the blue light photoreceptor and core clock component WC-1 in N. crassa, play differing roles in development, metabolite levels, and mycoparasitism in laboratory conditions. However, the authors do not fully establish that the rhythms are controlled by a circadian clock , nor that TcFRQ is a core clock component. While aspects of this work will be of interest to circadian and fungal biologists, the not all of the aims were met, and the data do not fully support the conclusions.

We sincerely appreciate the positive reception of our work. The reviewer's primary concern is related to the absence of data showing that TaFRQ is indeed a clockcore component. After careful examination, we have pondered our results and performed additional experiments that should help dissipate any potential doubts about that main conclusion. Thus, to fully support the latter, and to clearly establish that a circadian clock controls the observed rhythms, we now have included relevant additional information describing that TaFRQ is indeed a core clock component based on functional complementation experiments (aka classic old school approach) in Neurospora crassa. Accordingly, as highlighted in the new version of the MS, we do not only demonstrate that T. atroviride's clock free runs and compensates for temperature, but also that the tafrq gene is capable of functionally complementing a frq null strain of Neurospora (new figures: Figure 2 and figure supplement 2, and pages 12-13). Most notably, the latter experiment also shows that the “long” free running rhythms characterized in T. atroviride can be "transplanted” along with the Tafrq sequence to Neurospora. We think that these data fully support our conclusions, including extra-circadian functions of TaFRQ (see below).

Strengths: The circadian clock in the fungus N. crassa serves as an important model for understanding the mechanisms that keep time in eukaryotes, and how this clock controls daily rhythms in gene expression. However, little is known about clocks in other fungi, despite conservation of core clock components found in N. crassa, including fungal pathogens and biocontrol agents like Trichoderma. Thus, the strength of this work is in that it goes a long way to establish a clock in T. atroviride that is directly, or indirectly involved in controlling development, metabolism, and mycoparasitism. Importantly, this work opens up the opportunity to determine how the clock impacts fungal-fungal interactions, with the potential of using this to improve biocontrol.

We sincerely appreciate the positive reception of our work.

Weaknesses: There are several weaknesses. The first is that while the authors established conditions to demonstrate two canonical properties needed to establish a circadian clock, a free running rhythm that is close to 24 h and temperature compensation, the authors did not fully test one of the cardinal properties of a circadian clock, entrainment. Second, the authors do not establish that TcFRQ is a core component of the clock oscillator.

We thank the reviewer's thorough review. As mentioned above, although we did not explore entrainment in this work, the new dataset (FRQ complementation) provides new and unequivocal evidence that TaFRQ is a bona fide core-clock component, and therefore of the existence of a canonical clock in Trichoderma. Additionally, our data also provides clear evidence that the T. atroviride system readily responds to temperature and light cues which, albeit it is not entrainment per se, is tightly connected with it. Thus, we can now establish that TaFRQ indeed encodes a clock-core component (new figures: Figure 2-figure supplement 2, pages 12 and 13). Having cleared the waters in terms of its clock function, we can also mention about its extra-circadian roles (see following question-answer below). This is important, as we have demonstrated an analogous observation in Botrytis cinerea, and we anticipate that more than an exception this extracircadian functions may soon emerge as a transversal and common property of clock components.

Third, the authors made conclusions from a strain that is supposed to overexpress TcFRQ from an actin promoter but, there is no data demonstrating that TcFRQ is actually overexpressed.

Again, we sincerely appreciate the reviewer’s exhaustive review. Based on his/her observations we performed RT-qPCR analysis, which confirmed overexpression, particularly under DD conditions (circa 4-fold), info which can now be found in Figure 3figure supplement 2 (new figure) and page 14, Line 21-23. Since we also observed that in LL the degree of overexpression is less marked (albeit still statistically significant), we have made that explicit in the text and in the discussion of the data.

Fourth, the rationale for concluding that TcFRQ has an extra-clock role, as opposed to a clock role, in development and metabolism is not clear.

Indeed, this may have not been clear enough in the text. Now with the new data we have unmistakably stablished that Tafrq has a canonical role as a core-clock component. In addition, it has “extra-circadian” roles, as it affects (delays) sporulation and injury response even in LL conditions. As the clock only runs in DD (and not in LL) we refer to these effects as “extra circadian” since they are not based on a running clock.

Finally, a red safety light was used in all circadian experiments in constant dark; however, there is no data to support that T. atroviride is not responsive to red light.

We apologize for the confusion: in all free-running experiments, constant darkness means the total absence of light. Red safety lights are utilized in the dark room, which houses our light-proof incubators (Percival). Thus, experiments (CCD recordings, growth in Petri plates, etc.) were conducted inside the incubators in full darkness or in the presence of white light (when indicated). Red lights were only used to manipule equipment when required, or when opening incubators. Indeed, cultures were seldom exposed to red light in the experiments conducted in this MS. Related to the general question raised by the reviewer, only a few genes (three) have been detected as red-light regulated in T. atroviride after a 5 min red light-pulse (PMID: 17074901). In any case, both light intensity and time of exposure significantly differ from occasional expose to redlight during culture manipulation (i.e., harvesting).

Figure 1 While these data support the existence of a circadian clock in this organism based on free running rhythms and temperature compensation, it is important to provide additional data to demonstrate that the rhythm is entrained, one of the 3 criteria established in the field.

a. To demonstrate circadian entrainment, as opposed to a direct response to the environmental cues, specifically light, they need to examine different length LD cycles to demonstrate that the clock entrains to the different cycles. In addition, to demonstrate that an acute light or temperature pulse is resetting the clock, as opposed to masking, a a phase response curve is needed to show advances and delays. It is not clear what phase the light pulse was given in Figure 1D.

As mentioned earlier, we were unable to properly perform entrainment experiments. Instead, we adopted a different approach to provide compelling data regarding the characterization of the Trichoderma FRQ-based clock (see complementation experiments). Future work will, undoubtedly, focus on additional circadiana of this system, particularly phase response curves. Nevertheless, we estimate the revised data set provides sufficient information to support the main conclusions of the current manuscript.

b. In the Supplement to Figure 2, several genes are arrhythmic under conditions in which TAFRQLUC is rhythmic. This is an important control to show, for example, that there is not a rhythm in ATP levels that might be driving the rhythm in the TAFRQLUC reporter. I would like to see this mentioned earlier in relation to Figure 1.

We are glad to know that the reviewer also appreciates this data. Indeed, now we mention this is page 9, lines 1-13.

c. It would be helpful to know circadian time in Figure 1, and of interest to know if the peak time is similar to N. crassa FRQ.

The data suggests that the phase of the first peak of TaFRQ expression (as FRQLUC) is similar, albeit slightly advanced, compared to what occurs in N. crassa (once converted to circadian time), being roughly CT 11 for the latter, and CT 8 for Trichoderma. This is now mentioned in page 7, line 18.

Figure 2 demonstrates that the cis-acting promoter element of N. crassa frq that bound by the positive element, the WCC, is necessary for frq mRNA rhythms and functioning of the feedback loop, is sufficient to drive rhythms in luciferase in T. atroviride in DD, and is responsive to light and temperature pulses. This experiment suggests that there is conservation of the c-box, and raises the possibility that TAFRQ functions similarly in the T. atroviride clock as a negative element; however, this experiment raises more questions than it answers, and therefore seems premature. There are several instances in the paper where TaFRQ is called a core clock component, but there are no data to support this claim.

Indeed, this experiment raises a lot of interesting new questions. Nevertheless, in addition to the new complementation data, it provides a general and valuable conclusion: there is conservation of core-clock mechanisms and components across two species belonging to the same class, and there is cross-class recognition of such components. Thus, we believe it nicely contributes to the story.

a. Is there a similar sequence present in the promoter of TAFRQ? If so, what happens if this sequence is mutated?

b. What happens to the rhythm, levels, of TAFRQ in a Blr1 deletion or mutated strain?

c. Additional experiments are needed to show that Blr1 binds to this sequence and to fully describe TAFRQ role in the clock mechanism.

This reviewer raises interesting observation/questions, that also intrigue us. While these formal questions are highly relevant, we deem that they are not essential in the context of the overall message of this manuscript. Indeed, we have not identified a defined "endogenous" c-box sequence in Trichoderma, nevertheless, as described in the manuscript, “Two putative light response elements in the tafrq’s promoter with a putative GATA box consensus sequence at proximal and distal locations (-355 to -319 and -1180 to -1171 from the TSS, respectively) have been postulated (Cervantes-Badillo et al., 2013), of which one of them could be acting as a putative Tacbox sequence.”.

We did not directly determine TaFRQ levels in a BLR1 mutant strain. Importantly, transcriptomic datasets address this, confirming that, as expected, tafrq expression depends on BLR1, and is downregulated in the absence of this TF (PMID: 27020152).

This is now mentioned in Page 4, line 16.

In addition, the collective evidence of the new data showing how TaFRQ complements the Neurospora's frq null mutant, the fact that c-box of Neurospora works rhythmically in T. atroviride, and the absence of rhythms of other promoter-luc constructs in the latter fungus, all clearly reinforces the idea that we are describing a circadian clock and that TaFRQ is indeed a core clock component along with BLR1, aspects that are now commented in the discussion. Thus, while we appreciate and also share some of the questions raised by the reviewer, we believe they are beyond the current scope of the work.

In Supplementary file 1, 2A, B and C, they examine if TaFRQ has a role in development, and this is supported by the data presented by comparing WT versus TaFRQ deletion strains. They show that conidia formation is delayed in the mutant compared to WT, and decreased following light treatment or injury. In addition, they also examined a construct aimed at overexpressing TaFRQ (OE::TaFRQ) using the actin promoter. No differences were observed between WT and OE::TaFRQ; however, it is difficult to make any conclusions here because there were no experiments demonstrating that TaFRQ was actually overexpressed in this strain.

As commented above, we have now measured tafrq expression in the overexpressing strain, confirming that levels are statistically higher in the latter compared to WT, which is particularly marked in DD conditions. Indeed, when it comes to the mentioned phenotypes (conidiation, injury response) the OE strain behaves as the WT. Nevertheless, as evidenced in Figure 5, regarding metabolic profiles, the OE strain shows a pattern quite distinct compared to WT, particularly under DD, when expression levels of tafrq in OE versus WT are more pronounced.

Figure 3 examines the ability of T. atroviride to overgrow B. cinerea under different lighting conditions and in mutants as an indicator of mycoparasitic behavior. The key findings were that constant light inhibits overgrowth, and that mutations in blr1 in T. atroviride enhances overgrowth in constant darkness. However, it is not clear how these data and those that follow establish and extra-clock role for TaFRQ in these processes.

We apologize for the confusion, as we did not intend to imply that the data in Figure 3 relates to the extra circadian role of TaFRQ. To provide more context, we were also interested to analyze whether TaFRQ had additional roles, besides its clock function, a thought inspired from our findings for Botrytis FRQ. This is a relevant observation since, in the case of Neurospora, the FRQ protein seems to have only clock-related functions, while in Botrytis, in an environmental condition where the clock is not functional (in constant light), the frq mutant shows additional extra-circadian functions related to altered development (conidiation). Now, this is better explained in the text in page 15, between lines 09-16.

Figure 4 looks at dawn and dusk confrontations between T. atroviride and B. cinereai in LD cycles. They found that WT T. atroviride and TaFRQ deletion strains had overgrowth that was enhanced at dawn, whereas deletion of TaBLR1 did not show a time of day difference. However, when frq was deleted in B. cinerea, all T. atroviride strains overgrew. These data supported that homologs of N. crassa clock components in T. atroviride and B. cinereai play differing roles in time of day specific interactions, and this information could prove useful in biocontrol measures in the future.

We appreciate the reviewer's comments as they highlight our results and potential future applications. Indeed, we are looking forward to see how our observation can be translated to applied studies.

Figure 5 examines if T. atroviride FRQ and BLR1 mutants alter secondary metabolism by examining diffusible and volatile compounds in DD and LL, and following a light pulse. They found several differences, but were unable to correlate these with the overgrowth experiments in Figures 3 and 4. A circadian metabolic profile demonstrated that some compounds were rhythmic in WT and arrhythmic in taFRQ deletion cells. These data provide evidence to support a role for a clock in controlling metabolism in T. atroviride.

Again, we appreciate the reviewer's comments as they highlight the relevance of our results.

Discussion: The paper lacks definitive experiments to show that taFRQ is a core clock component, and therefore, it is not clear how these data support a extra-circadian role for taFRQ. In addition, aspects of the discussion are very lengthy, especially the section describing how this work could foster looking for clocks in other fungi.

We acknowledge, as the reviewer pointed out, the limitation that our study had. Therefore, we took the approach of complementing an arrhythmic Neurospora strain with tafrq (see above). Such results not only provide compelling evidence of TaFRQ role in the clockworks, but also opens the door to interesting future comparative studies. Having dissipated such doubts, it may now be easier to visualize the concept of “extracircadian” roles of FRQ, as they lead to phenotypes even in a condition where clock function is abrogated (constant light). We have also modified parts of the discussion, to make it more fluid.

Methods:

a. It is critical to show that T. atroviride is not sensitive to red light given red safety lights were used in circadian experiments.

We have now clarified that low level red-lights are used only to manipulate cultures, equipment, although most of the experiments described herein were conducted in full DD (inside incubators), which were actually housed inside the dark room equipped with the safety lights. Please, refer to (above).

b. The constructs used to examine potential rhythms in known fungal ccgs used the promoter, but not the 3' ends of the genes. The authors may want to consider adding this in the future.

We thank the reviewer's suggestions. Indeed, we are considering this in other studies conducted with collaborators.

Supplemental Figures

1.4 In part A, the light pulse did not seem to improve the rhythm similar to what was shown in Figure 1. What the light pulse given at the same time of day?

We have modified the legend of figure 1.4, to better reflect that the conditions of the light pulse were not equivalent to the one in Figure 1.

1.5. When was the light pulse given? These data should be plotted.

We have also modified the figure legend to better explain when the LP was given.

2.1. The data in A appear different from Figure 2A, although it appears to be the same experiment.

We have simplified the legend of figure 2.1 (Figure 2—figure supplement 1) so it is now clear that the experiment was conducted in GYEC, whereas the one in 2A was conducted in GYEC + peas, which (as seen in previous figures) dramatically improves rhythms.

File 1. This figure is difficult to follow.

A series of modifications were made to the figure and its legend for simplification.

File 2: It is not clear if the plot in B represents 3 or 7 days after a light pulse.

This file (now called Supplementary file 3) has been improved as requested.

Reviewer #2:

In this manuscript, Henríquez-Urrutia and colleagues establish the existence of a core circadian rhythm in the mycoparasitic fungus Trichoderma atroviride. Using both translational and transcriptional reporters for a core clock component, FRQ/frq, the authors demonstrate that the rhythm meets all the requirements of bona fide circadian oscillator, e.g. entrainment and temperature compensation. Interestingly and importantly, they demonstrate that the robustness of the oscillation is largely dependent on the nutritional environment; specifically, the rhythm was only discernable under growth conditions that likely resemble the natural environment of the fungus. This information will be of keen interest to the chronobiology community, particularly those that attempting to identify a clock in their microbe of interest. Moreover, the authors demonstrate that two processes are under control of the Trichoderma clock, or at least under the regulation of clock components: (1) secondary metabolism, and (2) the myoparasitic interaction with another fungus, Botrytis. Although the connection between those two phenomena in this study is unclear, together they demonstrate the importance of biological clocks in regulating fungal behaviors of interest. Understanding how the time-of-day influences fungal parasitism, for example, could inform the optimization of fungi as biocontrol agents in the agricultural setting. In conclusion, the work provided here is novel, the conclusions are supported by the data, the ideas are well-marshalled. Consequently, I believe this would be would be a good fit for eLife and its readership. However, the manuscript may be strengthened by an expanded discussion or additional experiments as outlined below.

1) The authors do an excellent job in defining how environmental parameters (e.g. nutrients and temperature), influence the robustness of Trichoderma core oscillation. It is therefore surprising that the Trichoderma/Botrytis interaction assays were not analyzed across a similar variety of conditions. For example, the authors performed the interaction assays on PDA media at 20C, the data from which support the conclusion the the Trichoderma FRQ does not significantly influence its parasitism of Botrytis. However, what would these results look like on media in which the Trichoderma oscillator is more robust, i.e. on GYEC media at 22C? Conversely, how would these changing conditions influence the Botrtyis clock proteins and their role in the interaction? The inclusion of such data may strengthen the overall discussion of the fungal clock operating within stringent environmental conditions.

We share the curiosity expressed by the reviewer. Examination of different media modulating the Botrytis-Trichoderma interaction will be a future area of study (particularly involving conditions mimicking soil). Nevertheless, they were beyond the scope of this first report, and due to all the complications of a closed lab during almost 16 months, and people moving on to new jobs, this was further delayed. Based on the reactions of colleagues, as we first presented the data in public in 2022 (Fungal Genetics, and Botrytis meetings), we are convinced that the story, as it is, will be extremely well received and, most importantly, will inspire new angles of studies in different labs.

2) For the interaction assay, it is clear the inoculating the plates at dawn results in greater Trichoderma overgrowth compared to inoculation at dusk. However, the authors state in the discussion (pg 33, line 15), that "overgrowth is increased when the "interactions started at dawn...". Does the inoculation time really represent the time at which the fungal interaction take place? Surely there must be a lag that reflects the growth of the organisms towards each other. Perhaps the interaction begins 12 h after inoculation, i.e. at dusk. Relatedly, how does growth rate of the various mutant strains (of either species) under the various light conditions influence the time in the solar/circadian day in which the initial interaction takes place?

As the reviewer noticed, there must be a lag reflecting the growth of both fungi towards each other. Interestingly, in the case of the Botrytis-plant interaction, which also is influenced by the time of the day as reported by our group years ago, there is also a lag: the infection assays are regularly conducted employing a droplet containing conidia that first needs to develop the infecting hyphae, and later, the appressorium to penetrate the plant tissue. However, differences are observed between dawn and dusk inoculation times irrespective of this delay.

The reviewer, for sure, is concerned that this delay might be too extended in time, explained, for example, by a significant difference in growth rate between the two fungi. Therefore, we controlled for it: after two days of growth, the colony sizes of Trichoderma and Botrytis was measured, and no statistical differences were observed. Please, refer to new figure (Figure 4-figure supplement 1) and page 17, Line 9-17.

3) Much attention is given to circadian influence on Trichoderma secondary metabolism, which is indeed very interesting. However, the relationship between this and the Botrytis interaction results are fairly weak. Can the authors demonstrate that culture supernatants of Trichoderma taken at different times across the circadian day, or in DD v LL, have an differential impact on Botrytis growth or viability? Maybe this is an oversimplified expectation. In any case , it is noted that Botrytis proteins have the greatest impact on the interaction, which would suggest that the circadian regulation of Trichoderma metabolites may not be particularly important. Do the authors think the relative susceptibility of Botrytis to Trichoderma metabolites, or some other stressor, is regulated by the Bc clock proteins? In other words, some discussion about the fungal-fungal interaction from the Botrytis perspective may be welcomed.

The question raised by the reviewer is fascinating and could even have biotechnological implications in using Trichoderma for biocontrol. And although the products secreted by Trichoderma when growing alone in a liquid medium differ from those produced when growing with Botrytis in the same Petri dish, the interpretation of the data would be very complex since the secreted products (proteins, metabolites, etc.) are very stable over time. We have briefly included ideas as the ones mentioned by the reviewer, in the discussion session.

4) Overall, the 'Introduction' and 'Discussion' sections are nicely written and easy to read. By contrast, the 'Results' section contains some phrasing and grammatical issues that should be revised.

Thanks. We have revised the Results section.

This is a very interesting study and my major "concerns" are outlined above. I may have misunderstood key aspects of the experiments, in which case a clarifying statement in the rebuttal may suffice. However, I do think that the authors should clarify some things in the manuscript as outlined here.

1) Please describe the assay conditions more clearly throughout the manuscript. The assay medium for Figure 3, for example, is not mentioned in the results or figure legend. I can't even see a definitive mention of the medium in the methods. In fact, the figure 4 legend is the only place where PDA is explicitly stated. Similarly, it is unclear what media was used for the secondary metabolite profiles. Based on the language in the methods, it seems that the light experiments were performed on PDA and the circadian time course was on GYEC… is that correct? If so, why use different media? This conditions be clearly stated in the figure legends in any case.

Thanks for bringing this up. We have now made sure that each key figure is explicit regarding the utilized media. The need to use PDA in some experiment’s and GYEC + peas media in others is discussed within the manuscript.

2) To what extent does the relative growth rate of the two organisms influence the interaction? For example, if a particular B. cinerea (Bc) mutant were slow growing, would this make the apparent overgrowth of T. atroviride (Ta) seem larger? The methods state that the readout is based on percent overgrowth, but this isn't really obvious in most of the pictures. To me, and perhaps to many readers, the readout (dotted line) seems to reflect the point of contact between the two organisms, sort of like a mating assay, which would presumably be growth rate dependent.

– To perhaps clarify this issue, the authors might consider is showing the each strain (Ta and Bc) by itself on a plate under each of the conditions (e.g. DD, LL, LD, etc). This would allow the reader to better visualize the morphology and growth rate of each organism in isolation, and consequently interpret the interaction experiments better.

Originally, we asked ourselves questions similar to the ones raised by the reviewer. We explored them by changing the relative position of the inoculation point of one of the confronting fungi yet, we saw results similar to the ones presented in the manuscript. Please, refer to response #2 (above).

3) Pg. 13, line 12: "After 72 h of cultivation in LL, conidia in Δtafrq exhibited a dark-green color compared to the TaWT and the OE::tafrq strains (Supplementary file 2A) which displayed the characteristic T. atroviride green coloration."

– This sentence is a bit confusing. So "green" is normal, and "dark green" is abnormal? It may be helpful for the unfamiliar reader if the authors briefly describe basic Trichoderma colony morphology, i.e. what color are the condia and underlying hyphae.

Please, see modification in page 14, lines 12-15.

4) Some specific areas in the 'Results' section that need revision include, but are not limited to, the following:

– Pg 13, line 8: "This distinctive phenotype…"

– Pg. 14, Line 15.

– Page 18, Line 2: "Regarding…"

Reviews are appreciated. All these comments were resolved in the corresponding sections.

5) Pg. 7, Line 14: "ostensibly" doesn't seem like the correct word here.

Modified. Now you can read “quality of the oscillations greatly improved”.

Reviewer #3:

The first two chapters describe the characterization of the circadian clock of T. atroviride. The authors show that it can be entrained by light-dark cycles, that it can be reset by a light or temperature pulse, and it is temperature compensated in a range between 20 and 26{degree sign}C. The mechanism of clock functioning appears to be similar to the one in N. crassa with a conserved cis element in the promoter of the frequency gene. Interestingly, addition of pea powder significantly enhanced the amplitude of the clock-dependent reporter expression. Is this a specific effect of pea or do other plants or fruits serve the same function? This is especially important because this aspect is also highlighted in the Discussion.

At present, we have not done systematic experiments to evaluate other plant species because this would deviate our efforts in the lab. But indeed, this is a very exciting area to explore, and particularly towards identifying the molecular nature of the plant element(s) that seem(s) to enhance rhythms. Future plans entertain the idea of adding different extracts from plant roots, which is a more "natural" environment for T. atroviride. Since, as a group, we have been working longer with B. cinerea, we routinely use plant material to stimulate conidiation in the latter fungus, but we also do not know the component(s) that promote this enhanced conidiation in B. cinerea.

I find it very surprising, but interesting at the same time, that several tested and known clock-controlled genes apparently are not clock-controlled in T. atroviride. The authors should look at some regulators of the pathways they identified as being under clock control. The candidates could be further analyzed for the identified cis element in their promoters.

Indeed, we were surprised too by their lack of rhythmicity. It is possible that the promoter region used does not contain all the information which is discussed in the manuscript. In any case, a systematic and unbiased strategy (e.g., RNA-Seq) could help indicate, in the future, whether orthologs of known ccgs (as well as unexpected ones) are rhythmic in Trichoderma.

Next, they tested a function of the frq gene outside the clock function, because such an additional function had been described before in B. cinerea. They found that indeed conidiation is delayed in a frq-deletion strain, independent of ligh-dark cycles. To verify these results the deletion strain should be re-complemented with a wild-type copy.

We acknowledge the reviewer's suggestions. We have verified our results by performing complementation experiments: please, see new Figure 3—figure supplement 3 and 4, (Δtafrq complementation), pages 15, lines 9-15.

In the following chapters they focus on the mycoparasitic interaction and use frq and wc mutant strains of both fungi in confrontation assays. They first found that light inhibits the parasitic capacity of T. atroviride and that the WC-1 orthologue is required for the aggressive behavior of T. atroviride in the dark. Again in this series of experiments a T. atroviride frq re-complemented strain is missing. In light-dark cycles it turned out that the B. cinerea Frq protein is important for the outcome of the interaction. This shows that the interaction is clock-controlled, but on the prey side.

We appreciate the reviewer's suggestions. As the lack of frq in Trichoderma does not have a major impact in these assays, we mainly looked at the complemented strain in the context of the previous question (see above).

In the last chapter they analyzed the production of different secondary metabolites and found that the production is under light control. The WC orthologue and Frq are involved in the regulation, independent of their functions in the circadian clock. However, the authors also show that the production of some compounds is clock controlled, and most required Frq. I guess for specialists the source data tables are useful. I cannot evaluate them.

Indeed, the data provides nice evidence of rhythmic metabolites (which depend on TaFRQ). We look forward to unveiling the molecular events controlling their production as well as their identity and physiological role.

https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.71358.sa2

Article and author information

Author details

  1. Marlene Henríquez-Urrutia

    1. ANID – Millennium Science Initiative Program - Millennium Institute for Integrative Biology (iBio), Santiago, Chile
    2. Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Biological Sciences Faculty, Molecular Genetics and Microbiology Department, Santiago, Chile
    Contribution
    Conceptualization, Data curation, Validation, Investigation, Visualization, Methodology, Writing - original draft
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
  2. Rebecca Spanner

    1. ANID – Millennium Science Initiative Program - Millennium Institute for Integrative Biology (iBio), Santiago, Chile
    2. Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Biological Sciences Faculty, Molecular Genetics and Microbiology Department, Santiago, Chile
    Contribution
    Investigation, Methodology, Writing – review and editing
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
  3. Consuelo Olivares-Yánez

    1. ANID – Millennium Science Initiative Program - Millennium Institute for Integrative Biology (iBio), Santiago, Chile
    2. Centro de Biotecnología Vegetal, Facultad de Ciencias de la Vida, Universidad Andrés, Santiago, Chile
    Contribution
    Data curation, Investigation, Methodology, Writing – review and editing
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
  4. Aldo Seguel-Avello

    1. ANID – Millennium Science Initiative Program - Millennium Institute for Integrative Biology (iBio), Santiago, Chile
    2. Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Biological Sciences Faculty, Molecular Genetics and Microbiology Department, Santiago, Chile
    Contribution
    Investigation, Methodology, Writing – review and editing
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
  5. Rodrigo Pérez-Lara

    1. ANID – Millennium Science Initiative Program - Millennium Institute for Integrative Biology (iBio), Santiago, Chile
    2. Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Biological Sciences Faculty, Molecular Genetics and Microbiology Department, Santiago, Chile
    Contribution
    Investigation, Methodology
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
  6. Hector Guillén-Alonso

    Department of Biotechnology and Biochemistry, Cinvestav Unidad Irapuato, Irapuato, Mexico
    Contribution
    Investigation, Methodology, Writing – review and editing
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
  7. Robert Winkler

    Department of Biotechnology and Biochemistry, Cinvestav Unidad Irapuato, Irapuato, Mexico
    Contribution
    Conceptualization, Resources, Data curation, Supervision, Validation, Methodology, Writing – review and editing
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
  8. Alfredo Herrera-Estrella

    Laboratorio de expresión génica y desarrollo en hongos, Unidad de Genómica Avanzada-LANGEBIO, Irapuato, Mexico
    Contribution
    Conceptualization, Resources, Data curation, Formal analysis, Supervision, Visualization, Writing – review and editing
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
  9. Paulo Canessa

    1. ANID – Millennium Science Initiative Program - Millennium Institute for Integrative Biology (iBio), Santiago, Chile
    2. Centro de Biotecnología Vegetal, Facultad de Ciencias de la Vida, Universidad Andrés, Santiago, Chile
    Contribution
    Conceptualization, Resources, Data curation, Supervision, Funding acquisition, Visualization, Writing - original draft, Writing – review and editing
    For correspondence
    paulo.canessa@unab.cl
    Competing interests
    No competing interests declared
  10. Luis F Larrondo

    1. ANID – Millennium Science Initiative Program - Millennium Institute for Integrative Biology (iBio), Santiago, Chile
    2. Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Biological Sciences Faculty, Molecular Genetics and Microbiology Department, Santiago, Chile
    Contribution
    Conceptualization, Resources, Formal analysis, Supervision, Funding acquisition, Writing - original draft, Project administration, Writing – review and editing
    For correspondence
    llarrondo@bio.puc.cl
    Competing interests
    Reviewing editor, eLife
    ORCID icon "This ORCID iD identifies the author of this article:" 0000-0002-8832-7109

Funding

Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (FONDECYT Regular 1211715)

  • Luis F Larrondo

Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (FONDECYT Postdoc 3180328)

  • Aldo Seguel-Avello

Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (FONDECYT Postdoc 3190628)

  • Consuelo Olivares-Yánez

Howard Hughes Medical Institute (the International Research Scholar program)

  • Luis F Larrondo

Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (Millennium Science Initiative Program - Millennium Institute for Integrative Biology (iBio ICN17_022)

  • Paulo Canessa
  • Luis F Larrondo

The funders had no role in study design, data collection and interpretation, or the decision to submit the work for publication.

Acknowledgements

We thank Orlando Camargo, Tzitziki González, and Abigail Moreno for their invaluable help. This research was funded by ANID – Millennium Science Initiative Program – Millennium Institute for Integrative Biology (iBio ICN17_022), ANID/FONDECYT 1211715, ANID/FONDECYT-Postdoctoral 3180328 (to AS), ANID/FONDECYT-Postdoctoral 3190628 (to CO-Y), and the International Research Scholar program of the Howard Hughes Medical Institute. We also acknowledge Fundación Ciencia & Vida for providing infrastructure and laboratory space for experiments.

Senior Editor

  1. Detlef Weigel, Max Planck Institute for Biology Tübingen, Germany

Reviewing Editor

  1. Antonis Rokas, Vanderbilt University, United States

Reviewer

  1. Kevin Fuller

Publication history

  1. Received: June 17, 2021
  2. Accepted: August 10, 2022
  3. Accepted Manuscript published: August 11, 2022 (version 1)
  4. Version of Record published: August 30, 2022 (version 2)

Copyright

© 2022, Henríquez-Urrutia et al.

This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.

Metrics

  • 666
    Page views
  • 239
    Downloads
  • 0
    Citations

Article citation count generated by polling the highest count across the following sources: Crossref, PubMed Central, Scopus.

Download links

A two-part list of links to download the article, or parts of the article, in various formats.

Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)

Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)

Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)

  1. Marlene Henríquez-Urrutia
  2. Rebecca Spanner
  3. Consuelo Olivares-Yánez
  4. Aldo Seguel-Avello
  5. Rodrigo Pérez-Lara
  6. Hector Guillén-Alonso
  7. Robert Winkler
  8. Alfredo Herrera-Estrella
  9. Paulo Canessa
  10. Luis F Larrondo
(2022)
Circadian oscillations in Trichoderma atroviride and the role of core clock components in secondary metabolism, development, and mycoparasitism against the phytopathogen Botrytis cinerea
eLife 11:e71358.
https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.71358

Further reading

    1. Cell Biology
    Jia Chen, Daniel St Johnston
    Research Article

    In the adult Drosophila midgut, basal intestinal stem cells give rise to enteroblasts that integrate into the epithelium as they differentiate into enterocytes. Integrating enteroblasts must generate a new apical domain and break through the septate junctions between neighbouring enterocytes, while maintaining barrier function. We observe that enteroblasts form an apical membrane initiation site (AMIS) when they reach the septate junction between the enterocytes. Cadherin clears from the apical surface and an apical space appears between above the enteroblast. New septate junctions then form laterally with the enterocytes and the AMIS develops into an apical domain below the enterocyte septate junction. The enteroblast therefore forms a pre-assembled apical compartment before it has a free apical surface in contact with the gut lumen. Finally, the enterocyte septate junction disassembles and the enteroblast/pre-enterocyte reaches the gut lumen with a fully-formed brush border. The process of enteroblast integration resembles lumen formation in mammalian epithelial cysts, highlighting the similarities between the fly midgut and mammalian epithelia.

    1. Cell Biology
    2. Genetics and Genomics
    Julie Trolle, Ross M McBee ... Harris H Wang
    Short Report

    Major genomic deletions in independent eukaryotic lineages have led to repeated ancestral loss of biosynthesis pathways for nine of the twenty canonical amino acids1. While the evolutionary forces driving these polyphyletic deletion events are not well understood, the consequence is that extant metazoans are unable to produce nine essential amino acids (EAAs). Previous studies have highlighted that EAA biosynthesis tends to be more energetically costly2,3, raising the possibility that these pathways were lost from organisms with access to abundant EAAs in the environment4,5. It is unclear whether present-day metazoans can reaccept these pathways to resurrect biosynthetic capabilities that were lost long ago or whether evolution has rendered EAA pathways incompatible with metazoan metabolism. Here, we report progress on a large-scale synthetic genomics effort to reestablish EAA biosynthetic functionality in mammalian cells. We designed codon-optimized biosynthesis pathways based on genes mined from Escherichia coli. These pathways were de novo synthesized in 3 kilobase chunks, assembled in yeasto and genomically integrated into a Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) cell line. One synthetic pathway produced valine at a sufficient level for cell viability and proliferation, and thus represents a successful example of metazoan EAA biosynthesis restoration. This prototrophic CHO line grows in valine-free medium, and metabolomics using labeled precursors verified de novo biosynthesis of valine. RNA-seq profiling of the valine prototrophic CHO line showed that the synthetic pathway minimally disrupted the cellular transcriptome. Furthermore, valine prototrophic cells exhibited transcriptional signatures associated with rescue from nutritional starvation. 13C-tracing revealed build-up of pathway intermediate 2,3-dihydroxy-3-isovalerate in these cells. Increasing the dosage of downstream ilvD boosted pathway performance and allowed for long-term propagation of second-generation cells in valine-free medium at a consistent doubling time of 3.2 days. This work demonstrates that mammalian metabolism is amenable to restoration of ancient core pathways, paving a path for genome-scale efforts to synthetically restore metabolic functions to the metazoan lineage.