Breast Cancer: How drug resistance takes shape
The majority of breast cancers are hormone receptor positive and are sensitive to the steroid hormone estrogen. This hormone binds to and activates a transcription factor known as estrogen receptor alpha (ERα), and drugs that reduce the production of estrogen or directly block estrogen binding by ERα can halt the growth of estrogen-sensitive cancers. However, in many cases, these endocrine therapies eventually stop working because the cancer cells develop resistance to the drugs. Recently, this resistance has been linked to a number of mutations in the gene for ERα that are almost exclusively found in patients who have received hormone therapy. The two most prevalent mutations to have been identified are the missense mutations Y537S and D538G. (Toy et al., 2013; Merenbakh-Lamin et al., 2013; Robinson et al., 2013; Jeselsohn et al., 2014 ).
The ERα mutations affect the part of the protein called the ligand-binding domain. Studies in breast cancer cell lines show that these mutations result in ERα activity, even in the absence of estrogen, and that they cause relative resistance to tamoxifen and other drugs that directly target ERα. Now, in eLife, Geoffrey Greene of the University of Chicago and colleagues – including Sean Fanning, Christopher Mayne and Venkatasubramanian Dharmarajan as joint first authors – report new insights into the effects that the two mutations have on the structure of ERα (Fanning et al., 2015). They also explore how these mutations can lead to drug resistance.
The ligand-binding domain of ERα consists of three layers of α–helices. The final helix, known as helix-12, acts as a molecular switch that changes position when estrogen binds to the domain. This enables co-activator proteins, such as the steroid receptor coactivator 3 (SRC3), to bind to and activate ERα. A previous study found that the ligand-binding domain from an ERα mutant known as Y537S has a structure that strongly resembles the wild-type domain when it is bound to estrogen (Nettles et al., 2008). This mutation stabilizes helix-12 in a conformation that allows the coactivator to bind (even in the absence of estrogen) by forming a hydrogen bond with another amino acid in ERα.
The crystal structure of the D538G mutant remained unknown and molecular modeling provided limited insight as to how this mutation allowed ERα to be active in the absence of estrogen. Furthermore, it was not clear how any of the mutations render cancer cells more resistant to drugs that target ERα. Some researchers proposed that the drug resistance was caused by decreased binding affinity to the ERα mutants, but few studies have been carried out to test this hypothesis.
Fanning et al. – who are based at Chicago, the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, the Scripps Research Institute, the Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center and Texas A&M University – addressed these questions by performing comprehensive biophysical and crystallographic studies on the Y537S and D538G mutations. This information is critical for the development of new molecules that target these mutations.
Fanning et al. show that SRC3 only binds to wild-type ERα in the presence of estrogen, while the Y537S and D538G mutants are able to recruit SRC3 in the absence of the hormone. In addition, ligand-binding assays demonstrate that the affinity for tamoxifen-mutant binding is lower than the affinity for tamoxifen-wild type binding. Taken together, the mutations stabilize the active form of ERα and make it harder for anti-cancer drugs to bind to it. However, the addition of estrogen still increased the ability of SRC3 to bind to both mutants, which suggests that depriving tumors of estrogen may still be important in treating cancers with these mutations.
Next, Fanning et al. obtained X-ray crystal structures of the ligand-binding domain from the D538G mutant on its own, and when it was bound to estrogen or tamoxifen. As expected, helix-12 in this mutant was more stable in the conformation that allows SRC3 to bind even in the absence of estrogen. This stability, however, is structurally different from that observed in the Y537S mutant and is more subtle. In addition, in the absence of estrogen, SRC3 binds to the Y537S mutant with an affinity that is higher than when it binds to the D538G mutant. These differences between the two mutations may have clinical implications, as recent data suggests that they may be associated with different outcomes in cancer patients (Chandarlapaty, 2015). However, additional studies are needed to fully understand how important these differences are.
In the presence of tamoxifen, the ligand-binding domain of the D538G mutant adopts a conformation that is different to that of the wild type domain. This difference is mainly due to changes in a loop that connects helix-11 and helix-12, and leads to a decrease in the inhibitory activity of tamoxifen. Likewise, computational modeling suggests that the Y537S mutation also induces a conformational change in the ligand-binding domain that reduces the ability of tamoxifen to inhibit ERα activity. Thus, resistance to tamoxifen stems from a combination of the drug being less likely to bind to the mutant domains and being less effective when it does bind.
The work of Fanning et al. significantly advances our understanding of the link between structural alterations of the ERα mutant and drug resistance, suggesting that new drugs will be needed to overcome the resistance caused by these mutations. These new drugs will need to bind to the mutant domains with higher affinity than existing drugs and be able to either stabilize helix-12 in the conformation that prevents SRC3 or other co-activators from binding, or promote the degradation of ERα. Future studies will also need to focus on the mutation known as E380Q that is also detected in breast cancer patients with resistant disease and may have similar effects to the mutations studied by Fanning et al.
References
-
ConferencecfDNA analysis from BOLERO-2 plasma samples identifies a high rate of ESR1 mutations: Exploratory analysis for prognostic and predictive correlation of mutations reveals different efficacy outcomes of endocrine therapy–based regimensSan Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium.
-
NFκB selectivity of estrogen receptor ligands revealed by comparative crystallographic analysesNature Chemical Biology 4:241–247.https://doi.org/10.1038/nchembio.76
-
Activating ESR1 mutations in hormone-resistant metastatic breast cancerNature Genetics 45:1446–1451.https://doi.org/10.1038/ng.2823
-
ESR1 ligand-binding domain mutations in hormone-resistant breast cancerNature Genetics 45:1439–1445.https://doi.org/10.1038/ng.2822
Article and author information
Author details
Publication history
Copyright
© 2016, Jeselsohn et al.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.
Metrics
-
- 1,087
- views
-
- 221
- downloads
-
- 1
- citations
Views, downloads and citations are aggregated across all versions of this paper published by eLife.
Download links
Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)
Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)
Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)
Further reading
-
- Biochemistry and Chemical Biology
- Structural Biology and Molecular Biophysics
Pancreatic KATP channel trafficking defects underlie congenital hyperinsulinism (CHI) cases unresponsive to the KATP channel opener diazoxide, the mainstay medical therapy for CHI. Current clinically used KATP channel inhibitors have been shown to act as pharmacochaperones and restore surface expression of trafficking mutants; however, their therapeutic utility for KATP trafficking-impaired CHI is hindered by high affinity binding, which limits functional recovery of rescued channels. Recent structural studies of KATP channels employing cryo-electron microscopy (cryoEM) have revealed a promiscuous pocket where several known KATP pharmacochaperones bind. The structural knowledge provides a framework for discovering KATP channel pharmacochaperones with desired reversible inhibitory effects to permit functional recovery of rescued channels. Using an AI-based virtual screening technology AtomNet followed by functional validation, we identified a novel compound, termed Aekatperone, which exhibits chaperoning effects on KATP channel trafficking mutations. Aekatperone reversibly inhibits KATP channel activity with a half-maximal inhibitory concentration (IC50) ~9 μM. Mutant channels rescued to the cell surface by Aekatperone showed functional recovery upon washout of the compound. CryoEM structure of KATP bound to Aekatperone revealed distinct binding features compared to known high affinity inhibitor pharmacochaperones. Our findings unveil a KATP pharmacochaperone enabling functional recovery of rescued channels as a promising therapeutic for CHI caused by KATP trafficking defects.
-
- Biochemistry and Chemical Biology
- Structural Biology and Molecular Biophysics
The phase separation of intrinsically disordered proteins is emerging as an important mechanism for cellular organization. However, efforts to connect protein sequences to the physical properties of condensates, that is, the molecular grammar, are hampered by a lack of effective approaches for probing high-resolution structural details. Using a combination of multiscale simulations and fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy experiments, we systematically explored a series of systems consisting of diblock elastin-like polypeptides (ELPs). The simulations succeeded in reproducing the variation of condensate stability upon amino acid substitution and revealed different microenvironments within a single condensate, which we verified with environmentally sensitive fluorophores. The interspersion of hydrophilic and hydrophobic residues and a lack of secondary structure formation result in an interfacial environment, which explains both the strong correlation between ELP condensate stability and interfacial hydrophobicity scales, as well as the prevalence of protein-water hydrogen bonds. Our study uncovers new mechanisms for condensate stability and organization that may be broadly applicable.